ipl-logo

Sophie's Choice Case Study

1001 Words5 Pages

What if a child with a potentially fatal disease had only one option for a cure, a treatment that cost 100 million dollars. Would you expect our publicly funded medicare system in Canada or a private insurance company in the USA to pay for it, or to opt to let the child die under the theory that the 100 million dollars could be better spent saving many more lives?

It a decision worthy of Sophie's Choice, where saving one life means condemning others to certain death, a decision that no rational human would feel comfortable making.

But the reality is that these decisions are made every day by government bureaucrats here in Canada or nameless insurance actuaries in the United States and belies the truth that we cannot provide maximum healthcare …show more content…

Bureaucracy and low productivity are the Achilles heal of the single-payer system whereby layers and layers of administrators rob the system of valuable resources and where inefficiency due to poor management and oversight are the bane of the system.

This can be best illustrated by the administration of health services in Quebec versus the rest of Canada, whereby Quebec's infamous bureaucracy and abysmally low productivity rate demonstrate how two single-payer systems operating under the exact same rules can register different results.

Let us remember that 25% of Quebecers cannot find a family doctor despite the province paying for more doctors per capita than Ontario. It is illustrative of how bureaucracy, bad management and laziness makes Quebec's healthcare system so bad as compared to other Canadian provinces, despite having equal financial …show more content…

The problem here is the cost, wherein many cannot avail themselves of the services because they don't have the means to pay or the insurance to cover it.

This is the American version of rationing.

When people vaunt the benefits of the American system over the Canadian system they always point to the availability and quality services as compared to Canada, but always fail to include the crucial aspect of access, whereby too many Americans are locked out of this fantastic medical system.

In the end no system is perfect, but let us consider that Canada spends half of what the USA spends on healthcare and I can only imagine how much better our system would be versus Trumpcare or Obamacare if we had double the

Show More
Related
1433 Words | 6 Pages

Better Now : 6 Big Ideas by Dr. Danielle Martin is a compilation of ideas to try and fix the Canadian Healthcare system. Martin gained popularity after a schooling Republicans at the United States committee led by the Independent Senator Bernie Sanders. The Canadian doctor was invited at the panel to represent Canada, alongside other countries like France, Denmark Taiwan, to discuss the nation’s healthcare system and what the United States could learn from it. Inevitably, one of the issues often brought up by Canadians is the long waiting periods that Capitalists like to blame on the single payer system. Martin argued that when Australia switched to a multi-payer system in the 1990’s, statistics showed that wait times in the public health

Read More
663 Words | 3 Pages

In Canada, Medicare allows people to sign up with the provincial government by a lone, administratively effective entry point in each region. This system recognizes the jeopardy of “skimming” and has had the idea to create legal restrictions to health care providers to avoid the rejection of patients. On the other hand, in the United States, large profitable corporations that become very successful with their range of services, reduce the competition. This results in people having less of a choice when it comes to their own healthcare. Canadian health care for the last 30 years has provided widely assessable health care to the people, and bringing in American managed care will only reduce accessibility to the

Read More
1608 Words | 7 Pages

Mind you, the idea all stemmed majorly from him, and the new CCF premier only signed it into effect. This replaced private insurances, and individuals had to pay $12 per year on premiums, and families $24. With this, everybody in the province paid for the healthcare of each other, and they were “reassured that a terrible illness in the family wouldn’t lead to bankruptcy”(tommydouglas.ca). John Diefenbaker, the Prime Minister at the time, already expressed interest in this, and his successor, Lester B Pearson would later pass the law, to enable universal healthcare all over Canada,“under all NDP members under NDP leader Tommy Douglas”(dufourlaw.com), in 1966. Tommy Douglas played very crucial roles in all of these

Read More
1074 Words | 5 Pages

It is a system which all Canadians are proud of. “Medicare’s basic principles embody how Canadians wish to both see themselves and distinguish their nation from a powerful, and at times overwhelming, continental neighbor ”(Shevell,2012,p.35). They did it. Nowadays, in the United States, there are only 48 million American who are able to enjoy medical treatment(Celeste& Roxanne, 2013). Furthermore, Medicare also brought benefits not only to local people but also immigrants.

Read More
420 Words | 2 Pages

The health care system provides benefits for Canadians such as covering costs for doctor’s visits, treatments and basically all care besides medical drugs. Likewise, this program was also very successful and effective therefore it still is apart of one of the many benefits given to

Read More
1351 Words | 6 Pages

Summary of “The American Healthcare Paradox” “The American Health Care Paradox” focuses on health care and how the United States is suffering compared to their peer countries. The United States has spent billions of dollars in health care and the problem is still growing. The government is responsible for not following or ignoring the issue that we suffered with, in today’s society the healthcare system is failing drastically. The health care system has been a problem for several decades now, even though it seems that things are getting better it’s not.

Read More
1050 Words | 5 Pages

As we know, after the 1940s, the two countries developed different health care systems. In the article, Maioni argues that completely different health care systems caused by diverse political systems in these two countries. The major point that the author makes to support her arguments was impact of the third party. The third party could only form in Canada, but not in the United States. This can be explained by the following two reasons.

Read More
938 Words | 4 Pages

The purpose of Maioni article is to analyze how Canada and United states ended up having two different form of health care insurance. Both countries until the 1940’s shared the same histories with their political ideology and economic development. This article examines how two counties with similar ideology came to have two different welfare states and most important government funded health insurance. Maioni points out two important reason why there was a diversion between both countries in terms of their health care. The first one is parliamentary government and the second was federalism.

Read More
1287 Words | 6 Pages

Is US Healthcare better than Canadian? Modern societies are based on their healthcare systems, which offer vital services to preserve and enhance the well-being of their citizens. There has been continuous discussion about comparing healthcare systems, especially those in the US and Canada. Each of the two nations' different approaches to healthcare delivery has advantages and disadvantages. The topic of this essay will be whether healthcare in the US or Canada is superior.

Read More
832 Words | 4 Pages

The one major difference between the Canadian health care system and the American health care system is that is that they have a privatized health care system. A documentary such as “Sicko directed by Michael Moore” demonstrates the crisis of American citizens without health care coverage. Canada’s universal health care system ensures those who cannot pay for health to not suffer, contrary to the Sicko

Read More
741 Words | 3 Pages

The United States is the only Western nation that does not authorize free health services to its people. The cost of healthcare to the uninsured is beyond prohibitive, and insurance plans are far more captivated with profit costs, rather

Read More
895 Words | 4 Pages

Canada enjoys the benefits of a “universal” insurance plan funded by the federal government. The idea of having a publicly administered, accessible hospital and medical services with comprehensive coverage, universality and portability has its own complex history, more so, than the many challenges in trying to accommodate the responsibility of a shared-cost agreement between federal and provincial governments. (Tiedemann, 2008) Canada’s health care system has gone through many reforms, always with the intent to deliver the most adequate health care to Canadians. The British North American Act, Hospital Insurance and Diagnostic Services Act, Saskatchewan’s Medical Care Act, and the Canada Health Act are four Acts that have played an important

Read More
727 Words | 3 Pages

Health care should not be considered a political argument in America; it is a matter of basic human rights. Something that many people seem to forget is that the US is the only industrialized western nation that lacks a universal health care system. The National Health Care Disparities Report, as well as author and health care worker Nicholas Conley and Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP), strongly suggest that the US needs a universal health care system. The most secure solution for many problems in America, such as wasted spending on a flawed non-universal health care system and 46.8 million Americans being uninsured, is to organize a national health care program in the US that covers all citizens for medical necessities.

Read More
1528 Words | 7 Pages

The research finding and data for the assignment was compiled from sources through various web sites, publications, online journals and abstracts. The resources used are from educators, HR professionals and are presumed to be trustworthy and accurate based on the resource author perspectives of employee recognition programs and HR special matter experts. The research implications are generalized based on the data collected and submitted. Types of effective and ineffective employee recognition programs The employee recognition strategy within an organization is the most complex step within the development of the program.

Read More
701 Words | 3 Pages

Health Care is a huge and important part of Canada and what it is. Canadian citizens all have access to Canada 's healthcare system known as `Medicare`. Medicare is managed by the federal government delivered through a publicly funded health care system, in cooperation with the 10 provinces and 3 territories. Under the health care system, individual citizens are provided preventative care and medical treatments from primary care physicians as well as access to hospitals, dental surgery, and additional medical services. With a few exceptions, all citizens qualify for health coverage regardless of medical history, personal income, or standard of living.

Read More

More about Sophie's Choice Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document