ipl-logo

Understanding Of Checks And Balances In The Roman Constitution

284 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Political system in roman republic

1. Summarize Polybius’s understanding of the checks and balances in the Roman constitution. Why does he think it is one of the most stable forms of government? Which of the three aspects of the Roman constitution (monarchy, aristocracy, or democracy) does he think predominates in the Roman Constitution? Polybius believed that this system of checks and balances made the Roman constitution one of the most stable and long-lasting forms of government in the ancient world. According to Polybius, the Roman monarchy provided stability, while the aristocracy represented the interests of the rich and influential classes, and the people's assembly (the democracy) supplied a voice for the ordinary people. He believed that the mix of these three elements
Show More
Related

How Democratic Was The Roman Republic Dbq

690 Words | 3 Pages

In document A according to the Greek historian Polybius he talks about the democratic system of governance in Rome. Polybius kept records during the extensive Roman expansion between 167 and 119 BCE held a great admiration for the Romans and highlighted their rise to global dominance. His

Read More

How Democratic Was The Roman Republic Dbq

515 Words | 3 Pages

Polybius goes on to say, “no one can say for sure whether the constitution is an aristocracy or democracy or despotism” in Document A. He then explains how the Roman Republic was each of them, an aristocracy, a democracy, and a despotism, for various reasons. One of these reasons was that, at times, the consuls, or the magistrates, and the Senate had more power than the Assemblies, but in different situations, it was the opposite. This shows that even Polybius, a man who was actually alive during the Roman Republic, didn’t know how to label

Read More

Why Did The Constitution Draw Up With The Idea Of Checks And Balances

868 Words | 4 Pages

The Constitution was written in 1776. The reason why the Constitution was written is that the Founding Fathers did not like how the Articles of Confederation was going. They decided to reorganize the Articles of Confederation into a new document. So in July, they set up a convention and they agreed and disagreed about many things. Overall though, they were able to finally draw up the United States Constitution.

Read More

Hum/1111 Final Exam

446 Words | 2 Pages

15.What were the major contributions of Roman civilization regarding borrowing from the Greeks, standardization of an imperial language, and standards in law and politics? 16.What does the term Pax Romana refer

Read More

Comparing The Constitution: Division Of Powers With Checks And Balances

296 Words | 2 Pages

The authors of the Constitution created a balance between federal and state government by creating federalism or a division of powers with checks and balances while maintaining the separation of powers. That being said, the Virginia Plan of having every state hold a two-house legislature was debated against the New Jersey Plan that entailed a single house Congress (Foner, 2014). The end result was a two-house Congress in which each state could then have two senate members that are required to serve for one term of six years and a House of Representatives in which member were elected directly by the people every two years. This system made sure that each population was represented equally despite one state being larger than the other (Foner,

Read More

The Government Check And Balances Against Tyranny In The US Constitution

639 Words | 3 Pages

The meeting called the Constitutional Convention that ended up creating the U.S. Constitution lasted for four months. Tyranny is when a person or group of people rule over others with cruel and unusual methods. Tyranny can happen with one rule or multiple, they can take the power, or be born with it. This means tyranny comes in many shapes and sizes. The U.S. Constitution guards against tyranny by splitting each government into three branches, splitting power multiple times within each branch, and letting each part of the government check and balance each other.

Read More

Principles Of Checks And Balances

923 Words | 4 Pages

The United States Constitution, written in 1787, is one of the most influential documents ever created and has continued to stay relevant for over 200 years. The Constitution was proposed in order to replace the ineffective Articles of Confederation, which previously held the newly freed states together. The main goal of the Constitution was to unite the states together under a strong national government, outlined within the document. Between 1787 and 1788 when the Constitution what ratified, two main political groups arose with opinions in regards to the Constitution. They were the Federalists and the Anti Federalists.

Read More

Roman Republic Checks And Balances

236 Words | 1 Pages

The Roman Republic was upheld by a republican constitution and, similar to the Athenian government, gave more power to the citizens in the decision making process. The Roman Republic constitution on the other hand also valued the rule of law and implemented checks and balances to prevent one single person or class from taking control of the republic. The republican constitution had a significant impact on the creation, maintenance, and success of the Roman Empire. By implementing the importance of the rule of law, the Roman Republic was able to create the groundwork for a successful republic to ensure that political leaders were going to be held accountable. They created the Senate which established a representative government to debate on

Read More

Checks And Balances Of The Founding Fathers In The United States

1174 Words | 5 Pages

In 1787, seven key figures known as the founding fathers in United States history came together and wrote the US Constitution. These men were George Washington, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, James Monroe and Benjamin Franklin.(Kettler) They decided the republican form of government would allow for the best outcome in the United States. With these intentions, they planned for the more educated, which in this time meant more wealthy, to have more influence on the decisions being made. The way that they laid out the voting system was to listen to the states decisions but if the electoral college, composed of more educated people in society, disagreed with their decision then they had the right to overturn the

Read More

How Did The Plebeians Contribute To The Formation Of The Roman Republic

431 Words | 2 Pages

This helped protect individual rights and prevent the arbitrary exercise of power. However, there were aspects that raised doubts about the democratic nature of the Roman Republic. “Evaluating the Roman Republic’s constitution and how it was applied in theory and practice it becomes clear that the Roman Republic, while constitutionally quite democratic, was in practice a fundamentally undemocratic society, dominated by a select caste of wealthy aristocrats.” (Brown Z.S.,

Read More

Roman Citizenship Dbq

739 Words | 3 Pages

In a representative democracy, citizens choose representatives to vote on laws and make political choices.   In ancient Rome, many political leaders and historians claimed that the government was a democracy. However, Rome was never truly a democracy, due to their unfair government organization, and lack of democratic citizenship. In terms of government career holders, and as regular citizens, some groups of people were more powerful and privileged than others.       To start off, the government of ancient Rome was far from democratic.

Read More

An Analysis Of Polybius's Third Punic War

841 Words | 4 Pages

In the instance of the Third Punic War, this repository was Roman-centric, enamoured in the fervour of its own superiority. Polybius was most critical in perpetuating these ideas. As a Greek prisoner of war, the poignant memory of his father advocating Roman rule infiltrated his writings. Just like his father, Polybius’s contemporary, Panaetius conceived similar ideals: if the subjugated states were morally inferior, a state’s dominion was justified. This was Polybius’ rationale .

Read More

Democratic Decision-Making In The Roman Republic

1137 Words | 5 Pages

Although some groups within the legislative body of the Republic had some overlap over another group, the duties and powers were distinct enough that the citizen body had some form of representation. Additionally, because of the veto powers that each group possessed, it could be presumed that if a group vetoed some legislation or policy because ot would not benefit the state, nor the citizen body, it would be fair to assume that the veto facilitates democratic decision making. The role of the veto had significant impact on the administration of legislation and policies, but ultimately allowed for a way to ensure democratic decision making within the Roman

Read More

Compare The Romans Life For The Plebeians

562 Words | 3 Pages

Imagine a world where the government was ruled by many people... What do you think the world would be like then? Well the world in the Roman republic was like this, as people called it a representative democracy. People elected representatives, to make main decisions. But the plebeians still had a say in what the government was like.

Read More

Fall Of The Roman Republic Essay

1512 Words | 7 Pages

The composition and the governing structure of the Roman republic was not uniform throughout its existence, but some of the fundamental elements of its government came into being in the immediate aftermath of the monarchy’s collapse. Therefore, it is unsurprising that many of these institutions were created in reaction to the monarchy and its failures, and thus were shaped by this relationship. For example, the fundamental opposition to monarchy and the rule of kings that came with the experience of the Kingdom of Rome, remained quite strong in the Roman mindset throughout the existence of the Republic and into the beginnings of the Roman Empire, and its influence can be seen throughout Roman political discourse especially in the discussion

Read More

More about Understanding Of Checks And Balances In The Roman Constitution

Related Topics

Open Document