ipl-logo

What Is The Controversy In 2001 A Space Odyssey

1064 Words5 Pages

The Soviet Union cera 1960 through 1970 is characterized by a sense of intense competitiveness. The nation was in the midst of the Cold War with the United States and both nations were going to extreme measures to prove that they were the World’s greatest power. From the space race to the accumulation of nuclear weapons, a main source of this competition stemmed from technological advancements. However, after what is know in Russian history as “The Thaw”, censorship decreased and more people began to critique the nation’s scientifically driven agenda. One of the main public figures worried about the nation’s future was Andrei Tarkovsky. Through his films Solaris and Stalker, filmmaker Andrei Tarkovsky argues that as the Soviet Union moves towards a society focused on technological advancements, the Soviet people lose their connection with nature and each other. …show more content…

Solaris has been said to be Tarkovsky’s response to Stanley Kubrick’s film, 2001: A Space Odyssey.
In the film Solaris, Tarkovsky ironically characterized the main character, Kelvin, as a psychologist suffering from immense grief resulting in psychological issues of his own. At the beginning of the film, Berton warns Kelvin about traveling to the space station that circles the planet Solaris. He says that the planet posses strange powers over people. Kelvin is purley interested in the science behind Solaris and believes that the space station should either be shut down completely or the space station's research should move forward at a more intense rate. Berton cautions Kelvin further about Solaris’ ability to create hallucinations, but Kelvin disregards his testimony and is cold towards him. After their conversation, Kelvin’s

Show More
Related
619 Words | 3 Pages

Post WWl, Russia was still not industrialized, suffering economically and politically and in no doubt in need of a leader after Lenin’s death. “His successor, Joseph Stalin, a ruthless dictator, seized power and turned Russia into a totalitarian state where the government controls all aspects of private and public life.” Stalin showed these traits by using methods of enforcement, state control of individuals and state control of society. The journey of Stalin begins now.

Read More
574 Words | 3 Pages

This should be greatly emphasized in textbooks because it's valuable to the Soviet Union's

Read More
723 Words | 3 Pages

Then, the protagonist attempts to fix her problem by devoting herself to her work entirely and conduct her own research in addition to her normal work responsibilities. Miss Leavitt starts to notice blinking in Cepheid stars while conducting her normal work and asks permission from her supervisor to stay overtime to research them. An example from the script reads: ANNIE. May I see what you sit here all night

Read More
1331 Words | 6 Pages

Through blatant examples of Soviet nationalism, Litvin exhibits Stalinist thought and the vast impact it has on Soviet

Read More
720 Words | 3 Pages

What Mr. Larson went through to find out about the star seemed to be very stressful to him and I’m shocked he still tried to find out more and more about the star. Mr. Larson made the documentary very impactful to the audience and myself, but he also gave strong evidence about his argument with the uses of ethos, logos, and pathos. In the use of ethos, Mr. Larson uses this with his expression with religion. The way he expresses his information, is through the Bible and how the Bible explains the finding of the star.

Read More
480 Words | 2 Pages

The region known as one of the world’s superpowers lost dominance after seventy years of corruption and destruction. The Soviet Union was the largest Communist bloc, which were countries under Soviet influence. It ended in 1991 because the economy that was government run could no longer sustain. What important things about the Soviet Union should be placed in textbooks? Textbooks should emphasize the USSR’s size, The Great Terror, and their military strength, because they have shaped who this region is today.

Read More
2040 Words | 9 Pages

Process of Findings The first part of this report will discuss the evidence pertaining to the “genuinely concerned, pragmatic” side to Joseph Stalin’s leadership. Stalin was a leader who was honoured and praised by many of his people in the USSR for various reasons. He was portrayed on propaganda posters as a kind, caring and genuinely concerned leader particularly towards children who were the future of the USSR (Source A). By Stalin being portrayed as a leader who shows genuine concern and care for the children of his country, it propagates the message that children and the entire population of the USSR will have an “enlightened future” under his leadership13 (Source A), and would in turn help Stalin gain more support for himself.

Read More
777 Words | 4 Pages

A New York Cartoon really summed up how life was during the Cold War. This cartoon illustrated a nice day with a family sitting outside relaxing on the lawn. One of the people says, “oh, dear, I’d really be enjoying all this if it weren’t for Russia.” This cartoon proves that no one could be happy or focus with the constant fear of communism taking over or the Cold War to enjoy

Read More
608 Words | 3 Pages

The author’s repeated use of word “clandestine” through phrases, such as a “clandestine decision”, serves to further denounce the Soviets in the eyes of the nation. The author

Read More
1159 Words | 5 Pages

There is no individual thought process nor is there any innovation in new technology meaning that Oceana’s society has no room for improvement. Also one of the leading factors to the Soviet Union’s demise was the restriction on freedom of speech, and thought; as well as the restriction of opposition and individuality. This quote, “…He [Big Brother] did succeed, through the management of the news and the censorship of the written and spoken word, in severely impairing man's ability to think freely,” (Message) shows how Big Brother restricts a comrade’s freedom of speech via censorship produced by the Ministry of Truth, but it also resembles how Stalin produced fake propaganda, news, and government documents among other things, to make the Soviet citizens believe in him and follow his rulings. Both of these situations lead to the constriction on individuality, opposition, and therefore, innovation; and each government enforced this via their respective secret police. Because the main goal of either government is to make the people conform to the status quo, the Thought Police and the NKVD were essential to making the citizens obey the government, but the organizations were also responsible for restricting individual rights and the future of

Read More
1140 Words | 5 Pages

The nature of Russian society is characterized by a sense of idealism. Russia’s beliefs of the potential for an ideal future have been pervasive throughout history. In 1920, Yevgeny Zamyatin wrote the short story “The Cave” during the midst of the Russian Civil War, a time when nationalism was at an all time low and people were hoping for a brighter future. In contrast to the goals that sparked the revolution, Zamyatin argues that the Russian Civil War will result in a primitive and decimated society that is ultimately worse off than the society that existed prior to the rebellion.

Read More
480 Words | 2 Pages

Descrbed as being the "first village of London," Chigwell is a small viallge with a population of approxaimtely 15,000 people, which can be found 11 miles North East of London. As far as the originins of the city's name go, it is beleived that CHigwell means Cicca's well with Cicca being an Anglo-Saxon personal name. However, folk etymology, proclaims that the name was derviced from a lost king's well, whcih was supposedly located south-east of the village center near the border of what's now known as the London Borough of Redrige. CHigwell was intially isutain whitn the hear of the fores of Essex. At one point, the forest was vast, until 1301 when it was greatly reduced and broken up into several royal forest by Edward I. By the 1640s,

Read More
1757 Words | 8 Pages

Therefore, despite the horrors of Stalin’s regime, one could argue that the socialist realism paintings could ‘mould the consciousness of the people’ into believing that Stalin was a great and wise leader, a kind and humble man, and the father of all Soviet people, thus reinforcing his cult of personality that tries to portray him in that light. However, while art might have the power to do this, one must not forget about other visual representations of life such as photographs and posters. Their relative power and influence will be discussed later in the

Read More
1702 Words | 7 Pages

The dogma was useful for the regime, because it stated that all nature can be explained in terms of matter and energy, and it also implied that a small group of party members can guide society. I will introduce and explain the effects of dialectical materialism on scientific research through the examples of the Soviet space program and the engineering of the “New Soviet Man” (effects on the individual level, expanding to a reorganization of society and its values), of Lysenkoism and genetics (systematic), and of a rare antidote to the monopoly of one ideology through the operation of Vernadskii and his scientific school. The Soviet Union and the USA both regarded the space race as a proxy for the cold war, and the reasons for building piloted ships were not

Read More
1237 Words | 5 Pages

In an interview conducted by Shaun Walker, Moscow’s - the Guardian correspondent, Zvyagintsev said “It’s like being in a minefield, this is the feeling you live with here. It’s very hard to build any kind of prospects – in life, in your profession, in your career – if you are not plugged in to the values of the system.” The director’s negative view of Russia was portrayed clearly in his film and it’s the reason why the film received such negative criticism from Russian-born critics/journalists. Vladimir Posner, a veteran Russian journalist, said “Anything seen as being critical of Russia in any way is automatically seen as either another Western attempt to denigrate Russia and the Orthodox Church, or it's the work of some kind of fifth column of Russia-phobes who are paid by the West to do their anti-Russian work or are simply themselves profoundly anti-Russian” (Macfarquhar 2015). This is only a single example of the scorn the movie received from its homeland.

Read More

More about What Is The Controversy In 2001 A Space Odyssey

Related Topics

Open Document