ipl-logo

Who Was Responsible For Edgar Allan Poe's Death

969 Words4 Pages

The death of an American writer and poet in the year 1849 has been a mystery for many years on how and why he died. For over 175 years many people have attempted to solve the murder of Edgar Allan Poe. With little evidence and many sides of stories and views, his cause of death was never determined. Hundreds of ways that Poe could have died, and the most reasonable one is murder. Out of many stories and evidence, but the evidence that makes the most sense is the murder of his fiancé Shelton's brothers. Accordingly, the reason that Poe could have died was murder by Shelton's fiance's brothers. This claim is the most reasonable for his sudden death because in the book Midnight Dreary the mysterious death of Edgar Allan Poe (Evangelist Walsh), …show more content…

So the people that saw that didn't think anything of it because they were doing the same thing to somebody else. I don't believe that the brothers would have forced Poe to drink something if he was unconscious. The way the brothers could have killed Poe could have been in a way that could almost be viewed as suicide. They could have suffocated him to death or even drowned him to death. After Poe was dead, the brothers then changed his clothing not only so that people wouldn't test his clothing for DNA or fingerprints, but also because if they were in a gang and practiced coping as well, that was something they were used to doing when they would change people's identity. So they did the same so that Poe wouldn't get recognized. When he was found dead, the hospital staff may have not checked his lungs for any damage and that is where they would have found the cause of his death. Hence, after all this, the brothers planned out Poe's death very cautiously and made sure they didn't leave any sort of evidence that would get them caught. Hiding the evidence after the murder could have been rocky for the brothers, and there had to be someone that saw them or suspected them for the murder. Poe's fiance would have been informed that her future husband was found

Show More
Related
209 Words | 1 Pages

Poe brings the horror even further once the murder has happened. The narrator starts the killing after the door was “open-wide, wide open-and I grew furious and I gaze upon it. I saw it with perfect distinctness- all a dull blue, a hideous veil over it that chilled the very morren in my bones”(2). The

Read More
147 Words | 1 Pages

This online article reviewed the many theories that surround the death of Edgar Allen Poe to date. The articled emphasized that the alcohol theory is the most commonly accepted cause of death recognized by majority of people. Even Poe’s good friend J.E. Snodgrass felt binge drinking caused his death. Other critics argued Poe was a victim of cooping, a practice that entailed bribing him with alcohol, thus forcing him to vote repeatedly in polling booths for a particular candidate, as Balitmore’s elections were notorious for political uproar and extortion. This would explain the conditions under which Poe was foundOthers suggested Poe died of other medical ailments ranging from brain tumors, heart disease, tuberculosis, rabies, epilepsy,

Read More
663 Words | 3 Pages

It is ironic that the creator of the mystery genre died in the most curious way. The death of Edgar Allan Poe on October 7, 1859 in Baltimore is one which stumps historians and professors to this day (Semtner). Was his extreme alcoholism the cause of his downfall? Was he beat to death by those whose works he criticized? Or was he simply ill; both mentally and physically?

Read More
255 Words | 2 Pages

The death seems to connect to cooping because he was found unconscious next to a polling station on election day in Baltimore. Edgar Allan Poe's death is clearly shown by the Cooping theory. Due to the corrupt and violent elections in Baltimore cooping is an obvious theory. Poe was found in different clothing and was found in a gutter. Cooping is when gangs kidnap innocent bystanders to vote for their preferred candidate; the gangs will go to the

Read More
359 Words | 2 Pages

The death of Edgar Allen Poe has been a mystery quite sometime as the details surrounding it are very few and the few we do have are quite vague. Through all of the unclear details two theories have arisen. The first theory of Poe’s death was alcohol poisoning. Poe was found outside of a tavern in a disoriented state of mind and for an unknown reason was wearing someone else’s clothes. He was taken to a nearby hospital where he was put into a room where he could recover from his apparent drunken state.

Read More
201 Words | 1 Pages

One possible theory that has been suggested is that Poe’s death was caused by rabies; however, when looked at closely, this theory is not valid. For example, in “Poe’s Death Is Rewritten As Case Of Rabies, Not Telltale Alcohol” the article talks about how “there is no evidence that a rabid animal had

Read More
501 Words | 3 Pages

Many people who know Poe thought he died because of his drinking problems. Evidence: The text states, “Dr. Moran’s description of his sweating, shaking, and hallucinations show that alcohol may have caused his death. Many others who knew Poe,including Dr. Snodgrass, also thought he died from drinking too much alcohol.” Explanation:Because even Dr. Snodgrass agreed and thought that he died of overdrinking as well as the way that Dr. Moran described Poe’s condition which describes someone who overdrank. Topic Sentence:

Read More
636 Words | 3 Pages

However, the lack of any discernible injuries or signs of struggle discounts the plausibility of foul play. Furthermore, given Poe's prominence as a literary figure, any attempt to harm him would likely have left more conspicuous evidence, making it highly improbable for a murder to go unnoticed or uninvestigated. In conclusion, while various theories attempt to explain the mysterious circumstances surrounding Edgar Allan Poe's death, the brain tumor theory emerges as the most plausible explanation. This theory provides a comprehensive and scientifically sound account of Poe's demise, supported by physical evidence, genetic predisposition, and the absence of alternative explanations. By considering the available evidence, it becomes evident that Poe's death was not the result of alcohol poisoning, violence, or rabies, but rather a tragic consequence of an undiagnosed brain tumor.

Read More
702 Words | 3 Pages

Death has always been an inevitable event that all of us are doomed to face. It is something that we cannot escape and we are all certain of its occurrence, however one thing that we are not certain of is the cause of death. A perfect example of this is Edgar Allan Poe’s death. Many theories have speculated about his tragic death and the two main causes of Poe’s deaths argued at the moment are death from rabies and death from alcoholism. Any individual could see both sides of the argument but the opinion with the disadvantage is that alcoholism was the cause of his death.

Read More
593 Words | 3 Pages

It is not known for sure that it was a room for drunkenness. According to Burton Pollin and Robert Bendetto, outside a Baltimore bar is where Poe was found (189). It was never been proved for sure that that is where Poe was found. With no specific evidence it isn't believable that Poe died from

Read More
464 Words | 2 Pages

As Dr. R. Michael Benitez said, Poe grew "confused and belligerent, then quieted down and died". He also stated

Read More
159 Words | 1 Pages

Poe didn 't drink alcohol and had an extremely difficult time swallowing water. This is a sign of hydrophobia. Furthermore, Poe became very belligerent during his final days.

Read More
512 Words | 3 Pages

Edgar allan poe death. Taigan cardwell Ms. Hardy English language arts November 17 2017 The death of edgar allan poe may always be a mystery. The theories behind the case range from alcohol to murder.

Read More
647 Words | 3 Pages

With all we know about Poe and his many works, we 're hit with suspense and anticipation by the first part of the story. Later in the tale, the narrator slows down and reveals his preparations that lead to the murder in such a deliberately enticing and suspenseful way, that even though you knew what was going to happen, it was still intense and suspenseful to read. These moods were further carried on by the way the narrator

Read More
558 Words | 3 Pages

The suspects of this crime are: The Red Death, The Raven, Annabel Lee, Lenore, Montresor, Mark Twain, Rufus Griswold, Auguste Dupin, and Person from the Tell-Tale Heart. Based on the evidence, the Raven killed Edgar Allen Poe. The Raven had two main reasons to kill Poe. One of those reasons was that Poe had created The Raven to only say “Nevermore”.

Read More

More about Who Was Responsible For Edgar Allan Poe's Death

Open Document