ipl-logo

Shame Is Worth A Try By Dan Kahan Summary

791 Words4 Pages

Olivia Muegge Dr. Moore English 1113 26 February 2018 Title Today, in the United States, there are many overcrowded prisons and many criminals. There are a number of offenses a person can commit that are against the law, and a number of these can land one in jail. Criminal acts are meant to be condemned. Public shaming is a financially sound and appropriate punishment for minor offense criminals in America. In the United States there are a large number of people incarcerated for a variety of offenses. This does not come cheap for the American taxpayer. American taxpayers pay for all of those incarcerated in the US. The sheer amount of imprisoned can lead to a hefty bill. This leads citizens to think about how to cut costs. When there are less people locked away, earning little or no money, Americans pay to feed, clothe, and house them. In his essay “Shame is Worth a Try,” author Dan Kahan states that “what the shame proponents seem to be getting, and the critics ignoring, is the potential of shame as an effective, cheap, and humane alternative” (Rosa and Eschholz 582). Even June Tangney, an author and opponent of public shaming, …show more content…

Public shaming addresses this issue improving the safety for others. Making others aware of one’s offenses as Kahan suggests “Drive drunk…and you might be required to place a ‘“DUI”’ bumper sticker on your car” (Rosa and Eschholz 582). Public identification provides a warning to those around the offender. This awareness can provide safety to the general public. Some people counter that such public shaming will spur retribution toward the offender. June Tangney argues in her essay “Condemn the Crime, Not the Person,” that public shaming “is typically accompanied by a sense of shrinking, of being small, worthless, and powerless, and by a sense of being exposed” (Rosa and Eschholz 577). However, the utmost concern must be for public

Show More
Related
283 Words | 2 Pages

5. Public trials and executions serve as a deterance of deviant behaviors. These sanctions act as a way to set an example and for people to see what will happen to them if they do the same thing, These sanctions can also be seen as reinforcing boundaries. Although public executions and trials in “town square” are not as common in most countries today, the media is utilized to fulfil the same purpose. When there are high profile cases going on in the United States often tmes the full trial and sentancings are televised so that much of society can see what the repercussions are for defying a social norm.

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

In Dan Kahan’s, Shame is Worth a Try, he claims that the use of shame as punishment is a more effective and economical alternative to imprisonment. Kahan uses a plethora of rhetorical devices in his article. He uses many examples of places in which shame is already being used as a punishment. In the first paragraph, Kahan states that “Nevertheless, courts and legislators have registered have resisted alternative sanctions-not so much because they wont work, but because they fail to express appropriate moral condemnation of crime”.

Read More
503 Words | 3 Pages

Short Summary: Chapter 2 of The Rich Get Richer and the Poor Get Prison was about how the way society sees crime can be distorted by the media, the justice system, and the information we are presented with about what crime really is. It points out that medical neglect, known environmental hazards, dangerous workplace conditions, and poverty cause more injuries yearly than murders, assaults, and robberies. Most people see the latter as “crime,” but not the former. Long Summary: Chapter 2 of The Rich Get Richer and the Poor Get Prison discusses people’s skewed perspective when it comes to what they think crime really is. The reader is asked to do an exercise regarding their own reason.

Read More
530 Words | 3 Pages

In Dan M. Kahan’s article Shame Is Worth a Try, he argued that shame can be used as an effective alternative method to punish law-breakers instead of sending them to jail. Kahan explained how shame works by giving several examples of shaming punishment, such as wearing disgraced signs or putting on embarrassing stickers. He stated that shame hurts people’s reputation as well as financial income and that is why it works as an alternative way to punish people. Nevertheless, he then brought up some opposing ideas held by courts and judges and the reason why shame does not work as effectively as expected. He explained that shame may fail short as a punishment in that it does not hurt as much as jail sentence, it can be easily abuse and it is rather

Read More
595 Words | 3 Pages

but we do it anyway because it makes people get attacked on a broader spectrum. So, by Ronson writing this book he is implying that all public shaming is bad and never should happen to anyone. On the other hand, if Ronson would have never been a victim of public shaming he might have a different view on the situations. Which is questionable because when he shamed the men who shamed him, in Ronsons mind it was just retaliation and nothing more.

Read More
638 Words | 3 Pages

The act of public shaming proves to be effective by changing the character of a person through self-condemnation and

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

Isaiah Sutter Mrs. Sever English 9 Honors B 1 March 2024 Inhuman—A Thematic Analysis of Flawed In today’s society, people who have committed crimes get labels such as “convict” and “felon” placed upon them. Although many do not realize it, these terms dehumanize such individuals, as they define them at their worst moments. In Flawed by Cecelia Ahern, a dystopian novel, a future country is described in which people who make moral mistakes are ostracized by society.

Read More
749 Words | 3 Pages

The United states spends a whopping 80 billion dollars on keeping people in jail each year. From less than three hundred thousand people in United States prisons in 1972 to over one million by the year 2000, The United States holds more of their own people in prisons than any other nation. We imprison more people than China and Russia despite having a significantly smaller population than both nations. 3

Read More
931 Words | 4 Pages

In ”Shame” Dick Gregory discusses the difficulty he was having in school when he was a teeenager just because he was poor kid who didn’t have much and he didn’t get the same value as the other kids in the classroom. First, Gregory mention he was seven years old that is when he got is first lesson in school and use to have a crush on a girl name Helene Tucker he would do anything just for that girl. During his teenage years, when the water get frozen at his house he would use shopped ice to watch his clothes so that he could keep himself clean for her and sometime he get sick from it because he put them on meanwhile it still wet. Finally, It took him twenty-nine years to forget about her crush and that is when he get married and making money so, that show me he was still being hurt from his past and everything that he do was connected with Helene Tucker. In this essay I will talk about Gregory past he was he was seven years old and why he took him twenty- nine years to forget about this girl.

Read More
1065 Words | 5 Pages

To begin with, public shaming a person for a crime that they have committed is a violation of their privacy. For instance, Canedy states, “The Scarlet Letter

Read More
172 Words | 1 Pages

This paper will demonstrate the effectiveness of Braithwaite’s reintegrative shaming theory in preventing recidivism among juvenile offenders depending on the crime committed. Although some research has suggested that reintegrative shaming can only be effective before the offender senses they are becoming an outcast within society, research also shows that the stigmatization of labeled offenders is often commenced by the harsh punishments placed upon them by the criminal justice system in the hopes of deterring future crimes. The research presented will elaborate on the effects of reintegrative shaming in attempts to prevent recidivism in crimes such as white collar crimes and drug and alcohol offenses on a college campus. There will also be

Read More
784 Words | 4 Pages

And quirky punishments designed to go viral don’t just fail to meet this standard of the law; they actively subvert it. Their primary goal is to court publicity, and that publicity can’t be accurately anticipated or controlled” (Beato). The reason Beato says this is because he feels that public humiliation can become cruel and unusual once it is published on the internet and it is a form of bullying for the criminal even if their punishment was for something that wasn’t that

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

Mackenzie Wolfe Mr. Boline AP Language Arts 29 March 2023 America’s Justice System is Broken High influence issues such as abuse of power and greed can change the course of hundreds of lives and impact the way the world treats people. As seen in Just Mercy, written by Brian Stevenson, these issues can be the difference between life, death and a long life of lasting mental health issues. The Justice System of the United States is broken because of the abuse of power and greed that hold high influence in America’s Justice System. Abuse of power is significantly influential in the Justice System. It corrupts officials, changes outcomes of “fair trials”, convicts innocent people and even sometimes is the cause of a wrongful death

Read More
490 Words | 2 Pages

The ineffectiveness of public shaming is linked to the fact that many people do not care about societal expectations as much as predicted, and do not internally feel ashamed of their actions. It is necessary for one to reflect on the past to move forward, a goal that public shaming rarely

Read More
684 Words | 3 Pages

The domino effect: when a short, mild action leads up to a full-scale, potentially dangerous outcome. It is all the same for violating laws and minor acts of misconducts, the possibility of a greater result is always plausible. Frank Trippett in his excerpt, “A Red Light for Scofflaws”, argues that American society has dulled out their importance of consequences to breaking laws. He believes that small acts of criminality are to be taken just as seriously as full scale acts of crime. Trippett first gives look on the apparency of people residing to this way of life, and continues by stating his personal belief that with more people breaking laws to adhere to a new trend, scofflaws will become an item of public norm.

Read More

More about Shame Is Worth A Try By Dan Kahan Summary

Related Topics

Open Document