ipl-logo

Michele Hanisee's Arguments Against The Death Penalty

807 Words4 Pages

Brooke O’Connell
Ms. Osborne
Advanced Writing
Sept. 26, 2017
Death Penalty Currently there are 3,035 people waiting on death row for a set execution date. Inmates who have been charged with crimes such as rape, murder, and treason. These inmates are waiting to receive the ultimate punishment. The death penalty. The death penalty is a punishment for those who are convicted a capital crime. The result of this, execution. The death penalty has been a punishment in America since 1608. It continues to be a controversial topic with many different views and arguments dividing this country between people for and against this punishment. Each side has several arguments to justify the reasoning of their beliefs. A main argument for those that are …show more content…

Hanisee believes that the death penalty is a must and made it clear that people against the death penalty shouldn’t fear of innocent people getting executed because twelve citizens must agree on the death verdict not just one person. This is true, each trial includes twelve jurors (citizens who know nothing of the sentenced person or of the crime) to decide if the inmate did such a horrendous crime to deserve the ultimate punishment, death. All twelve jurors must come up with an agreed decision. Hanisee believes that innocent people could not be convicted with twelve jurors watching the trial.
Nebraska state senator, Ernie Chambers disagrees with Hanisee and claims innocent people have been executed even with the jury. He proclaims, “Over 150 people in the last few years have been taken off death row because they were innocent.” 150 people who went to trial with a jury of twelve and was still found guilty for a crime they didn’t commit. He then suggests that there has had to have been several innocent people executed from a crime they were charged with, to later be found innocent. Yet, it was too late. To abolish the death penalty is to save innocent people from …show more content…

Richard C. Dieter, former director of the death penalty information center says, “All of the studies conclude that the death penalty system is far more expensive than an alternative system in which the maximum sentence is life in prison.” Dieter and many against the death penalty have a problem with the expense of death penalty when life in prison keeps criminals off the streets and is much cheaper. The latest study showed cases were the death penalty cost over one million dollars as cases without cost over $700,000. This doesn’t seem like a ton of a difference until it comes out of taxpayers pockets. It cost taxpayers approximately $90,000 more each year for an inmate who is on death row. Robert Evnen, Co-founder of Nebraskans for the death penalty agrees with the expense of the death penalty but blames the cost on “decades of appeals.” He even comes up with a suggestion to fix the cost by “limiting the number of appeals.” Evnen understands that numbers don’t lie, but relizes that most of the cost comes from multiple trials and appeals. He believes that the death penalty is appropriate in certain times and comes up with a plan to limit the amount of money coming from taxpayers

Show More
Related

In The Case Of Atkins V. Virginia, Daryl Atkins

671 Words | 3 Pages

One side of the argument, Legal Director of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, Kent Scheidegger stated that, “...for some crimes any lesser punishment is inadequate as a matter of basic justice… I believe that an effective, enforced death penalty deters some murders.” On the flip side, Death Penalty Focus, an organization that wants to abolish capital punishment, voiced that, “We believe that the death penalty is ineffective, cruel. It… diverts attention and financial resources away from preventative measures that would actually increase public safety, risks the execution of innocent people, and does not deter crime.” When Kent Scheidegger talks about the death penalty being adequate, he shows how different his view of the human condition is versus the Death Penalty Focus’ view stating that it is ineffective, targeting, and cruel. In the case Gregg v Georgia, Justice William J. Brennan addresses, “In the punishment of death, it treats ‘members of the human race as nonhumans, but instead as objects to be toyed with and discarded.”

Read More

Analysis Of Abolishing The Death Penalty By Sean Mcelwee

559 Words | 3 Pages

In 2013, Sean McElwee, a researcher and writer based in New York, published an article called “It’s Time to Abolish the Death Penalty.” He believes the death penalty needs to be abolished due to it being unjust, ineffective, and costly ways of dealing with convicts. McElwee is currently a policy analyst; he produced innovative new research and analysis on democracy issues. The article provides a well established base of ideas that include personal evidence, statistics and history; this evidence he provides builds a strong case of how the death penalty weakens the purpose of our criminal justice system.

Read More

Green's Argument In Favor Of The Death Penalty

511 Words | 3 Pages

6 in 10 americans favor the death penalty for convicted murderers. There is no question that killing another person is the most heinous crime that one can commit. Yes, most prisoners convicted in death row are murders but there has been cases where someone innocent has been wrongly executed. For example, of this failure is the case of Roosevelt Green, who was executed in Georgia for the kidnapping and murder of a young woman. According to author David Bruck, "Green swore that his companion shot her . . .

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Green Party

1332 Words | 6 Pages

and I really do not know what my stance is. Both sides have good points, and on one hand I believe it is immoral and does not serve any justice especially if someone is falsely convicted, but for some crimes I believe if guilty it isn’t that horrible of a punishment. On the topic of false conviction and how many people on death row tend to be innocent, the the article “Justice Is Not Served with the Death Penalty” by Raymond Lesniak explains it well, stating that “Since 1973, 130 human beings on death rows throughout the United States have been released from jail for being wrongfully convicted. During that time, over 1,100 prisoners were executed. How many of them were innocent?

Read More

Punishment: Ethical Considerations Of The Death Penalty In The United States

1012 Words | 5 Pages

According to the natural law, everyone's lives matter. Despite what crime an individual has committed it is still morally wrong to kill. Innocent people have been executed because of this form of punishment. Levy states, the innocence rate for death row inmates is 4.1%. Similarly, since 1973, there have been 144 people on death row that have been exonerated (Levy 2016).

Read More

Argumentative Essay: The State Of Indiana Death Penalty

593 Words | 3 Pages

In the United States there are many concerns on if the death penalty is or is not a form of cruel and unusual punishment. There are also many heated debates on if the death penalty should be illegal or remain legal. This report will discuss the cost, most used method and circumstances in which a person is not able to be executed. Many people say that the death penalty costs too much. According to the Death Penalty Information center (death penaltyinfo.org) in the state of Indiana.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Death Penalty In America

1276 Words | 6 Pages

Many prisoners waiting on death row usually end up waiting for years in confinement for execution, and to make things worse, sometimes the execution will be fully set up and before it can occur,

Read More

Why Is Capital Punishment Deadly Wrong

635 Words | 3 Pages

Capital Punishment:The Deadly Truth The death penalty is the punishment of execution, administered to someone legally convicted of a capital crime. People in the United States are constantly debating over capital punishment and if it is beneficial in our society. One side of the debate states that some people can redeem themselves and that it is inhumane. Others claim that the inmates are guilty and should suffer the consequences for their actions.

Read More

John Coffey's Arguments Against The Death Penalty

1185 Words | 5 Pages

According to Amnesty International, a human rights organization, the United States ranks fifth in the top 10 countries that impose the most executions world-wide. In fact, as of 2012, the U.S. executed only 36 fewer people than its war enemy, Iraq (Rogers and Chalabi). According to Oregonians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty (OADP), since capital punishment was reinstated in the U.S. in 1976, 138 people were removed from death row after later being found not guilty (“Facts”). Byler points out that proponents of capital punishment may say that if we kill 99 guilty people, and only one innocent person, then the benefit is greater than the detriment. However, this very thinking contradicts our justice system that believes a defendant is “innocent until proven guilty,” by basically saying that justice doesn’t even pertain to capital punishment.

Read More

The Controversy Surrounding The Death Penalty Today

1702 Words | 7 Pages

The death penalty, or capital punishment, is one of the most controversial topics that is still debated about in America today. People question whether it is morally justifiable, or even if it is actually about justice itself. The more people question these things, the clearer it becomes in the long run. The death penalty is about justice, not revenge, as it allows for justice to be dealt to those who have committed unimaginable crimes. It begins to make us feel safer knowing that these heinous criminals have been put down.

Read More

The Controversial Issues Surrounding The Death Penalty

505 Words | 3 Pages

Death sentences are imposed in a criminal justice system that treats you better if you are rich and guilty than if you are poor and innocent,” (Stevenson). Stevenson’s claim proves that there is bias in the selection process for those who are chosen for capital punishment. Also, there is a higher possibility that in the biased selection process that potentially innocent prisoners are executed over those who are more guaranteed to have committed the crime. Some people will argue that the death penalty is given to those who deserve the punishment in return for terrible and merciless crimes and that life in prison is not enough payment for the crime. Though many others believe and eye for an eye is not successful in achieving anything besides ridding of a dangerous person, even though they are incarcerated and typically incapable of causing more harm.

Read More

Opposing Views On Death Penalty

1615 Words | 7 Pages

For perhaps as long as mankind has existed, the concept of death has been one of discomfort, confusion, fear, and greatly of opinion. There are many themes within the confines of the greater topic of death that affect ones’ opinion on the matter, making it even more complex. Many questions are likely to arise when death is the subject, but in more recent history, the death penalty is one area that grabs the spotlight. In the United States, we see this hotly debated topic flip flop every ten years or so between a more unanimous “yes” or “no” regarding approval of the death penalty as punishment for capital crimes.

Read More

Controversy: The Anti-Death Penalty Reform

1394 Words | 6 Pages

The death penalty has been a system of punishment since its establishment in 1608 when Captain George Kendall became the first recorded execution in the new colonies. As the deaths caused by the death penalty per year began to lower, the levels of controversy surrounding its use began to rise. Today the death penalty has become more of a burden than a boon to society. I believe that in its current form the death penalty is a costly, discriminatory, and cruel system that needs to be reformed. One reason the current death penalty needs to be reformed is it costly system..

Read More

Timothy Evans Arguments Against Capital Punishment

1009 Words | 5 Pages

One of the most cogent arguments against Capital Punishment is the fact that innocent people have been killed due to flaws in the justice system. Witnesses, prosecutors and jurors can all make mistakes, which could cost an innocent persons life, and these mistakes cannot be put right. In 1979, a total of 69 people have been released from death row in the US after evidence of their innocence had emerged. A historic example of this would be the Timothy Evans case in 1950 which was one of the most dreadful miscarriages of justice ever in the British legal system. Timothy Evans was wrongly convicted with the murder of his wife and daughter, and was therefore executed for a crime he had not committed and was further given a royal pardon in 1966.

Read More

Why We Should Death Penalty Be Illegal

505 Words | 3 Pages

Death penalty has existed for as long as we know. It is most common in dictatorships, but it is also performed in places that are usually considered more or less liberal, such as the USA. Each year, around 250 people are added to the so-called death row and 35 people are executed in the United States. Death row is what they call the row of people who have been sentenced to death, and are waiting for their own execution. People often have to wait several years in the death row.

Read More

More about Michele Hanisee's Arguments Against The Death Penalty

Related Topics

Open Document