Song Analysis Of Judy Collin's Punishment By Judy Collins

261 Words2 Pages
The Judy Collin’s rendition was very simplistic with emphasis on her voice and the words. It wasn’t until later in the song that string instruments and the piano were introduced. The first introduction of a string instrument doesn’t occur until almost a full minute and thirty seconds into the song. She sings the song in a perfect pitch that resonates based on the simulated echo. This rendition gives you the opportunity to sit and reflect about the moment and the spiritually. What can I say? The Aretha Franklin rendition is a stark contrast to Judy Collins. From the beginning of the song it is clear that her song is more complex as it probably takes place during a church service. Based on the introduction, it is clear from the audience