ipl-logo

Rhetorical Analysis Of William Damon's The Death Of Honesty

1085 Words5 Pages

William Damon’s “The Death of Honesty” presents a solemn analysis of the decline of modern virtue due to a “dysfunctional tipping point” where honesty is no longer viewed as a moral characteristic worthy of pursuing. Dishonesty is presented as both a virtue and a vice that is shaping our contemporary society. The Hoover Institution of Stanford University published Mr. Damon’s article in 2012 under the Task Force on the Virtues of a Free Society, which would provide a target audience of students, educators, parents or anyone with an interest in sociology, specifically in the United States. A rhetorical analysis exposes flaws in Mr. Damon’s logic, while the appeal of ethos and pathos are successful tools in creating a connection with readers. …show more content…

The author starts to develop a bond with the reader by acknowledging that the truth is not always spoken and that dishonesty comes in many forms: acceptable white lies, “courageous deception” and distortion of the truth. This strategy provides a level of respect for the reader, and does not assume a tone of moral supremacy; the reader can relate to the assumption that truth is not always observed. Similarly, exposing politicians as guilty of language that is designed “to hide, soften, or misrepresent” the truth is a statement that many readers would agree with. The focus is then put on the individual with the statement that all liars will be shunned when their dishonesty is exposed; no one wants to be the victim of a public shaming. Ironically, the reader may agree with the assumption that one must lie to get ahead in the world of business. Again, the reader is drawn into the text when the future of society is placed on the moral development of its children. Parents become sympathetic to the message when dishonesty is believed to be detrimental to our children. An underlying tone of fear is created by references to abandoning integrity, breaches in the moral fabric, the danger of departing from truth, and the “lethal threat” to democracy that is created by children not being taught honesty. Using an emotional appeal to the reader is effective because of the personal …show more content…

Damon fails to create a convincing logical argument to support his thesis statement. Falling guilty to the fallacy of oversimplifying, the author claims that dishonesty alone will be responsible for the demise of civilized society. Laying the blame on the education system as a whole for no longer teaching honesty, or for teachers actively encouraging dishonesty, does not recognize the academic institutions and individual educators that make honesty and academic integrity a core precept. The examples of academic maleficence are valid support for the argument, but do not support the generalization of “organized and systemic misconduct” within the education system. Secondly, Mr. Damon assumes that children learn their moral code exclusively from the education system; offering only a minor concession to parental influence. This fallacy could cause a reaction by parents who feel their role in raising their own children is being usurped. Mr. Damon fails to recognize the relationship that parents and schools jointly bear for instilling a moral code in children. Additionally, the suggestion that children educated during the mid-twentieth century received a higher level of education and moral training because of the McGuffy Readers that were used to “dispense unambiguous moral lessons to students” is a false correlation. Finally, Mr. Damon places absolute value on the virtue of honesty as the basis of a moral code using the Roman goddess Veritas (truth), who was

Show More
Related
834 Words | 4 Pages

When a politician is caught in some scandal, we expectation him to give a repentant talk in which he reveal us all circularly equitable how unsuitable he was. Why? When George Washington apocryphally cuts down a ruddy timber, we find it illustrious that he admits it even though he doesn't have any apparent consideration to. Why? When the Reverend Dimmesdale doesn't prove that he fathered a child with Hester Prynne, it eats away at him until he finally does.

Read More
70 Words | 1 Pages

Children’s roles in the scarlet letter and literature are portrayed as perceptive, honest and neutral in society opposed to the hypocritical puritan adults. Children act as judges of character and tend to be more perceptive and honest due to the loose limits of acceptable behaviour in society as children and ability to see the truth not gossip, free to express themselves more than adults in the 17th century Puritan society.

Read More
741 Words | 3 Pages

The Truth About the Sinner In D.H. Lawrence’s essay “On the Scarlet Letter,” Lawrence discusses how he believes that Hester Prynne, the protagonist of Nathaniel Hawthorne's novel The Scarlet Letter, is evil and her sin of committing adultery is the cause of the novel’s problem. He states that Hester causes many problems in the novel by seducing Arthur Dimmesdale and bringing his whole life down. D.H. Lawrence achieves his purpose of showing Hester as evil and the source of the problem by using passionate hyperboles to exaggerate her sin, exuberant syntax to repeat himself, and a sarcastic tone to emphasize how evil she is.

Read More
710 Words | 3 Pages

Rhetorical Analysis Most people tend to believe that lying is a way of life, that without it the whole world could crumble and fall. While some tend to believe that any form of lying is a sin and there should be consequences. One author, Stephanie Ericsson, wrote “The Ways We Lie” published in 1993 she talks about how we all lie, it has become an everyday chore to make life easier. She begins by trying to strengthen the bond between the reader and writer showing how they are one of the same. She does this by referencing past experiences, adding informed opinions, and using quotes from other well acknowledged authors, her argument is strong throughout the whole article that lying isn’t just evil, it can be used for good when used the right way.

Read More
419 Words | 2 Pages

9/12/2016 Abdulaziz ENG -100 Assignment No.1 Kate Brennan In “Slip-Sliding Away, Down the Ethical Slope,” by Robert J. Sternberg, the author is concerned about a real problem that begins to spread within the whole society, which, in his words “goes much deeper than the occasional incident”. In fact, it is okay for cheaters to cheat, but they do not want to be caught. He starts off by giving two examples for two types of cheating. First, copying the work of someone else and getting exam answers beforehand.

Read More
1543 Words | 7 Pages

In the words of Niccolò Machiavelli’s The Prince, “…one who deceives will always find those who allow themselves to be deceived.” This piece is regarded as the first written account of sordid political theory that believes the end always justifies the means, no matter how immoral or unethical (Machiavelli 70). If Machiavelli were alive today, two movies he might enjoy would be Wag the Dog from 1997 and the 1978 film, Capricorn One, both graphic illustrations of bureaucrats’ propensity to deceive and the ease in which the public allows itself to be deceived. The art of deception and all of its subsets: lying, fraud, trickery, manipulation, etc., is one of the most prevalent traditions in politics today (Brooks). Politicians and bureaucrats employ

Read More
1190 Words | 5 Pages

Stephanie Ericsson begins her explorative essay, “The Ways We Lie,” with a personal anecdote of all the lies she fabricated in one day. She told her bank that a deposit was in the mail when it was not, told a client that the traffic had been bad when she was late for other reasons, told her partner that her day was fine when it was really exhausting, and told her friend she was too busy for lunch when she just was not hungry, all in the course of a day. She shifts from talking about herself to talking about everyone, claiming that all people lie, exaggerate, minimize, keep secrets, and tell other lies. But, like herself, most still consider themselves honest people. She describes a week in which she tried to never tell a lie; it was debilitating, she claims.

Read More
610 Words | 3 Pages

Though he admits himself to being a compulsive liar, he is condescending of their “fake” and socially accepted attitudes. Perhaps by partially admitting his own “fakeness” and simply being aware of “phoniness” in the world, he believes he is setting himself apart from all those he believes to be

Read More
929 Words | 4 Pages

In Piper, Kansas a high school teacher, Christine Pelton, failed one-fifth of her biology students on their end of semester project because she found out that they had used the internet to cheat. After the parents of the failed students complained, the Piper School District ordered her to lessen the punishment; Christine Pelton then made the decision to resign in protest. The issue over plagiarism is not just happening in the small town of Piper, Kansas, but it is actually happening all over the nation. Pelton’s actions regarding the issue were justified because the students did actually plagiarize their work which makes them play a part in the bigger issue, the national decline in integrity. Some people claim that Pelton’s punishment was

Read More
655 Words | 3 Pages

Academic integrity needs to be taken much more serious than it is. It plays a very important role in who you are as a college student and your direct learning of the material. Personal and academic integrity are important to me because they reflect who I am and how serious I take my education. I believe that academic integrity and personal integrity go fairly hand in hand because if you have personal integrity it flows over into your academic life too. Those who hold themselves accountable for their personal integrity know that their education is a part of their personal life too therefore both hold substantial importance.

Read More
477 Words | 2 Pages

Dishonesty harms us and harms others as well. Being honest at school is by choosing not to cheat in any way.

Read More
1885 Words | 8 Pages

Introduction According to Alford (2007), a whistleblower is one who speaks out against illegal or unethical practices in school or in the organization where he or she works. Whistle-blowing, is an essential factor for pin-pointing and eradicating unethical activities in most organization set ups (Brown, 2008). According to Sawyer, Johnson and Holub (2010), most individuals disregard the idea of whistle-blowing because they fear that they will be avoided and could end up losing their job careers and also their good names. When an individual is torn between two or more deeds and have virtuous reasons for choosing each action, this is regarded to as an ethical dilemma.

Read More
1064 Words | 5 Pages

For this purpose, I will examine the concept of morality mainly from Rust’s and Marty’s perspectives and I will

Read More
898 Words | 4 Pages

Honesty,a necessity in all healthy relationships--whether its a marriage, business partnership, or a friendship. In higher academics, this honesty becomes extremely important due to the large sum of money invested into university or community college education. Many schools across the United States have included an honor code to enforce this honesty into class assignments or assessments, however these rules don’t always see success in American schools. Why would such a high level of education struggle with honesty and an honor code? This struggle could be related to the academic environment within the walls of four year universities or a community college.

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

A decade of enormous growth and innovation in the field of online learning has had significant impact upon Higher Education by highlighting the issues of Academic Integrity. The Center for Academic Integrity (CAI) defines academic integrity as “a commitment, even in the face of adversity, to five fundamental values: honesty, trust, fairness, respect, and responsibility. From these values flow principles of behavior that enable academic communities to translate ideals to action.” (REF) The growth of online learning in higher education has created unique challenges in maintaining academic integrity (Rowe, 2004).

Read More

More about Rhetorical Analysis Of William Damon's The Death Of Honesty

Related Topics

Open Document