ipl-logo

Transformative Negation: Bruce Lincoln And Nancy Jay

1149 Words5 Pages

Vincent DeMaria Professor Blunt REL 310 4 May 2023 Transformative Negation: Bruce Lincoln and Nancy Jay In his analysis of ancient Greek fantasies about the ritually violent lives of others, Bruce Lincoln challenges traditional theories of sacrifice that attempt to maintain its benevolent function. Lincoln contends that such theories oversimplify and overlook the violent nature of sacrifice in ancient Greek society. According to him, these fantasies are not just mere depictions of ritual violence but are the product of deeply ingrained cultural beliefs and practices. In this paper, we will explore Lincoln's critique of sacrifice and the evidence he marshals to support it. Furthermore, we will compare his analysis with that of Nancy Jay, who …show more content…

Jay believes that “sacrifice is a process that achieves social differentiation” (370). She argues that the ritualized violence of sacrifice is a way for humans to assert their dominance over the natural world and, in particular, over women's reproductive capabilities. This idea of domination over lineage is particularly evident in societies where women are viewed as the primary agents of reproduction, as the act of sacrifice becomes a way to overcome the limitations imposed by the maternal …show more content…

Sacrifice is often intertwined with religion, politics, and social hierarchy, and serves as a means of reinforcing these structures. The violent act of sacrifice is not only a way to appease the gods, but also a way for those in power to assert their dominance over others. Through sacrificial practices, societies often justify the oppression and marginalization of certain groups, and reinforce the status quo. Thus, the study of sacrifice provides insights into the larger cultural and societal structures that shape and are shaped by this practice. Nancy Jay claims that sacrifice is used to diminish the power of childbearing women. Jay states that “sacrificing can identify, and maintain through time, not only social structures… but also other forms of male to male succession” (378-379). This allows sacrificial ritual to warrant the creation of patrileanal descent as the principle of social organization. Jay’s work shows how the act of sacrifice can shape, change, or maintain societal norms and

Show More
Related
1439 Words | 6 Pages

Sacrifice is the surrendering of a possession to offer a God. In the beginning of the book, the mother Orleanna Price, tells her story of the guilt that she is feeling from losing her child. She explains everything she has sacrificed to make her husband’s

Read More
1090 Words | 5 Pages

Now that was one example of sacrifice and it wasn’t too extreme. In the books Poisonwood Bible and Things Fall Apart, just like us, the characters in the books are forced to sacrifice things in life to achieve their goals. When they do make these sacrifices they are revealing to us what they believe in and what they value in this life. Sacrifice can be defined by Merriam – Webster as the act of giving up something that you want to keep especially in order to get or do something else or to help someone. In the book Poisonwood Bible we are introduced to a character by the name of Nathan Price.

Read More
687 Words | 3 Pages

Outsiders may look upon Aztec human sacrificial practices as disturbing, but to the Aztecs, it was a beautiful, worthy, and prideful thing to do. In fact, it was considered an honor to be a human sacrifice, and as described by one 17 year-old boy watching a sacrificial ceremony, he described that he felt “amazed by the physical beauty of the enemy warrior who was killed at the end of the festival.” In the time before one is sacrificed, he is given all the finest luxuries from the nobles' storehouses, including foods, clothes, teachers, women, and instruction. He walks among the Aztec people as “a living god.” There have been many works of art depicting the sacrifice, which are direct references that historians can refer to for Aztec culture and history.

Read More
1399 Words | 6 Pages

But once they're sacrificed how much are they really valued? How much needs to be sacrificed before the things valued are recognized? What will ultimately cause one to realize the very things they do really value? As Orleanna looks back on the events and her place in the Congo she realises how submissive and passive she was due to the aggressiveness of her husband.

Read More
863 Words | 4 Pages

Furthermore, humans make sacrifices everyday whether it includes opening the door for someone or letting them have the extra food at lunch. In the story the jews resort

Read More
595 Words | 3 Pages

There were other ways that humans would be sacrificed - shot with arrows, drowned, burned, or otherwise

Read More
1357 Words | 6 Pages

Their sacrifices in

Read More
677 Words | 3 Pages

Sacrifice is an inevitable element of our world, exacerbated by the greed and rapid expansion in the population of humans. The idea is relevant to the themes and events surrounding the plot of Their Eyes Were Watching God, a romantic, feminist novel by Zora Neale Hurston. The protagonist Janie grows up disparaged, as her mother left her at birth with her grandmother. Janie learns of love, self-respect, expression, and ultimately sacrifice as she goes from partner to partner after her grandmother’s passing. Sacrifice and the implied investment of a sacrifice reveal much of the deeper meaning of Their Eyes Were Watching God.

Read More
1036 Words | 5 Pages

Manya Kapur Ms. Kanika Dang English Thesis Paper 9th November 2015 You Before Me The act of sacrifice can significantly be highlighted in the Islamic religion, where one must resign from the materialistic realm to re-establish the divine connection with Allah. Khaled Hosseini has masterfully crafted The Kite Runner and made numerous references to slaughter of the lamb as a portrayal of one’s love towards God.

Read More
1519 Words | 7 Pages

He stated an example of this when he said “It was common for all men, on the day customarily set for human sacrifice, to sprinkle the altar with human blood.” Showing that sacrifices have been common throughout history. This familiarizes the act as a habit of ancient people who had not been introduced to Christianity. He stated more examples such as “The Carthaginians had the custom of offering human victims to Saturn and when they had been conquered by Aglothocles, the King of Sicily, they thought their god was angry with them and so that they might more diligently blot out their crime, they sacrificed two hundred noble children.” This large scale of sacrifice also diminishes the impact of the Native Americans own hefty ceremonies.

Read More
1952 Words | 8 Pages

Abigail Turra 3425702 In “Markets in Women’s Reproductive Labor,” Stanford professor and philosopher Debra Satz questions the morality of contract pregnancy through the lens of the Asymmetry Thesis. The Asymmetry thesis is the idea that reproductive labor should be considered differently than other types of labor in a capitalist economy. While Satz upholds this theory, and the idea that contract pregnancies are morally wrong, she finds that most reasons supporting the theory are invalid, and provides “better” support for the theory. In this essay, I will argue that contract pregnancy is not inherently morally incorrect and acknowledge some validity in the degradation hypothesis.

Read More
775 Words | 4 Pages

When sacrifices are made, a goal is accomplished by the person sacrificing the object and a life is affected by the sacrifice made which could be seen in The Lottery by Shirley Jackson, The Veldt by Ray Bradbury, and Good Country People by Flannery O’Connor. In The Lottery, a community of people stand with their traditions even though it harms their society. In The Veldt, the children sacrifice someone they should love and replace it by a room they love more. In Good Country People, Hulga, a mid age, deformed, and independent, woman sacrifices something she needs for a person she thinks she knows.

Read More
448 Words | 2 Pages

In Greek culture, honor was immensely important and the Cyclops has none. In contrast, Odysseus brags about the great feats of Agamemnon yelling, “So great a city he sacked, such multitudes he killed”(9.298-299) That Odysseus sees pride in killing, shows that the Greeks valued killing, but only if honorable. There is a stark contrast between the killings of the Cyclops and those of King Agamemnon. In the eyes of the Greeks, Agamemnon’s killings were for his country, his people, and the greater good of society. These murders had a selfless purpose.

Read More
697 Words | 3 Pages

Because of these strict beliefs, cultural norms birth rates were down considerably compared to today, for many women wanted to await child birth; until they were financial secure or stable. Additionally, “we never read (or heard) about family violence and almost nothing about singlehood, cohabitation, stepfamilies, or one parent families” (Jones, ASID, IIDA, IDEC and Phyllis Sloan Allen, 2009, p. 74). However, in the 1970’s people began to expand their horizon’s, and soon ventured out to explore other cultures; causing challenges towards the social movement on their views of a traditional family structure. This is why, “since the 1970’s three of the major shifts have occurred in family structure, gender roles, and economic concerns” (Jones, ASID, IIDA, IDEC and Phyllis Sloan Allen, 2009, p. 74).

Read More
681 Words | 3 Pages

For the event paper, I watched the documentary Trapped, that was playing at the school November 17th. I was very hesitant to watch this film; I was worried there would be an angry undertone but it ended up being the exact opposite it was a sad undertone. The film focused on the southern states and their battle with the laws being passed that restrict women from getting safe abortions. Back in 1973 the court finally made the decision in Roe vs. Wade to make abortion legal to end pregnancy in the first three months stating that decision belongs to the women not the government. States can make restricts against abortion if it doesn’t cause undue burden to the women

Read More

More about Transformative Negation: Bruce Lincoln And Nancy Jay

Related Topics

Open Document