ipl-logo

Controversy Surrounding The Dichotomy Of Corporal Punishment

1629 Words7 Pages

Our culture is indubitably conflicted in regard to childrearing. There are incongruous conceptions of childrearing that can be seen across society, as some individuals are advocates for corporal punishment, while others are critics of the use of corporal punishment in raising children. Whereas some individuals view corporal punishment as a method of punishment that enforces discipline, others regard it as child abuse. Some individuals see corporal punishment as a necessity in disciplining children, whereas others consider it as an inappropriate punishment that leads to feelings of worthlessness, aggression and dislike of authority. This dichotomy in principles can be traced back to thousands of years ago, when these ideologies originated with …show more content…

Thomas Arnold and Jean Jacques Rousseau. Corporal punishment is not merely a relic of the past, as it has made its way to our modern day culture and society. John Wesley, who was the the founder of the Methodist movement in the eighteenth century had asked his mother, Susanna Wesley for an “account of her educational precepts” (Cleverley & Phillips, 1986, p. 28). Susanna's first responsibility of childrearing happened to be the restraint of self-will in the child. As per the reading, “Good habits were developed under a strict regime of controlled sleeping, fasting between meals, whispered requests for food at table, regular family prayers, and the judicious application of corporal punishment.” Susanna seems to be adamant in terms of corporal punishment and being that she enforced discipline and her overall control, John Wesley came to adopt her …show more content…

Thomas Arnold, who was a famous educator. Arnold claimed that he perceived “evil hearts in boys” (Cleverley & Phillips, 1986, p. 31). Accordingly, Arnold established three educational standards that were to guide the eviction of evil, namely chapel, expulsion and corporal punishment. It is clear that Dr. Thomas Arnold saw corporal punishment as a crucial facet of governing within a school setting. In essence, although Dr. Arnold was unarguably a proponent of corporal punishment, he felt that the younger boys could be inspired by virtue. In terms of the preceding principle of expulsion, we still see that in our present day society, with children displaying unfavorable behavior being expelled from school, which is quite synonymous with the term

Show More
Related
218 Words | 1 Pages

Tongues pierced with hot irons, branded cheeks, and slashes from whips. What better way is there to snap criminals back into place? Jeff Jacoby, a columnist for the Boston Globe, promotes the reintroduction of torture, reviving the past days of heavy corporal punishment, in his article Bring Back Flogging. Jacoby uses shocking statistics and compares the effectiveness of Puritan punishment to today’s methods, However, his argument lacks acknowledgement to vast differences between societies, and fails to provide a solid plan for incorporating corporal punishment back into the penal system. The article begins by referencing accounts of the Puritan’s punishments of misdemeanors.

Read More
1016 Words | 5 Pages

In the article “No Spanking, No Time-out, No Problems”, Olga Khazan uses many rhetorical strategies to support and persuade her audience. That traditional punishment methods of parents will not change a child’s/children’s unruly behavior overall, but positive reinforcement will increase the chances of better behavior not only now, but in the future as well. “Positive reinforcement is the presentation of a pleasurable consequence following a behavior” (Craighead). This twist to traditional discipline teaches children to work towards a resolution instead of teaching them to lean toward violence. “For example, the way that parents discipline their children is how children discipline their peers” (Khazan).

Read More
438 Words | 2 Pages

In the early 1900’s, corporal punishment was a very common practise among all schools. Corporal punishment was allowed to be committed by teachers in almost every situation, but at Trinity there was a different story. Only the headmaster was allowed to commit corporal punishment and if so, “on extreme occasions”. Although the government has since banned corporal punishment for non-government schools in 2006. Other states are still yet to take action and corporal punishment is still allowed in non-government schools.

Read More
1049 Words | 5 Pages

Punishments and violence in child education remain as something that never left humanity since the beginning of the age. Parents ordinarily conducts punishments, even incorporating violence on it for the right cause. Moreover, in a majority of cultures and history, the common belief incites that punishments must act as the absolute way of disciplining and raising a child right. But in recent times, researchers and scholars who have conducted the study and are claiming that violence and punishment for the children, even the mild ones, are never to be done since it affects the children negatively. Using various elements of nonfictions, ethos, pathos, and logos, in the article “No Spanking, No Time-Out, No Problems” author Khazan attempts to persuade

Read More
601 Words | 3 Pages

The inclusion of a rhetorical question forces readers to see how seemingly simular acts elicit differing responses from the public, and how this conditioned aversion is ‘damaging’ our young. Professor Susan Malone from ‘RACP Paediatrics & Child Health Division’ correlates Critchley’s contention by affirming that research shows a connectedness between corporal punishment and long term health issues such as ‘metal disorders and domestic abuse’. This appeals to the reader’s sense of protection and family, maintaining that the ostensible historical and innocent character of a ‘tap on the bottom’, could have unthought-of adverse effects on their own children. Emotive words such as ‘abuse’, ‘harmful’ and ‘depression’ are integrated not only in the first argument, but throughout the entirety of the opinion piece, to evoke a sense of culpability within parents who do ‘smack’ their children, outlining the negative repercussions these actions

Read More
376 Words | 2 Pages

There was a strong correlation between the perceptions of children and how they were disciplined. Since children during the 16th century were viewed as sinners who needed to be fixed through education and strict discipline, parents would harshly control their children through threats and beatings. As seen in Doc 1C and Doc 2C, children were “sharply taunted, so cruelly threatened...sometimes with pinches and bobs” (Doc 1C) and often “cast [on] the ground and spurned and kicked” (Doc 2C). The circumstances children had to undergo were jarring and savage. Children, in return, viewed their parents as their masters whom they must obey.

Read More
674 Words | 3 Pages

“Why Are 19 States Still Allowing Corporal Punishment In Schools?” was published on October 17, 2016 in the neaToday.org website. The NEA is against corporal punishment, and Tim Walker composed this article questioning the reasoning of why over one-third of the United States still allow the use of corporal punishment as a disciplinary tool in its schools. In 1977, the United States Supreme Court in its ruling of Ingraham v. Wright, ruled that corporal punishment was legal and not considered cruel and unusual punishment (www.britannica.com/event/Inraham-v-Wright). The author of this article wondered if the nineteen states that allow corporal punishment were actually using the practice. It is a good question to consider, since many local

Read More
686 Words | 3 Pages

Some parents take it too far by burning, torturing, and killing children. The scripture was never meant to be taken in the literal meaning. Nowhere in the text does it ever imply causing or afflicting great harm to a child. This is why so many psychologist disagree with corporal punishment. It is suggested that parents try other discipline techniques that are less harmful to the child.

Read More
1519 Words | 7 Pages

Numerous studies demonstrate the vanity of punishing as a disciplinary method, yet none demonstrate its value. In the previous thirty years in pediatric practice, we have watched a huge number of families who have had a go at hitting and discovered it doesn't work. Our general impression is that guardians punish less as their experience increments. Punishing doesn't work for the youngster, for the guardians, or for society. Hitting does not advance great conduct, it makes a separation amongst guardian and tyke, and it adds to a savage society.

Read More
1731 Words | 7 Pages

Corporal punishment of children is the legal form of punishment to deliberately cause pain or discomfort in a response to undesired behavior with fair reason; however, it is debatable over when the use of this discipline technique extends into lines of abuse. The debate around the use of corporal punishment in American parenting is a subject of controversy within the child development and psychological communities, which questions the effectiveness the discipline practice has among correcting misbehavior within children. The courts of the United States have weighed the controversial arguments around the use of this discipline technique into categories of pros and cons that lead to the national epidemic of whether or not the use of corporal

Read More
500 Words | 2 Pages

Spanking can be effective when a child is not listening to a parent. If a child isn’t following proper rules and disregarding their parents’ statement, then a spanking can enforce a form of respect that the child has to follow (Jasmine, 2015). It can be an awakening to reality as the child could now think of how their actions are deviant. Parents that don’t resolve to spanking as the first and only method of discipline is essential for both the parents and the child. I believe a parent should always try to enforce rules by talking and showing examples of how deviant actions are frowned upon.

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

For many, spanking a kid is deemed to be one of the best ways to raise a kid. Since the previous generations, also known as the older generations were raised this mode, many accredit that applying the almost exact same method on their kids can lead these youngsters to learn and grow straight, therefore expecting that a spanked kid will aftermath in a prospective society with future gracefully informed and well educated adults. However, corporal punishments aren’t indeed the appropriate way neither the best solution to deal with the misbehavior of a little bairn. Spanking a kid, whether it’s with bare hands or a flat object, may lead some kids to actually rebel against their family.

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

I. Introduction A. P. J. O 'Rourke once said “Everybody knows how to raise children, except the people who have them” (O’Rourke, Pg.10). Parents always want their children to be better than what they used to be when they were at their age; that is why they care about every detail in their children’s life especially when it comes to behavior, obeying them and listening to their words. B. Background Information: i. People came to realize that physical punishment is a rough, atrocious, unacceptable mean of punishment that should be banned for its appalling, horrifying effects. ii. Facts about physical punishment (sources used) 1.

Read More
1747 Words | 7 Pages

This study purports to investigate why the use of corporal punishment persists despite its abolition two decades ago, its implications, and an alternative means of disciplining students without applying it. 1.1. Background Corporal punishment of children is a worldwide problem. Because it is a problem in most of the societies throughout the world it is necessary to conduct research about this issue. This Essay will focus on attitudes and opinions about corporal punishment in South Africa.

Read More
1739 Words | 7 Pages

Introduction Corporal punishment is a controversial topic and has been the source of extensive legal debate on a global scale, with evidence being presented to support numerous countering views and opinions. Reasonable corporal punishment in the home is still protected by the law in South Africa, and many South Africans are in support of the continuation of its legality. Although some of the arguments raised are valid, the evidence conveying the harms inflicted on children by physical disciplinary methods supports the viewthat the defense of reasonable disciplinary chastisement in South Africa should be discontinued and corporal punishment should be illegalized in its entirety. The future of corporal punishment is questionable, and with more

Read More

More about Controversy Surrounding The Dichotomy Of Corporal Punishment

Related Topics

Open Document