ipl-logo

Martin Luther King Jr Vs Malcolm X Dbq

724 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Impact of Martin Luther King on the Civil rights movement

The Civil Rights Movement inspired racial harmony between blacks and whites in America. The Movement was led by many leaders and activists. Some of the biggest leaders/activists were Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X. They both had different philosophies on how to earn freedom and civil rights. The big question is whose philosophy was better in the 1960s. Martin Luther King believed that blacks and whites should join together as one country, but the only way to achieve that was through nonviolence. Malcolm X believed that blacks and whites should work separately, but have the same rights as one another. He also thought that blacks must achieve that through any means necessary. I believe that Martin Luther King had the better philosophy. He understood that violence wouldn’t fix everything, he was extremely determined, and he wanted the black and white communities to join together as one nation. I believe that MLK had the better philosophy because he understood that while violence may stop the racists for the time being, it will never end racism for good. He believes that violence may kill the person who is committing the crimes, but it won’t stop the crimes from being committed by someone else. In document J, MLK says, “Violence may murder the murderer, but it doesn’t murder the murder.” In document F, MLK says,”Basic …show more content…

He refused to stop fighting for his cause because of the destruction of their buildings and physical attacks. In document D, it states, “We are on the move now. The burning of our churches will not deter us. We are on the move now. The bombing of our homes will not dissuade us.” In document H, it states, “We will meet your physical force with soul force.” My interpretation of the first quote is that MLK would not be stopped by bombs or fires. In the second quote, it means that MLK would fight the violence with speeches and boycotts. Martin Luther King was determined to fight for his beliefs and never give

Show More
Related
724 Words | 3 Pages

MLK’s views on the economy was better. When his teachings were applied to all the blacks lives the outcome was just as he said. Income salaries were increased and store owners need to hire the blacks helping them in their

Read More
404 Words | 2 Pages

I agree with Jackie Robinsons method of civil disobedience even though he knows he can never be non-violent. I do not agree with Malcolm X and the nation of Islam approach because it is more violent and aggressive even though they do not want to live together with whites. I believe that the civil rights movement was about making a change for African Americans and the only way to make a change is through nonviolent acts. The civil rights movement was to make a change and Malcolm X and the nation of Islam's approach would have caused more problems than solved any for African Americans. Malcolm X believed that blacks should live separately from white's and he called it separation.

Read More
373 Words | 2 Pages

Though both Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X were initially fighting for equality, the manner each fought with was completely opposite. Malcolm believed in getting civil rights through violence while King strongly stood firm in his nonviolent approach. Martin Luther King believed that handling a situation with a non violent approach would be more powerful. As stated in document 6, he proposed to African Americans refusing to buy products that were produced by the white Americans who did not support civil rights. This would cut into the amount of profit that a company makes and would speak louder than acting out of anger and hate.

Read More
417 Words | 2 Pages

Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X are very important historical figures. Throughout the Civil Rights Movement they have created two different approaches. The beliefs grew from their childhood. King grew up in a middle class family and was well educated. Malcolm X however, grew up in a deprived atmosphere that was very harsh and he had barely any schooling.

Read More
498 Words | 2 Pages

Did Martin Luther King Jr have a better philosophy than Malcolm X? Martin Luther King Jr was born on January 15, 1929, in Atlanta Gorgia, he passed an entrance exam to Morehouse University at the age of 15 and studied the beliefs and non-violent tactics of Mahatma Ghandhi. Was Martin Luther King Jr’s Philosophy more effective than Malcolm X’s philosophy? Martin Luther King Jr had the better philosophy because of his economic strategy to slowly achieve racial equality, his ideas on why people should take a non-violent stance as a method of protest, and his drive and dream of better more equal society and education.

Read More
537 Words | 3 Pages

What MLK is saying is that the most effective way of dealing with a problem is nonviolence. In document L it states,”the Negro would face the same unchanged conditions, the same squalor, and deprivation, the only difference being that his bitterness would be

Read More
1512 Words | 7 Pages

Philosophical differences between martin luther king and malcolm X The philosophical differences between Martin Luther King and Malcolm X have to do with the their protest strategies. MLK never fought with violence. Although he would get physically attacked, he stood his ground and continued to fight for equality peacefully. King believed that whites and blacks should come together to end the hate and violence.

Read More
857 Words | 4 Pages

Martin Luther King’s string of peaceful protests against the self-thought superior white race is what earned him the Nobel Peace Prize, Malcolm X spit hot fire against the white man’s oppression on African Americans, stating that they were blocking the path in civil rights progression. Both public figures fought for the same goal of equal treatment and opportunity, but the actions taken by this duo to reach this goal were anything but the same. When you have two ingenious men battling for the same cause, progression is bound to happen, another given is one will stride farther than the other, and in this case that’s exactly what Malcom X did. One of the reasons Malcom X and Martin Luther King were so different has to do with how they grew up,

Read More
606 Words | 3 Pages

Martin Luther King Jr.’s civil rights philosophy made more sense for the 1960’s. During the 1960’s the civil rights movement proved prominent. Through the 60’s thousands of leaders rose, but only two emerged above the rest. Those two were known as Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X. Both Martin and Malcom were very intelligent men but the two had totally different views on how blacks should go about gaining civil rights. Both proved to be pioneers of the movement, however it was Martins philosophy that reigned supreme.

Read More
576 Words | 3 Pages

During the 1960’s, Martin Luther King Jr. had the best philosophy compared to his counterpart, Malcolm X. They both have different methods of solving racism and having civil rights for black Americans. Martin Luther King Jr. wanted to solve racism and to have civil rights peacefully and nonviolently. Malcolm X on the other hand, wanted to solve racism and to have civil rights by any means necessary.

Read More
718 Words | 3 Pages

Martin luther king and Malcolm X were two well known speakers. But there has always been the same question being asked around, whose philosophy is better? Mlk is a supporter of non violence. So is Malcolm X, but his beliefs are a little different than Martin Luther King 's. Malcolm x does not like violence but he does encourage it when the other party starts the disagreement. Mlks believes if the other party has started it you do not fight or hurt them.

Read More
411 Words | 2 Pages

The violence is immoral. There were a lot of violence. MLK believed that violence ends by protecting itself. He thinks that Negro cannot win the respect for white people. He believes that people are going to change when he does this.

Read More
1974 Words | 8 Pages

Martin Luther King and Malcolm X were two influential men who served as important figures for the Civil Rights Movement. The two men came from diverse backgrounds and had contrasting views in life about religion and African American’s stance in society. Malcolm X was born in Nebraska and had great amounts of exposure to racism. Martin Luther King was born in an educated family in Atlanta, where he experienced racism, but to a lower extreme than Malcolm X. Although they passed away long time ago, they continue to live on today in a world independent of segregation. Martin Luther King and Malcolm X used opposing principles to achieve equality for blacks; King utilized integration of both races and nonviolence as opposed to Malcolm X who separated the same races and employed non violence so as to achieve the same goal.

Read More
1125 Words | 5 Pages

Martin Luther King Jr said,“We must learn to live together as brothers or perish together as fools”. In the late 1960s, racial tension was high, African Americans were not given the right to vote, the right to a fair education, and the right to a fair judgement. This then led to the separation of schools and the destruction of a normal livelihood. Dr.King and Malcolm X, two men in the face of oppression rose up to challenge the racial barrier, thus changing the world forever. Although Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X seem to have mutual respect and an equal understanding of the inequality, their philosophies were quite different from each other.

Read More
783 Words | 4 Pages

One well known leader of the movement was Malcom X, Martin and Malcolm’s banter throughout the movement was the friendly kind, But they had one big difference in getting their message across. Malcolm X resorted in violence against white people to imprint a message about racism while Martin Luther King used a nonviolent tactic and befriended some white leaders that would help him spread his words. Though many people agree with Malcom X’s strong ways of getting the message across, both leaders have an effective way of spreading their ideas. In the Autobiography of MLK they devote a chapter of the book to explain the relationship between Martin and Malcolm, chapter 25 “All of these were signs of a man with passion and zeal seeking a program through which he could channel his talents.” Although they seem

Read More

More about Martin Luther King Jr Vs Malcolm X Dbq

Open Document