ipl-logo

Robert Merton's Theory Of Science

858 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Ethics in natural sciences

Introduction
This paper will give a brief history as to the rise of science as a discipline as described by Robert Merton. The paper will give an explanation and sociological overview of Robert Merton’s sociology and his concepts of the ethos of Science. The paper assess the strengths and weaknesses of his ‘CUDOS’ definition of scientific ethos by drawing upon evidence of contemporary scientific practises, institutions, organisations and funding. The essay will also consider the extent to which his ‘CUDOS’ formulation of the scientific ethos can be considered to withstand both (a) the subsequent changes in the structure and organisation of science, and (b) the criticisms and findings of subsequent social studies of science. In so doing the …show more content…

It is clear that Merton’s attention is more focussed on the values governing scientific activities, and this he calls ‘cultural structure of science’ rather than the institutions themselves. This he states is a ‘limited introduction to a larger problem’ mainly the ‘study of institutional structure of science’ (Merton, 1942). However, not only had Merton argued that the social scientist changed but the roots and sociological landscape of science changed during World War II and moved from society to the study of organisations and institutions, and out of the ashes rose the new discipline, sociology of science and a new set of imperatives, (Mendelson, 1989: …show more content…

Scientists worked for the good of humanity and their rewards are esteem and reputation not economic benefits through patens on scientific breakthroughs. Merton talks about the commercialization of science, and that this battle between reputation and the division of labour is a trade-off between diversity, commercialization and specialization, and that scientists in to-days society are pressed to promote commercialisation for companies, (Merton, 1942). For example, the anti-depressant Prozac, the wonder drug of modern medicine first hit the shelves in America in 1988 and while the company Eli Lilly made billions the research team got a few awards. Strength: However if this scientific research team worked from a communism frame work then the drug would have been shared with the public free. ‘The utilitarian findings of science are a product of social complexities shared with the wider community. They constitute a set of societal traditions in which the impartiality of the individual producer is severally limited and property rights in science are held down to the bare minimum by the rationale of the scientific ethic’ (Merton, 1942). Weakness: However experience has shown that this theory is unrealistic in an every day working capitalist society as funding is paramount inorder for sceintific research to progress

Show More
Related
1480 Words | 6 Pages

In her book, The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, Rebecca Skloot reveals how Henrietta Lacks, an African American woman diagnosed with cervical cancer, was exploited by the medical community for the development of the immortal “HeLa” cells that have since become the most widely used cells for medical research and advancement from the 20th century to the present day. The HeLa cells have since led to the formulation of the polio vaccination along with groundbreaking research on diseases such as AIDS, gene mapping, in vitro fertilization, and possible treatments for various forms of cancer in humans (Zielinski). However, this breach of medical ethics in regards to removing Lacks’ cervical cells without her knowledge or consent has led to questions

Read More
585 Words | 3 Pages

: Science, ethics, and

Read More
831 Words | 4 Pages

Scientific research is a crucial part of human progress and discovery, which is a scarcely understood procedure for many. John M. Barry, author of The Great Influenza, describes the 1918 flu epidemic in order to analyze the impact of scientific research. This enlightening account of a vital part of human history maintains the reader’s interest by relating what naturally draws people in to a narrower topic. The author incorporates comparisons, contrasting key points, and clever rhetorical inquiries to give the reader a better comprehension of the practice of scientific research.

Read More
546 Words | 3 Pages

During the sixteenth and seventeenth century, many scientists had developed a new perspective on the world around them. Scientists such as Galileo and Copernicus envisioned a world where natural phenomenons could be proved through experimentation. Furthermore, the work of scientists during this time period were affected by the approval of political figures, the support from influential members of the church, and social factors that influenced the development and acceptance of new theories. To powerful political figures, scientific theories were regarded as an opportunity to gain power and money.

Read More
1110 Words | 5 Pages

“Our advances in science over the past two centuries have truly been extraordinary, but our society still suffers from the forces that reject reason and prevent our ability to take full advantage of discoveries

Read More
1254 Words | 6 Pages

Although scientist’s work can be displayed as factual, valid and relevant many religious, political, and social factors contributed to the work publishings of these scientists. Religion and religious figures included the extent of scientist’s finding that where made public. A majority of this was due to the Catholic church’s belief in God. Science was a secular matter and did not involve God, which was a problem for the presently heavily religious Europeans. This also lead to the reason of why Catholics did not experience science until much after the Protestants did, due to their different beliefs.

Read More
492 Words | 2 Pages

Scientific research seems very factual and straight-forward. In reality, science deals with uncertainty, something that, when not used in the right way, creates weaknesses. The uncertainty of scientific research allows scientists to explore intellectually as well as creatively, and “venture into the unknown” to create the known. In his account from The Great Influenza, John M. Barry uses formal diction, strategically placed rhetorical questions, and an appeal to logos to characterize scientific research.

Read More
1192 Words | 5 Pages

Ethics throughout science are very controversial as they are the model of distinguishing between right and wrong throughout all aspects of research. Throughout Honeybee Democracy and The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks we are given an insider’s perspective to the ethics, or the lack there of, regarding the ongoing research and the researchers conducting it. Although the books cover very different subject matter, there are divisions of their research and within their individual ethics that are almost indistinguishable. One of the most highly debatable and common questions of ethics stems from the idea of whether it is acceptable to sacrifice lives for science.

Read More
895 Words | 4 Pages

As time went from the 16th century to the 18th century, the Renaissance thinking transformed to the Scientific Revolution. Soon, it would enable a worldview in which people were not invoking the principles of religion as often as the Renaissance. As an example, these natural philosophers, known as scientists today, developed a new thinking in which the world was no longer geocentric. The thought of an Earth-centered universe as the Bible would say, transformed as heliocentric or in other words Sun-centered. Within this period, Scientists were starting to understand the world’s functions, for they created experiment methods incorporating discipline, mathematics, and the essential Scientist communication.

Read More
1552 Words | 7 Pages

The Scientific Revolution “refers to historical changes in thought & belief, to changes in social & institutional organization, that unfolded in Europe between roughly 1550-1700” (Hatch). This revolution was a time to replace

Read More
748 Words | 3 Pages

During the seventeenth century, many of Europe’s diverse and numerous countries were going through countless political, economic, and cultural transformations. The Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment were two of the greatest, most important changes of the early modern era which greatly altered the course of history in most of Europe. People were starting to question and challenge widely accepted beliefs and applying approaches to knowledge rooted in human reason to the physical universe and human affairs. The study of history often focuses on these events and its effects on Europe, excluding or ignoring its effects on places outside of Europe. The Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment both sparked interests in science in China and

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

He argued that science is essential to our understanding of the world and plays a crucial role in shaping our society. He stressed that science should be a public trust and that it is the responsibility of scientists to use their knowledge for the benefit of humanity. He supported his argument with a variety of examples, including the role of science in creating new technologies and in solving important social problems. He also spoke about the importance of international cooperation and the role of scientists in working together to create a better

Read More
898 Words | 4 Pages

There were scientific findings before the 16th century and there were more to follow the 18th century. Shapin’s thesis covers that there was no specific scientific distinction between the 17th century and the rest of time for this period to stand out and be a revolution but he explains that the Scientific Revolution is more of a process. Shapin still believes that the scientific findings of this time can be considered revolutionary. Shapin explains that “Science remains whatever it is-certainly the most reliable body of natural knowledge we have got” (165) to show that he still understands how important science and the findings in science are to the world and civilization.

Read More
1410 Words | 6 Pages

Modern science is typically subdivided into the natural sciences, which study the material world, the social sciences which study people and societies, and the formal sciences like mathematics. The formal sciences are often excluded as they do not depend on empirical observations.[5] We have to keep in mind that science helps us describe how the world is, but it cannot make any judgments about whether that state of affairs is right, wrong, good, or bad and individual people must make moral judgments.

Read More
1335 Words | 6 Pages

Merton was passionate about social science. His interests lay in interactions and the importance between social and cultural structures and science. One of Merton’s contributions to sociology was the notion of “Self-Fulfilling Prophecy”. For Merton, he cited ‘Thomas

Read More

More about Robert Merton's Theory Of Science

Related Topics

Open Document