ipl-logo

Summary Of Coakley And Kates: Challenging Sweatshop Labor

697 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essays on sweatshops

Coakley and Kates: Challenging Sweatshop Labor

In their criticism of sweatshop labor, Coakley and Kates consider the morality of sweatshop labor through a welfarist lens similar to that of Powell and Zwolinski’s. To begin, Coakley and Kates summarize Powell and Zwolinski’s pro-sweatshop argument as a set of three premises:

Sweatshops are better for workers than the available alternatives.
Regulating sweatshop labor will lead to a decrease in sweatshop employment.
Therefore, regulating sweatshop labor will be harmful to workers.

Coakley and Kates provide some evidence that minimum wages or workplace regulations perhaps may not increase unemployment. However, for the sake of argument, they grant the validity of assumptions (1) and (2). Despite these assumptions, Coakley and Kates contend that, although actual employment in sweatshops is “an important factor to consider”, it cannot be the sole moral concern in a regulatory discussion (635). From a welfarist standpoint, Coakley and Kates assert that a more comprehensive evaluation of sweatshop regulation is necessary.

Elasticity of Labor Demand …show more content…

According to Coakley and Kates, this evidence indicates that elasticity of labor demand within sweatshops is very low. With this in mind, the authors believe that the net welfare of sweatshop workers may in fact rise significantly due to increased wages. This is because a large proportion of workers would realize large increases in income and well-being, while only a small proportion would bear the costs of unemployment. Although this is an unresolved empirical claim, Coakley and Kates appear to be confident in these

Show More
Related
176 Words | 1 Pages

Ravisankar begins his essay by focuses on America’s need one finding the lowest prices products. The problem he identified is by addressing the problem of workshop conditions and lack of pay . Ravisankar assumes his readers are consumers in America. His purpose in this essay is to inform America about the horrors of workshops and inform them are doing more harm than good. In order to accomplish, he appeals to Pathos by addressing the lack of humanity towards workshop workers.

Read More
754 Words | 4 Pages

Having traveled to Guatemala and seeing how most people live in third world countries the fact that well know American companies treat their oversees employees so poorly makes me angry. While in Guatemala many of the people there would work multiple jobs and still don’t make enough to be able to support their families. Their working conditions that I saw were terrible and their living conditions were not favorable just like the ones that were showed in the Nike sweatshop video. Although many people are looking for work in these third world countries to support their families, companies need to respect them and give the workers what is deserved. I believe that sweatshops still exist today, it’s changed from over time and they all have moved overseas because there are not many global laws that prevent against the harsh working conditions for these

Read More
809 Words | 4 Pages

Up until the early 20th century, American labor laws did not protect employees and work environments were not monitored for unsafe conditions. Factories were allowed to run without proper fire exits, ventilation, pay, breaks and even children were forced into labor. These unsafe conditions came crashing down just before the end of the workday on March 25th, 1911 in the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory in New York City. In just under 30 minutes, 146 lives perished (Benin). Today, we call these factories “sweatshops” and they are primarily found in countries that lack laws enforcing proper working conditions.

Read More
1000 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction The fire that erupted at the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory in New York City is remembered as one of the worst disasters since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. The infamous incident claimed 146 lives of young immigrant workers due to negligent safety precautions. To this day this incident has continued to have great significance because it highlights the inhumane working conditions that industrial workers have to be subjected to. Sweatshops before 1911

Read More
1871 Words | 8 Pages

Through the lens of intersectionality, we are allowed to see that sweatshop workers experienced double oppressions from structural racism and structural sexism that limited their choices of occupations and class inequality that exaggerated imbalanced power between laborers

Read More
873 Words | 4 Pages

Labor Practice Paper Angelia Henry PHL/320 May 2, 2016 Bridget Peaco Labor Practice Paper Merriam-Webster online defines a sweatshop as a shop or factory where employees work long at a low wage that is under poor and unhealthy conditions (Merriam-Webster On-line Dictionary, 2016). Sweatshops are factories that violate two or more labor laws to include wages, benefits, child labor or even working hours (Ember, 2014-2015). Companies will attempt to use sweatshop labor to lessen the cost to meet the demands of customers. When we think of sweatshop, we always want to look at third world countries and never in our own backyard. In 2012, the company Forever 21 was sued by the US Department of Labor for ignoring a subpoena requesting the information on how much it pays its workers just to make clothes (Lo,

Read More
946 Words | 4 Pages

The demand is more likely to be elastic for which

Read More
647 Words | 3 Pages

Sweatshirts from Sweatshops: Intellectual Standards and Logical Fallacies The essay “Sweatshirts from Sweatshops” was a persuasive piece that covered the issues of companies overseas that thrive through the exploitations of its workers. The reading selection depicted the behind the scenes activities that actually occurs with the mistreated workers and also the morality of such treatments. Throughout the essay, the reader can assume the writer’s overall objective was to discourage their audience from wearing such attire until their school decides to switch their apparel supplier. The writer also violated a few universal intellectual standards as well as a few logical fallacies.

Read More
1060 Words | 5 Pages

The main goal of businesses, in the growing manufacturing economy, was to produce the most product at the cheapest price. With a large influx of desperate immigrants looking for jobs, companies were able to quickly capitalize on the rights of vain workers. Viewing as them as easily replaceable, owners were easily able to take advantage of the rights of workers and utilize them to their advantage. The desperation prevalent in those willing to take the jobs that nobody else wanted supplied labor to factories, often for a high price. Worker’s rights were often manipulated in the industries exemplified throughout The Jungle.

Read More
852 Words | 4 Pages

The most frequent somber setback for sweatshop workers was being without a job. It was ordinary for a laborer, predominantly untrained, to be out of an occupation for a portion of the

Read More
404 Words | 2 Pages

The first article of November 17th’s readings was called Sweatshop Workers, by Miriam Ching Yoon Louie. As stated in the article, “Mexican immigrant women and U.S born Chicana ’s have emerged as the backbone of many of the lowest-paying, most back-breaking jobs” ( Louie 65 ). Going along with that, this article introduced a new connected term of transnational corporations, which housed these low paying and back breaking jobs for Mexican immigrant women in the United States even before they crossed the border. While this article readdressed passed weeks covered topics of immigrant workers, it also added the usually suppressed feminine spin to the topic.

Read More
1577 Words | 7 Pages

The work was also dangerous with not much supervising by the government. Workers, on the other hand, had little or even no bargaining power to leave the unsafe conditions. Nowadays, When Americans only pay attention when extreme work strike, levels of abuse are the norm hidden in the factories around the globe. Although the condition seems much improved, consumers don’t know the true fact- “Today, American citizens simply cannot know the working conditions of the factories that make the products they buy.

Read More
1825 Words | 8 Pages

How have sweatshops benefitted society or caused harm to it? This research paper will identify and analyse the significance of sweatshops, reasons for its prevalence and compare its positive and negative impacts on society. Literature review A sweatshop is a term for a workplace that violates local or international labour laws, such as providing workers with atrocious working conditions and minimal compensation (New World Encyclopedia, 2008).

Read More
1348 Words | 6 Pages

While such a situation may be preferable for an international company, it is not profitable to the future of humanity (Spath, 2002). The conditions in sweatshops are, at the very least, unsavory. Children and adults, alike, are forced to work long, nearly profitless hours in confined quarters that resemble those of American factories in the 1800’s (Reporter, 2013). Unlike American factories, however, many of the sweatshops weren’t built on safe foundations. The Rana Plaza, a clothing factory built on swampy ground near Dhaka in esh is a prime example of shoddy workmanship (Buncombe, 2013).

Read More
1269 Words | 6 Pages

It will further elaborate on the ongoing debate about what role laws and regulations should take on the growing issue of sweatshops and child labor, and how they can be improved on without disabling the poverty-stricken foreign workers, who may rely on this type of work to support their families. The proceeding essay will take on the cause and effects as well as a few pros and cons of sweatshops in the United States regarding the beginning of sweatshops and the effects on people involved. A few of the main ideas will include contributors that began sweatshops and how it has evolved, why laws and regulations were implemented and if they’re making a difference or not, as well as the pros and cons that come along with the

Read More

More about Summary Of Coakley And Kates: Challenging Sweatshop Labor

Related Topics

Open Document