ipl-logo

What Is Corporal Punishment The Right Decision?

1160 Words5 Pages

Research Proposal: Is Corporal Punishment the Right Decision?

There has been controversy over the subject of corporal punishment and its effectiveness in the last couple years. Everyone is in a debate whether corporal punishment is a necessary form of negative reinforcement. Some see it as abuse, and others see it as the quickest and most effective disciplinary action. Many psychologists have studied the behavioral patterns of children in the two different situations, recorded their results, and their belief on the subject.
One of the psychologists that’s studied this subject, Elizabeth Gershoff, says no, physical punishment is not the way to go. Gershoff’s studies showed 11 cases where a child experienced corporal punishment resulted in …show more content…

In the scenario that my child is in the grocery store running up and down the aisles yelling, do I warn him of a punishment that might happen once I arrive home or do I threaten them of a spanking if they do not obey immediately? I believe that corporal punishment is the most effective punishment for children between the ages of 3-9 due to the fact that once they pass this age taking away their favorite device would be most effective. I understand that corporal punishment easily confused with abuse, but what matters is how the parent goes about the spanking. Spanking should be the last resort, it should be moderate, and it will not result in psychological issues in the future. Spanking helps the child decide which choice is the right choice. Children now are being raised with low respect for peers and elders, and corporal punishment is an easy way to eliminate the amount of disrespectful …show more content…

I used this article to shine a positive light on physical discipline and show that spanking is not abuse and that children are not going to grow into emotionally damaged adults because they were spanked.
Gershoff, Elizabeth, and Larzelere, Robert. “Is Corporal Punishment an Effective Means of Punishment?” American Psychological Association (2002) Web. This article shows the point of view of two different psychologists with opposing views and compares the two. Gershoff is opposed to the idea of anything physical for punishment and says that it should cease. While Larzelere disagrees that it should be thrown out. He believes that there is not enough accurate information to form this theory that corporal punishment is wrong.
I used this article to show how there are psychologists that understand that there is not enough information to factually say that corporal punishment is an absolute bad idea. I also used this article to show some opposing views.
Gershoff, Elizabeth. “Perspectives on the Effects of Corporal Punishment: Comment on Gershoff” Psychological Bulletin 128.4 (2002): 590-95.

Show More
Related

Physical Punishment In To Kill A Mockingbird By Harper Lee

396 Words | 2 Pages

The Effects Of Physical Punishment Physical punishment increases the risk of negative development outcomes. In To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee, the narrator, Scout Finch, gets spanked for swearing. Scout was swearing at her cousin Francis because he was saying derogatory phrases about her father, Atticus. Francis was also antagonizing her. Scout fought with Francis and had already been warned by her Uncle Jack that if she swore she would be in trouble and get spanked, he did just that and never listened to her side of the story.

Read More

Why Are 19 States Still Allowing Corporal Punishment In Schools?

674 Words | 3 Pages

It can serve as a deterrent, showing a student who is in control at school, in a swift, cost-effective manner. On the other side, it is sometimes used unnecessarily and may create an unsafe environment for a student. One must be careful in protecting a student’s self-esteem and counsel carefully why corporal punishment is going to be administered before the disciplinary action is used. Knowing the student and his/her background is a must, as an administrator would not want to continue with an abusive-act towards a student who was already being abused at home. Corporal punishment is an effective disciplinary tool, when used properly can have great results.

Read More

Controversy Surrounding The Dichotomy Of Corporal Punishment

1629 Words | 7 Pages

Our culture is indubitably conflicted in regard to childrearing. There are incongruous conceptions of childrearing that can be seen across society, as some individuals are advocates for corporal punishment, while others are critics of the use of corporal punishment in raising children. Whereas some individuals view corporal punishment as a method of punishment that enforces discipline, others regard it as child abuse. Some individuals see corporal punishment as a necessity in disciplining children, whereas others consider it as an inappropriate punishment that leads to feelings of worthlessness, aggression and dislike of authority. This dichotomy in principles can be traced back to thousands of years ago, when these ideologies originated with

Read More

Spankings: Objective Or Effective?

232 Words | 1 Pages

Although, I did not enjoy receiving spankings from my aunt’s husband, I do believe spankings can be effective, especially since pain is a basic motivator for driving behavior, when the objective is clear and reasonable force is used. Berger states

Read More

Right To Spank Children

465 Words | 2 Pages

The idea behind spanking a child is that it will help improve their behavior. There have been studies showing that people who were spanked as a child are more successful. They are also more likely to volunteer to help others. Also people who were spanked as children tend to be more disciplined.

Read More

Spanking Is Good For Children Essay

1249 Words | 5 Pages

Many studies have been conducted by doctors for numerous years. The doctors have developed a study to conduct if spanking affects children negatively or positively. There was a study done by Gunnoe and Mariner in

Read More

Corporal Punishment In The United States Today

640 Words | 3 Pages

Introduction Corporal Punishment is seen as a corrective process where a person in authority such as teacher, principal, or even a parent uses force such as smacking, punching, kicking, spanking, etc to correct being disobedient. Literature Review Corporal punishment remains a highly controversial topic in the United States today, mainly because it usually involves the use of physical contact to “correct” disciplinary issues. (Essex) The U.S. Supreme Court ruling of the Ingraham v. Wright that corporal punishment did not violate constitution rights. Leaving the decision up to states and school districts to enforce it.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Does Spanking Harm Children?

948 Words | 4 Pages

Does spanking harm children? There is an immense difference between a spanking and intentionally harming a child. Spanking does not lead to child abuse and/or later violence; Being harmfully abusive since a beginning does lead to later violence. Naughty Children, who are not lightly spanked, tend to feel that they are superior and bigger than their weak parents, and therefore attempt or achieve in “ruling” their home. By defining the issue that children need to learn that when they make poor choices or break rules in their future, they will be punished in different forms.

Read More

The Negative Effects Of Spanking Children

254 Words | 2 Pages

This topic is a little touchy because spanking has become more controversial lately. Some arguments that defend the use of occasional spanking of children in order to discourage negative behavior are that it teaches long-term discipline and that children should be spanked to learn discipline to function well in society. Some of the negative after-effects that have been linked to spanking children are that children who are spanked are more likely to be aggressive, withdrawn, or have behavioral problems when they go to school. Some of the more shocking effects from spanking that were in the accompanying media were that kids who have been spanked have a decreased verbal capacity by age 9 and that it may cause children to have mental health issues.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Spanking

500 Words | 2 Pages

Spanking can be effective when a child is not listening to a parent. If a child isn’t following proper rules and disregarding their parents’ statement, then a spanking can enforce a form of respect that the child has to follow (Jasmine, 2015). It can be an awakening to reality as the child could now think of how their actions are deviant. Parents that don’t resolve to spanking as the first and only method of discipline is essential for both the parents and the child. I believe a parent should always try to enforce rules by talking and showing examples of how deviant actions are frowned upon.

Read More

Argumentative Essay About Spanking Your Children

600 Words | 3 Pages

Whether spanking is helpful or harmful to children continues to be the source of debate among both researchers and the public. Many argue that spanking your children helps inforce good behavior and is a form of discipline for the bad. Although this maybe the reason why parents spank their own children many say spanking is a form of abuse. They say spanking your child can cause mental health problems and can cause negative outcomes.

Read More

The Line Between Corporal Punishment And Abuse

737 Words | 3 Pages

Corporal Punishment There has always been a very complicated line between corporal punishment and abuse. Corporal punishment is when physical force causing pain, but no injury, is used to change or improve the behavior of a child. On the contrary, physical abuse is the act of in to their cognitive immaturity. If this is true, parents should be teaching their kid what the right thing to do would be, not corporally punishing them for something they weren’t knowingly doing.

Read More

Spanking Persuasive Speech

954 Words | 4 Pages

What is the long term outcome? Is there a better way to assist the situation? Many parents feel that it is unnecessary to spank a child because it is not okay to hit, on the other hand, other parents view it as a way of getting the child’s attention and telling them “No.” There are just as

Read More

Thesis Statement On Physical Punishment

717 Words | 3 Pages

Studies have shown that spanking increases aggression 2. Spanking has been linked to lower IQ 3. Physical punishment is associated with increased mental illness C. Thesis Statement: Even though most parents use

Read More

History Of Corporal Punishment

1739 Words | 7 Pages

Introduction Corporal punishment is a controversial topic and has been the source of extensive legal debate on a global scale, with evidence being presented to support numerous countering views and opinions. Reasonable corporal punishment in the home is still protected by the law in South Africa, and many South Africans are in support of the continuation of its legality. Although some of the arguments raised are valid, the evidence conveying the harms inflicted on children by physical disciplinary methods supports the viewthat the defense of reasonable disciplinary chastisement in South Africa should be discontinued and corporal punishment should be illegalized in its entirety. The future of corporal punishment is questionable, and with more

Read More

More about What Is Corporal Punishment The Right Decision?

Related Topics

Open Document