ipl-logo

James 'Standardized Testing Vs. Education'

501 Words3 Pages

ENG 108 "Standardized Testing vs. Education" Analysis Name: Jooho Kim

1. According to James, how does standardized testing define education?

According to James, "Standardized testing tells students and society that education is a quantity to be consumed and measured. ... Standardized testing teaches students that education means getting content from a teacher or getting good at a skill. Students come to think education means getting a grade on the test, accumulating points, and arriving at an average grade based on those points. Standardized tests make education boring."

P.S. In James's opinion, "Standardized tests teach students to practice and perform, but education is more about developing a sense of curiosity."

2. What is James's line of reasoning? What basic premises must you follow before you accept his main claim? (Are any of those premises unstated in James's essay?) …show more content…

From this anecdote, James tells us standardized testing makes students bored and unenthusiastic. Then he argues what education is, why standardized testing should not be defined as education. First, he argues education is developing a sense of curiosity. Second, he provides quotes from other people who know side effects of standardized testing to explain why standardized testing should not be defined as education. Consequently, he reaches his conclusion, standardized testing is a harmful definition of education.

3. Discuss how the following sentence makes an appeal to values:
Standardized testing ends up sending a wrong message: It tells students and society that education is a quantity to be consumed and measured (paragraph 1).

The word "wrong" includes an opinion and judgement about the value of standardized testing. It makes a connection between the topic and a shared value:

Show More
Related
804 Words | 4 Pages

All students dread one thing when it comes to school - testing. Standardized test are the main focus in our school systems instead of actually gaining knowledge at the end of the year. As a mother, Michelle Rhee, understands the lack of attention given on education as a whole instead of just waiting on the scores, but she still agrees on continuing with standardized test. Kristina Rizga opposes the opinion of Michelle Rhee as she does not believe standardized test truly measure the intelligence of a student. Kristina Rizga proves her stand against standardized test by utilizing solid use of argumentation.

Read More
877 Words | 4 Pages

Standardized testing creates an environment where children come to despise learning and with that, begin to despise the pursuit of knowledge in general. This focus on “rote learning” stays with children their entire lives, hindering their ability to think at a deeper level and even to create independent and original thoughts and

Read More
1212 Words | 5 Pages

Proponents see standardized testing as a way of making testing more efficient and effective by minimizing cost and increasing people’s accountability for their performance in the system. Opponents on the other hand argue that the systems has limitations based on its very nature on what can be tested and as a result of these standards needing to be met sacrifice some very important aspects of students education experience as well as force onto students and teachers a one size fits all model that has failed to deliver on its promises. After having reviewed all the evidence in detail it becomes clear to me that standardized testing is not an effective system for educating students and does more bad than good

Read More
487 Words | 2 Pages

In the 1950s people of different races didn’t have equal rights. Thanks to the civil rights movements of Dr. Martin Luther King,. Jr. and his famous “I Have A Dream” speech that’s not how it is today. People may wonder how something that happened more than 50 years ago can still be affecting people today. I’ll say that for a fact, his movement has shaped my life.

Read More
1297 Words | 6 Pages

standard curriculum. All teachers must abide by the common core curriculum as well as promote students to get high scores on standardized testing in order to receive more funding for school activities. Mr. Hwong, however, believes that standardized testing is an unfair test to students based on knowledge that is designed “teach for the test” rather than teach for undestanding. Just as it states in Armstrong’s article, 15 Reasons Why Standardized Tests are Worthless, Standardized tests do not provide any feedback on how students can perform better, it does not value creativity in students, and it favors those who have socio-economical advantages. Mr. Hwong believes that it limits what the teacher is allowed to teach and constricts the student’s

Read More
754 Words | 4 Pages

For many students, they must retain knowledge for many different classes. The student can also be involved in other organizations. Standardized testing only measures a small portion of what a student learns. Standardized tests only measure knowledge, they do not measure a student’s creativity, curiosity, and other qualities that students have. These tests do not measure a student’s answer to a real world problem.

Read More
1334 Words | 6 Pages

Standardized Testing hurts children who think in different ways. This is quoted by Valerie Strauss, who makes a great point by saying children can only learn by the way it 's taught and it cannot be learned from other sources. Standardized Testing limits what children can learn and how they learn. Schools also spend an extraordinary amount on testing that could be going to better education and more funding to arts and extracurricular activities. Although, some say standardized testing is beneficial to the way students learn, statistics show that this is simply not true, standardized testing adds unnecessary stress on students, suppresses their creativity, and limits the creativity of teachers.

Read More
503 Words | 3 Pages

The tests damage the classroom experience because they take the fun out of learning. Teachers also spend more time teaching to the tests than actually doing other activities that help with the test such as worksheets that explain things that are on the test. Some classes spend more time doing things to prepare for the test than doing other activities. This paragraph explained why standardized tests take the fun out of learning and that teachers spend more time teaching to the test and that the tests should be cut down.

Read More
915 Words | 4 Pages

Standardized test causes kids and teachers to become stressed. Kids have to worry about passing the tests so they can graduate and the teachers begin focusing on helping students ‘pass’ the test. Teachers become so focused on the test that they began to “teach the test” when they do this it doesn’t teach the student other skills that they might need. Test don’t provide the knowledge, habits, or skills that they might need for college. Fairtest.org says “Measurement experts agree that no test is good enough to serve as the sole or primary basis for any important educational decisions.

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

Additionally, the lack of seriousness transitions into students being uninterested in school because they have to take unnecessarily long tests. Not only do standardized tests cause lack of school interest but they increase students stress. Having to sit through a test that impacts your grade, represents your intelligence, and future adds a lot of pressure to oneself. Overall, when standardized tests aren 't taken seriously the data collected makes it hard for educators to improve education, students lack motivation, and adds a lot of pressure to people 's everyday lives.

Read More
492 Words | 2 Pages

The Truth of Standardized Testing According to an unknown source, “What better way to prove something than to perform a task based on prior learning?” You see, students should have to take standardized tests! It helps students prepare for the road ahead. Not only that, but it helps officials evaluate school district’s success rate and the school districts evaluate their teachers!

Read More
1278 Words | 6 Pages

The standardized testing approves the act of comparing students with other students. Society puts pressure on conformity and reaching this unattainable image. The method of standardized tests does the exact same thing because, as James W. Popham (1999) states, these tests permit “…comparisons among students from only a small collection of items” (p.3). Students are pressured to score high on these tests just as teachers are pressured to learn all the material and then proceed to teach it in the time allotted. Not every student, or person for that matter, is born with the same abilities.

Read More
573 Words | 3 Pages

Annually, about 1.7 billion dollars are spent on standardized tests (Ujifusa). These tests waste a lot of money and do not improve education in any way. The 1.7 billion dollars that we waste could be spent on higher education, but instead it’s wasted on these tests. Students across America are struggling to pass their classes, and they could use more support from teachers. The money that we’re wasting on standardized tests could go to helping these students, but it’s practically thrown away.

Read More
1631 Words | 7 Pages

The misuse of testing surfaced because of data-driven educationists who have placed their trust in statistics but are ignorant of technical issues such as validity and reliability. Thus, the problem is not with the idea of standardized testing but with its misuse and

Read More
1159 Words | 5 Pages

These people see standardized testing as inaccurate and a false way of measuring academic achievement. That is only a few of the many things seen as cons for standardized testing. Along with that the tests fail to measure such important aspects such as creativity and critical thinking skills. Studies indicate that standardized tests reward superficial thinking and might discourage more interpretive thinking. Next, as a result of the small fragment of knowledge that is tested, standardized tests capture a incomplete picture of student achievement.

Read More

More about James 'Standardized Testing Vs. Education'

Related Topics

Open Document