ipl-logo

Key Differences And Similarities Between Modern Australia And Amish Communities

1285 Words6 Pages

Modern Australian teenagers, to a great extent, can be considered to be living completely opposite lives to adolescents within Amish communities. This can be exemplified through concepts of family, roles and status, conflict, cooperation and decision making, gender, communication and power, authority and influence. All of these concepts will be explored in order to discover the key differences and similarities between the vastly different cultures of modern Australia and Amish communities.
Similar to most of these concepts, it was obvious where differences could be found among the cultures whereas similarities were hard to uncover. Comparing the two different family structures is difficult when they are made up completely different. Amish …show more content…

The similarities come from the Amish tradition of Rumspringa and the growing independence of Australian teenagers, which they typically gain at eighteen. Rumspringa can create conflict within the community due to the conviction of teenagers distributing drugs within the Amish community becoming more common. 9 This comes after the teenagers experiment with alcohol and illicit substances for the first time and can lead to a range of serious issues within the community. This is also an issue for Australian teenagers who too often delve into the world of drugs and alcohol which can cause issues and conflicts to arise, both socially and legally. Commerce is also a source of conflict within both Amish and Australian communities. Money often becomes too powerful and out of hand, creating conflict between people and businesses. Money often signifies success, especially in Australian society, therefore it turns to a competition to who can be best. A significant difference among the communities come from cooperation. The Amish community is based on a system of cooperation where the community comes together to work towards an end goal, an example of this being barn raising. While Australians do have a sense of community, help is usually done indirectly through things such as financial donations to a charity rather than participating in helping themselves. Within an Amish community, decision-making is done by the ministers, bishops and deacons for the entire community and the men within the family whereas Australian communities have the majority of decisions made by government institutions for the wider community and by both parents in a

Show More
Related
154 Words | 1 Pages

A system that is based on relationships such as ceremonial roles, funeral roles and who marries each other within the Aboriginal community. Family within the Aboriginal community is based on the kinship system where everyone is related to each other based on their beliefs and customs. Taking children away from their families and fostering them out to eligible organisations. This started as early as when the Europeans started to settle on the land. The children were used as servants or to work the land.

Read More
414 Words | 2 Pages

This type of stuff can be really awesome. Being a great person is always spectacular There are many differences between the Inca, an ancient population of Peru, and the Hopewell, a Native American tribe of Indiana. Their nutrition was varied, due to the climates they inhabited, and the tools and clothing they made were diverse of each other. The foods of the two tribes were individual to the tribe itself.

Read More
241 Words | 1 Pages

The Pima and The Maricopa The two tribes, the Pima and the Maricopa are united as one people on the Salt River Reservation. The SRPMIC was established in 1879 by President Rutherford B. Hayes. Both tribes have been dwelling on the desert for thousands of years. The culture, language, and pottery have many similarities and differences.

Read More
630 Words | 3 Pages

Critical Response 3: Amish Religion The Amish religion is governed by men. Only men are allowed to serve in positions of authority in the church. Women are even forbidden from holding ministry roles (Zavada).

Read More
50 Words | 1 Pages

Belonging to the land and to each other is fundamental to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and their culture. Connections with the land, families, clans and communities are at the core of Aboriginality. It is through these connections that nurture belonging from which Aboriginal peoples identities and cultures emerge.

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

Is a perfect world possible? Can a society be created in which equity, equal opportunity, and peace are completely prevalent? In my opinion, no, but, this is a debatable point. Dozens of unique societies have risen up since the beginning of history, however, none have yet managed to create a perfect community.

Read More
416 Words | 2 Pages

However, due to the ongoing issue of prejudice and ethnocentrism, it can be harder for them to achieve this. In Australia, it is believed that Australians have held overwhelmingly negative

Read More
1244 Words | 5 Pages

When I was sixteen, my family and I visited the Amish country. As we toured the area, I found myself very fascinated or interested in the vast grassland and the citizens pre industrial choice of living style. I see the beauty or significance in the Amish country. In my eyes, its as if we are going back in time to the pre industrial era. But in the eyes of my family it was just another day of buying iteams and touring a different society.

Read More
1025 Words | 5 Pages

The Amish are a community of people that nobody knows much about, but everybody wants to learn more about. In her essay “Becoming Literate: A Lesson From the Amish,” Andrea Fishman attempts to outline some of the principles of Amish culture and the way that the Amish raise their children. Her uncertain focus leads the reader to a whirlwind of thoughts while reading this essay and could confuse many readers that are paying close attention to her content. Fishman bases her essay around differences between the Amish child and the mainstream child and goes into detail about how each child is raised learning to read. She attempts to discredit the way that Amish children are taught to read, yet also praises the Amish and how they bring up children.

Read More
1579 Words | 7 Pages

Indigenous Australian youth still face numerous difficulties growing up in a modern Australian society, even though they are living in a time of ‘equality’ for all religions, races and genders. This paper examines the main cultural influences for indigenous youth, and challenges they face growing up. In particular, it will explore the ways in which Indigenous youth today continue to be affected, connected and interdependent to both a dominant white culture and indigenous culture. It also includes the reasons why the indigenous youth of Australia continue to be marginalized, oppressed and stereotyped while growing up in a society that claims to be an egalitarian democratic country. Examples of Indigenous youth from the film ‘Yolngu Boy’ are used to explore this topic.

Read More
953 Words | 4 Pages

“To what extent does religion influence Australian society?” Religion can be defined as “a personal or institutionalized set of attitudes, beliefs and practices, which may include a system of prayers and religious laws” (Peta Goldburg, 2009). It is to be questioned whether or not religion influences Australian society. This is evident in the education system of Australia, organisations that contribute to social welfare, in particular, the homeless and the influence of religious requirements on food. As time progresses, religious participation in Australia has become less prevalent, with the number of people affiliated with Christianity decreasing.

Read More
976 Words | 4 Pages

From the 1970’s Australians have been viewed as bush people as they were seeming as heroic and brave. Never the less, internationally, Australians have been showcased as vulgar, racist that have strong pride for their country. Consequently, Australia has also been viewed as an alcoholic nation as companies continuously push the stereotype to market their products. In turn, Australian’s collective identity is made up of multiple other stereotypes that have been fed into. Despite being incorrectly portrayed; the Australian identity has a positive effect on Australian culture.

Read More
1543 Words | 7 Pages

Manuel Diaz Ms. Elam Per. 2 ERWC November 20, 2015 Clashing Cultures: US vs. Amish All cultures/societies around the world have similarities and differences, some being more different than others. However, in the case of two societies, they are profoundly different. The Amish, a religious group mainly residing in the eastern part of the US, tend to be outsiders to society.

Read More
1000 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction There are many different types of cultures in society around the world, all with their own individual accepted ways of behaviour, some cultures might be familiar and others might seem strange to us. Cultures have their own set of norms to control acceptable behaviour. If we as fellow human beings all took the initiative to understand each other’s cultures, it might not seem that strange to us anymore and it is possible that we could help others in a way that is acceptable to the society in which we live in. The aim of this essay is to discuss, using a view based on the sociological imagination, whether a unique personal family issue can be related to an issue in society.

Read More
199 Words | 1 Pages

Many people tend to confuse Mormonism and the Amish. Although they’re both Christian Denominations, they have lots of differences. First of all, the Amish is primarily congregational, meaning the church is very independent. Their hierarchy is viewed as being not very important, as well as a central governing authority. On the other hand, Mormonism, is heavily hierarchical.

Read More

More about Key Differences And Similarities Between Modern Australia And Amish Communities

Related Topics

Open Document