ipl-logo

Maybe We Need Segregated Schools Link Byfield Summary

745 Words3 Pages

In Link Byfield's article "If Girls Can Succeed Only at the Expense of Boys, Maybe We Need Segregated Schools" the author explores the changing statistics of academic success between boys and girls in the school system. This essay seeks to critically assess Byfield's flaws in his argument. He argues that both genders would academically perform better if separated by gender. He examines the latest results from the School Achievement Indicators Program (SAIP). Link Byfield notes that while females are still lagging behind boys in reading and writing, they have made progress in math and science. Byfield wonders whether girls' advancements must come at the expense of guys and expresses worries about whether this reflects progress or regression. He mentions previous critiques of the educational system's preference for boys and offers the idea of sex-based classroom segregation as a solution. Byfield's primary arguments are that there are gender differences in academic performance, that boys' performance is dropping, and that divided classes could be a feasible solution. …show more content…

He bases his whole paper on statistics from the National School Achievement Indicators Program (SAIP), conducted cooperatively by Statistics Canada and the Council of Ministers of Education. To provide an example, he claims that “The number of girls graduating is rising, to the point where there are now more girls finishing than boys” (Byfield, par. 3. Then, the sand is sanded. This piece of context and many others provide no other resources to back up his statements. Not only is the SAIP the only evidence he provides, but Byfield is not confident and agrees it is “far from conclusive” towards the subject (Byfield, par. 1). 2). The adage of the adage. He offers his own and his wife's personal experiences in school as data which is not enough when thinking critically to solve an

Show More
Related

Of The Article 'Unequal Opportunity' By Professor Linda Darling-Hammond

685 Words | 3 Pages

Darling-Hammond broke the article into different sections which made the flow of the paper easier to read and understand when a new topic was introduced. By separating the sections of the article, she allowed a new discussion to occur underneath the overall topic of unequal opportunity with education. The author also used factual information to further back the observations being made. An example of this would be when she started the discussion about the end of legal segregation within the school systems and noted the scores of African-American students Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) to climb 54 points between 1976 and 1994, while the white students remained the same (Darling-Hammond,. 1998). Darling-Hammond brings this statistic into the article because it strengthens her argument that equal opportunity for education causes students to achieve better overall grades and test scores due to the availability of resources.

Read More

Summary Of Outliers By Malcolm Gladwell

958 Words | 4 Pages

He wants to present data to his readers in a way they can understand, using simple and in a way that is persuasive language in the hopes of encouraging change and the way we think about the world and the people within it. It is especially the educators, policy makers and parents These identified groups of people who are the ones most likely to to be able to produce a change in the way peoplewe think about achieving success in the world. These people have the ability to influence and alter educational policies presently in effect that were primarily influenced by Stanford professor Lewis Terman. According to Terman?s incorrect hypothesis, his very influential studies that tracked children, known as ?

Read More

Analysis Of School Bands Should Not Be Entertainment Adjunct For Sports By Frank Deford

850 Words | 4 Pages

In his opening argument Deford references Myles Brand, but he never quotes or gives a full view of the response from Brand. Brand responds to a previous piece Deford wrote, but Deford fails to addresses the text Brand is commenting on. The reader questions the previously written information and why no account of the previous article exists. Also, Deford fails to provide statistics of the numbers of scholarships awarded to collegiate athletes and to band members. The reader does not understand how substantial the difference in numbers of scholarships awarded.

Read More

Summary Of Hidden Intellectualism By Gerald Graff

1257 Words | 6 Pages

Without facts of any kind his argument lacks any sort of authority. Had Graff provided statistics about kids using material they like to write academic papers and doing far better than traditional papers his claim would have been much more credible. Another part of Graff’s childhood that he discusses is how boys his age were divided into “…clean-cut boys like me and working class hoods…” (Graff, 382). He talks about how he struggled maintaining a balance between being smart and being tough.

Read More

Summary Of Against School By John Gatto

667 Words | 3 Pages

The essay intends to persuade and provoke the reader. By using non-statistical based evidence Gatto manages to build a solid case for their being problems with the education system, however, his solution to these problems is incredibly lackluster. The solution Gatto presents is simply for the reader to teach their own children, rather than have them schooled. The problem with this is that this solution will only ever apply to people who read Gatto’s essay, it fixes none of the problems with the education system. The lackluster solution is even more sad since Gatto presents good evidence that the issues are systemic, and by ignoring a potential solution the essay reads more like a consumer warning than a serious treatise on the education

Read More

Similarities Between Frederick Douglass And Malala Yousafzai

557 Words | 3 Pages

This article says “formal education for girls historically has been secondary to that of boys.” Throughout history the normal roles of society were the boys did all the heavy duty jobs while the girls stayed at home and helped out around the house. From 1870 to 1985 the amount of women attending college by 30%. Also the amount of undergraduate degrees has risen 40% since the beginning of the 20th century. We are still the minority in colleges but we are slowly working our way up to the top of our

Read More

Missing In Interaction By Myra And David Sadker

288 Words | 2 Pages

The social institution of education maintains inequalities through the demonstration of two of our assign readings. First, the reading Missing in Interaction by Myra and David Sadker is an essay that was based on how segregation exists in the classrooms and the impact it has on both boy and girls (Ore, 2011b; 305). Their main argument is that sexism occurs in the classroom without the teachers realizing it. Teachers tend to focus more on the boys than girls when a class discussion begins. There are two examples within this essay that demonstrates this.

Read More

Why Johnny Won T Read: Gender Stereotypes

1055 Words | 5 Pages

In Why Johnny Won't Read by Mark Bauerlein and Sandra Stotsky, they state, ¨From 1992 to 2002, the gender gap in reading by young adults wid­ened considerably. In overall book reading, young women slipped from 63 percent to 59 percent, while young men plummeted from 55 percent to 43 percent.¨ This shows that although girls did decrease by a slight percent, boys were still below them. It shows that boys have a disadvantage when it comes to education because they may be concentrated in other things such as sports for example that they don't portray the same amount of concentration that they have on the sport onto their education status. In addition, in Mind Over Muscle by David Brooks, he states ¨In high school, girls get higher grades in every subject, usually by about a quar­ter of a point, and have a higher median class rank.

Read More

How Boys Learn Rhetorical Analysis

1633 Words | 7 Pages

Others say that the idea of segregating boys and girls is part of the problem and that the best way to solve the problem is to stop looking at boys and girls as being so different and to look at them as individuals rather than as two groups. The view is represented

Read More

The Boys At The Back Summary

1074 Words | 5 Pages

For a long time now girls have been behind boys in schooling, which can be attributed to the misconceptions in the past regarding females limited capacity for learning. Yet, after all the centuries of girls being left in the dark concerning schooling they have not only caught up to the boys, they have surpassed them. The article, “The boys at the Back” by Christina Hoff Sommers, talks about how girls now receive better grades than boys and the implications that come with it. Christina Hoff Summers is a Scholar who studies the relationship between gender, sexuality, and politics. As an expert in gender, sexuality, and politics she is very knowledgeable about this topic and can provide accurate information.

Read More

Calvin White Schools

803 Words | 4 Pages

The overall percentage of the boys in the academic classes are decreasing as the female success rates are increasing. Teachers and others in higher positions are slowly forgetting about the existence of boys

Read More

Mission Statement For Xavier University

616 Words | 3 Pages

The mission statement of Xavier University of Louisiana states, “The ultimate purpose of the University is to contribute to the promotion of a more just and humane society by preparing its students to assume roles of leadership and service in a global society.” My educational goals are to successfully complete fours of undergraduate education and receive my bachelors degrees in Biology. I also plan on applying to and going to medical school upon receiving my bachelors in Biology. My career goals are to practice obstetrics and gynecology. With much practice and skill I hope to work towards having my own practice in this field, being able to accommodate all types of people.

Read More

A College Education Is Worth The Cost

1309 Words | 6 Pages

Additionally, in paragraph 3, when he says, “Concerns regarding student indebtedness and educational quality are legitimate,” he is acknowledging an opposing argument. At this point, he does not refute this argument in which he should have done. This makes him lose his power in persuasion. Though Smith remains unsupported to his assertion at some point in paragraph 3 and 7, Smith’s article is effective in using facts, examples, appeal to the emotions, logical organization, and stylistic techniques to convince his audience.

Read More

School Dress Code Essay

895 Words | 4 Pages

Women are treated as minorities, even though the majority of females do better in school, they are still graded on different standards. This could be one of the main reasons why the female gender does better in school is because they are graded on a lower level than their male classmates. Women succeed in their schooling even

Read More

Annotated Bibliography On Gender And Mastery

1607 Words | 7 Pages

(2002) contend that equal opportunity may not necessarily result in parity of male-female representation across all areas of the educational spectrum due to differences in gender-based preferences. Males are more likely to earn degrees in inorganic sciences and engineering than females, and females earn more degrees in health and medicine (Benbow et al., 2000; Sadler et al., 2012). Lubinksi et al. (1992) argue that this difference is partially due to male students’ abilities but mostly because of their preferences. In fact, mathematically talented women tended to be more verbally talented than mathematically talented men; therefore women tend to gravitate toward opportunities that draw on their verbal skills (Webb et al., 2002).

Read More

More about Maybe We Need Segregated Schools Link Byfield Summary

Open Document