ipl-logo

Sentencing Children As Adults By Lawrence Gorski

1028 Words5 Pages

As children, we were told some variation of the phrase that if you do the crime, then you do the time. This phrase acts as a reminder that individuals are responsible for their actions. So, when a child commits a crime, typically the consequence is being sent to a juvenile center. While some argue juveniles should be held responsible, trying juveniles as adults in the justice system fails to consider the developmental differences between children and adults. It harms the principles of rehabilitation and promotes a cycle of violence and injustice within society. In the essay "Sentencing Children as Adults,” author Terence Gorski talks about the negative impacts of trying juveniles as adults in the criminal justice system. Patrick McCormick's …show more content…

Subjecting juveniles to adult sentencing raises profound concerns regarding human rights, dignity, and the principle of proportionality in punishment. The ethical principles of justice demand that the punishment fits the crime and considers individual factors like age, mental health, and potential for rehabilitation. Treating young offenders, the same as adults, ignores these important principles. Gorski, in "Sentencing Children As Adults", gives the example of a 12-year-old boy who was sentenced to death in prison for an accidental homicide offense, highlighting the extreme consequences of subjecting juveniles to adult sentencing. "Lionel thought he was playing when he emulated the moves and tactics of the professional wrestlers who were his heroes and role models. Lionel, an immature 12-year-old, assumed he could do to other kids what these heroic wrestlers did to each other.Thinking he was playing, Lionel body-slammed, head-kicked, and knee-dropped Tiffany. It was over quickly, too. Lionel was shocked and traumatized to see that he killed Tiffany." Since the judge was unaware of Lionel's intentions and immaturity, he was sentenced to death in prison for the accidental homicide. This tragic case sheds light on the devastating consequences of subjecting juveniles to adult sentencing. Also, in this case, the boy was unsupervised and was lacking guidance. This proves that there can be other factors contributing to why kids might commit crimes. It is crucial to consider the circumstances surrounding juvenile offenders and provide them with appropriate support and guidance to prevent such tragic outcomes. Lack of supervision and guidance can significantly impact a child's behavior and decision-making process, emphasizing the importance of addressing underlying issues in juvenile delinquency

Show More
Related
743 Words | 3 Pages

In the book Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson, who is an attorney, guides us through his life in Alabama and how he helps defend innocent, poor people and children on death row who were wrongly convicted. Nearly 44,000 youth are incarcerated in juvenile justice facilities. Currently an estimated 250,000 youth are tried, sentenced, or incarcerated as adults every year across the United States. While some may argue that young adult offenders should be tried and punished as adults to ensure that their actions do not reoccur, the United States Justice Systems should implement rehabilitation and less harsh punishments for younger offenders to fully develop and mature.

Read More
970 Words | 4 Pages

Many people complain about how juveniles lack brain development and this should be an excuse. It makes others uncertain about trying them as adults since they lack decision-making and impulse control. Despite the lack of development, it’s ideal to recognize that for certain violent crimes, “there have to be consequences to actions” (Ford). Allowing juveniles to simply avoid adult punishment doesn’t help to promote public safety or give adolescents the responsibility they need in the future. But most people believe that juveniles still have room for rehabilitation and change.

Read More
931 Words | 4 Pages

In the 1990s, there was a major increase in the number of juvenile prisons being built. By 2000, it was common for juveniles to be sent to adult jails for crimes they had committed (“Juvenile Justice”). Bryan Stevenson is a lawyer who works with children who were given the death penalty. During his career, he wrote the book, “Just Mercy” to inform people about how poorly and unfairly the justice system treats juveniles. In the book, “Just Mercy”, Bryan Stevenson makes the argument that the juvenile justice system needs to change.

Read More
983 Words | 4 Pages

They May Seem Young But Not Always Throughout recent years in the United States there has been several homicide cases involving juveniles under the age of eighteen. At such a young and rather undeveloped age, they are considered as minors however, in the eyes of the justice system nearly all are punished as adult victims and given life imprisonment without parole. These decisions have unintentionally ignited a dreadful controversial debate across America.

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

As he faced justice through the court system, advocates unnecessarily argued that he was only a child and too young to serve as an adult. To show that an individual’s age should not be used as an excuse to justify their actions, Weir states “Some juveniles commit crimes so serious, so heinous, that public safety mandates — and justice demands — full accountability in our criminal justice system. There are those who argue this is unfair and unjust. They say the juvenile brain is not fully developed until well into the

Read More
746 Words | 3 Pages

According to “Kids in Prison” by Brian Hansen, juveniles are being tried as adults for violent and non-violent crimes. Kids being tried as adult is the most controversial topic the world cannot agree on today. It is hard to pick one side due to every case being a different situation, but I think I have established a well-thought opinion. Children should not be tried as adults due to their level of cognitive capability, proneness to harm in adult prisons, and their inability to be rehabilitated in a harmful environment. First, a child’s cognitive thinking is at a different level than an adult’s, so a child does not have the means to survive in an adult prison.

Read More
259 Words | 2 Pages

Children are not Adults The controversial issue of juvenile crime is a frequently intangible topic. Naturally, most people find the idea of a young child committing a severe crime very appalling, as no one expects a wide-eyed child to engage in such a heinous act of misconduct. In the essay “Adult Crime, Adult +30Time”, Linda J. Collier affirms that children who engage in adult conduct should undoubtedly be sent to an adult prison (Collier 608). Clearly, a child should be penalized for a corrupt act such as murder, but, Ms. Collier’s solution is considerably harsh for a child of such a young age. In the order of criminal justice, a young child should certainly not be disciplined in the same manner as an adult.

Read More
998 Words | 4 Pages

An average juvenile was involved in an argument with his teacher and took a gun and shot him without any intentions. When on trial, he realized that he made an unwise decision and responded quizzically to the interrogation questions from the prosecutor. Subsequently, demonstrators outside the trial court argued that “a child is not a man” and shouldn’t be punished like one. Such a case was presented in the trial of Nathaniel Brazill. Although all lives matter and children are known for being compulsive, dangerous citizens of our society, they are juveniles and deserve to be tried as juveniles.

Read More
386 Words | 2 Pages

There persists a heated and controversial debate nationwide as to whether, under any circumstances, a juvenile should be tried as an adult and sentenced to life in prison without parole. While recent efforts to ease the punishment have reduced the ultimate sentence for juveniles to forty years in some areas, the problem remains unaddressed at its root. Juveniles should not be sentenced as adults to life without parole because they lack in cognitive development, have rehabilitative capacity, and cost more annually to be held in prison than to be put through programs that address the root of the problem. First and most importantly, Juveniles should not be tried and sentenced as adults for life because the adolescent brain is in a period of cognitive

Read More
911 Words | 4 Pages

Juveniles who commit a major crime (think of murder) might be let out earlier than an adult who also commits because they are in the juvenile system. “Violent crime rates and juvenile crime have been in a steady decline over the past 20 years; however, reforms to restore the juvenile court system to its original vision have not been as swift” (Marsha Levick). This evidence is important because it shows the importance of the Criminal Justice System and how it protects the

Read More
1247 Words | 5 Pages

they are far more able than adults to learn new skills, find new values, and re embark on a better, law-abiding life” (“Minors Are Not…”). Juveniles can rehabilitate from their mistakes and change their lives. They may need a little help to change, but the help and resource they need are not found in prisons. Sentencing juveniles as adults causes them to lose hope in their future. It makes these teens feel as though they can never accomplish anything in the future because of their one mistake; however, that is far from the truth.

Read More
622 Words | 3 Pages

In today’s society, juveniles can and do commit violent crimes. As a result, many are tried as adults and, if convicted, are sent to adult prison and sentenced to juvenile life without parole. Life without parole means that a young person is locked up for life without a second chance. Although some may argue that juveniles, who have committed violent crimes, deserve juvenile life without parole sentence, in reality, juvenile offenders should not be sentenced to life without parole because juveniles are mentally and emotionally immature, the victims of their own environment, and can be rehabilitated. Juveniles are not ready for life sentence without parole because of their mental and emotional immaturity.

Read More
1303 Words | 6 Pages

Minors are often immature when they commit horrendous crimes. Furthermore, they don't have an appropriate level of psychological understanding to make sound decisions. Trying juveniles as adults is wrong because juveniles are not mentally stable enough to understand that the decisions that they make can negatively impact their future, trying minors as adults hinders their growth as individuals and harms their productivity in the long run. Instead of juveniles being sentenced as adults for their criminal offenses, they should be obligated to participate in intervention programs. Juveniles don't have a fully developed mental stability to make sound decisions.

Read More
693 Words | 3 Pages

In the United States, the juvenile justice system was founded with the purpose of focusing on rehabilitation rather than punishment when a juvenile has committed a crime [1]. Although the juvenile justice system continues to serve this purpose, there has been an ongoing conflict between protecting society from harm through equal punishment regardless of the perpetrator’s age, and rehabilitation goals regarding the juvenile in question [2]. Due to this ongoing conflict, the question of whether juveniles should be tried as adults for violent crimes is controversial, for one side claims that not doing so is unethical because it is unjust, whereas the opposing side claims that doing so is unethical because it violates the principle of least harm.

Read More
916 Words | 4 Pages

Die In Prison The rate in which juveniles have been tried as adults for committing heinous crimes have increased in recent years. In comparison to the same actions being done by adults, it has been controversial with how a young adult should be treated and where his or her future will eventually end up in. The main problem occurring within these individuals is whether they should be given life in prison without parole or have the ability to be given a second chance.

Read More

More about Sentencing Children As Adults By Lawrence Gorski

Open Document