ipl-logo

Moral Issue Of Abortion Analysis

1186 Words5 Pages

An Analysis on the Moral Issue of Abortion
According to the Supreme Court’s liberal rulings, the debate on abortion is considered to be the most controversial moral issue of our time. There are two kinds of arguments concerning the morality of abortion: 1. The moral status of the embryo-the question of whether the embryo has a right to life, is the sort of being it would be seriously wrong to kill, in the moral sense. An affirmative answer would support claim: in the central anti-abortion argument, while a negative answer would support claim in the central pro-choice argument. 2. The moral status of whether the woman’s bodily rights justify abortion even if the embryo has a right to life. A negative answer would support claim in the central …show more content…

Many believe that the virtue ethicist will have the option to abort. I am also in agreement with Hursthouse when she questions, “How can virtue ethicist claim that abortion is the right action? (Only when starting with the assumption that the fetus has moral value, or is a person).” Under the law, the fetus is not regarded as having its own “life” until it is separate from its mother. Therefore, a fetus can never be a “human being” because it becomes one when it is born. However, in some jurisdictions, the fetus is regarded as a separate being if the mother is …show more content…

Article 2 of the Human Rights Act, (aka absolute right), states that nobody, including the Government, can try to end a life. Everyone’s right to life shall be protected by law. No one shall be deprived of their lives intentionally save in the execution of a sentence of a court following their conviction of a crime for which the penalty is provided by law, likewise, deprivation of life shall not be regarded as inflicted in contravention of Article 2 when it results from the use of force which is no more than absolutely necessary. The Government should take appropriate measures to safeguard life by making laws to protect a life when it is at risk. Absolute rights can never be interfered with by the state; however; a person’s right to life is not breached if they die when a public authority, (police officer), uses necessary force to: stop them carrying out unlawful violence, make a lawful arrest, stop them escaping lawful detainment, and stop a riot or uprising. The philosophical arguments in the abortion debate are deontological or rights-based. The view that all or almost all abortion should be illegal generally rests on the clams: that the existence and moral right of life of human beings begins at or near conception-fertilization, that induced abortion is the deliberate and unjust killing of the embryo in violation of its right to life; and that the law should prohibit unjust violations

Show More
Related
211 Words | 1 Pages

For the past forty years, abortion has been a topic of great discussion in the subjects of ethics, politics, and law. This is largely attributed to the landmark decision made by the supreme court in the famous Roe v. Wade case where it was decided that women have the constitutional right to an abortion during the first two trimesters of pregnancy provided it follows the regulations put in place by the state. This case has been contentious since the court passed down its decision in 1973. The deep political divisions that the case created reflect not only conflicting social and moral views, but conflicting views of law as well. Supporters of the decision believe a woman 's right to choose whether to have an abortion or not is a fundamental right,

Read More
465 Words | 2 Pages

A pressing women’s right issue that has divided the nation for the last 40 years is Abortion. It’s a procedure in which a woman medically terminates her pregnancy, this option to terminate a pregnancy has come under great fire due to moral permissibility and ethical concern. The right to abortion was granted on a constitutional basis under the landmark decision by the supreme court case, “Roe Vs. Wade” but has been attacked and attempted to be dismantled by sweltering opposition by several special-interests groups.

Read More
1236 Words | 5 Pages

Moreover, the article equates the anti-abortionist’s viewpoint-against abortion, as well as the pro-choice stance-supports abortion,

Read More
1769 Words | 8 Pages

George and Lee mention that the only cases where abortion would be appropriate and not defined as intentional killing is when the mother’s life is in harm. This statement was modified in the persuasive argument because George and Lee stated at the beginning that they believed “all abortions were intentional killing” (20). This is a prime example of the authors’ acknowledging that the opposition made a point that was legitimate. George and Lee note that pro-choice supporters believe that “an unborn human being has a right to life but that right does not entail that the child in utero is entitled to the use of the mother’s body for life support” (20). Pro-choice supporters defend the mother’s choice with this statement: “the mother has not voluntarily assumed responsibility for the

Read More
557 Words | 3 Pages

Abortion is describes as a medical procedure used to end a pregnancy and cause the death of the fetus. In today’s society, abortion is seen in one of two ways. Abortion is described positive towards women’s right, when believed that pregnant women should have the right to choose whether they want to have an abortion or not. However, abortion is also viewed negatively with pro-life activist who stand against abortions and believe a fetus should have the right to live regardless of the mothers situation. There is no right or wrong answer when it comes to abortion, making it a controversial topic in society.

Read More
1229 Words | 5 Pages

Therefore, it is evident that abortion remains an extensively disputed topic, and the question of whether a mother should be morally permitted to request an abortion has no clear

Read More
2006 Words | 9 Pages

In recent years, a particularly controversial topic in politics is the issue of abortion. Abortion is the act of prematurely and deliberately ending a pregnancy. The moral dilemma that the debate revolves around is both highly sensitive and controversial in that it deals not only with the rights and power women have over their bodies but also concerns itself with the ethics surrounding personhood. The two differing sides in the debates over abortion are the anti abortion pro-life and the pro abortion pro-choice groups.

Read More
1024 Words | 5 Pages

The reading for this week from the book, “Taking Sides: Clashing Views on Bioethical Issues”, discussed the issue of abortion. The topic of abortion has always been a huge ethical discussion in America. The topic of abortion is so important that many of our potential political leader’s futures are based on their position with the issue. One also correlates one’s position of abortion to women’s right and religion. I personally believe that abortion should not be seen as immoral under certain circumstances.

Read More
1077 Words | 5 Pages

Abortion has been and still is a major argumentative topic in the world today. The basis of its morality has been argued countless times in our government and society throughout the years. The only way that this question can be answered is by defining if an unborn child is a human or just a cluster of tissue. Because an unborn child is human, abortion can be defined as a process that is morally and ethically wrong. Amongst other things, pro-abortionists do not ever consider the psychological damage that this procedure does to the woman’s mind.

Read More
579 Words | 3 Pages

Ultimately, arguments from a diverse array of sources - philosophy, biology, religion, law, economics, human rights and more - inform both sides of the abortion debate, and on the balance of these arguments as a whole, a liberalised abortion policy is the best option in modern society. The moral permissibility of abortion hinges on the comparison between the mother’s rights and interests and the rights and interests of the fetus. In public discourse, one’s moral position on abortion is often defined by which side of this dichotomy one gives precedence to over the other. The pregnant woman’s interests support the argument for abortion; for instance, her moral entitlement to bodily integrity holds that she may counteract unwanted intrusion with her person.

Read More
1138 Words | 5 Pages

This is particularly common in cases where one of the life would almost certainly be lost if continue the pregnancy such as ectopic pregnancy, which is incorrect implantation of zygote in the uterine tube. In the aspect of personal health, it seems reasonable to claim that the right of mother to live is at least as important as the right of fetus to live. Furthermore, both mother and fetus will die unless the pregnancy is terminated, then morally speaking, that only one life is lost instead of two is the best outcome upon two lives ends. In general, sacrificing the life of mother in defense of the fetus is morally incorrect as morality does not require people to sacrifice large personal of themselves for either deontology or virtue ethics. Thus, in the life-threatening cases of pregnancy, it is reasonable to conclude that the right of mother to life outbalanced than that of the

Read More
440 Words | 2 Pages

As in any argument, and more so, for a good and valid argument, it must consist of three elements, (1) moral theory, (2) reason (s), and (3) conclusion (MacKinnon, 2012). Also, the argument must show a “logical connection” (MacKinnon, 2012, p. 8) between the reason or premise and the conclusion. At this point, I would not argue for or against abortion.

Read More
969 Words | 4 Pages

Those who want to abortion may face a moral dilemma between the obligations not to end the potential life versus other factors, such as inability to support a child or it endangers her health. People who choose an abortion may not have the means to support their child or may risk their health being endangered. Many against abortion strongly feel that abortion is no different from murder, and is selfish and irresponsible (Lake, 1986). Philosophy may give answers to such questions people have. Papers discuss issues people face such was whether it is ethical or not to abort the fetus.

Read More
1957 Words | 8 Pages

The topic of abortion has always been, and still is, a widely debated subject. No one can agree on whether or not the fetus is a person, whether or not abortions are dangerous, or whether or not abortions should be made legal everywhere. The list for arguments from both pro-choice and pro-life advocates is endless. Whether one believes abortions should be banned completely or they should be legalized everywhere, many arguments point to beneficiality of abortions. Abortion should be accessible to women because philosophical, moral, and ethical arguments prove that abortion is much more beneficial than it is harmful.

Read More
1864 Words | 8 Pages

The abortion debate deals with the rights and wrongs of deliberately ending a pregnancy before normal childbirth – killing the foetus in the process. Abortion is a painful topic for people who find themselves facing the ethical dilemma of whether to terminate a pregnancy. Abortion is a significant ethical issue because it touches upon many important, fundamental ethical questions: like the nature and rights of human beings, human relationships and personal autonomy; and the extent of state authority over personal decisions. Most people feel particularly strongly about abortion because there is no way of getting any opinion from the foetus – the potential “victim” – about the issue (unlike in most moral dilemmas, such as euthanasia, where the “victim” can be asked their opinion) and because the foetus can easily be portrayed as an entirely innocent and defenceless

Read More

More about Moral Issue Of Abortion Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document