ipl-logo

To What Extent Was Christopher Columbus Right Dbq

622 Words3 Pages

Ripley Riegert
Carrington
Writing 7A
March 7, 2023

DBQ
You know the explorer Christopher Columbus right? Well he was one of the many explorers during this time period who set out to explore. Typically explorers set out for Gold, God, and or Glory. What we didn't know was that when they landed they treated the natives there terribly. They forced the Native Americans to convert religions, brought disease, and took away their homes and families.
One of the worst things that happened to the natives was disease. Smallpox had spread to the Native Americans and their immune system wasn't used to it. PubMed says, ¨Native American populations were exposed to new infectious diseases, diseases for which they lacked immunity.¨(Katherine B 2002) This wasn't even the worst part. It was also how other people who didn't get it were affected that was bad. ¨They starved to death because there was no one left to care for them.¨ (Doc. 2) That seems almost worse than having the disease. Having to die because there wasn't anyone left to care …show more content…

If you didn't convert your religion they would kill you. ¨Native Americans burned for refusing to convert to Catholicism.¨(Doc 5) No one should be forced to change their religion. just like no one should be burned alive for not converting their religion. In the textbook it says, ¨Spanish missionaries also saw a purpose in conquering the region. They wanted to convert the native peoples to Christianity.¨ (World Civilizations 799) So multiple people took the opportunity to try to change their religion. Christopher Columbus was a main enforcer of this. Osu.edu says, “Columbus forced the natives to convert to christianity and begin practicing this new religion against their desires.” (Myles Hudson) Christopher Columbus was not the best guy. I used to think he was cool but now I see that he was a very bad person who takes advantage and harms innocent

Show More
Related

Christopher Columbus Dbq Essay

539 Words | 3 Pages

Additionally, Christopher Columbus enslaved and mistreated the natives. Not only did Christopher Columbus change the culture of the natives but actually tortured them. Columbus used the natives for his own use. “Throughout his years in the Americas, Columbus forced natives to work for the sake of profits. Later, he sent thousands of Taino “Indians” to Spain to be sold, and many of them died during the journey.”

Read More

Was Christopher Columbus Selfish

301 Words | 2 Pages

Christopher Columbus was one of the greatest explorers known to man. Columbus had many different reasons for his explorations. Later, the main reason for his explorations was selfishness. Just like many other explorers before Columbus, he wanted land, he wanted power, and he also wanted gold. The reason for his very first voyage to what he thought was India, but later was found out to be Central America, was to get land for Spain.

Read More

Christopher Columbus Dbq

436 Words | 2 Pages

Finally, when Christopher Columbus came to the Americas he wanted everybody to convert to Catholicism. If the Native Americans didn’t convert to Catholicism the Europeans would burn them(OSU.EDU). Christopher Columbus didn’t think that the Native Americans had a religion(ChristianHistoryInstitute.com) Even though they were going to be burned, the Native Americans didn’t want to convert to Catholicism(OI). This is the final reason why the Native Americans population decreased

Read More

Age Of Exploration Dbq Research Paper

508 Words | 3 Pages

Finally, the horrid consequences of the native peoples refusal to convert to Catholicism. In doc 5, the picture shows Native Americans being burned for refusing to convert to Catholicism, causing there to be even fewer Native Americans left alive. Native Americans had a tough decision of either converting to Catholicism or being burned to death. When Christopher Columbus first came to America, one of his first thoughts when he saw the native peoples was, “they would make good slaves and should be converted to Christianity,”(5 Minutes). As you can see, the conquerors wanted to convert Native Americans to Christianity from the first sight of

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Christopher Columbus

1142 Words | 5 Pages

Christopher Columbus and Controversy Christopher Columbus, widely celebrated for his “discovery” of the Americas, became a controversial figure whose actions had significant and lasting consequences on both the Indigenous communities and the European colonization of the New World. The debate surrounding Columbus comes from his negative actions toward Native Americans on encounters with them on his voyages. Additionally, his impact on the push for European colonization had detrimental effects on these communities. The controversy around Christopher Columbus has tested many people's opinions of him over time because of his actions on his voyages and attitude. Columbus loved the sea from a very young age and went on many voyages where he discovered

Read More

Age Of Exploration DBQ

961 Words | 4 Pages

As Arthur M. Schlesinger said in Columbus on Trial, European culture has "its share of monsters and atrocities" and that civilizations who had many conquests "did not show anything like concern for moral behavior and treatment of others" (Document 6). Ultimately, European explorers, conquistadors, and settlers from the Age of Exploration should not still be glorified and celebrated because they caused more harm than good, and tore apart others just to make a name for

Read More

Christopher Columbus Should Not Be Abolished Essay

623 Words | 3 Pages

This quote from CNN.com stabilizes my statement. “Columbus wasn’t the first to discover the New World. Indigenous people had been living there for centuries by the time he arrived in 1492 and Leif Eriksson and the Vikings beat him to it five centuries earlier.” Columbus had cared very little about his people therefore went even madder consequently when his own brother created a revolt against him. “He treated them and even his own crew very poorly.

Read More

Essay On Why We Should Not Celebrate Columbus Day

750 Words | 3 Pages

Columbus would command his men to torture the Natives because “he punished minor offenses against his domination by cutting off the Natives’ noses and ears.” Columbus killed these Natives slowly so they would feel the crucial pain before they die, which is just horrible. Columbus really explore to terrorize others lives because he did not even achieve any of the goals he intended to

Read More

Christopher Columbus Faith And Wealth Analysis

472 Words | 2 Pages

Mostly for selfish desires but some just wanted to escape Europe and King George's rule. The people wanted a new start in life and desired adventure. Back in Europe people were already set to be succseful such as major noble families that were the "Rockerfellers" of their nation and would most likey continue to succeed while killing off any chance to make a decent living and thriving business. Also the people wanted to become famous and one way of doing that is being part of a group that is actually "doing" something. Cristopher Columbus was not just searching for a route he was trying to change a whole business deal by finding a huge shortcut, later on he discovered something much more important (not the America's) a whole "New World".

Read More

Causes Of Bacon's Rebellion

376 Words | 2 Pages

Bacon 's Rebellion was the consequence of discontent among backcountry ranchers who had taken the law into their own particular hands against government debasement and abuse. Numerous Virginians were indebted individuals. Obtaining on the quality of paper cash was ceased by the British Government, prompting more discontent against the vendor classes. A large number of the supporters of the defiance were obligated workers and slaves, who were a lion 's share of Virginia 's populace. Students of history have pointed out that a standout amongst the most essential changes made amid Bacon 's administration was the acknowledgment of the privilege to remain battle ready, so that the normal man could safeguard himself from threatening Indians

Read More

Christopher Columbus Portrayal Of The Natives

1277 Words | 6 Pages

When Christopher Columbus set sail in 1492, he was trying to find the western route to Asia, as per his orders by King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella. When he landed his ship on the New World, he believed that he has found a route to Asia, unbeknownst to him that he found a whole new continent. Upon exploration, he came across some indigenous people. In his letter to the king and queen, he described the indigenous people that he met on the islands as being well-built, timid, and generous. His portrayal of the indigenous people reveals that they would serve well as slaves and as a source of information in Spanish colonies in order to further the economy of the Spanish Crown.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Christopher Columbus And Religion

308 Words | 2 Pages

Columbus comes across as deeply religious, strategic, and politically ambitious. Firstly, Columbus comes across as deeply religious based on the way he acknowledges God for bestowing on him myriad journey mercies that led to a successful voyage. Additionally, since he knew Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand II had strong ties with the Catholic Church, Columbus tactfully introduced the idea that the numerous native peoples he had found constituted a prime ground for Christian conversion and expanding the monarchy’s political jurisdiction. Secondly, Columbus is highly strategic, starting with the way he throws in political and religious ideas to the Spanish rulers, trying to demonstrate that the Indies were ready for conquering by Europeans.

Read More

Why Were The Europeans Able To Conquer The Americas

654 Words | 3 Pages

It is estimated that approximately 95% of pre-Columbus Native Americans were killed by European diseases. Since the outbreak of the diseases spread because of the European colonization, it made conquering the Americas much easier. Health was definitely the most detrimental obstacle that the Native Americans had to face as a result of the European

Read More

Introduction Of Smallpoxs To The New World

139 Words | 1 Pages

Some Europeans though had actually gained an immunity to some of the disease’s and were

Read More

Compare Christopher Columbus And Bartolome De Las Casas

861 Words | 4 Pages

The 15th Century marked the beginning of exploration to the new world. Explorers Christopher Columbus and Bartolome de Las Casas had different perspectives about the natives they encountered upon their voyages. Columbus’ journal and de Las Casas’ narration portrayed the Indians’ appearances similarly however; both explorers had different attitudes towards them. From Columbus’ first encounter with the Indians, his attitude was condescending. He described them as very poor people and believed them to be ignorant.

Read More

More about To What Extent Was Christopher Columbus Right Dbq

Related Topics

Open Document