ipl-logo

The 1917 Debate Of Smith-Hughes Vocational Education Act

1129 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Theroies of vocational education

In a 1917 debate on Smith-Hughes Vocational Education Act, a case was made for aid to be provided for practical or vocational education. A farmer needs knowledge specific to his trade, such as the importance of phosphate in increasing crop yield, and that this is more valuable to sustain society, than only focusing on academic knowledge (Office of Education, 1965, p55). Philosopher Alfred Whitehead wrote in 1929:
“What we should aim at producing is men who possess both culture and expert knowledge in some special direction.” (Office of Education, 1965, p57)
Whitehead goes on to discuss the flow of education from cultivating genius to mere pedantic routine as he warns against what he calls “inert ideas” of no practical application. He suggests …show more content…

Teaching implies knowledge. Knowledge is truth. The truth is everywhere the same. Hence education should be everywhere the same…I suggest that the heart of any course of study designed for the whole people will be, if education is rightly understood, the same at any time, in any place, under any political, social, or economic conditions. (Office of Education, 1965, p59)
Following World War 2, American society was comprised of an increasingly diverse population with diverse needs where security and survival instincts were heightened (wraga; iorio; parker,p13). A good education meant good job security. The battle between a vocational dual systems and progressive unified systems gave rise to the comprehensive high school as a potential compromise. (wraga, p6)
In the 1950’s, James Conant promoted comprehensive high schools that could provide for both the academic and vocational needs of the student, offering a wide variety of courses that could be selected by the individual or determined by student assessments. (wraga p6, parker p8, iorio p14, Office of Education, 1965, p83) With the launch of Sputnik came competition with Russia, which set off a new wave of educational reforms focused on vocational advancement. (iorio, p16; parker, p9; wraga, …show more content…

(iorio, p26) Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) of 2015, the NCLB successor, introduces more flexibility into the system and is less punitive than its predecessor (The Understood Team, 2017).
These are some of the Federal mandates, additionally a host of state and local initiatives have cycled through, including numerous curricular formats and theoretical frameworks like Marzano and Danielson, all in the interest of improving student outcomes. While all agree that improving student outcomes is a valid and worthy goal, as Theodore Sizer noted “School improvement cannot come about quickly nor can it be hurried by a rush of mandates. It requires a slow and determined effort, reflected in sound policies and patience.” (Sizer, 1985,

Show More
Related
288 Words | 2 Pages

Those who were responsible for crafting essa ESSA sought to shift the focus from federal accountability and oversight to more local and state-based control; under President Obama’s waiver program, CCSSI and RTT initiatives, the direction of education policy was one on increased federal control over education. An oft-quoted Wall Street Journal editorial claimed that ESSA would represented, “the largest devolution of federal control to the states in a quarter-century.” Chairman of the House Education and the Workforce Committee John Kline further billed ESSA as a rejection of the “Washington-knows-best approach to education” and touted ESSA as “the kind of responsible education reforms the American people want and deserve.” While the rhetoric

Read More
730 Words | 3 Pages

Public school is one of the primary sources of education for many children in the United States, therefore it should be the school 's sole purpose to teach them the essential elements they need to succeed in life. This means more than teaching math, science, history, and English. A school, primarily high school, must provide courses that focus on a student 's future career plans, courses that challenge a student academically, and courses that help a student navigate their life as adults. Without classes that help students expand and delve into their future career choices, they can limit their views of success. An excellent example of this can be found in Jonathan Kozol 's Still Separate, Still Unequal, particularly in his interviews with the students of Fremont High School in Los Angeles.

Read More
957 Words | 4 Pages

By looking at this fact, another purpose derived from the land grant was that the bill provided funding that should be, “used to endow at least one college where the leading object shall be, without excluding other scientific and classical studies, and including military tactics, to teach such branches of learning as are related to agriculture and the mechanical arts” (Hofstadter and Smith, 1961, p.568). The bill also provided funding to higher education by giving railroad textile, oil and steel tycoons the notion that their, “… millions would be used to support the few young people interested in studying psychology or religion.” (Cohen, 2010, p.

Read More
1121 Words | 5 Pages

He argues against this idea and pushes for more respect for vocational students. He wants us renovate our ideas about

Read More
1263 Words | 6 Pages

en Z1791763 EPFE 321 Mid-term Over the years there have been many different views on the direction that education and schooling will take in the role of the United States society taken by influential people. Some of these people included the Puritans of the Plymouth Colony, who believed that children needed to work to prevent them from being influenced by the devil. Thomas Jefferson who believed that everyone needs to be educated for the betterment of society and that people should earn their respect and merits and that it shouldn’t be just given out for nothing. Horace Mann started to try and standardize schooling so that if children moved they would still be learning nearly the same curriculum that they had left, he also tried to further

Read More
611 Words | 3 Pages

Next I will present Whitehead’s position on discipline, and how he would likely feel about NNN. Finally I will present my position on discipline in education and explain why I think the NNN model is effective, and how it could be made even more effective with minor modifications.

Read More
1837 Words | 8 Pages

Confidence in the principle of universal equality of educational opportunity is difficult to maintain when one views the breadth of the educational landscape in America. When observing two schools that fall on opposite sides of the spectrum in nearly every measurable aspect, it is crucial to make sense of where such disparity is founded so that the education system can be altered to better society. One such example of a tremendous educational gap is found in the 3.6 miles that span between the Nashville High Schools Pearl Cohn and Hume Fogg. Pearl Cohn, an entertainment magnet school located in a predominantly African American and poor socioeconomic area, has a 69% graduation rate, whereas Hume Fogg, an academic magnet school with 97% of students

Read More
1498 Words | 6 Pages

(Jones, “Gandy”) While conducting at Virginia Normal and Industrial Institute on the morning of August 29 he opened a session. Followed by a talk on “The Present Status and Prospect in Vocational education of the state board of education”.(“Agricultural Experts”) In contrast, while being appointed to professor, the university name soon changed to Virginia State College for Negros in 1930 and established a graduate school in 1937. (Jones, “Gandy”).

Read More
780 Words | 4 Pages

This is stated in the Constitution of the Brook Farm Association, a 19th century organization based on furthering education and agriculture. In it the founders of the organization describe how a basic education instills invaluable moral, social, and intellectual advantages to the next generation. In short, the proposed that the widespread teaching of a broad curiculum could make a better country. Additional arguments for education reform is best outlined by William McGuffrey in an excerpt of Reader. His argument targeted anyone who opposed the movement, hoping that he could persuade them.

Read More
475 Words | 2 Pages

Informational Report   Trade schools have received a bad reputation due to invalid stigmas surrounding the subject. Back when trade schools were new to the post-secondary education system, the school’s effectiveness was debated. Scholars believed trade schools didn’t properly prepare students with the life and professional experience they needed to be successful. How could one learn to think critically and creatively in a trade school like they would in college? This was the previous mindset held against vocational schools, and what began as negative opinions, lead to lingering stigmas surrounding the world of trade school (1867, 87 Notre Dame L. Rev.).

Read More
978 Words | 4 Pages

Education leads to individual success and empowerment. Every person has a different way of teaching, but in the end, the teaching method should

Read More
1045 Words | 5 Pages

(01 June 1998, para. 1) In the 1970s and 80s, desegregation became federally enforced and the importance of having an educated community became a main priority. Unfortunately, according to Miggins, “The majority of students were not able to pass Ohio's new proficiency test for 9th grade students. Many graduates couldn't qualify for entry level jobs” (para.

Read More
1205 Words | 5 Pages

“For instance, schools, themselves,  have been spending more on faculty and different opportunities for students, so they can improve their education and future references in college” (“Today 's College”). With the different types of electives that have been offered, not only will they make students have a higher education, but will give students more experience in other courses besides English, math, science and social studies.   Back in the 1960s, there were less opportunities for students to be involved in school electives that would aid them in college. For example, computer classes were not popular until the 1980s, and even then the classes were basic coding. Thankfully,  variety in education has greatly increased  today versus in the 1960s due to the better quality, and how educational facilities are spending more on different elective courses, and more opportunities that interest students.

Read More
974 Words | 4 Pages

Developing countries were obliged to follow the generally accepted rules of education due to various global discourses which were fostered by globalization. Some of these discourses are lifelong

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

An issue plaguing India today is the rising rate of crimes against women. In 2015, the number of recorded rape cases stood at 34, 615- a decline compared to the 36,735 cases recorded in 2014 (Venkat, 2017, para. 4). Clearly, our country lacks a supportive social environment and healthy attitude between the genders, which would prevent these crimes in the first place. To achieve this, practices that promote gender equality must be adopted right at the primary school level, to help children imbibe it in their crucial, formative years. This must be holistic and include dimensions which positively impact children individually, and their interpersonal interactions.

Read More

More about The 1917 Debate Of Smith-Hughes Vocational Education Act

Related Topics

Open Document