ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Indian Removal

467 Words2 Pages

The white men were trying to force the Cherokee out of their own land. The white men made the Indian removal act to force the Indians out no matter what. The historical question means, should the Cherokee leave or stay and if they stay they will lose all their ways but if they leave they could have their own land. People might disagree because they feel the Cherokee owned the land before any white man would have even known that land existed. My answer to the question is for the Cherokee to leave and just not bother with the men trying to make them change their ways. The Cherokee tribe say if they stay that the laws they would have to live under would ruin the Cherokee people. In the text written by the Cherokee they say, “even though we love the land of our fathers, we believe that moving will be far better than giving into the laws of the states. If we stay we will witness the ruin of the Cherokee people.” this means that even though the Cherokee loved their land they would rather leave than stay and be under the laws of the United States. The Cherokee nation cannot be re-established in the middle of the white men. In the text written by the Cherokee they say, “We believe that this nation cannot be re-established in its present location”. Therefore we ask this question, is it better to stay or go? It is …show more content…

The land was passed down to them from their ancestors and their fathers are buried on that land. In the Cherokee letter, it says “Our fathers passed down this land to us. They have possessed this land since before people can remember. It was a gift from our common father in heaven.” This means that the Cherokee love the land they have. It is sacred to them because their ancestors gave it to them. This is a good reason to want to keep their land, but the Cherokee has even said before that they would leave the land they love rather than live under the laws of the United

Show More
Related

The Pros And Cons Of The Indian Removal Act

368 Words | 2 Pages

The Cherokee people were faced with a problem because they were forced to leave their property due to the Indian Removal Act. This Act was presented by Georgia so the state could have Cherokee land. The historical question is asking what path was best; migrating west or to stay put and fight back? The tribe was torn on what side to be a part of.

Read More

Comparing The Cherokee Removal, Perdue And Green

446 Words | 2 Pages

In the book, The Cherokee Removal, Perdue and Green argue that the Cherokee Nation was treated unfairly by the U.S. Government in the 1800s. The majority of Americans were not fond of the Native Americans, and the Americans felt as if the Native Americans were on their rightfully owned property. Perdue and Green display how the states were trying to remove the Natives when they write, “A state could use its legal institutions to make life for Indians so miserable that they would gladly sell their lands and flee to the West” (Perdue and Green, 73).

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Indian Removal Act Of 1790

1501 Words | 7 Pages

The Act led to an array of legal and moral arguments for and against the need to relocate the Indians westward from the agriculturally productive lands of the Mississippi in Georgia and parts of Alabama. This paper compares and contrasts the major arguments for and against the

Read More

Indian Removal Act Dbq Essay

552 Words | 3 Pages

In Document 3, Cherokee Nation, a cherokee tribal member gave a speech that one part states, “This is the land of our Nativity; the land of our birth. We cannot consent to abandon it for another far inferior [place]”. Meaning they will not give up there land that they were born on, for somewhere else. Theodore Frelinghuysen’s speech, (Document 5, Theodore Frelinghuysen) mentions that a long, long time ago, God placed the tribes where he wanted them, which means they were here way before us, and we should not force them to move. Both documents infer that their land is important and sacred to them.

Read More

How Did The Indian Removal Act Affect The Cherokee Nation

219 Words | 1 Pages

But Jackson still forced them out and the Native Americans which they called the Indian removal act. The Cherokee nation knew they wouldn't survive if they fought so they

Read More

Objections To Cherokee Settlers

174 Words | 1 Pages

The Cherokee had several major objections to moving to new locations. The Cherokee wanted to stay instead of moving to a place such as Arkansas because it is “unknown” to them and is already occupied by the Indians. Therefore, the Indians would look at the Cherokee as if they did not belong or be seen as an enemy when the Cherokee meant no harm. Also the Indians were not really supplied by wood and water, which was bad for the Indians because they could not live as agriculturalists, but also bad for the Cherokee because they were worried there was not a lot of land for farming. Furthermore, the Cherokee had major objections because the people around the Cherokees were so different compared to them.

Read More

Cherokee Dbq Essay

554 Words | 3 Pages

Hundreds of Cherokees were moved from their land by white people for selfish reasons. The Cherokee lived in northern Georgia. The Cherokee were not citizens of the American so they couldn't vote. The didn't have any rights. They had a lot of land and access to the rivers and lakes.

Read More

How Did The Us Fulfill The Ideals Of The Declaration Of Independence Dbq

1091 Words | 5 Pages

All that the Cherokees wanted was the liberty to remain in the land that they had been inhabiting for generations. Instead, they were tossed around like dolls by the U.S. The Native Americans stood up for themselves and the rules that the U.S. was founded on, yet they got punished. This letter from the Cherokee nation shares the same

Read More

Manifest Destiny Research Paper

351 Words | 2 Pages

The concept of the manifest destiny was to make and have America be just one big continent with overtaking Mexico and Canada but as we can see now it did not happen. The causes and effects of Cherokee Nation being removed was when they had them move many died, from traveling they would die of hunger, thirst, and ambush them why they would be traveling. Another cause and effect was with the removal of the Native Americans they would force them to have to completely leave some people left each other, or got lost with all the chaos on wanting to quickly leave. Basically, America came in and took over Indian Territory George Washington did not discover America because America had already belonged to the Native Americans so, America came in and

Read More

Indian Removal Act Research Paper

778 Words | 4 Pages

The Indian Removal Act was signed in 1830 by President Andrew Jackson to remove the Cherokee Indians from their homes and force them to settle west of the Mississippi River. The act was passed in hopes to gain agrarian land that would replenish the cotton industry which had plummeted after the Panic of 1819. Andrew Jackson believed that effectively forcing the Cherokees to become more civilized and to christianize them would be beneficial to them. Therefore, he thought the journey westward was necessary. In late 1838, the Cherokees were removed from their homes and forced into a brutal journey westward in the bitter cold.

Read More

How Did The Trail Of Tears Impact America

449 Words | 2 Pages

In fact, they wanted the land they had, as they were settled in large areas art of the Us Terriortiry. President Andrew Jackson urges Congress to pass the Indian Removal Act, until it was finally passed in 1812, Despite their efforts to become as white men as possible the Whites ill wanted the Native Americans out of their lands. Yes, the whites were a selfish brutal bunch who did not want to live wior mix with ther races but this forceful behavior brought them to where they are today so it’s actually bitter swee. The Whites eventually achieved their gosl of relocating the Natives,however, the CHerokeess put up a stronger fight onto the Americans Above all pros, the American’s Manifest Destinh was greatly affected by the Trail of Tears.

Read More

Slavery During The Antebellum Period

1036 Words | 5 Pages

Freedom is the power or right to act, speak, or think as one wants without hindrance or restraint. The foundation of America is freedom. Freedom from Britain. However, the freedom is limited to white males who own property. When colonists started to immigrate to America, they wanted to escape from under the rule of Britain.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Cherokee Removal

621 Words | 3 Pages

This removal may not seem very important to anyway outside of the Cherokee nation because they do not understand the gravity of the situation. It is not as simple as simply moving. Even if we did move the task itself would prove to be too difficult for many of our elders and children, plus the trail westward has its own dangers. Even if we did forgo this, we still do not want to leave this land for it was given to us by our gods.

Read More

Cherokee Nation 1830 Analysis

402 Words | 2 Pages

On July 17, 1830, the Cherokee nation published an appeal to all of the American people. United States government paid little thought to the Native Americans’ previous letters of their concerns. It came to the point where they turned to the everyday people to help them. They were desperate. Their withdrawal of their homeland was being caused by Andrew Jackson signing the Indian Removal Act into law on May 28, 1830.

Read More

The Importance Of Tribal Sovereignty In The United States

1036 Words | 5 Pages

Part of this argument is that tribes aren’t sovereign in the first place, saying “American Indians are not a separate nation any more than blacks or Jews or Korean immigrants are” (Riley, Naomi). And while knowing the US. government has broken promises and treaties with the Native people, they also bring to light that the US. decided that they could modify or terminate any treaties with Native Americans, without the tribes consent (Riley, Naomi). “It is time for both the US government and the tribes to stop pretending that they are like foreign countries negotiating a settlement” (Riley, Naomi). People are confused and troubled as to why the government is acting as though they are separate from the United States.

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Indian Removal

Related Topics

Open Document