ipl-logo

Rhetorical Analysis Of The Medical Field Is Failing Obese People

1322 Words6 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Rhetorical analysis about obesity

Janeth Cruz Inst. Harbinson English 111 2 April 2024 Rhetorical Analysis Essay: The Medical Field is Failing Obese People. Obese people are not as cared for as an average weighed person would be at a doctor's office. They have to go through overweight discrimination by the doctors and nurses that take care of them. Therefore, the doctor takes less time looking for the reason for the patient's symptoms and blames it on the person's weight. Studies have proven that this is true and that most obese people die from undiagnosed illnesses rather than their own weight. Another way obese people are being discouraged from going to their local doctors is that the equipment used to check them is inadequate for their size. The equipment is either …show more content…

She mentions that “[m]any nurses admit they feel repulsed by our bodies and do not want to touch us. Doctors are more likely to view us as a waste of their time and have less desire to help us” (Manne, Kate). “Opinion | Medical Fatphobia Does Serious Harm to Patients - The...” Doctors Have Fatphobia, Too — Which Does Serious Harm to Patients, 31 Jan. 2024, www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/01/31/kate-manne-fatphobia-health-care-discrimination/). From reading the first paragraph, one can conclude that Manne is directly targeting people that work in the field where they check the physical and mental wellbeing of patients that come …show more content…

“Opinion | Medical Fatphobia Does Serious Harm to Patients - The...” Doctors Have Fatphobia, Too — Which Does Serious Harm to Patients, 31 Jan. 2024, www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/01/31/kate-manne-fatphobia-health-care-discrimination/). The negative connotations of these words go to explain how the fat/obese population is dealt with when going to physical screenings. Although through the first half of the passage, where Manne shows a lot of negative connotations toward the doctors and nurses, the other half does not contain as much as negative feelings toward these people, but rather a disappointing outlook on the medical

Show More
Related

Summary Of Why Shame Won T Stop Obesity By Dhruv Khullar

1067 Words | 5 Pages

Obesity is an issue that affects many people worldwide. In the article “Why Shame Won’t Stop Obesity”, by Dhruv Khullar, Khullar tries to argue that obesity is a major problem in the United States and the way the country is handling this issue is incorrect. Khullar goes to medical school and experiences first hand the problems people with obesity have to deal with. He believes that some people have no option when it comes to what they choose to eat and that food industries are influencing people in the wrong way. He makes a strong and clear argument by identifying issues, providing evidence, solutions, and counter arguments.

Read More

Summary Of Fat Acceptance A Basic Primer By Seminara Geissler

736 Words | 3 Pages

Fat acceptance: A basic primer Critique essay Cynara Geissler’s article “Fat Acceptance: A Basic Primer” was first published in Geez Magazine in 2013. Geissler addresses a lot of issues about fat acceptance and how it is affecting our society and people’s attitudes towards over-weight people. One of the reasons why Geissler thinks that is because many health industries now days have a slogan “Thinner is better” and that makes over-weight people seem lazy or just not willing to put the effort to become better. Most importantly Geissler mentions that health industries and causing people to make a negative attitude towards overweight people which can be seen.

Read More

Summary: The Plague In West Mobile County

1122 Words | 5 Pages

A plague is devastating America and has run rampant for several years. Modern health care has been struggling against this plague that strikes across all social, racial, political and geographic boundaries. A plague that the American public is well aware of and one that is still pervasive and life threatening. A plague that strikes everyone, but that starts with our children. This is the plague of obesity and its effect on the American people and the health-care community is frightening.

Read More

Essay On Shadowing Dr. Holly Lofton

502 Words | 3 Pages

During the spring of 2015 until the summer of 2016, I gained a considerable amount of clinical experience by shadowing Dr. Holly Lofton at NYU Langone Medical Center. Dr. Lofton works in the field of bariatric medicine, where she specializes in medically supervising patients who combat a series of eating disorders. However, obesity being one of the prominent diseases among her patients. Unfortunately, within our society obesity holds a negative connotation, it is simply dismissed as a disease that develops due to an individual’s loss of self-control. On the contrary, obesity should not be dismissed as a self-control issue, it has more complexity to it.

Read More

Summary Of In Defense Of Fat Acceptance By Mary Worley

836 Words | 4 Pages

Her goal may be to make the word fat comfortable and a less offensive word. However, it becomes unsuccessful as it begins to make readers uncomfortable as though they were being a bully. However, her article could’ve been more effective if she eliminated the number of times she used the word fat and alternatively added words to substitute them such as overweight, obese, or heavier. Worley uses various logical fallacies to convince her audience that being fat is and should be acceptable in today’s society as a whole. One of these logical fallacies include, “[They] would rather die or cut off a limb than be fat” (163).

Read More

Controversial Issues In Malcolm Kendrick's Doctoring

754 Words | 4 Pages

While in the result section of the paper it is even stated that falling into the overweight BMI category is slight associated with a reduction in mortality, the paper has the vague title of “Excess Deaths Associated With Underweight, Overweight and Obesity” (Flegal). Through Doctoring Data Kendrick exposes the discrepancies between the data in research and the way it is presented to the public.

Read More

America's War On The Overweight Summary

707 Words | 3 Pages

As these people who hate, are discouraging the overweight people who are really trying to lose weight and make themselves healthier individuals. While, yes there are some who are truly lazy and do not care about their health, it does not give others the right to discriminate against them. Living in a rather free society people should be able to choose whether they want to be overweight or not. Also they note that thin people feel threatened by overweight people as they think the overweight people are getting something they are not, or are getting more than their fair share of the things in

Read More

Mary Maxfield Food For Thought Analysis

786 Words | 4 Pages

Americans, along with Pollan, have concluded that diet, health, and weight are linked together. Maxfield doesn’t think so and tries to defend her argument by quoting law professor and journalist Paul Campos’s claims, “’lies about fat, fitness, and health…not coincidentally serve the interest of America’s $50-billion-per-year diet industry (Maxfield, 444)’” as well as activist Kate Harding who observed that “’if you scratch an article on the obesity crisis, you will almost always find a press release from a company that’s developing a weight loss drug…(Maxfield 444)’” She further defends herself, again by going by what Campos and Harding claim, when she dumps the concept of using the body mass index (BMI) tool, which is widely used by medical professionals to determine a person’s health risks based on his or her body fat

Read More

Gary Taubes Mind/Body Health: Obesity

970 Words | 4 Pages

Author, Gary Taubes states in an interview for Fed Up that, “This whole generation of kids, they’re doing their best, they’re torturing themselves to do the cure that we tell them and it is the wrong cure and we’re blaming the willpower, the immortal fortitude of these kids, and it’s a crime.” (Fed Up) Obese patients are doing the “cure”, as Taubes describes it, that society is telling them will work but it is not doing anything for them and instead of questioning the “cure” society blames obese patients. This causes these patients to doubt themselves and can lead to depression and an increase in weight. This topic of discussion from the documentary if supported by the paper, Mind/body health: Obesity published by the American Psychological

Read More

Obesity Annotated Bibliography

360 Words | 2 Pages

James Hamblin wrote the article Body Weight, Clash of Ideologies for The Atlantic on January 16, 2015. Hamblin (2015) stated media has an important role in educating the public on what obesity is, therefore influencing policy. Hamblin (2015) wrote about a meeting of the Institute of Medicine (IOM) where he spoke about media's part in obesity. According to Hamblin (2015) reduction of obesity rates has been slow because the public does not understand obesity is a biopsychosocial disease.

Read More

Obesity Interdisciplinary Issue

1125 Words | 5 Pages

We have laws to prevent prejudices against a person based on race, sexual orientation, religion, and gender however there are currently no laws to protect the obese against unfair harassment. The social mistreatment of the obese, no matter their age, gender or economic status has the opposite of the intended effect, leading to weight gain, not weight loss. Couple this with widespread depression and you end up with a disease of epidemic

Read More

Obesity Satire Essay

988 Words | 4 Pages

Not only does obesity bring about various medical issues as well as it's not instructing the fate of America to be dependable with their bodies and to live sound lives. people need to begin assuming liability for their activities, and quit accusing fast food places and junk food as the reason for their weight. The main way you get to be distinctly hefty or overweight is whether you permit yourself to. We have to begin treating our bodies like the sanctuaries they are, we have been honored with life and individuals are underestimating it. The destiny of the nation depends on our era to begin rolling out an improvement in our ways of life.

Read More

Literary Analysis Of Cheryl Peck's 'Fatso'

745 Words | 3 Pages

Every individual is different and unique in their own way, may it be their body size or the color of their skin. No individual is similar, which is precisely the point that Cheryl Peck makes in her essay “Fatso”. The essay portrays Peck’s view of the conflicts that she goes through in her life as an overweight person. She makes a point by point contrast to her imaginary life, repeating the phrase “I have never”, and her real life where she faces discrimination because of her weight. Peck’s use of tone and word choice highlights the purpose of her essay, which is to raise awareness about discrimination against overweight people to audiences who are thin and have not experienced any judgment from others.

Read More

Obesity Should Be Censored Essay

1289 Words | 6 Pages

Obesity is a very sensitive topic to talk about in today’s culture around the world. Way back in the day it used to be a good thing to be fat because it showed that you have money to eat but that has since changed. People can get very offended and be aggressive about the topic if it brought up in conversation. Today’s society, at least in the United States, obesity in ways can be censored or punished by the social media and other forms of media. Below are a few ways I see how obesity is censured in the culture I live in.

Read More

How Obesity Affects Society

830 Words | 4 Pages

According to Reuters Health people who are obese have a greater risk of falling into depression another health concern of this country. People who are obese suffer from low self-esteem and can estrange themselves from others because of their weight. Women who are normally very self-conscious of their personal image and can have low self-esteem tend to even have lower views of themselves when they are overweight. This can lead to them turning to anorexia or bulimia just so that they can slim down. (American

Read More

More about Rhetorical Analysis Of The Medical Field Is Failing Obese People

Open Document