ipl-logo

STEM Education Controversies

1552 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The Case for STEM Education

STEM Labor and Supply Controversies
Throughout the years, America experienced a developing controversy over whether or not science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) education has had a positive impact on the growing economy. The K-12 education systems across the nation have actively enforced STEM in order to attract students into these fields of study. The 2005 reports, Rising Above The Gathering Storm, Tapping America’s Potential, and Innovative America, all address the issues concerning teacher quality, an adequate amount of workers, international test rankings, H1-B visa permits, and achievement gaps, which could all be factors in hurting the economy. The United States is making an effort to improve STEM education in order …show more content…

Although the labor and supply shortage is being criticized, the value of STEM education and workers are still recognized. It is important to upcoming generations because the careers in these fields are crucial to not just America, but world development. For instance, the research of scientists lead to breakthroughs in developing cures to various diseases, as well as engineers who design software systems, machines to help the environment, and most importantly our everyday uses such as cars and phones. Without STEM education, America would be suffering from a lack of basic knowledge and become less competitive. Some factors that could wear down competition in the United States are immigrants who come to the United States with H-1B visa …show more content…

However, the STEM field is not suffering from a lack of workers because of poor education, but rather from an outside factor such as H-1B workers who displace native workers. A solution to this problem would be to reform the H-1B revision process so that companies can not find loopholes to access cheap labor. The immigrants that businesses are taking advantage of are displacing American workers, which are leading policymakers to invest their time and money into improving STEM education when it is not necessary. The STEM labor supply is crucial to America’s economy and society because this work field is what leads to great discoveries and breakthroughs. Without an adequate amount of workers, the United State’s national development would be falling behind, and the nation would lose its title of being the number one

Show More
Related

Analysis Of Anthony Carnevale's Essay 'College Is Still Worth It'

730 Words | 3 Pages

He structures his essay to make a valid argument. The formation of his essay is a preview of what will be discussed in detail. He begins his argument from an economic perspective, pointing out that the national Bureau of Labor Statistics data is incorrect because it under-predict demand for college educations. He shows his audience that the BLS predictions do not come close to what actually happened in the economy. For an example, the Bureau undercounted the number of postsecondary educated workers by about 17 million in the year of 2006.

Read More

Summary Of We Can T All Be Math Nerds And Science Geeks

753 Words | 4 Pages

How exciting would the world be if everyone was either a scientist or mathematician? What would the world be like? Of course there will be a bountiful supply of scientific breakthroughs thank we can bank on, but what how will all of the other aspects of the world fare? As of currently, all across the country there has been a jolt of urgency for the incorporation of a more STEM based education in schools. A more “STEM” based education like the type described in We Can’t All Be Math Nerds and Science Geeks by Fareed Zakaria narrows student’s once broad-based learning foundation and directs it into a more specific line of learning, which is the reasoning behind Zakaria’s disapproval of the movement.

Read More

How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America By Lloyd Bentsen

1040 Words | 5 Pages

The value of the STEM system (science, technology, engineering, and math) is steering the education world in a new and positive direction, although some may believe otherwise. In Lloyd Bentsen’s article, “the United States educational system will continue to fail our children,” he talks about how he disagrees with Zakaria, another writer stating his views on the STEM system. Bentsen believes the STEM system will benefit America. In Scott Gerber’s article, “How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America,” he talks about how people can correlate their majors into entrepreneurship. Lastly, in Fareed Zakaria’s article, “Why America’s obsession with STEM education is dangerous,” he shares his belief that our obsession with STEM is just a way to overlook

Read More

Why Stm Majors Are A Terrible Investment John Skrentny

809 Words | 4 Pages

With today's economic issues like high inflation, having good pay is crucial to living a content life. When companies go out of their way to stop the increase in pay, STEM majors won’t see a beneficial financial return on their investment.

Read More

We Don T Need More Humanities Majors By Edward Conard

805 Words | 4 Pages

But that growth is constrained in two ways. It is constrained by the amount of properly trained talent, which is needed to produce innovation. And it is constrained by this talent's willingness to take the entrepreneurial risks critical to commercializing innovation" and then goes on saying that "it is hard to believe humanities degree programs are the best way to train America's most talented students" (469-471). The reality is, humanities sheds a light on the huge influence science has had, and does have on shaping society and the quality of people's lives, both negatively and positively (Dalbert, 2011). To excel in the STEM world, we must understand the impact that STEM and medicine has had on society and understand the future scientific needs.

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Rivalry Between Washington And W. E. B Dubois

189 Words | 1 Pages

We should not have to only receive an education related to agriculture, commerce, and

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Why Is Science Too Straight By Manil Suri

907 Words | 4 Pages

This articles main argument is that there is a bias in the STEM community and work field of the L.G.B.T. community. Suri’s based this argument on his own experiences and the experiences of others. Suri supports this argument based on personal experiences, the experiences of others in the engineering field, statistics, and policies in certain companies. Suri persuades the audience by providing many examples of discrimination to the L.G.B.T. community and how it affects them and

Read More

Bluecollar Jobs Case Study

444 Words | 2 Pages

But shoud we pressure children to go to college for a degree that doesn’t mean anything to them. Due to this there are not enough trade people. There has been a shift from massive

Read More

Not What It Used To Be Written For The Economist

623 Words | 3 Pages

As opposed to much of the past, most jobs today require at least a small amount of higher education, and the work field is increasingly competitive. This need for further education allows colleges to raise tuition costs, as most people have no choice but to pay the fees to have a career. Colleges are also spending more money trying to compete in rankings. Despite all this spending, the article states that “America has only the 15th-largest proportion of young people with a university

Read More

Liberal Arts Argument In STEM Field

121 Words | 1 Pages

I’ve seen students struggle with being literate and numerate so I’m not even sure they could begin to concern themselves with becoming competent in STEM fields during high school. It would seem that educators might be more helpful to encourage students to use high school to build a breadth of knowledge in many different areas, knowing that college will be the time to build depth. High school could be used to develop the basics and apply elements from many, non-science fields to their work similar to a liberal arts approach. Providing students with a broad-based high school foundation before entering college would help develop them into well-rounded students prepared for whichever program they choose whether it’s a STEM program or not.

Read More

STEM Education Dbq

864 Words | 4 Pages

The future of the Earth is dependent upon science and mathematics development, whether it’s traveling millions of miles away to other planets, creating microscopic circuitry to control military technology, or figuring out just why the sky is blue and the sun is yellow. STEM education, therefore, is the most important frontier to pursue for the evolution of mankind. Not only do the STEM fields need to be nurtured and funded by society, but STEM fields of research and work need to be emphasized at a young age and encouraged for women and people of color. As the world becomes increasingly dependent upon advances in the STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) fields of work, less and less funding and societal support is

Read More

Unocumented Latino Immigrants

479 Words | 2 Pages

According to the Pew Research Center, 47 percent of undocumented Latino immigrants have less than a high school education. It is difficult for them, nowadays, to find a good job without having a complete education, because most of the high quality jobs are hiring people with high education rather than hiring someone with a low education. Moreover, people with a higher education tend to earn more than the ones who are less-educated (Greenstone & Looney, 2012). This shows the importance of having a complete education. In addition, something interesting that the United States Department of Education has towards the undocumented immigrants is that they have not denied education to the undocumented (May, 2014).

Read More

Is College Worth All The Time

470 Words | 2 Pages

“ The U.S. has been transformed from a manufacturing based economy to an economy based on knowledge.” The economy change makes it hard for people who were planning on going into manufacturing jobs. Even those who aren't looking into a manufacturing job is still finding it difficult to find a job. With the economy the way it is its making everyone more competitive when it comes to job hunting. “ The global economy is becoming increasingly more competitive, and in order to give yourself a chance for a well-paying job, you must first understand the importance of a college education.”

Read More

Undocumented Immigration Sociology

1370 Words | 6 Pages

This is because, a given type of worker may be scarce either because the U.S. supply of his skill type is low relative to the rest of the world, as with workers who have little schooling, or because the U.S. demand for his skill type is high relative to the rest of the world, as with computer scientists and engineers. They further note that between 1960 and 2000, the amount of working-age native-born U.S. citizens with less than twelve years of schooling fell from 50 to 12 percent (Hanson, 2007). Furthermore, it has been found that over time, although many native-born citizens believe that immigrants may take their job opportunities away from them, research says otherwise. Costa, Cooper, and Shierholz (2014) report that in the long run, immigrants do not, in fact, reduce native employment rates. However, from a short-term perspective, they may slightly reduce native employment, because the economy takes time to adjust to new influxes of immigration.

Read More

The DREAM Act

1319 Words | 6 Pages

In recent discussions of immigration reform regarding the DREAM (Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors) Act, a controversial issue has been whether to allow undocumented students to pursue higher education without any specific criteria to qualify, or deny them access to it. On the one hand, some argue that “illegals” take away job opportunities after obtaining a college degree. On the other hand, however, others argue that undocumented students greatly benefit the economy through providing a larger educated workforce. In the words of one of this view’s main proponents, the DREAM Act “rewards motivated, hardworking young adults” for their work rather than grant a free ride to college to illegal immigrant students (Deverall). According

Read More

More about STEM Education Controversies

Related Topics

Open Document