ipl-logo

Patient Six And Let The Five Patients Die Essay

616 Words3 Pages

Say you are a doctor and working at a hospital in the middle of nowhere. There are five patients in need of organs, but the hospital doesn't have any organs for them at the time. There is a sixth patient that is an organ donor and is in need of medicine. If you give the medicine to the sixth patient they will live or if you don't they will die and you can use their organs to save the other five patients. So the question is would you kill patient six to save the five patients that are in need of organs, or give the medicine to patient six and let the five patients die?

In my opinion, the most ethical response is to save patient six, and let the five patients die. The reason why is because it's my job to save patients lives that I can. Additionally, there is a possibility of me going jail if I kill patient six because it is illegal.

The first reason is it's my job to save lives I am able to. I physically have the medicine on hand to give to patient six. I physically don't have the organs to give to the five patients. It also would be my fault if patient six dies because I have the medicine and I didn't hand it over to them. On the other end, I don't have the organs. Also it wouldn't be my fault if the f be patients …show more content…

It is firstly, illegal to do so. Also think about what if patient six wasn't an organ donor? Would you still kill them to get their organs or no? If I also do kill patient six someone would definitely find out whether it would be a doctor or patient six’s family, and they would seek legal action. Also someone made a point on the other side saying that you are selfish if you save patient six because you don't want to go to jail, and you just want to save patient six just for yourself. I do think that is not selfish because you obviously don’t want to lose your good job for doing something illegal. Also people won't trust you if they find out you did this to a

Show More
Related

Ethical Issues In The Case Of John The Paramedic

568 Words | 3 Pages

Saving the patient is my job, my duty, and like any other person's job, I have a professional status to accomplish.

Read More

Trolley Problem Vs Transplant Surgeon Problem

896 Words | 4 Pages

It is the more favorable action that rescues more people because regardless of the decision somebody is going to die. Now, in the Transplant Surgeon Problem I think that the healthy man shouldn’t die. Even though, doing so has the potential of saving five lives I don’t think that it is the morally right thing to do. Just because he doesn’t have friends or family doesn’t mean that he can’t live his life happily or to its full potential. The man’s life shouldn’t be cut short because another human said so, just in order to save more people.

Read More

Examples Of Euthanasia In Of Mice And Men

627 Words | 3 Pages

Life To Euthanasia A distinct beep echoes around the operating room; a defibrillator is quickly set to 200 joules as the doctors rush to save the patient. Suddenly, a phone call reaches the operating room. The operating surgeon is notified of the patient’s request for euthanasia prior to the surgery that was found hidden in a drawer. Should they end the patient’s life?

Read More

What Is The Thesis Of The Survival Lottery By John Harris

897 Words | 4 Pages

897 Witte Precis 2 In The Survival Lottery, John Harris argues about the difference between killing and letting die. He presents this information through questioning it in a thought experiment. In the thought experiment he presents a situation where two people are in need of organ transplants like a heart and set of lungs. If there is a stock of spare organs then to save the lives of the patients, all that the doctors would have to do would be to do the transplant. If they refused to do the surgery and the patient died as a result then the doctors essentially killed their patients.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Futility

1726 Words | 7 Pages

Ethical differences can occur because of individual perseption of a subject or event (Legal dictionary, 2017). The ethical difference even may be political or religious in nature (Legal dictionary, 2017). Legal reasoning helps people to distinguish between what is right within society compared to what they think they should do. In this case, the moral reasoning is to end the patients suffering and to allow the resident to die is the kinder option (Moore, 2017). The legal reasoning in this case would be to honor the families wishes with the exception that the decision for life saving treatments was made in a malicious manner (Moore,

Read More

Thomas Scanlon On The Doctrine Of Double Effect

730 Words | 3 Pages

The doctor has the medication to cure the disease except that the patient is an organ donor match for five other patients. The doctor chooses to let the patient die in order to use the organs of that patient to potentially cure the other five. This is an example of the Doctrine of Double Effect due to the doctor making a decision to allow the first patient to die in order to potentially save the other five. In the doctor’s mind, potentially saving five people is more necessary than surely saving the one patient. It is somewhat similar to playing a game where odds come into

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Physician Assisted Suicide

946 Words | 4 Pages

Not only does it give physician, who is still human, too much power and room for human error, it is religiously and morally incorrect, violates the Hippocratic oath, and above devalues the precious gift of life. As stated earlier, treatment is possible and should be looked into instead of giving up. Donating your final moments to research and to help aid in discovering different treatment options, could give a child a chance to live that is diagnosed with the same illness. There will always be pros and cons to this subject but my opinion stands. A person has to right to refuse or accept treatment, but should not be able to take their own lives by assistance of a

Read More

Essay On Ethical Dilemmas In Organ Donation

1184 Words | 5 Pages

Ethical dilemmas have continued to plague the process of organ allocation and transplantation. The supply and demand of organs available continue to make the decisions surrounding organ distribution controversial; the choice of organ recipients should always be made with unbiased, clinical knowledge of which patient will have the best possible outcome from receiving the organ. Organizations are in place to help determine which candidates should

Read More

John Doe Research Paper

293 Words | 2 Pages

Using the individual versus community we are forced to make a decision to either honor the John Doe or to do what is best for the community and put his organs up for donation. If we choose to honor the dead John Doe we would not donate his organs to the others that are on the transplant list seeing that we do not know if that is what he would have wanted for himself in his life. We do not know if donating his organs goes against his religion, beliefs, or personal standards. However, if we think about the community, more people would benefit from the organs if they were donated then if they were kept with the John doe. More people die waiting for organs than the amount of people who receive a second chance from being on the list, so as a community we should take every step we can to save the members of the community.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Organ Transplantation

1196 Words | 5 Pages

Organ transplantation is conceivably one of the most momentous technological and medical advances of the twentieth century. However, advances are never met without difficulty. With an unparalleled aging population and a rapidly escalating demand, organ transplantation is at a crossroads with modern legislation. In accordance with other highly significant matters, organ transplantation has also developed roots as a moral and ethical dilemma that crosses over human sanctity and religious beliefs. The system of organ transplantation is established upon altruism and values of justice.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: The Controversy Of Organ Donation

1217 Words | 5 Pages

We need a way to save these lives, and we have one: Organ donation. When you become an organ donor, you can saves the lives up to eight people. Controversy surrounds this option for many reasons, and some do not find this option to be ethical but most believe it is what God’s calls us to do. The Catholic sees it as love and charity.

Read More

Assisted Suicide Persuasive Speech

840 Words | 4 Pages

People who are involved in these can suffer just as much as the patient. The choices bear on the good of the population, doctors are supposed to help your health, knowledge, and friendships. They are taught to save lives not to take them away. They are taught to act against anything that brings harm towards the person. To end someone’s life even for a better end shows what someone thinks of human life.

Read More

Ethical Issues In Health Care Essay

1072 Words | 5 Pages

There can be no right or wrong answering this. There is a policy known as the Dead donor rule that raises a lot of ethical questions. Medical professionals must weight the value of saving a life with the individual rights with their body. However, with this rule the person must be declared dead before a doctor can harvest the organs. My debates lie in when is dead dead.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Organ Donation

1415 Words | 6 Pages

There is also a misconception that if the doctors know that you are a registered organ donor, they won't do everything they can do to save your life. Therefore, focusing on building trust, addressing faults, providing education and training health professionals should be prioritized rather than jumping straight to altering the

Read More

Hippocratic Oath Essay

517 Words | 3 Pages

As a medical professional, should he/she be obliged to assist the patient in ending their suffering in the most humane approach in a perfectly legal manner or allow the pain to continue? In one hand, if the oncologist proceeds with the euthanasia, the physician would be breaking their Hippocratic Oath. In the other hand, the physician might face the reality that the patient has to live the remainder of the life suffering, against the wishes. This is only one of an infinite quantity of scenarios that could have been created.

Read More

More about Patient Six And Let The Five Patients Die Essay

Related Topics

Open Document