ipl-logo

What Is Amtrak Privatization

516 Words3 Pages

4.g. Privatization of the National Railways
Beyond restructuring, privatization of the national railways should also be considered widely while discussing their reform alternatives. The privatization of a government corporation occurs if the Congress decides that the corporation should operate as a fully private company. However, in the US, some government corporations are considered as a transition step towards a full privatization when they were converted originally from a Federal agency. A government corporation can be fully privatized;
• when their assigned functions are no longer necessary for the Federal involvement,
• when the business conditions that lead to its creation have changed, and
• when they do not provide the most efficient way to achieve their expected public purpose.
On the other hand, the privatization of a government corporation may not be viable;
• when there are market weaknesses or imperfection of the market that can possibly make the privatization inappropriate,
• when the government needs to protect or continue an unprofitable service, and
• when there is a regulatory or …show more content…

Besides, Amtrak receives annual funding directly from the Federal government. Another barrier to the privatization of Amtrak, is the majority of US railroads are owned by private freight firms that control their own tracks. Freight railroad corporations have a legislative duty to allow Amtrak’s trains on their tracks, but they do not have any legal obligation to allow their railroads to other private railway providers. Moreover, private railways possibly have to pay more than Amtrak to operate on the property of freight railroads, so it is difficult for other private companies to compete with Amtrak without additional support, which makes it further more challenging to privatize

Show More
Related

Comparing Canadian National And Canadian Pacific Railway

256 Words | 2 Pages

The Canadian National Railway Corporation has been able to grow into the leading railway transportation nation-wide. It supports 46,000 kilometers of track and produces about $10 billion per year. This is generated mostly by rail freight operations, 95% and the 5% coming from commuter, intercity, and tourist passenger rail services, such as VIA Rail. Canadian National (CN) and Canadian Pacific Railway (CP) are the two main freight operators Canada. The Canadian National Railway makes up for about 50% of the revenues, while the Canadian Pacific Railway composes for approximately of 35% of their revenues.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Vanderbilt And Jay Gould

251 Words | 2 Pages

They also take advantage of the government’s lack of oversight, which allows them to charge exorbitant rates and make unreasonable demands of the railroads they own. The consequences of the actions of Vanderbilt and Gould are devastating.

Read More

Railways In Canad A Case Study Of Canadian Pacific Railway In Canada

407 Words | 2 Pages

In 1974, the government merged the Canadian national and Canadian pacific railway and named the public railway as VIA railway. But in the year 2000, CPR was given rights to control the freight transportation and today it is Canada`s second biggest railway network focusing primarily

Read More

The Negative Effects Of The Orphan Train System

1046 Words | 5 Pages

The United States underwent significant industrial development in the mid-19th century, which fueled the growth of American industry and the expansion of the railroad system. With industrialization came the need for cheap labor to provide the manpower for the industrial expansion. Immigrants flowed into the country in record numbers in the early 20th century, with many living in overcrowded conditions, which resulted in young families falling apart. The New York Children's Aid Society (CAS) was established to care for the growing number of orphaned or abandoned children. Charles Loring Brace, the founder of the CAS, developed a system called "placing out," whereby children would be sent to families throughout the United States, Canada, and

Read More

State And Federal Collective Bargaining Agreement Model The NLRA

234 Words | 1 Pages

Private sector gain its fund from its customers. Public sector’s collective bargaining is shaped ultimately by political forces. The services provided by government is only available in public sector. Services such as health, safety, and welfare. Public sector does not have competitors but works as

Read More

How Trains Changed America

1047 Words | 5 Pages

The idea of trains has been around since 2nd and 1st millennia BC in Persia. One of the earliest forms of the use of the concept of train and railroads was in Persia they had dedicated roads which had cut out ruts in the rock which allowed wagons being pulled by horses or bulls. Because of the ruts in the ground the wagons required no steering by the merchant driving on the road. This lead to a major connection between major cities and trade posts. With the development of trains and the steam engine nations began further development.

Read More

Transcontinental Railroad: Big Business, Industry, And Expansion

691 Words | 3 Pages

When creating my formal lesson plan, “Transcontinental Railroad: Big Business, Industry, and Expansion,” I originally intended to create a lesson plan that focuses on a large, student-centered activity in which students were to act out groups from the Central Pacific and Union Pacific railroads in a classroom-sized board game. Unfortunately, that particular lesson was too lengthy as it would take multiple days to complete. Therefore, I created a new lesson plan that took turns in being both student and teacher-centered to ensure that the material will be covered more efficiently. While my lesson plan was not as engaging as a game, I did implement an activity that called for students to think critically. Both lessons were guided by Dewey’s educational

Read More

Principal Agent Theory And Hampton Routes

482 Words | 2 Pages

First, privatization arrangements generally create multiple levels of principal-agent relationships. This makes it impossible for government to monitor all agents. No matter how much monitoring a principal does, some

Read More

Discuss The Pros And Cons Of Privatization Of Public Services

680 Words | 3 Pages

As I reviewed our class power PowerPoint on Urban services and literature about the pros and cons of privatization of public services. The groups I was in discussed the pros and cons of privatization and we seemed to all have different ideas of what public services should be. We also discussed the need for certain services in a city the size of San Antonio and what the goals were for having these urban delivery services. I personally believe, there could be a privatization of transportation services but I am on the fence of whether solid waste management and water and sanitation should be deemed private.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Privatizing Space Travel

276 Words | 2 Pages

In your argument calling for a stop to privatized space travel, you utilize a nice mix of statistical evidence and analysis. I particularly like how you integrate NASA’s shrinking budget to prove how the US has stopped supporting their space industry. However, throughout your essay you put forth many ideas without further developing them and/or linking them to your point. I can see where you're going with the argument concerning the US government’s lack of interest in the space program, but you fail to explicitly say that this has lead to greater privatization of the industry. You also say that their lack of funding has hindered scientific achievement, but you don't mention any specific examples, which really weakens your argument.

Read More

How Does John Macgregor Justify The Privatization Of Railways

1586 Words | 7 Pages

Discussion Competition The case for privatisation of the railways is generally fought over increased efficiencies, cheaper prices due to lower costs and better quality of service in this instance via faster times, lower fares and better seating among other things. The argument for the privatisation goes back to July 1992, when the then Minister for Transport, John MacGregor published a White Paper called “New Opportunities for the Railways, the privatisation of British Rail” which was used to justify the privatisation for the railways with a series of theories and promises. MacGregor (1992)believed that the free-market would benefit the consumers, employees and managers as privatised companies would care more about the customers' needs due to the greater incentives that management and employees in the private sector have, to provide the services which the consumer wants (Macgregor, 1992, p.4).

Read More

Communism And Fascism Similarities

258 Words | 2 Pages

The government controls the market, meaning that it privately owns companies and regulates what is

Read More

Police Privatization Disadvantages

445 Words | 2 Pages

Privatization is the process of reassigning ownership rights of a firm or possessions from the public or government to a private individual. Privatization has its merits and demerits. The merits are important to the stakeholders while the demerits work against the public who in a way are denied their basic services or more so charged a higher fee for which they could have covered with their taxes. Privatization of the police has two sides of benefits to the public, the citizens and the government. Considering the benefits, it is good to start with the public, which is more affected by the works of the police.

Read More

Essay On Military Privatization

1679 Words | 7 Pages

With military privatization it is too complex for one to be able to adequately capture in one single term, nor can one contain its moral complexities with a simple good or bad title. Private corporations have penetrated the western warfront so deeply that they were second only to the pentagon as the largest contributors of coalition forces in 2003 when the war in Iraq first began. (Traynor 2003) Most of the analysts in the Defense department acknowledge now it is not whether to privatize or not, but where do we draw the line and how do we regulate? The private contractors, while extremely necessary for the standing military to sustain combat, have also made it easier for American leaders to pull the war trigger, as the colonels like to say, and to do it without having to have their policies or common sense examined.

Read More

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Government Intervention

1195 Words | 5 Pages

Regulations that the government implement, licensing for example, increases the barrier of entry into the market and decreases ways for the traders to gratify consumer demand. This case is prevalent in the monopoly market. The market is sometimes best to decide how much and what to produce since it has better information and knowledge of the consumers compared to the government. Economic decisions may also not be competent when the government is motivated by political power rather than economic imperatives. Sometimes, economic policies are designed to retain power rather than to ensure maximum efficiency in the economy.

Read More

More about What Is Amtrak Privatization

Related Topics

Open Document