ipl-logo

Kass's Argument On Genetic Technology

536 Words3 Pages

Now that the four arguments have been explained, it is possible to find a connection between all of them. The main connection is that the genetic technology is not the problem; the problem is the underlying reductionist philosophy. Kass argues that a result of technological advances is that we have accepted a view of a man that is no more than a material being controlled by his or her genes and environment (i.e. a vision of a man without free will or the possibility of ideals) (138). Therefore, the connection between all of the arguments is that they are coming from a religious perspective. For example, recall that part of Kass’s first argument was that it would be difficult justifying saying no to new genetic technologies when there promise …show more content…

Once everyone understands and respects the different philosophies we should listen to more of Kass’s advice, we must not allow the use of technology to grow with self-increasing limits. Instead, we need to use moral, intellectual, spiritual, and political rule to be certain that we are making the right decisions. Specifically it is essential that we focus on human freedom and dignity. For example, it worries me that a small number of scientists could increase their rule over a huge number of individuals by using genetic technology, resulting in decreased human freedom. A solution to this problem would be everyone using moral, intellectual, and spiritual rules in a political setting to make sure that a large number of voices are heard. It also troubles me that scientists could play God by deciding who is worthy of living and by designing the unborn. Regardless of deficiencies everyone should be viewed as an equal, especially because human diversification is an asset to all of us. I also agree with Kass that our suffering will only be shifted as health care continues to improve. The reason is that we have to focus on our spirituality in addition to our health. In this paper I have explained Kass’s arguments related to four areas of concern regarding genetic

Show More
Related

Dinesh D'souza Staying Human Summary

646 Words | 3 Pages

Through bio-technology parents attempt and succeed in changing their child, but this does not change the fact that humans exist as unique individuals. D’Souza states, “We are molecules, but molecules who know how to rebel.” When “designing” their offspring, parents forget that their children will mature into their own persons, with unique dispositions and futures in which they will decide their own

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Genetic Engineering In Harrison Bergeron

698 Words | 3 Pages

The Pros and Cons of Genetic Engineering also show that genetic engineering can lead to overpopulation and wars. First of all, in Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut Jr., everyone is the same and they have strict laws. In Harrison Bergeron, people are made to be the same by putting weights on strong people, making beautiful people wear ugly masks, and hindering smart people’s thoughts. In Jonas’ community, there is Sameness, which is making everything the

Read More

Ethics And The New Genetics The Dalai Lama Analysis

1414 Words | 6 Pages

The topics that he mentions involve things such as genetic manipulation as well as cloning. He begins by mentioning how this has been simply used for the growth of plants and crops, but he questions where this is potentially leading and how the future of the environment could potentially be destroyed in many ways. He makes a strong argument about this by saying, "But by doing these things, we are changing the genetic makeup, and do we really know what the long-term impact will be on the species of plants, on the soil, on the environment? There are obvious commercial benefits, but how do we judge what is really useful?" (133).

Read More

Fahrenheit 451 Modernization Analysis

620 Words | 3 Pages

Modernization of technology limited the freedom to think for one’s self. It has caused the people of the world to rely solely on orders and rules without thinking of the consequences of those actions. The technology once used to enhance your daily life, now runs it. All people who have succumbed to the advancement of technology have given up their freedom to think, and their ability to live life like it was meant to be lived.

Read More

Eugenics In John H. Evan's A Brave New World

564 Words | 3 Pages

Human eugenics has become a popular technology in the biology world of reproduction. The idea of conserving the superior traits and deleting the tainted traits has become an exciting movement where even novels like Brave New World has predicted us with the dramatic future of eugenics. Although the idea of deleting tainted traits such as disease seem ideal, the fear of creating “perfect” traits will create dominance from the upper class and will strip individualism. John H. Evan talks about the pros and cons of human eugenics in his article. Inspired by the novel Brave New World, Evans first introduces the idea of class separation between the selected designed babies.

Read More

Summary Of Building Baby From The Genes Up By Ronald M Green

1250 Words | 5 Pages

Hayes believes that the genetic modification will become a race which will lead to a greater divide in the population. Hayes argues that by using genetic modification the population will seek to enhance themselves for reasons cosmetic, athletic and cognitive reasons which would be passes of to their offspring who would later too enhance their offspring, leading to the eventual loss of the common human

Read More

Ronald M Green Babies Summary

620 Words | 3 Pages

Green briefly touches on gene therapy that aims to cure diseases in an individual. He also considers the fact that this is therapy is particularly risky and dangerous, he holds strong with his idea that, “if the disease is serious enough […] it is usually worth trying.” (pg. 56). Green then moves onto the second ‘square’ of this chapter-germline gene therapy. Green goes much more deeply into this section, mostly because this subject often

Read More

Science Vs. Progress In The Progressive Era

897 Words | 4 Pages

In today’s world, you can have your baby with blue eyes, perfect height, and how you want your baby to look when is old. Now we can even make a baby be born smart because now scientists are more specialized in genetic and how the genes work. For example, if women can’t have babies she can rent a belly from another woman so she can have the baby but the baby is going to have the DNA of the women who can’t have babies, not of the other woman. Is pretty impressive how today scientist can modify genetically the genes of babies before they are even born. Now in today’s world is almost possible to create the perfect baby if we want.

Read More

Yuval Levin's Essay Imagining The Future

2049 Words | 9 Pages

Yuval Levin’s essay ‘Imagining the Future’ is an essay that explores and debates the cultural, ethical, and political concerns that arise in modern society with the introduction of technology. In essence, it acts as a cautionary tale that reflects the potential adverse implications humanity faces with rapid breakthroughs in science and technology. As such, the central idea of this essay is to convince the audience that despite the multifaceted nature of our environment and the presence of our unconscious prejudice, it is still within our capability to create a better future for future generations. We can achieve this through the introduction of constructive conversations and the instillation of accountable leaders. Levin – a traditionalist

Read More

Technology In There Will Come Soft Rain

1174 Words | 5 Pages

This, as a result, will certainly cause humanity as a whole to lose their own instinct of independency and self-control. What will be left of society will most unfortunately be unbalanced, inefficient, and appalling. As a result, society should come to the conclusion that technology isn’t disastrous itself alone, it is the connection and reliance that we have with it that makes it disastrous. Before we come face to face with terrible and unexplainable situations, it is wise for us as a society to reach a decision to overcome this dependency and be able to function properly once again to continue to live a prosperous and fulfilling

Read More

Francis Fukuyama Genetic Engineering Summary

781 Words | 4 Pages

Fukuyama brings up topics that can be split into two categories: risks and benefits of genetic engineering along with the affordability of genetic engineering. Considering scientists aren’t entirely sure how genes work, they bring about several ills they wouldn’t be aware of, whether they be immediate ills or ills that show up much later (Fukuyama, 678). Genetic Engineering could have horrific effects on a population which could lead to the abandoning of genetic modification, just like in the way that hydroelectricity is no longer used as much because of the potential of dam breaks or environmental effects (Fukuyama, 680). There is also a possibility that only the rich will have access to this technology, so the state would possibly have to intervene to fix this inequality (Fukuyama, 680). Fukuyama concludes his writing by posing the fact that no matter what happens with genetic engineering, genetic engineering will change the course of human history on several levels, and on levels greater than that of any human biotechnology (Fukuyama, 681).

Read More

Government Control In Brave New World

1863 Words | 8 Pages

The novel serves as a warning against the dangers of government control and the suppression of personal freedoms in the pursuit of social stability. In today's world, we are constantly grappling with issues related to government surveillance, social conformity, and the tension between individuality and group cohesion. One of the most pressing issues facing contemporary society is the impact of technology on personal freedoms and individuality. With the rise of social media and other forms of digital communication, individuals are increasingly connected to one another, but also face new pressures to conform to social norms and expectations. Similarly, advances in genetic engineering and biotechnology raise important ethical questions about the limits of human intervention and the potential for government control.

Read More

Double Helix Nancy Werlin Summary

1450 Words | 6 Pages

That is my point Mr. Samuels. There’s a difference between using gene therapy for the treatment of existing medical conditions, and using our growing, but far from perfect, knowledge of genes to declare that we absolutely know who has a right and who hasn’t to live at all.” To me, what this quote is saying is, just because we can doesn’t mean we should. Even if we could see if a baby is not going to be healthy or “perfect” when it is born, do we have the right to deny it life? This is an extremely hard ethical decision to make.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Genetic Engineering

779 Words | 4 Pages

This essay will look more on the advantages and disadvantages of genetic engineering. Genetic engineering has some advantages. Firstly it allows for faster growth rate .Genetic engineering allows of plants or animals to be modified so their maturity can occur at a quicker pace outside of the normal growth conditions that are favourable without genetic changes as well .Secondly, it may also provide a cure for disease to improve health (apecsecadmin, 2014). Genetic engineering can be used to eradicate a number of incurable and deadly disease which could be done by identifying the genes that cause these disease, and manipulate them to prevent people from contracting these potentially deadly diseases.

Read More

Theory Of Evolution Essay

1006 Words | 5 Pages

He says that, “We can not select genes that are not in the gene pool of the species.” For example there is no gene for wings in the gene pool of a pig. Would you expect to see a new born pig with a growing set of wings? No, because it is not in it’s DNA. This is what natural selection is proposing.

Read More

More about Kass's Argument On Genetic Technology

Related Topics

Open Document