ipl-logo

The People Vs. Brock Turner Case Analysis

1690 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essay on rape law

“They are all innocent until proven guilty. But not me. I am a liar until I am proven honest. (O’Neill)” Over the past few years, rape cases have been appearing more often. Often times men and women are afraid to speak up about rape because often times attorneys and judicial figures choose to baby the suspect and sympathize with them. Rape victims are questioned about the rape, but not in the way they should be. Questions like, “What were you wearing?” are asked, but should be replaced with, “What was the situation surrounding the rape?” Rape has become such an everyday occurrence in the US today that it might as well be legal. Women and men are constantly being told that they are the problem and that it is their own fault they were raped. …show more content…

This case occurred in this past year and caused quite the controversy among the American people. Stanford University swimmer Brock Turner was convicted of sexually assaulting an unconscious woman outside a frat house. Right off the bat the media does not use the word rape, they choose sexual assault instead. Turner was sent to Santa Clara County jail in California and he was only behind bars for three months (Buncombe 1). The former swimmer moved back to Ohio to live with his parents and now he must register as a sex offender for life. Now I know you may be thinking that this woman received justice, but 3 months in prison is not even close to justice for a rapist in the eyes of a rape victim. Even when the victim outlined every detail of the rape itself the judge still gave Turner a 6 month sentence and he was released early due to “good behavior” (Buncombe 1). After reading the victims full account of everything she went through that year and is still going through I honestly want to beat Turner myself. Due to alcohol being a factor, the victim was considered blackout drunk and therefore did not remember anything from that night, so she was unable to tell her story. My question is if she was considered too drunk to remember anything from that night, how was she somehow able to give consent? And regardless of consent, why would this woman want to have sex behind a dumpster at night in a public place? Not to mention the fact that Turner was given a lighter sentence because of his swimming status and due to all the “emotional stress” he endured during the trial. Poor Turner, he raped this woman and HE endured the pain and stress, NOT

Show More
Related
361 Words | 2 Pages

In the January 29, The Stanford Daily editorial Stanford, California, it debates the different essential of the principle of morality and identified Brock Turner had applied a use of force in raping an unconscious woman behind the dumpster. Furthermore, the young man attended Stanford University and participated in his college swim team dreamt of partaking in the Olympus. The victim heartfelt statement during the trial is disregarded because he comes from a class of privilege and is a man. Not to mention, Brock Turner’s father wrote a letter to expressing the universalizability to court saying, “my son’s life shouldn’t be ruined over 20 minutes of action (Dreher,Rod).” Therefore, Aaron Persky who is a California judge implemented an ethical decision that contemplated the clarity around both the specific choice and decision then declared a six months sentenced ruling.

Read More
1696 Words | 7 Pages

People vs. Tuner Case Analysis Background Brock Allen Turner was a nineteen-year-old star athlete, a freshmen swimmer at Stanford University who was admitted in the fall of 2014 on a swimming scholarship. On January 17, 2015, he attended a party at Kappa Alpha fraternity house where he met the victim, twenty-year-old women who later identified as Emily Doe, her sister and their friends. Turner and the victim both consumed alcohol at the party. Shortly after the midnight of January 18, 2015, Tuner and the victim left the party and the victim was split up from her friends. The victim made a couple unintelligible phone calls from 11:54p.m to 12:28 a.m with her friends, then later on passed out behind a nearby dumpster outside the fraternity

Read More
689 Words | 3 Pages

Even from Dan Turner, (Brock Turner’s father) stated that Brock has been through too much already and sentencing would be too much for “20 minutes of action” (Irish Times). This statement on its own makes it very hard to believe that six months was a “fair” sentencing. Considering that the average jail time for a rapist across the United States is in between eight and nine years (SexOffenderAttorney). Considering that any other rapist in the U.S. would be charged with sixteen times the sentencing that Brock received, it is blatantly obvious that Turner was undercharged by a long shot.

Read More
240 Words | 1 Pages

In “Crime and Punishment: The saga of Richie Parker” published in Sports Illustrated, Gary Smith helps to explain just how many people are affected by a single sexual assault case. He does this in a very unique style by giving 12 sections explaining the incident from different points of view and the effects of a single crime. One person affected was Jill Agostino, the sports copy editor for Newsday. Her unnamed colleague had given her a copy of an article he was writing on Richie Parker and called asking if she liked it. Little did he know, stories like his were keeping her up at night, reminding her of the time she was raped nine years earlier.

Read More
980 Words | 4 Pages

Brock Allen Turner was a Stanford University student. However, after a frat party his life and a women’s life changed. Tuner was caught raping a woman who was unconscious behind a dumpster. With two witnesses present in court, Tuner was only sentenced to six months in jail.

Read More
2086 Words | 9 Pages

They say that it is better that ten guilty men go free then one innocent man be wrongly convicted. On a 60 Minute broadcast, reporter Lesley Stahl did a story regarding the wrongful imprisonment of an innocent man based off of a rape victim’s eyewitness identification. The man convicted of the crime was sentenced to life plus fifty years at the age of twenty-two for a crime he never committed. Eleven years later, his innocence was finally proven when DNA was able to exonerate and clear his name.

Read More
446 Words | 2 Pages

I was also surprised that Dr.Tuttle down right killed Bill instead of just fighting him off or getting away. I had not thought much about how a victim might act after fighting off an assaliant, I never considered the psychological trauma that might be incureded even when successfully fighting off an assailant. The Accused sheds a new light on how a victum might act after such a traumatic experience with Dr.Tuttle unnecessarily hiding and sabotaging the invenstigation despite her only acting in self defense. I believe that within the context of The Accused rape is treated fairly legally.

Read More
751 Words | 4 Pages

This is mainly because during this whole incident, Coker had just escaped from prison while serving multiple sentences and capital offenses, including murder, which, according to the Supreme Court, validates a death sentence. Furthermore, the state of Georgia’s laws mentions that rape can be punishable by death if it also occurred with or during a capital felony. Both instances were present because of Coker’s previous capital convictions, and the fact that the rape happened during an armed robbery since Coker stole the Carver’s car and threatened them with a knife. One could argue that what was really “grossly disproportionate” was the Justices’ decision and lack of common sense in this particular case. As stated by Justice Rehnquist, rape is not a minor or unimportant crime that can be overlooked, as it leaves vicitms with serious trauma and difficulties.

Read More
579 Words | 3 Pages

Some victims might have had their lives ruined by assault, but might not feel comfortable enough to actually go into court and speak about it. In the case of the Brock Turner trial, the victim was very open about the aftermath of her assault and was very willing to share her moving and emotional experiences. However, there are likely many other victims who have

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

Brock Allen Turner, shares the story of 19 year old, Stanford swimmer, Brock Turner and his heinous crime of sexual assault on multiple accounts towards Emily Doe. The assailant pleaded innocent throughout his trial, however, throughout his interview his linguistics told a different story. While speaking with authority, he failed to “directly acknowledge her, this deflecting his responsibility to her for his action, essentially erasing the victim from the description of the event.” Which continues to prove his guilt in the case. “While these charges can carry up to fourteen years in prison, Brock Turner served just three months in a county jail”.

Read More
910 Words | 4 Pages

“ Even though Judge Aaron Persky argued that a longer sentence would have “severe impact on Turner,” the victim’s letter to Turner states that the assault had “serious impact” on her (Baker). In her letter, she narrates how this hurt her. This is evident when “Emily Doe” says, “ I would drive to a secluded place to scream. I didn’t talk, I didn’t eat, I didn’t sleep” (Baker). The judge should have put into consideration the adverse effects of the assault on the victim before giving a shorter sentence to the

Read More
1154 Words | 5 Pages

The other victim is a young girl whose name was not given, and she was raped at a high school party after getting highly intoxicated. Many witnesses say that they saw her passed out, unable to walk, and even called her a mess during the time. There were various pictures and videos of her posted that night where the statements of the witnesses were confirmed (Strasser,2013). Both victims were taken advantage of and thankfully their rapists were both convicted. The first case was a little more difficult because there’s always going to be an issue with disability and consent.

Read More
1075 Words | 5 Pages

His lawyer told him that was the thing for him to do especially with having an all-white jury. He spent five years and two months in prison and it wasn’t until 2012 that his accuser renounced her story. This may have gotten him of jail, but he had already lost half of his life to a crime he didn’t commit. Luckily during prison, the twice his age men never asked what he did. In the usually case people that are locked up for any sexual charge are in some form are sexually assaulted.

Read More
1099 Words | 5 Pages

In the past year, a major court case involving famous comedian Bill Cosby was brought to the public eye. Cosby’s sexual assault allegations, brought on by nearly 60 women,

Read More
1277 Words | 6 Pages

Sexual assault is one of the most underreported crimes in America. With 21 percent (1 in 5 women) of undergrad students stating that they have been sexual assaulted since starting school, 63 percent are never actually reported to the police. Why do women have such a hard time with reporting their cases? The truth is, when the survivors come forward, prosecutors often won’t take on their cases. Reason being is that it’s hard to get a guilty verdict in a sexual assault trial, leaving them to only take on the cases that have a higher chance of a win.

Read More

More about The People Vs. Brock Turner Case Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document