ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Covert Action

715 Words3 Pages

have more validity. Even if the president has choosing power to some extent Congress can keep any major decsions in check.5 Covert action, in other words, is a necessary evil for the United States now and during the Cold War. The ethical dilemma of covert action has been pointed out, but the problems that arise with the loss of covert action are worse in the grand scheme of things. In the book
Regulating Covert Action: Practices, Contexts, and Policies of Covert Coercion Abroad in International and American Law Michael Reisman states “The United States may, as a moral matter, simply decide to eschew all covert action of certain kinds. But this would not, we believe, lead all other actors, whether from weakness, desperation, or rational calculations, to refrain similarly from such actions. On the …show more content…

But now that most important covert actions have been declassified. The judgement of most operations in hind-sight forgets one key factor, that This type of covert action during the Cold War served as a developmental stage in the future of clandestine activity. The media will look at this activity and criminalize it because it may cause problems some other places. Furthermore, the media will always attack the government for not acting when they had a hunch that something bad was going to happen. It is a lose-lose battle so the decision makers have hard decisions to make every time something important comes up because whatever choice they make is the wrong one in someone’s eyes so just make the best choice for United State interests.6(139) The future of clandestine activity comes down to a decision of not whether covert action is should be used, but how it should be used. In Espionage and Covert Action Melvin Goodman writes “’If the United States is to survive, longstanding American concepts of “fair play” must be reconsidered. We

Show More
Related
411 Words | 2 Pages

Before he was an Associate Professor of Government at Armstrong Atlantic State University, William Daugherty was a CIA Officer, one that was a hostage in Iran for 444 days (Washington Post 2006). His 2004 book, Executive Secrets: Covert Action and the Presidency draws on his authority as a former CIA Officer involved in arguably the most infamous American covert action and as an American government professor. The book details the development and execution of covert actions with evaluations, and the Presidency’s aspect of the book deals directly with executive oversight. Daugherty refutes the claims that the CIA is conducting covert actions on its own, assuring that every President since its inception has utilized covert action programs

Read More
1013 Words | 5 Pages

Without the Espionage and Sedition Acts, the United States’s national security might have been threatened, and the United States might have never won the war.

Read More
1042 Words | 5 Pages

It is far more dangerous to attempt to gag the people than to allow them to speak freely. If the Espionage Law stands, then the Constitution of the United States is dead. American institutions are on trial here before a court of American citizens. The future will render the final verdict (Foner, Voices of Freedom, Document

Read More
1382 Words | 6 Pages

I, § 9, of the Constitution forbids Congress to pass; (2) it penalizes and punishes appellants and restricts their liberty on legislative and administrative fact findings that they are subversives, and, in effect, traitors to their country without giving them the benefit of a trial according to due process, which requires a trial by jury before an independent judge, after an indictment, and in accordance with all the other procedural protections of the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Amendments, and (3) it denies appellants the freedom of speech, press, and association which the First Amendment guarantee. The Subversive Activities Control Act is supposed to be designed to protect this Nation's "internal security. " This case offers another appropriate occasion to point out that the Framers thought (and I agree) that the best way [p519] to promote the internal security of our people is to protect their First Amendment freedoms of speech, press, religion and assembly, and that we cannot take away the liberty of groups whose views most people detest without jeopardizing the liberty of all others whose views, though popular today, may themselves be detested tomorrow” (APTHEKER v. SECRETARY OF STATE

Read More
1417 Words | 6 Pages

CIA covert action during the Cold War was justified because it minimized confrontation, kept military costs low, and held enemies at a distance by fear. The first reason covert action during the Cold War was justified is because by using covert methods, confrontation

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

The American people are bounded by the laws in the Sedition and Espionage Acts. Any violators of these laws were prosecuted for betraying their oath of Allegiance. Notably, Eugene Debs was condemned for doing exactly this. A nationwide controversy sparked and it seemed as if everyone had an opinion regarding the American government forcing silence upon its citizens for the sake of war. This controversy is especially seen in HR, as people condemned these violators of the oath, like Debs.

Read More
929 Words | 4 Pages

Both of these sections of the Espionage Act are examples of how hard the government fought against anti-war propaganda even though the restrictions took away many freedoms from the Americans that didn’t support the war. This is highly ironic because the country was involved with a war to protect its citizens, but was limiting many of its citizens’ liberties and rights at

Read More
502 Words | 3 Pages

As the United States of America entered World War I, the world realized this was a whole different type of conflict, due to the industrialized progress of the time period, weapons, ammunition, and means of transportation were entirely new and more advanced. This made the war one of the bloodiest and darkest the world has ever seen. This caused worry during and even after the conflict concluded, since people have seen the future of warfare. Due partly to fear and suspicion, the United States passed the Espionage Act in 1917, shortly after they entered the war. This has since been criticized as an infringement on civil liberties, though to me it seems like a necessary choice to keep the country from collapsing in on itself.

Read More
4153 Words | 17 Pages

had developed a fear of a post-World War II communist world domination. This became apparent when the CIA began to shift from an intelligence-gathering function under President Truman to one under President Eisenhower that focused on more aggressive actions. However, upon further examination, it is revealed that the National Security Act mentions nothing about conducting secret operations overseas. According to Weiner, it more or less instructed the agency to “correlate, evaluate, and disseminate intelligence information, and to perform other functions and duties related to intelligence affecting national

Read More
855 Words | 4 Pages

In cases where there is a conflict between the two, the need for national security must take precedence. The lessons of classified information are complex and multifaceted, shaped by historical events, technological advancements, and political developments. From the 1953 overthrow of Iranian Prime Minister Mohammad Mossadegh to the 2013 leaks by National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden, many examples of classified information being protected and disclosed, with significant

Read More
2799 Words | 12 Pages

This is why oversight within the intelligence agency is so important: although oversight in congressional terms is used for governing the intelligence community and setting budget plans, oversight in the intelligence community is used to make sure no agency abuses its power as the turn of the 21st century began with the War on Terror increased surveillance on citizens. The example used earlier for moral and ethical issues in intelligence was the examination of Soviet era maskirovka a which was defined as Russian military deception tactics during World War Two in the Cold War. Dressing in Afghan army uniforms for surprise attacks and wearing white uniforms to camouflage in the snow were all moral and ethical issues that resembled guerrilla tactics that are often shunned in war. This is directly related to the legitimacy of covert actions since they were primarily used during the Cold War by the United States to overthrow communist and left-leaning governments to stop the spread of communism. However, after that era passed and public media became popular through technology, covert actions, and spies are at extreme risk if agencies ever use human intelligence.

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

Introduction Does having the CIA be the responsible body for carrying out covert action create a conflict of interest when CIA/National Clandestine Service is responsible for both covert action AND collecting and feeding information to CIA/Directorate of Intelligence for strategic intelligence analysis? To answer this question, I will analyze who the CIA delegates human intelligence collection to as well as covert action through the Directorate of Intelligence and the National Clandestine Service, to identify a conflict of interest in any instances over time. The Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) is a massive federal government agency that primarily works overseas, in other countries, conducting operations, collecting intelligence, and analyzing it. Discerning whether there is a conflict of interest can only be done by understanding what the National Clandestine Service and the Directorate of Intelligence do and an instance in which may have compromised both the Directorate of Intelligence and the National Clandestine Service, to cause a conflict of interest.

Read More
1471 Words | 6 Pages

Snowden first leaked the documents in June 2013. Some documents included information on American espionage efforts against enemies. Others revealed how the NSA was spying on its allies as well. When Snowden leaked the information, it didn’t just make the enemies hate the US further, but it also harmed the relationship it had with its ally countries. Aside from that, terrorist groups already have an idea on how the intelligence activities were performed, not only by the US, but also its ally countries such as Australia and UK.

Read More
1178 Words | 5 Pages

When one thinks of espionage between the United States and the Soviet Union, the first time period that usually comes to mind is the Cold War. The Cold War is perhaps the point when Soviet Intelligence was at its peak performance in obtaining large quantities of intelligence at an exceptionally expedient pace against the United States. This superb performance, however, did not materialize overnight; it took vast networks of agents and procedures for recruiting and handling assets that required trial and error. The establishment of Soviet espionage in the U.S. required years of construction, dating back to the New Deal era. Allen Weinstein and Alexander Vassiliev’s

Read More
674 Words | 3 Pages

Frank Pavone once said, “If we took a moment of silence for each person lost abortion, we would be silent for over 100 years.” Ever since the Roe v. Wade Supreme Court case in 1973, abortion has been an extremely heavy topic. The people that are pro-choice believe that a fetus is an organism, not a person and that a woman’s rights override an “organism's” development. While there are some other claims a pro-choice person may have, there are not as many claims as a pro-life person. Abortion is murder, regardless of when it occurs.

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Covert Action

Related Topics

Open Document