ipl-logo

Who Was Responsible For The Death Of Jack In Lord Of The Flies

465 Words2 Pages

In The Lord of The Flies, the island starts out with a sensible leader whose sole goal was to save the boys from getting stranded on the island. It soon changes into a chaotic, unorganized place because of Jack Merridew. His leadership consisted of brutality and provoking fear into the other boys. This may or may not have helped cause the deaths of two boys on the island. It is possible that Jack helped cause the deaths of Piggy and Simon, but in no way is it true that he is the sole cause of their murder, as it is obvious who is. Some could say that Jack is at fault for the deaths of Piggy and Simon on the island. They say that he provoked fear into the other boys which caused their actions (killing the boys). They also say that if he (Jack) …show more content…

I believe that the person who did the killing of either Simon or Piggy is at fault. That is why Roger is the cause of Piggy’s death as he is the one who pushed the boulder into him. Roger is responsible for his actions and he is old enough to control himself. People who disagree with me will say that Jack told Roger to push the boulder, but there is no proof. And, as I said before, Roger should be able to control his own actions. The death of Simon is a bit more complicated. Several people were involved in his killing. People who believe Jack is at fault, say that he provoked fear into the group, or that he knew it was Simon and just said it was a beast when he yelled to attack it. However, it is pretty much impossible to lay the blame on one person. Even Ralph felt guilty for participating in the murder of Simon. This means even he, Jack’s enemy, did not blame Jack. Thus, it does not make sense for anyone to blame Jack for killing Simon, when he is not the only person who participated in the murder. You could say he is partly responsible for Simon’s death, but he is not any more guilty than any other boy on the island. You would be ignorant to say that Jack is the sole person that is responsible

Show More
Related
855 Words | 4 Pages

Jack, being one of the main boys who were stranded on the island, cannot be held responsible for the murders of Piggy and Simon, two boys who were killed on the island. Jack Merridew was on the island at the time of the murders but cannot be held fully responsible for the

Read More
207 Words | 1 Pages

Even though jack never directly kills anyone by himself, he has been in a group that beat someone to death, he had one of his hunters kill piggy, and he tried to stab ralph. Did Osama bin Laden do 9/11? Most people would say yes because he sent the martyrs to fly the planes in to the buildings, the pentagon, and the white house. This is the same reason jack is considered a killer. He turned Roger to his side and planted the idea into his head that piggy and ralph needed to die.

Read More
962 Words | 4 Pages

Simon’s death serves as a way to prove that people are more evil than good. Simon was in the forest, and learned how the beast was false and didn't exist. When he comes out of the forest at night, Jack and his group ritualistically murder him. Even though at first it seems like it's a mistake, a later quote

Read More
359 Words | 2 Pages

Why should Jack and Roger be held accountable for their actions while on the island? On the island, there are a group of boys, Jack, Piggy, Simon, Roger, Sam, and Erik, they end up getting stuck on the island. Tragic events will start to happen throughout the chapters due to their actions. The boys should be held accountable for their actions while on the island. Jack and Roger should be held accountable for their actions due to murdering Piggy and Simon.

Read More
1073 Words | 5 Pages

Piggy should be blamed for the chaos and destruction on the island How would you feel if you were stranded on a deserted island with no one except cruel little children? The Lord of the Flies is an allegorical, dystopian novel written by William Golding in 1954 that symbolizes the good and evil that lives within everyone. The main characters are Jack, Ralph, Samneric, Piggy, Simon, and Roger. The boys find themselves stranded on an uninhabited island isolated from the nuclear war that is breaking out on the mainland. They have to establish order and work together if they want any chance of making it out alive.

Read More
497 Words | 2 Pages

“Piggys heads contents exploded and the conch shattered.” (Golding 181). Rodger rolled the rock off the cliff to kill Piggy, so Jack didn't do it. Rodger killed Piggy with the rock and no one really cared except Ralph (Golding 181). Jack didn't roll the rock, Rodger did.

Read More
898 Words | 4 Pages

The morning after Simon’s murder, Ralph and Piggy and discuss what they have done. Ralph realizes the extremity of his actions and confesses that “the things [Piggy and Ralph] did… were murder,” and not just just an accident as Piggy claims it to be (156,157). Although Ralph feels remorseful, he cannot change his actions and he cannot bring Simon back to life, and that cannot excuse what he has done. Successful leaders should be able to sense when something they are doing is wrong, and stop themselves and others before it gets out of control. Soon thereafter, Piggy tries to deny their involvement in Simon's death by stating that it “was an accident” and that the only reason they killed Simon is because “it was dark” and “[the boys were] scared,” but Ralph retorts that he “[was not] scared” and that he did not kill Simon because of the darkness, but out of savagery (156,157).

Read More
731 Words | 3 Pages

In the novel “Lord of the Flies” by William Golding the ultimate one responsible for the destruction of the island is Jack. In the novel Golding has wrote about how a group of british boys crashed on a plane and landed on a island where there are no adults,just little british boys stranded on a island .In the beginning one of the boys Ralph was the responsible leader where he knew what to do an how to manage. But of course there was this one cureles jealous boy that wanted to be a leader,the one in charge. Because of how ruthless and savage Jack was he took the fear that the boys had within them and used it against them to make them join his tribe which started the destruction of the island.

Read More
597 Words | 3 Pages

The boys that started following Jack caught most of the island on fire trying to capture Ralph, but because of the fire Ralph was smoked out causing him to run towards the sand, finding rescuers. Jack took Piggy's glasses causing him to not be able to see therefore, when Piggy went to get his glasses from Jack, some of the boys ended up pushing a bolder onto his head. Since Simon was caught in the middle he ended up going insane, causing him to put the pig's head on his head, which caused the boys to believe he was the beast, so they ended up accidentally killing him.

Read More
696 Words | 3 Pages

The anger they had with each other which caused the death of Simon and Piggy and numerous amounts of conflicts. Jack is envious of Piggy’s mind and proceeds to call him derogatory names, for example at the beginning of the novel he called Piggy “fatty”. The final sin is pride. Jack is arrogant and prideful. He constantly brags.

Read More
979 Words | 4 Pages

In fact Jack stayed so calm that it actually seems like the murder was premeditated. Therefore adolescents do know what they’re doing especially when it comes to committing a crime. He should be guilty for his murderous actions. While Jack had premeditated this, he had the time to undergo any emotions before the killing took place, which would explain why he was so insensitive. Jack was not bothered by Piggy’s

Read More
880 Words | 4 Pages

Jack’s manipulation even is used to justify the death of Simon later. Simon is brutally murdered but Jack claims that the beast is just taking a different form rather than acknowledging the group’s wrong. The book suggests that Jack knows of the murder of Simon“This head is for the beast. It's a gift. ”(146)

Read More
1143 Words | 5 Pages

The deaths and destruction that happened, only happened because of Jack’s decline into savagery and when he sees that most of the group is taking his side, he grows even more power hungry ultimately causing the downfall of the island. When Ralph is trying to explain to Jack that they go back to the shelters because it was about to rain, Jack had already begun chanting “kill the beast, cut his throat, spill his blood” (Golding 152). Jack starting this chant was a way to gain more power over the boys in the tribe by enabling a vicious part of them that was shown through when they killed the pig and because Jack has such a strong need for power he is willing to do whatever means necessary for him to stay in power even if that means unifying all the boys together to create a mob that only thinks of violence. Since all the boys are in a violent mob-like trance when they see Simon the group do not register that he is not a beast but a human and ultimately killing Simon while chanting. The death of Simon was caused by the chant that made the group feel a sense of security and protection being with Jack which made them unafraid of anything and as soon as they murdered Simon their last shred of civilization was gone and savagery took over.

Read More
857 Words | 4 Pages

Several different circumstances converge and lead to the first murder on the island. The multiple factors that caused the death to occur were Jack, the beast, the storm, the dancing, and Simon’s constant wandering off alone. Without these factors the first murder on the island would have been very different, but either way Simon would have eventually been killed. To start off, Jack was one of the main factors that lead to the murder. Jack’s madness and cruelty affected the other boys’ minds and caused them to think that it is okay to participate in atrocious activities.

Read More
913 Words | 4 Pages

This action causes the boys to go into a savage frenzy , screaming, yelling, and mass chaos, all because Jack told them to do their dance. Their dance turned into ritual killing where all the boys, including Jack, ruthlessly stabbed and beat Simon repeatedly to death. Jack had caused the mass chaos and if he had never done that, Simon would still be alive and not a corpse at the bottom of the ocean. Jack and his tribe committed murder and only Ralph recognized it for what it was: “that was murder…. I wasn’t

Read More

More about Who Was Responsible For The Death Of Jack In Lord Of The Flies

Related Topics

Open Document