ipl-logo

New Deal Dbq

1285 Words6 Pages

The 1920s were called “The Roaring Twenties” because many people contributed to the economy. This led to overproduction, and eventually, the stock market crash of 1929. The stock market crash was a big event that led to a lot of bank runs. After the bank runs out, very few people receive all of their money. A tariff was introduced that taxed imported goods, effectively cutting off trade. Because of this, less money was put into the economy, people lost their jobs, and the US was in the Great Depression. People couldn’t afford to buy things anymore, wages were cut and many people became homeless. President Herbert Hoover decided to have the government become only slightly involved in the economy. These policies didn’t help because the gross …show more content…

A letter was written to Harry L. Hopkins, the administrator of FERA in New York, NY on May 25, 1936. An American citizen was upset that working taxpayers needed to pay more to support non-working people. They believed that the administration should be entirely replaced if it continued. The writer was against this relief program because he believed it was taking away from taxpayers and giving to people who were “lazy” and from his perspective, didn’t deserve the money. The New Deal was a failure because it made taxpayers pay more to provide for the “lazy” people who were not currently working. Another piece of evidence that supports this claim is a letter written by Roy Wilkins, an NAACP secretary to Robert Weaver. Weaver was an American economist and politician. The letter was about the NAACP’s concern with the FHA’s racial tendencies when dealing with housing loans. Wilkins was concerned about the way that the FHA was giving out loans. The FHA was very racist and didn’t allow black people to receive loans for a house. This shows that the New Deal was a failure because of the loans that the FHA gave out in a racist manner. Although some evidence supports the idea that the New Deal was a failure, more evidence suggests that it was very …show more content…

On April 5, 1936, workers from the Works Progress Administration (WPA) at Battle Creek, Michigan, wrote a letter to President Roosevelt. The W.P.A. workers told Roosevelt how good the program was. They felt that they were earning their money, rather than just being given it. The workers were grateful for the new jobs as well as the money that they earned to put into the economy. They expressed gratitude for the New Deal and wanted it to continue. The New Deal was a success because people were able to get jobs through the program and felt that they earned the money that they made. The New Deal gave people much more confidence, which helped repair the economy. A graph of US unemployment rates from the years 1930-1945 shows unemployment rates during the Great Depression and when Roosevelt took office. The graph shows that Roosevelt taking office and the New Deal led to the lowering of unemployment rates in the US. The Great Depression increased unemployment rates significantly. However, when Roosevelt took office and created the New Deal, the unemployment rate decreased due to all of the jobs that the New Deal created.The graph proves that the New Deal was a success because it led to the decrease of unemployment rates. In conclusion, the New Deal helped the economy by giving people jobs and fixing the US unemployment

Show More
Related
546 Words | 3 Pages

The new deal was a program that created jobs during the Great Depression. The New Deal was a program that created jobs for people during the depression. Some of the programs they made where the CCC, WPA and other programs (Doc B). The New Deal had a positive effect on the people during the great depression because it gave people jobs and a way to make money. The New Deal had employed many people giving them jobs for example, at the beginning of the Great Depression unemployment was at its highest 25% and when the new deal was put into action unemployment

Read More
866 Words | 4 Pages

Herbert Hoover, the previous president, had stubbornly refused to help the unemployed and homeless, since he assumed that individual self-reliance and charitable organizations would be sufficient. The Roosevelt administration, however, knew that the numbers of people in need far exceeded the capacity for charity to cover it. To compensate, Roosevelt’s team provided over 4 million federal jobs through new worker programs such as “The Federal Emergency Relief Administration” and “the Civil Works Administration (CWA)” and organized a variety of similarly useful projects. However, by 1934, after the program’s budget became too costly, Roosevelt ordered the CWA’s dissolvement and 4 million workers, whose jobs were cut, were left unemployed once again. Shi 1148-1150.

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

While the New Deal aimed to bring back America’s prosperity, some people believe that the efforts and support were not enough to produce a significant change. Nonetheless, the New Deal was effective in helping Americans during

Read More
918 Words | 4 Pages

The Public Works Administration offered these projects to privately owned contractors to do by hiring unemployed people. In ‘The New Deal, Then and Now,’ Alan Brinkley points out that the New Deal creates the Works Progress Administration, which was “the most extensive federal work-relief program ever created”. Brinkley adds that the WPA kept about two million people employed in it’s eight-year time period. In addition, The New Deal created financial support programs such as Social Security. Social Security was a support system created to provide welfare to the elderly, disabled, orphaned, and widowed.

Read More
277 Words | 2 Pages

The New Deal helped many Americans out of poverty and malnourishment. According to Harry Hopkins, he believes “those days [of poverty and malnourishment] are over in America”(Document 2). Hopkins is referring to the many poor, helpless people in America during that time. Auspiciously, FDR helped

Read More
1007 Words | 5 Pages

The New Deal brought down the unemployment rates from 22% to 9% in 5 years and then 12% to 6% in 3 years, also from the journal. The New Deal helped bring down the unemployment rates, making sure that most homes were able to have a way to buy food and keep their homes. Some may say that the unemployment rate went down too late, but the New Deal started bringing down the rate the year after by 2% and then more for each year. The New Deal was proven a success with how it dramatically brought down unemployment from 22% all the way down to 6% in 9

Read More
235 Words | 1 Pages

Although President Roosevelt’s New deal did not end the Great Depression, I thought the New Deal was a success. The New deal helped employ millions of Americans and also made the US economy and banks more stable in the future. The new deal provided many new programs that helped shape American economy and land. Many people believed that the New Deal was supposed to end The Great Depression; however, the New Deal still helped many poor Americans and set up programs that we still use today.

Read More
1561 Words | 7 Pages

4. The New Deal helped with bringing money back into the market, but in turn the government lost money. The New Deal, brought to life by Franklin D. Roosevelt, created jobs for the United states; it brought the market out of its depression. The New Deal was a group of policies that were enacted as executive orders during Franklin D. Roosevelt’s first one-hundred days in office. Some of the policies were also passed by congress.

Read More
256 Words | 2 Pages

The New Deal provided support for the U.S. citizens during the Great Depression. It created a new way of the economy and giving Americans hope again. Some things that came from the New Deal harmed the economy further, yet the New Deal was successful. The New Deal was successful in providing relief, recover, and reform from the Great Depression by providing jobs for the unemployed, as well as regulating banks and the stock market. People were overconfident in the economy, and they would spend more money than they could afford buying stocks.

Read More
269 Words | 2 Pages

The New Deal was successful in ending the Great Depression by reducing unemployment and making life better for workers. While some believe that the New Deal was a success, others believe that it failed. Some may argue that the New Deal was unsuccessful in reducing unemployment

Read More
1265 Words | 6 Pages

The New Deal, created by the 32nd president of the United States Franklin D Roosevelt, was partially successful in solving the problems of the Great Depression. The programs created by the New Deal were able to decrease the unemployment rate. They were also able to create programs that attempted to solve the surplus that farmers experienced. The American people restored their trust in the banks and stock market. Because of the New Deal, problems of the Great Depression were partially solved.

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

Among its defects, there is plenty of evidence proving how the New Deal benefited America. Pertaining to the taxes imposed on almost all Americans where a Depression-era couple with two children and making about $4,000 would only be taxed $16 whereas a family making around $12,000 would instead be taxed $600 (Kennedy, 2009, 252). This is an example of the efforts made in order to accomplish the previously mentioned full economic recovery where it fell substantially short. Of the many New Deal programs the ones that survived to this day, though not without gradual modification, have survived because they aimed to make life in America less risky and more predicted to achieve a more liveable life (Venn, 2009, 254). This shows how the pros of the New Deal outweighed the cons and ultimately proves that the New Deal was a good thing for

Read More
379 Words | 2 Pages

The New Deal was a success because it provided many people with jobs. Organizations such as the CCC and WPA provided jobs for many unemployed people (748). Most of the jobs were construction works, but among the many structures were roads, schools, and hospital, which were what people needed and helped many Americans (class lecture). Not only that, the New Deal

Read More
847 Words | 4 Pages

The New Deal had a positive effect on the American people by the jobs it created. “His administration also established the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), which employed millions of young men, mostly urban, to work in camps at national parks and forests on conservation and reforestation projects” (“New Deal”). This shows that the New Deal had a positive effect by creating jobs because this New Deal program helped surmount the very exorbitant unemployment rates. Now, all these men can get money from their new job. Another way this evidence shows that the New

Read More
326 Words | 2 Pages

The New Deal was mostly a success as it was partially responsible for ending the depression by suppling jobs instead of handouts. The New Deal was a failure because Roosevelt did not really achieve his aim of getting Americans back to work. On the other hand The New Deal did have its successes. The New Deal created millions of jobs. This suggests to us that The New Deal was a success because by introducing more jobs people had more money to spend.

Read More

More about New Deal Dbq

Open Document