ipl-logo

Should Transgender Athletes Be Able To Compete In Women's Sports Essay

1534 Words7 Pages

In recent discussions with transgender athletes, a controversial issue has emerged whether transgender athletes should be able to compete in women’s sports. On the one hand, supporters contend that “allowing transgender women to compete in women's sports argues that no evidence exists that trans women are ruining athletics or displacing cisgender women” (Issues & Controversies). From this perspective, transgender athletes should be allowed to participate in women’s sports. On the other hand, however, opposers argue that transgender athletes should not be able to compete in women’s sports. “Opponents of allowing transgender women to compete in women's sports argue that it is an objective and proven fact that, broadly speaking, people born male …show more content…

These factors gave Thomas an unfair advantage over her cisgender female competitors. Allowing such advantages to exist compromises the principles of fair competition. Cato Institute Transgender athletes are frequently setting new records in women’s sports which undermines the achievements of their hard working cisgender female competitors. Several notable examples of transgender athletes winning in women competitions include CeCe Telfer’s victory in the NCAA Division II 400-meter hurdles event, Laurel Hubbard achieving multiple gold medals at an international women's powerlifting competition, and Rachel McKinnon winning the Masters Track Cycling World Championship in 2018 and 2019. (Issues and Controversies) Transgender athletes competing in women’s sports compromises the rights of cisgender female athletes. The inclusion of transgender athletes in women’s sports poses a threat to the rights of transgender female athletes. Riley Gaines, a former collegiate swimmer at the University of Kentucky who competed against Lia Thomas, voiced her concerns before Congress stating, “Under the proposed rule, women’s sports aren’t just for …show more content…

If allowed, this will endanger women in sports and private spaces and take away opportunities for women in sports and academia. Never in a million years did I think I would be sitting here at 56 fighting to get back the rights that were given to women and girls 51 years ago.” Title IX is a federal civil rights law that prohibits sex based discrimination in any educational institution that receives funding from the federal government. For more than half a century, Title IX has ensured equal athletic opportunities for female athletes. US Department of Education (US Department of Education) However, the Biden Administration is pushing to make a significant modification to Title IX to accommodate transgender athletes by allowing them to compete according to their gender identity alongside cisgender athletes. (Jack Wolfsohn, Legislative Correspondent in the United States Senate) This modification would prioritize inclusion over fairness which jeopardizes the rights and opportunities of cisgender female

Show More
Related

Judith B Stamper's Face-Off On The Playing Field

141 Words | 1 Pages

In the article titled Face-off on the playing field By, Judith B. Stamper explains girls have their own story of support or discrimination, success also the debate of girls be allowed to compete on boys’ sports team. First, the writer Title IX explains female athletes are been treated second-class for long enough and should pass of inequalities and biases of girls. The writer also clarifies that girls doing sports make them healthier, physically, and emotionally. Other girls that don’t play sports are less likely to use of drugs. In addition, she notes a former Stanford University basketball player Mariah says, strength and independence of things girls learn from sports, the opportunities that are changing women.

Read More

Title IX Is Still Fighting Perception It Hurt Men's Sports Summary

533 Words | 3 Pages

Although Wells and Marbella suggest that men’s sports are being hurt because of Title IX, Goodale establishes that Title IX is not negatively impacting men’s athletics and is necessary for colleges to follow. Title IX, a 40-year law establishing equal opportunity for women has not negatively impacted men’s sports, as clarified in “40 Years Later, Title IX is Still Fighting Perception it Hurt Men’s Sports” by Gloria Goodale. First and foremost, sports like Football and Basketball take up a majority of a college budget for men’s sports, and when colleges cut minor teams such as baseball or tennis Title IX is unfairly blamed. A large amount of colleges decide to limit men’s athletic to large money-making sports such as football or basketball

Read More

Summary Of 37 Words By Sherry Boschert

895 Words | 4 Pages

One experience from personal experiences also illustrates the changes in how Title IX has affected sports. The first story takes place at Stanford University, a school with an athletic program that has been at the forefront of gender equity in sports. Boschert describes how the school’s Title IX, coordinator, Katie Martens, works tirelessly to ensure compliance with the law. Martens monitors the athletic department’s budget, ensure equal treatment of male and female athletes, and investigates complaints of discrimination. Her efforts have paid off, with the school receiving high marks for compliance with Title IX.

Read More

Examples Of Title 9 Discriminate Against Male Athletes

739 Words | 3 Pages

Title IX discriminates against male athletes by cutting teams, trying to make male sports equal to female sports, and news coverage. First of all, male athletes are being discriminated against by cutting the teams. By cutting the teams, the males are being excluded from participation in the sport, which is a violation of Title IX. Just because there are too many male athletes, doesn’t be that the

Read More

Title IX And Its Effects On Women's Sports

891 Words | 4 Pages

Title IX is a landmark piece of legislation that is now 42 years old and still going strong in representing mainly women’s athletics and establishing a foundation to stand and improve upon. Before this piece of legislation, men’s sports dominated women’s sports in all aspects, both in money, participation, physicality etc. With this law being established women now have a stronger presence in the sporting world because of this law. Women’s sports still have a long way to come in gaining media attention especially in big tournaments like NCAA March madness. Title IX is now turning into controversial debates with the increase of women’s sports and programs for athletics but to make room for these sports, some men’s sports have to be cut.

Read More

Title IX And Gender Equality

227 Words | 1 Pages

Title IX was signed into law in 1972 and it required equality for male and female students in each educational program and activity that received federal funding. This means that universities had to offer sports that women could participate in. The reasons Title IX came into being was a demand from Women’s Rights organizations for equal opportunities. Prior to 1972, sports, competition, and many other university programs were generally considered to be masculine and “ not ladylike.”

Read More

Women Athletes Do Not Have Unfair Advantages Summary

660 Words | 3 Pages

A women’s work is never done, that is, in Katelyn’s eyes. In Katelyn Burns article, “No, Trans Women Athletes Do Not Have Unfair Advantages”, she wants to bring attention to transgender athletes. Her purpose of this article is to show how hard it is for trans genders to compete in sports because of an ‘unfair physical advantage’. Burns is building her credibility with personal facts and logic, stating very good knowledge about hormones in a trans women, and successfully employing emotional appeals; however, using pathos and logos throughout, her attempts to appeal the audience using emotion and logic help her credibility and ultimately, her argument. (Thesis)

Read More

Female Athletes In 'Blood Sweat And Jeers'

372 Words | 2 Pages

Even though female athletes are now becoming more accepted, they are still being challenged with a stigma known as “the image problem”, for example, all female athletes are lesbians. To avoid this “problem” the media employs a feminine apologetic in which they heterosexualize female athletes through emphasizing their relationships with men. In “Blood Sweat and Jeers” Knight mentions that female athletes continue to be confronted with the “image problem” or homophobia. She also notes that, “There is an underlying ear in society that participating in sports will encourage homosexuality or even convert female athletes into lesbians and prevent them from fulfilling their stereotypical domestic and maternal roles.” I strongly agree with this statement

Read More

Game Face: Film Analysis

1347 Words | 6 Pages

Acceptance and equal opportunities should be obtained when it comes to LGBT athletes. For instance, according to the Gay, Lesbian, and Straight Education Networks 2011 National School Climate Survey, nearly 30 percent of LGBT athletes report being attacked or harassed for their sexual

Read More

Arguments Against Title IX

1740 Words | 7 Pages

The United States needs to protect and enforce Title IX better than we are because the law provides countless opportunities for women and equals the playing field between men and women. Schools have worked hard to create scholarships and respected programs for women across the country. By not enforcing or protecting this law, the country will take severe steps in the wrong direction. From the issues involving sexual assault victims on campus, to transgender students still be discriminated against, and everything in between. There needs to be more enforcing of this law.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Billie Jean King

1456 Words | 6 Pages

Billie Jean King announced to the United States, “ I have often been asked whether I am a woman or an athlete. The question is absurd. Men are not asked that. I am an athlete. I am a woman.”

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Coed Sports

721 Words | 3 Pages

Imagine finally having the sport you are most passionate about available for you to participate in, yet not being able to compete in it simply because you are not of the correct gender. Nowadays, this is a fairly common issue. Whether it is because of both gender differences or due to the common belief that “boys are stronger than girls”, coeducation exercise is not exceedingly popular. Although many people believe males are stronger than females and think that coed sports are unfair, this type of athletics can benefit all athletes in multiple ways because it will allow both genders to work together more efficiently, allow the participants and sponsors to pay less, and help create connections with others that would not originally be made.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Transgender Female Athletes

548 Words | 3 Pages

(MacKenzie, 2022) Although there is a clear advantage, Lia Thomas and other male-to-female athletes remain competing against biological female athletes, dominating women’s sports. Being against male-to-female athletes competing against biological female athletes does not make you transphobic. While competing in their sports women have a right to safety and fairness, but they do not have either of those right now. The history of women’s sports must be upheld.

Read More

Examples Of Competing In Women's Sports

3496 Words | 14 Pages

Transgender Women Competing in Women's Sports There are many examples of transgender athletes causing problems in elite sports. Transgender athletes are taking away opportunities from women who worked hard. One of the most controversial examples is Lia Thomas who swam competitively in the NCAA. The NCAA Policy on Transgender Student-Athlete Participation (2022)made new changes for the accommodation of transgender gender athletes.

Read More

Essay On Transgender Identity In Sports

635 Words | 3 Pages

In sports, should there be a category for people who identify themselves as transgender? I believe people should not be limited or labeled for just one gender. In society, a binary system is a difficult complex system. A binary system is a system with two gender identities where male’s bodies have a certain biological identity and where female’s bodies have a certain biological identity. The International Olympic Committee (IOC) and the International Association of Athletics Federation (IAAF) should not organize and group Athletes by either Male or Female genders for the purpose of fair competition but should have groups of athletes with transgender identity and biological identity incorporated into both male and female categories because identities are non-binary.

Read More

More about Should Transgender Athletes Be Able To Compete In Women's Sports Essay

Open Document