ipl-logo

Roman Vs United States Senate Essay

1284 Words6 Pages

Roman VS United States senate The Roman and United States senate are both very similar, and it is clear that the Roman Senate was a precursor to the United States Senate. As the Roman Senate came first and we could watch the history unfold, the United States made smarter decisions to create a more stable and people-serving government. Those who do not learn history repeat it, and with the advantage of time the US Senate got to learn from the Romans mistakes. I will be taking the position that the United States Senate is better and more efficient than the Roman Senate. I am going to give a light overview of each Senate, and compare and contrast them. The word “senate” came from the root word “senex”, …show more content…

The rules were set and grounded right away. The requirement was 30 years of age for Senators. 100 Senators are put in place. Senators were selected by state legislators instead of citizens in the beginning, but later was changed to Senators were elected by the people for the people. Senators must live in the state that elected them, and they serve a term of six years. Though each state has different populations, each state is equally represented by two senators. The Senate has stood strong since the beginning, through weak and strong presidents. It shares many of the same powers as the House of Representatives. Alexis de Tocqueville says the Senate is “eloquent advocates, distinguished generals, wise magistrates and statesmen of note, whose language would at times do honor to the most remarkable parliamentary debates in Europe.” …show more content…

However, the President does not have as much power in the Senate as the Princeps Senatus Would have had. The power is evened out, allowing the President to vote in the Senate in the case of a tie. Unlike in the Roman Senate the power of the President and Vice President is controlled by strict rules, these rules are put in place to keep Senators and leaders from overstepping their authority. The powers that the Senate has are written in the constitution, and different from the other branches of government. For example, if the house of representatives recommends an impeachment, it has to go through the Senate first. “The Constitution assigns the Senate and House equal power for declaring war, maintaining the armed forces, assessing taxes, borrowing money, minting currency, regulating commerce, and making all laws “necessary and proper” for the operation of the government. However, the Senate holds exclusive authority to advise and consent on treaties and presidential nominations.”

Show More
Related
388 Words | 2 Pages

Overall, different people have different opinions on the Senate. Some want to abolish, reform or keep it as is. However, I believe it should be reformed to make it more equal for everyone across

Read More
1618 Words | 7 Pages

The term length for a Senator is six-years, with one-third of Senators being up for election every two-years. This keeps a constant rotation of new ideas and people within the Senate, while providing stability to the legislative branch. Eligibility for a Senator requires you to have attained at least 30-years of age and a citizen for at least nine-years. According to Madison, this helps prevents the inexperienced and foreigners who wish to cause harm from being

Read More
234 Words | 1 Pages

There are many similarities between the Roman Republic senate and the United State senate. We can begin with both the Roman Senate and U.S. Senate. Members of opposing parties’ debate in chamber.

Read More
1117 Words | 5 Pages

Article I described the powers of the legislature which were the ability to (page 35) ratify treaties, collect taxes, borrow money, regulate commerce, to print money, declare war, to establish a post office, declare war, build roads, to maintain a Navy and Militia. It also gave special responsibilities to each body. All bills regarding revenue must originate in the House. The Senate has the ability to approve presidential appointments and would preside over any possible impeachment trial of a sitting President. Article I allowed each body of the legislature to establish its own rules and elect its own leaders.

Read More
868 Words | 4 Pages

In Virginia, the House of Representatives were elected by the people of the state and the Senate were nominated by the state

Read More
1298 Words | 6 Pages

Furthermore, Livius’ article (2002) stated that, “The emperor Augustus lowered this age to 25 years,” which reflected how Augustus attempted to make the position of Questor more desirable. Further reorganisation of the senate was highlighted through the Praetors. For example, Dio Cassius explained how praetors was a desired position as it afforded them the opportunity to manage public festivals and manage the treasury. This references how praetors powers to preside over law courts, manage the treasury (2 of them), organise games & festivals (given to them 22 BCE on wards), assist the consuls and Augustus and participate in military

Read More
742 Words | 3 Pages

As with Madison, Senator Morris believed that the public could not be trusted in making law for the country’s whole well-being even if the government’s legitimacy flowed from the people. Hence, the Founders established the Senate to represent state governments’ interests and temper the legislative process. They achieved the former goal by establishing equal state representation, six year terms, and senators’ selection by state legislatures. Demonstrating the Senate’s responsibility to temper the legislative process, the Constitution grants it several exclusive powers, including jurisdiction over approving treaties. If this power was also granted to the House, the Founders feared that majorities would quickly overturn treaties with the quick ebb and flow of popular opinion.

Read More
1531 Words | 7 Pages

With the dominance of the government in the house and its ability to restrict and limit debate the Senate becomes one of

Read More
222 Words | 1 Pages

In any event, the Framers of the Constitution vested that task in the Senate and nowhere else. The last

Read More
496 Words | 2 Pages

However, it was the Emperor, Augustus, who held the true powers of the state. Augustus who inherited a Senate whose membership had increased to a size of 900 Senators by his adoptive father Julius Caesar, sought to reduce the size of the Senate to 600 Senators. To reduce the size of the Senate, Augustus expelled Senators who are of low birth. He reformed the rules which specified how an individual becomes part of the Senate. “Under Augustus’ reforms, a Senate must be a citizen of free birth, have not convicted any crimes under lex Julia de vi privata, and have property worth at least 1,000,000 sesterces.”

Read More
1095 Words | 5 Pages

The point of Senators is to give the people of their state a voice in deciding whether to agree with a law or not on their behalf. Tyranny does not allow citizens to have a say on what gets passed or not. The United States made sure that there was no possible way we would fall into the category of tyranny by doing

Read More
323 Words | 2 Pages

Many patricians bought their way into the Senate or bribed Senators to pass laws favoring their

Read More
693 Words | 3 Pages

The "power" was only allowed to the patricians at first too. The Senate had different executive power called auctoritas. Even though it had no legal power, it still had some influence as advice of sorts to the consuls and later on, emperors. Members of this were unpaid and served for life unless they did something bad and were guilty. Senators were not allowed banking or trade either.

Read More
1027 Words | 5 Pages

There are many similarities that can be noticed between the American Nation and the Roman Empire such as the same founding of government and both dominated in military, and economic similarities. Rome is famous for their harsh discipline amongst their own ranks and their mercifulness brutality amongst their enemies. Rome warfare was characterized by great ferocity and the roman pursuit of victory was determined. Rome gave many good ideas; the senate was ruled by the people of Rome. The Roman Republic Government was a large complex constitution, which was secure by many checks and balances, so that no man could have complete control.

Read More
670 Words | 3 Pages

Slaves and women were not citizens, nor had the right to participate in politics. All citizens must serve in the army, and only those who had served at least 10 years in the army could be eligible as consuls and magistrates (Saint Leo University, 2021). There were severe class distinctions. Senators were patricians, the upper class people, and the Consuls were also from the senatorial classes (Saint Leo University, 2021). Some political bodies were more powerful than others.

Read More

More about Roman Vs United States Senate Essay

Related Topics

Open Document