ipl-logo

Public Misconceptions: Australia's Failure Of An Indigenous Treaty

1488 Words6 Pages

Failed Definitions and Public Misconceptions: Australia’s failure of an Indigenous Treaty. This essay argues that controversial opinions concerning conflicting definitions and public misinformation among the Australian community hinder progress in Indigenous treaty-making. The Uluru Statement from the Heart 2017 called for Voice, Treaty, and Truth, and with the recent failure of the yes referendum, there must be a shift in the treaty process. This is because a treaty will recognise Indigenous sovereignty and allow for negotiation in their best interest, like improvements to healthcare. Unfortunately, controversial opinions are a barrier that prevents progression and healthy discussion due to conflicting definitions and public misinformation. …show more content…

A group comprised of Aboriginal representatives were appointed to lead consultations in treaty negotiations. With the State government’s support, there was a rapid progression as Australia’s first Bill passed: The Advancing the Treaty Process with Aboriginal Victorians Act 2018. This act meant the government must recognise a First People’s Assembly self-determination fund to support treaty negotiations. As Hobbs highlights, the implementation of an Indigenous representative body opens healthy discussion and development, which is a positive process because this can address controversies and …show more content…

Following the controversial definition of sovereignty, a popular argument emerged claiming ‘a nation cannot make a treaty with itself’ from former prime minister John Howard. With Howard’s highly influential status, this was quickly adopted by many Australians who insisted that Indigenous people are also Australians and therefore a treaty would divide the nation. However, Howard’s definition is based on an extremely narrow understanding of the terms ‘treaty’ and sovereignty. This misconception negatively affects the process of treaty-making as it creates unprecedented fear when in reality Indigenous people do not seek recognition of statehood. Therefore, as the controversial debate over the implications of sovereignty continues, the underlying issue must first be addressed: an embedded and outdated definition weaponised by the HCA to prevent progression in treaty-making. Australia must stand as a united front to uproot this definition and gain traction in the process of treaty-making. However, to garner support and agreement, public misconceptions need to be addressed, leading to the next issue: controversial public misinformation. Misconceptions that damage relationships. Since the release of the Uluru Statement, copious discussions and debates have flooded the community. This has led to controversial opinions and embedded narratives that misconstrue Indigenous history, consequently harming the progression of treaty-making. Such

Show More
Related
767 Words | 4 Pages

After 10 long years Torres Strait Islander Eddie ‘Koiki’ Mabo has lead indigenous Australians to a victory over the Queensland government. This win this case is a historical moment, as of yesterday, the indigenous Australians have been recognised as the owners of Murray Island. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders are known to have resided in Australia, 40,000 to 60,000 years before the British arrived in 1788. When the British took over they decided to take all the land for themselves even though the indigenous Australians were here first. This court case recognises indigenous Australians unique connection to the land and acknowledges that they have the rights to the land.

Read More
1505 Words | 7 Pages

The pivotal case of Mabo v Queensland [No.2] constitutes a significant shift in Australian law, authorising a new version of history that recognises Indigenous land rights and uses historical evidence to justify legal decisions. Utilising law and history reshaped legal history and redefined legal doctrines, notably with Indigenous land rights and how it overturned the doctrine of terra nullius. The 'Mabo' case, decided in 1992 by the High Court of Australia, challenged this doctrine by affirming Indigenous land rights, specifically on Eddie Mabo's claim to Murray Island. The essay ventures into the breakdown of the case decision. Looking at how it utilised historical evidence, its connection to legal precedent and sovereignty, and its reshaping

Read More
962 Words | 4 Pages

Formed in 1957, the Federal Council for the Advancement of Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders commenced their campaign with a series of petitions displayed in Source 4 that called for a referendum. This had the effect of not only mobilising support for a change to the constitution but also of informing the public of the issues facing Aborigines. Over the course of the campaign, more than 100,000 signatures were collected and presented to the Parliament in 94 separate petitions (NMA, n.d.). This was a key factor in changing politicians’ minds and the government’s stance (Koori Mail, 2007). A key factor of the support of the referendum by non-indigenous Australians was the Federal Council for the Advancement of Aboriginals and Torres Strait Islanders ‘Yes’ campaign.

Read More
1583 Words | 7 Pages

Here, the Aboriginal Protection Act 1869 (VIC) was made to establish an inclusive scheme of control over the lives of First Australians (Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies, 2014). New South Wales’ equivalent to this was the Aborigines Protection Act 1909 (NSW) which was to provide protection and care of Aboriginal People but rather legislated for the control of their lives. The policies of assimilation directly related to and relied on segregation and protectionism policies. This policy reflected the views of all governmental bodies of Australia, in that they thought it necessary that Aboriginal people were to eventually exercise the equivalent method of living as non-Indigenous Australians and to live as members of a sole community appreciating the same rights and freedoms, accept the same responsibilities, observing similar duties and be predisposed to the same loyalties, hopes and

Read More
1234 Words | 5 Pages

Finally, As Ring and Elston (1999: 231) argued, “the current situation [in funding for Indigenous health], where the Commonwealth is spending perhaps a fifth of what it should be spending on a needs basis, is a major impediment to effective reconciliation”. Altman and Hunter (2003) also questioned the effectiveness of the Howard Government’s emphasis on ‘practical’ reconciliation. They concluded that, “while practical reconciliation forms the rhetorical basis for Indigenous policy development since 1996, there is no evidence that the Howard governments have delivered better outcomes for Indigenous Australians than their predecessors” (Altman and Hunter 2003: v; see also Hunter and Schwab 2003: 94-96; Ross 2001: 155; Wyatt 2001: 181-182; Gunstone 2007). Therefore as the above evidence suggests, eleven years after the announcement of this “practical reconciliation” policy, Indigenous socio economic disadvantage

Read More
1127 Words | 5 Pages

This paper will give an overview of the act and how it impacted the Indigenous community into becoming

Read More
301 Words | 2 Pages

Demonstrating an understanding when communicating effectively with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people is extremely critical as the negative impacts of past racial and economic disadvantages is something that is still fresh within the minds of indigenous Australians. A series of past government policies, including segregation, displacement and separation of families has contributed to heart ache and torment which has caused mistrust held by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people towards government agencies and non-indigenous Australians. In today's dominant Western society, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people continue to be a marginalised and socially disadvantaged. Compared to other Australians, Aboriginal and Torres

Read More
929 Words | 4 Pages

The history of Aboriginal alienation was an important context that assisted Silvey in the making of his novel, and furthermore establishing a successful play. The year 2009 was an influential year for Aboriginal’s rights. After twenty years of negotiation, the United Nations

Read More
1081 Words | 5 Pages

Alternative Essay on The Devil and Tom Walker In the short story of The Devil and Tom Walker written by Washington Irving, religion played some parts throughout the story but didn’t have a very huge impact on the protagonist, Tom himself. Tom’s character only turned to religion near the end of the story to ask for help from God in reverse for what he has done to the innocent people of Boston. In other terms, Tom turned to religion for his personal benefits rather than his inner relationship with God, which in the end didn’t go so well in his favor.

Read More
851 Words | 4 Pages

In spite of the government's best efforts, the White Paper highlighted long-standing conflicts and inequalities in the relationships between Indigenous people and colonists, laying the groundwork for current discussions over Indigenous rights and self-determination. Indigenous Perspectives on the White Paper Indigenous perspectives did not welcome the white paper with open arms. It resembled a slap across the face. Imagine being informed that your identity, culture, and way of life are all suddenly subject to negotiation. That was the feeling in many Indigenous communities.

Read More
2026 Words | 9 Pages

Historically, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health has been severely neglected and intentionally devasted by governmental policies and legislation. Despite some reformation in the health system, Indigenous people's health is still far below their non-indigenous counterparts. To rectify this, a human rights approach must be utilised, as by turning human rights from purely legal instruments into effective policies, practices, and practical realities, the Australian Parliament can redress its ongoing failures to incorporate Indigenous perspectives. The implementation of damaging legislation and policies created a system in which Aboriginal people were denied their human right to health, this system still governs Indigenous people today.

Read More
1190 Words | 5 Pages

Abstract Being an aborigine in a white dominated society is a complicated identity. Australia, one of the white governed nations, also owns many aboriginal tribes. They lived harmonious lives in the early period. But European colonization has made a profound effect on the lives of Aboriginals in Australia, which led to the total demolition of their native culture, identity and history. As a result the new generation Aboriginals have lost their Aboriginal heritage and have been accepted neither by Aboriginals nor by whites.

Read More
758 Words | 4 Pages

Serious concerns related to treaty rights, governance with indigenous peoples, and land claims are linked to the rights, independence, and well-being of indigenous people in Canada. Treaty rights refer to the agreements made between the government of Canada and Indigenous peoples, outlining the rights and responsibilities of both parties. The process of making choices and putting policies into action that have an impact on the rights, interests, and well-being of Indigenous peoples in Canada is referred to as governance. This covers issues related to land, resources, autonomy, culture, and language, as well as the decisions of public services like healthcare and education. The process by which Indigenous peoples in Canada exercise their rights to their native homelands that were taken from them during colonialism and the nation's growth is known as making land claims.

Read More
530 Words | 3 Pages

The Aboriginal communities in Canada are isolated from the rest of society, and their issues are often overlooked by the mainstream media. Furthermore, regarding the unsolved cases and other Aboriginal issues, former Prime Minister Stephen Harper stated ‘most’ of the cases are solved and that "… it isn 't really high on our radar, to be honest. "(Kappo, 2014). This reflects the former government’s complete disregard for the extremely important issues that currently affect Aboriginal communities. Although a federal inquiry into this issue has been launched due to pressure from various activist group, this does not eliminate the blatant disregard for Aboriginal issues in Canada.

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

(2002). Aboriginal identity in contemporary society. Stepney, S.A:

Read More

More about Public Misconceptions: Australia's Failure Of An Indigenous Treaty

Open Document