ipl-logo

Unit 6 Writing Assignment: HAZ-MAT Scenarios

1005 Words5 Pages

Unit 6 Writing Assignment
My position on this situation is that the Mayor made an ill-informed, but well-intentioned decision that will undoubtedly result in confusion and frustration. With that being stated, I think that the decision to put the NYPD in a position to take full initial command in situations involving hazardous materials is a terrible idea for two reasons; these reasons are because fire departments are better equipped to handle these emergencies and it unnecessarily fuels the fire in the feud between police and firefighters.
I think that fire departments are more equipped to handle HAZ-MAT situations because more often than police officers on average, firefighters are more highly trained in HAZ-MAT situations and techniques. …show more content…

Moreover, the fact of the matter is that when dealing with the chaos involved in responding to an emergency, those in charge need to be the most knowledgeable, capable, and effective people available—and in this case, I think it would be the fire department. Another reason why I think it would be beneficial for the fire department to maintain on-scene command is that leadership at the fire department will know the dynamics of the personnel and their experience of past HAZ-MAT situations and will be able to use this information for the betterment of the current situation.
Also, another benefit of letting the fire department maintain control is that the fire department will already by familiar with the ICS and SOPs/SOGs-- which we all know, already can be confusing for those who deal with the situations regularly, let alone for someone who isn’t familiar at all—like the police department (Jr., …show more content…

Works Cited
Adwar, C. (2014, April 21). Why NYC Cops And Firefighters Keep Getting Into Massive Brawls. (Business Insider) Retrieved September 25, 2016, from Business Insider: http://www.businessinsider.com/the-nypd-and-fdny-have-a-long-history-of-disputes-2014-4
Jr., J. B. (2013, November 26). Communication & Personnel Accountability for ICs: Keeping track means more than knowing where team members are. (FireRescue) Retrieved September 2016, from Firefighter Nation: http://www.firefighternation.com/article/incident-command-0/communication-personnel-accountability-ics
McIntire, M., & O 'Donnell, M. (2005 , May 10). Fire Chief Challenges New York Emergency Plan. (The New York TImes) Retrieved September 25, 2016, from The New York Times: http://www.nytimes.com/2005/05/10/nyregion/fire-chief-challenges-new-york-emergency-plan.html?_r=1
Phibbs, W. M., & Snawder, M. A. (2014, November). Embracing the Incident Command System Above and Beyond Theory. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin. Retrieved September 25, 2016, from

Show More
Related

Overview Of Chief Terry Mangan's Strategic Planning In Spokane, Washington

813 Words | 4 Pages

Moreover, board members described the experience as an improvement in the communication throughout the department. Numerous issues facing the district became known about in the planning committee’s discussion. Mangan's critical project: provided details on defining the community's values. Mangan felt that became crucial to take the organizational culture and examine the history and say who they were and what the city stood for and why. Mangan gathered several value statements from other police departments, then presented them to the strategic planning committee.

Read More

Mitosotis Familia Case Study

695 Words | 3 Pages

NYPD Commissioner James O’Neill called the violence against police officer a “dishonor to civilized society.” " That is why violence against the police

Read More

9/11 Failures

837 Words | 4 Pages

A six-month examination by The Times found that the rescuers ' ability to save themselves and others was hobbled by technical difficulties, a history of tribal feuding and management lapses that have been part of the emergency response culture in New York City and other regions for years. The other flaws in their plan were lapses in leadership and coordination and a lack of proper planning and training and lack of emergency resources (ambulances). Due to lack of coordination, the Fire Department could not account for the number of fighters that were sent into the towers, and where they died. The Emergency Medical Service said they only had ambulances for 400 calls while the chief of the Port Authority police said the region 's bridges, tunnels, and ports were drained of

Read More

Ghettoside Book Review

632 Words | 3 Pages

“Circumspect Police Ends the Drop in Crime?” This debate topic speaks about police being less proactive, because of vitriol, and causing an increase in crime rates. This debate topic is not directly related to the book, Ghettoside, but falls into the same bracket. The debate talks about the police becoming less involved because of denunciation, and rates of crimes increasing because of that. Ghettoside talks about the black-on-black homicide rates going up, one reason, because of the ignorance of the police.

Read More

Thomas Strained Relationship

730 Words | 3 Pages

During the 2014 evaluation cycle Det. Thomas developed a strained relationship with some patrol officers, as he included irrelevant material in reports, in a manner to shine light on other officer’s deficiencies. He was instructed not to utilize narratives in that manner but document in memo form and advise. I was also provided information from the prosecutor’s office that they did not like Thomas’s approach with them in reference to warrants, or prosecution of cases, and the feeling as though he was trying to tell them how to do their job. It was then requested that all requests come from me in the communication process as they did not feel as though they would receive cooperation from Thomas.

Read More

Fbi Agent Research Paper

1319 Words | 6 Pages

New York: Ferguson, 2007. Print. This book introduces readers to an adventurous career in law enforcement Kronenwetter, Michael. The FBI and Law Enforcement Agencies of the United States. Springfield, NJ: Enslow, 1997.

Read More

ASAC Peter Kowenhover And St. Louis County Police Department

414 Words | 2 Pages

While not on a scale anywhere near the events ASAC Kowenhover and Chief Belmar were in charge of, the community I police has been in a crisis of its own. In recent years the precinct I oversee has been subjected to brutal gang violence. There have been seventeen gang related homicides, many of the victims, teenagers, have resulted in federal prosecutions. Weekly meetings with members of the FBI Gang Task Force, HSI and my agency have helped develop trust and eased coordination with the continuing investigations. Each agency has a role and cooperates fully with the other agencies.

Read More

Battalion Chief Essay

489 Words | 2 Pages

Chief: as per the conversation during our meeting, you asked me why I wanted to be a battalion chief (BC). In answer to your question, I have identified the following three reasons. 1. To take on new challenges by moving up in the organization. 2.

Read More

Police Brutality Reform

1454 Words | 6 Pages

In addition to these notes, Hryniewicz has produced policy recommendations in the Journal of Interpersonal Violence, Violence & Victims, Society & Mental Health, Health Sociology Review, Contemporary Justice Review, and many more (“Danielle Hryniewicz” 1). On the other side of the debate, Professor of Criminology and Criminal Justice at the University of Missouri-St. Louis, David A. Klinger, supports reform through the police force in his article, "Police Training As An Instrument Of Accountability," issued by the St. Louis University Public Law Review in 2012. Along with his specialization in policing, terrorism, and the use of deadly force, Klinger possesses the experience of a patrol officer for the Los Angeles and Redmond Police Departments ("David A. Klinger, Professor" 1). With Hyrniewicz’s perspective of police brutality as a social issue which can be prevented through civilian oversight, and Klinger’s belief that it is a psychological issue resolved by refining police training, the two authors also disagree on who should be responsible for the reform that reclaims police accountability and

Read More

Constitutional Police Brutality

2453 Words | 10 Pages

In Law Enforcement and enforcing the law there is six areas in which police departments have been found to be defective or deficient. This is a very difficult topic for me to agree with because police officers are put in to very stressful and unknown circumstances on a daily bases. In many cases these scenarios require a decision to be made in a split second or it could be life or death. This split second decision has months and months to be twisted and picked apart by lawyers, jury, and mostly the media. Another reason police receive such attention is because it is their job to be in the view of the public at all times and today’s technology is making it even more difficult for them to effectively and efficiently do their jobs.

Read More

Racial Profiling In American Police Report

991 Words | 4 Pages

After years of ungrounded criticism from the press and activists, after highly publicized litigation and the passage of ill-considered laws—such as the one making officers financially liable for alleged “racial profiling”—NYPD officers have radically scaled back their discretionary activity. Pedestrian stops have dropped 80 percent citywide and almost 100 percent in some areas. The department is grappling with how to induce officers to use their lawful authority again to stop crime before it happens. Garner’s death was a heartbreaking tragedy, but the unjustified backlash against misdemeanor enforcement is likely to result in more tragedy for New Yorkers” (36, Heather Mac Donald).” Here, Mac Donald makes me feel threatened by the criminal justice system.

Read More

Police Profiling

642 Words | 3 Pages

Racial Profiling and the disproportionate use of police force are controversial political issues. Debates on racial bias in policing continue to reverberate across the country making headlines, aside from the importance of the debate on racial profiling and police use of force, such events create intergroup conflict, foreground stereotypes and trigger discriminatory responses. A serious issue in today’s society is the rising tension between the police force and the community which has developed through racial profiling and police brutality. In New York City, the controversial “stop, question, and frisk” policy was endorsed by some as essential for reducing crime rates (MacDonald 2001) and challenged by others as racially biased with a heavy burden placed on affected individuals and communities (Fagan et al. 2010).

Read More

Police Brutality Controversy

282 Words | 2 Pages

Police officer’s reputations are reduced and they lose the public’s trust as protectors. Specifically, society talks about the act of a white police officer savagely attacking a black citizen. The black population was enraged by this act and formed activist movements to prevent any police brutality brought upon them. As the controversy rise, society starts picking a side to defend. In this case, the nation is split into two sides.

Read More

A Rhetorical Analysis Of Ladder 49 By Captain Mike Kennedy

269 Words | 2 Pages

I feel that the summary of the speech from “Ladder 49” by Captain Mike Kennedy, for the eulogy for Jack Morrison was that in life it is never easy to say goodbye to anyone. Especially for a firefighter, the hero. Firefighters are ones who help people whether it is in a house fire, a car wreck or another type of catastrophe. They are the ones that save so many lives and their homes. The moral to this is to never give up even if somebody loses their life or how dangerous or bad your situation is in your life.

Read More

Field Training Essay

661 Words | 3 Pages

todays society in which the police force are so highly criticized, it is crucial that they receive the best available training possible so they can adapt to handle a variety of calls and situations. Throughout this text I will look at ways to better the training that officers receive, also I will identify things that I believe they are doing well to help prepare officers for difficult circumstances that they might get involved with. Management is a key aspect for developing a training that successfully prepares the best officers possible, it looks at everything from how they conduct their training to the attitude they have when conducting training. Police officers get the most training of all people going into their field and there are many

Read More

More about Unit 6 Writing Assignment: HAZ-MAT Scenarios

Related Topics

Open Document