ipl-logo

Where Representational Mind Begins Analysis

1286 Words6 Pages

Philosophy 7: Philosophy of Mind
Professor J. Armstrong
ID: 204563815
TA: Jenna Donohue
Where Representational Mind Begins
In this paper, I will consider Tyler Burge’s argument claiming that perception is the most primitive kind of representational state and where representational mind begins. First, I will explain each of Burge’s claims, clarifying what Burge takes perceptual states to be and why he believes that perception is a capacity shared among all minded organisms. After, I will engage with Burge’s first claim, offering my own reasoning as to why perception is the most basic form of mental representation. I will conclude by summarizing my argument and promoting Burge’s notion that perception is the most basic form of representation. …show more content…

In fact, Burges first claim is that the most elementary forms of representation are already present in perception. Burge develops a functional account for perceptual states that assigns them the role of representing basic particulars and attributes of the environment. He calls this role “perceptual representation.” According to Burge, sensory systems pick up information from the physical world, which is then processed by perceptual systems. Burge believes that perceptions are carried out by a series of computational steps that process information, from proximal stimulations in the environment, without the need of resorting to cognitive capacities. As such, he promotes the idea that primitive mechanisms of perception take place without the involvement of cognition. Burge also holds that perceptual processing is objective in the sense that sensory input is processed by perceptual systems that produce inferences. Accordingly, this enables perceptual systems to transform information obtained from by the system’s sensory organs into perceptual states that correlate with attributes of the physical …show more content…

Perceptions refer to what a system is able to perceive, the information that a system is able to discern from the physical environment. Through perception, a system becomes aware and is able to interact with the natural world. Unlike sensory systems that are dependent on the vagaries of proximal stimulations, perceptual systems represent attributes of the environment, even in the presence of varying stimulation. Our ability to perceive an apple as being red through variable changes in illumination mediated through perceptual modules that help us represent and attune to the environment. Without the presence of perceptual states, a system would not have to, or be able to, represent properties in the

Show More
Related

Perception In Brave New World And Grendel, By John Gardner

1327 Words | 6 Pages

Often, the way we perceive something is altered or controlled by someone/something. Like mentioned earlier, we have our more ordinary influences, like social norms/expectations. But in many cases our perception is tailored. In Brave New World, the Government had complete control over the society's perception. The Government did this by only allowing people to see what they wanted them to see, and not really supporting personal perception.

Read More

In Defense Of J. Valberg's The Puzzle Of Experience

1185 Words | 5 Pages

In The Puzzle of Experience, J. J. Valberg argues that, concerning the content of our visual experience, there is contention between the answer derived from reasoning and that found when 'open to experience '. The former leads to the conviction that a physical object can never be “the object of experience,” while with the latter “all we find is the world” (18). After first clarifying what is meant by 'object of experience ', the 'problematic reasoning ' will then be detailed. Afterwards, it will be explained how being 'open to experience ' opposes the reasoning, as well as why the resulting “puzzle” cannot be easily resolved. Lastly, a defence of Valberg 's argument will be offered on the grounds that it relevantly captures how we understand our visual

Read More

Man Who Mistook A Hat

533 Words | 3 Pages

Given a red rose, he comments on it for its length, color, shape and size but Dr. P. cannot be entirely sure until he smells it. He is unaware of anything unusual in his method of perception. As the title of this piece suggests, because of a similarity in size and shape, he is even capable of mistaking his wife’s head for a hat. Cognitive science is a new discipline that began in the 1950’s, so there is bound to be new discoveries and such cases as Dr. P.’s call into question established ideas about the brain and its

Read More

Clinical Judgement

1108 Words | 5 Pages

The process entails a cycle of sensory activities which are starting with perception

Read More

Descartes Sixth Meditation Analysis

1919 Words | 8 Pages

Conclusion: The mind is substantively different from the body and indeed matter in general. Because in this conception the mind is substantively distinct from the body it becomes plausible for us to doubt the intuitive connection between mind and body. Indeed there are many aspects of the external world that do not appear to have minds and yet appear none the less real in spite of this for example mountains, sticks or lamps, given this we can begin to rationalize that perhaps minds can exist without bodies, and we only lack the capacity to perceive them.

Read More

Peekaboo, Hide-And Seek Analysis

1650 Words | 7 Pages

According to the cognitive developmental theory of Swiss psychologist Jean Piaget, object permanence develops at the Fourth Substage of the Sensorimotor Stage. This is the

Read More

Thomas Nagel's What Is It Like To Be A Bat

619 Words | 3 Pages

Nagel contributes to the mind-body dualism by posing challenges to faulty reductive theories by discussing the importance of the consideration of subjectivity. He is entitled to the assumptions he makes because reductionism overlooks the gap between the subjective and the objective. Further exploring such gap can signify the creation of new methods that invoke the objective as well as the subjective. As of now the call for innovative approaches to understand the consciousness are essential to better understand our species and others

Read More

Corrupted By Life In Plato's Allegory Of The Cave

844 Words | 4 Pages

Corrupted by Life The mind is a powerful force that drives all humans. Throughout history, many great philosophers and scientists have questioned the origins of the human mind (Jacobus 455). According to “A World of Ideas,” there are many questions that rise and are further explored about, “the nature of the mind and its relationship to consciousness, knowledge, intellect, and the other means by which we work to understand ourselves and our world” (455).

Read More

Mid Trimester Abortion Research Paper

1939 Words | 8 Pages

Abortion is the medical termination of an unborn fetus. The termination is usually performed in the first 28 weeks. The procedure they use is called suction aspiration. “During the first twelve weeks the cervix opening is widened with rods of increasing size and a tube is then inserted into the uterus. The fetus and placenta are vacuumed out.

Read More

Ian Stewart Letters To A Young Mathematician Analysis

1450 Words | 6 Pages

Role of Situatedness in Comprehending the World People say, and mostly believe, that it's the brain which thinks, analyses and understands the concepts and patterns around us. For the brain to do its duty, few basic information has to be provided to it, which is usually done by the eyes and the place they are located. Eyes see, observe and pass the information to the brain, which processes it for further knowledge. So to understand the world around us, it is necessary to see or feel it. What is seen depends on where the eyes and the subjects of interests are located.

Read More

Summary Of John Searle's Chinese Room Argument

2029 Words | 9 Pages

Moreover, I utilise my definitions of understanding and meaning, to explain that computers are incapable of both semantics and syntax. Where understanding regards syntax and meaning regards significance of which both are consciousness-dependent concepts. Lastly, I differentiate sensation from perception, where perception is the ability to interpret sensory information, in order to

Read More

The Upanishads, The Orient And The Mideast

640 Words | 3 Pages

The sensory cognitive processes can know things as individuals, but to know the relation of one thing to another is proper only to intellect and

Read More

Representative Realism Research Paper

1455 Words | 6 Pages

When it comes to Philosophy there are many theories that have been created, researched, and shared and taught in the fields of academia. For instance, there is the theory of perceptual knowledge – known as Representative Realism, and the problems that challenge the theory holistically. With that being said, this paper will illustrate what the theory of knowledge or Representative Realism is, and the problems that can ensue. To illustrate, Representative Realism (or the theory of perceptual knowledge) is the philosophical position that the world we see (in conscious experiences) is not the world itself, but rather a miniature virtual-reality (or in virtue) of the world internally.

Read More

Strengths And Weaknesses Of Perception Essay

812 Words | 4 Pages

We have been used to living with perception so we molded our living around our senses and most of the knowledge we acquire is through them. However there are certain flaws to it, such as optical illusions and background that influences our perception, that makes us question how accurate our way of seeing the world is. Overall, sense perception is a good way of knowing if shared with other people so, with all the different perceptions of the world due to different life experiences, it all can be combined in a greater a more accurate perception of

Read More

William James's Theory Of Perception

1689 Words | 7 Pages

This essay will discuss the statement by William James, “-whilst part of what we perceive comes through our senses but another part (and it may be the larger part) always comes out of our head.” (James, 1890). This excerpt relates to the topic of perception, which can be defined as the acquisition and processing of sensory information to see, hear, taste, or feel objects, whilst guiding an organism’s actions with respect to those objects (Sekuler & Blake, 2002). Every theory of perception begins with the question of what features of the surrounding environment can be apprehended through direct pickup (Runeson et al. 2000). Is it only vague elemental cues that are available, and development and expansion through cognitive processes is required

Read More

More about Where Representational Mind Begins Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document