ipl-logo

Medical Care Analysis Essay

1385 Words6 Pages

The Analysis of Today’s Medical Care In healthcare, the patient's best interest is supposed to be the top priority. An article from The New York Times written by Pamela Hartzband and Jerome Groopman, two physicians, shows how health care may be going away from caring for the individual in order to look out for the population. The physicians use lots of ethos, logos, and pathos to build a strong argument informing the audience as to why they think medical care is becoming corrupt. The physicians begin their article stating what every patient should expect when they into the hospital; the best interest for themselves. Hartzband and Groopman are informing that medical care may be turning away from the best interest of an individual to the best …show more content…

The way physicians Hartzband and Groopman build their argument is well put together. Logos is a big part of the article because the physicians know the medical field well, and as they make their argument, they make a point to include facts to provide real medical situations to the reader. The physicians' credibility is created by the use of facts that prove they are up to date with their information and know how patients are affected by certain situations. They also include the counter-argument to their argument and use facts to prove why they are more correct. That adds on to how credible this article is. Pathos comes into play while the physicians use typical patient questions and show the struggle doctors face. The authors also use bold words such as “...never have an incentive to override the best interests…” and “...diminishing the autonomy of…” The physicians have a really strong argument because each appeal compliments the other. The only thing that is questionable is how this article relates to today. It was written in 2014 and I don’t know if this article has had an impact on the healthcare world. I also do not have all of the sources to get this answered completely. It would be interesting to know if these concerns were addressed or if the healthcare still faces these

Show More
Related

Metaphors And Models Of Doctor-Patient Relationship Summary

633 Words | 3 Pages

In James F. Childress and Mark Siegler’s article, “Metaphors and Models of Doctor-Patient Relationships: Their Implications for Autonomy,” they discuss the types of relationships in healthcare and how those relationships allow the physician and patient to interact to make negotiations. Childress and Siegler say that relationships are either between intimates or between strangers and that when it is between strangers there is a lack of trust because of the way physicians are viewed most days. Because of the way society has turned to rules and regulations and the pluralistic nature of our society, physicians are often viewed as technicians and contractors rather than as parents or friends. Often times people refuse to visit the doctor’s office because there is a lack of trust towards the idea of a physician rather than the physician herself. Health care has become dictated by economics and politics, which are fields people consider to be cold and calculating.

Read More

Analysis Of Ken Murray's Essay 'How Doctors Die'

526 Words | 3 Pages

By this time, the patients will have undergone extreme and undignified situations, and their families will have spent thousands of dollars. This isn’t anyone’s fault in particular, he writes, “in many ways all the parties are simply victims of a larger system that encourages excessive treatment.” Doctors, he writes, often opt out of this system. Murray volunteers “Charlie,” a renowned orthopedist and his personal mentor, as an example.

Read More

Managed Care Ethics Paper

584 Words | 3 Pages

It necessitates the physician to keep their patients’ information confidential, to avoid mischief and sexual misconduct, and to give no harmful or lethal agents. In short, the physician must become their patients’ advocate, using their professional knowledge and the patient's trust for the patient's good. Managed care forces physicians to balance the interests of their individual patients with the interests of other patients in the system by requiring them to ration care and constrain costs, and may place the physician in a position where the needs of their patients are in conflict with his own financial interests. The physician’s income may be at risk also because many managed care organizations drop physicians who incur higher cost treatments than their colleagues, even though they take care of sicker patients. This fear of retribution for providing appropriate, but more expensive care can become a powerful force in distorting physicians' clinical judgment.

Read More

Biomedical Ethics Book Report

963 Words | 4 Pages

David Hollie REl 524 Week 11 Book Report Tom L Beauchamp is a Professor of Philosophy and James F Childress is a professor of ethics at historical colleges in the United States. Together they are co-authors of the book “Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 7th Edition”.(Oxford University Press,2016). The four principles that are considered to be the core of moral reasoning in health care today include autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, and justice are explored in this book. The book itself gives the reader a look into morality in dealing with the health care profession.

Read More

Ethical Issues In Managed Care

421 Words | 2 Pages

Most physicians in the surveys believed that managed care prevent them from using their ability to put the patient's interest first and to avoid conflicts of interest with their patients. According to the survey, "forty-nine indicated negative effects when respecting their patients' autonomy. These finding, along with the concerned expressed above, that under managed care cost cutting took top priority over the quality of patient care and as a result trouble conflicted in the interest for physicians and patient care (Feldman, Novack, & Gracely,

Read More

Jean Brody As A Conflict Of Interest

285 Words | 2 Pages

According to Brody, conflict of interest is “the criticism of close ties between the medical professionals and the pharmaceutical and medical device industries” (Brody, 23). In this article, Brody mentions the ethical viewpoints on when conflict of interest gets brought up in a health care setting. Since Brody has his own opinion, he will also address those opinions that are opposing to him. For example, some people view the relationship as a conflict of interest and some people view the relationship in terms of potential loss of trust between patients in general the AAFP (Brody, 24).

Read More

Pharmacy Field Experience Essay

1288 Words | 6 Pages

Overall, no matter the health profession, all healthcare providers have an obligation of doing no harm to patients and practicing a patient/person-centered approach. In addition, healthcare providers must help to the fullest extent based on their training and credentials. Equally important is to always demonstrate honesty and integrity, while maintaining compassion and confidentiality. Patients come in all shapes, sizes, races, backgrounds, and as such, should all be respected and treated equally. Lastly, in order to provide the best care possible, all professional knowledge must remain current (via continuing education, seminars, or trainings) as new health technologies, new medications and devices, or advances in medicine emerge.

Read More

Healthcare Ethical Dilemmas

1470 Words | 6 Pages

Undeniably, the issue on providing everyone with an immediate access to basic medical care and services remains to be a concern (Larson, 2013). In fact, America's health insurance program for seniors and the disabled has become more expensive (NPR, 2013). Furthermore, Gerard Migaill, PhD, noted that there are still questions about implementing the healthcare reform law, as well as the expansion of the Medicaid (as cited in Larson, 2013). Ultimately, “access to basic care is a hallmark of a civilized society” and if many are still unable to have access to it, that is considered as a problem (Larson, 2013). 3.

Read More

Doublethink In George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four

645 Words | 3 Pages

The judgment of clinicians is a far better guide. Medical practice must rely on a variety of inputs. There are several themes running through this book. The most prominent theme is the restoration of a genuine free market in medical care—not the “market” touted by corporations, but a market more akin to the traditional free market and Greek and Medieval medical care. Even free markets operate under constraints, the fewer the better—these have traditionally included science, humanitarian and ethical concerns.

Read More

Health Care Ethics Case Study

1464 Words | 6 Pages

Morrison, EdH MPH, LPC, CHESS, a professor in the School of Health Administration at Texas State University and Berth Furlong, PhD, HD, RN, an associate professor in the Center for Health Policy and Ethics at Creighton University in Omaha, Nebraska. In chapter one of the print book, Theory of Health Care Ethics, Summer, a contributor contributes a scholarly account of the main theories that apply to the ethics of health care situations. His contribution was based on the fact that one needs a foundation in ethics to be able to have a structure upon which one can defend the many issues arising from the complexities of health care in the 21st century. He reasons that as health care is becoming sophisticated, it will come along with a corresponding complex issues bothering on ethics and for that matter it is a necessity, as a player in the health care industry, acquire knowledge in ethical principles which would make one versatile in handling the challenges that will come about as a result of the constantly expanding scope of

Read More

Social Contract In Health Care

853 Words | 4 Pages

Health is a right for all humans. The fact that providers were taking advantage and overcharging patients at a service for fee payment plan with inflated charges the pressure from the public for greater transparency is gradually changing because the contract

Read More

Economic Analysis In Healthcare

745 Words | 3 Pages

The first commitment of an ethical physician is to the patient. However, money could prevent that commitment to the patient. Physicians might think that small improvements for clinical outcomes is not worth the money. When money is spent to make medical improvement, it should be based on medical care that would have a greater benefits or meaningful purpose. In order to improve the physician's choices, they should be taught to use social and individual resources for clinical interventions.

Read More

Effect Of A Shifting Culture On Healthcare Management

1685 Words | 7 Pages

The healthcare industry is currently undergoing mass-scale changes causing providers to adapt to new ways of doing things. It is the dream of every provider to give out the best service by the use of the most accurate and newest test and treatments. The United States healthcare system has been poor for a very long time; the greatest fault comes from the fragmentation of the delivery system which leads to low quality service in the country despite the highly skilled professionals. Neglected health care services usually arise from the primary stakeholders; patients, providers, employers, payers and the government in the healthcare system. Jonas, Goldsteen & Goldsteen (2012) explains that the patients form the greatest stakeholders in the healthcare system.

Read More

Transformation Of Ethics In Healthcare Over The Past Century

175 Words | 1 Pages

Hello, Professor & Classmates; The transformation of ethics in healthcare over the past century involves prominent ethical and value-based theories such as deontology, utilitarianism, moral relativism, absolutism, virtue ethics and ethics of care. The foundation of fundamental ethical principals in healthcare are: autonomy-the level of respect for someone and the capacity to make decisions that affect their health; beneficence-goes beyond prevention to moral action, it deals in respect of individualism and how to nurture this in subordinates; nonmaleficence-the prevention of harm bestowed upon individuals, creating a safe practice environment for treatment; and justice-expeditiously treating people with fairness and meeting their needs at any

Read More

Health Care Ethics Study Guide

538 Words | 3 Pages

“Ethics, Professional Ethics,and Health Care Ethics” The main topic of Chapter 1 “Ethics, Professional Ethics, and Health Care Ethics” is health care ethics and how it applies to the health care fields and the ethical decisions made by patients. The chapter begins by giving us an insight in ethics as a branch of philosophy. Philosophy discusses the capabilities of the human mind relating to the nature of reason and reality. Ethics determines if human actions may be considered right or wrong. The chapter states that ethics does attack religion but rather, “ethics and religion consider the same problems and share important insights”.

Read More

More about Medical Care Analysis Essay

Open Document