ipl-logo

Why Is The Lobotomy Important

1033 Words5 Pages

The Lobotomy, The Dark Past In American Mental Health
America in the 1900's was a growing country and expanding scientifically. In 1935, the Social Security Act passed which led to better funding for treating mental disorders (Kemp 260). Doctors began to link mental condition with physical condition and started to use physical methods to treat mental disorders. The lobotomy procedure was developed by Walter Freeman and James Watts and was used to treat a variety of mental disorders from depression to Schizophrenia. The procedure severed the frontal lobe of the brain through inserting a pick above the eye and hitting it to serve brain tissue. The procedure's intent was to repair emotional disorder through physical means.
To what extent was the …show more content…

The procedure's highly experimental approach "lacked coherent medical theories" to explain it (Rochefort 31).
This made the Mental Health system rely mostly on predictions and luck rather than actual science. Direct observation of the brain is not possible and was very limited in the 1940's. As result it was difficult to even justify the theories. The Mental Health System did not yet have the technology to explore more efficient treatment options.
The mental Health system started to lack reasoning and started to look for a "quick fix". The lobotomy was almost a default solution for when a patient was not responding to other treatments. Prescription treatments for mental illnesses were not developed at this time, making treatment options limited.
The lobotomy is a permanent severation of the brain tissue and left many Americans having problems and their "shredded brain was damaged forever" (Bibeau)
Many people were left with stunted emotions and they had to cope with the effect of this surgery for the rest of their life. Studies on the surgery suggest that most patients of the surgery did not have the same social functions due to their lack of ability to …show more content…

However, even despite bad outcomes, this treatment was not questioned until a decade later after thousands of people had the procedure performed.
The science behind the procedure was based upon predicted theories. The theories at the time were not proven or justified, just predicted. Thus making the credibility of the procedure decrease and the credibility of the institutions' medical knowledge status decrease.
The lobotomy sparked progression in the American Mental Health system.
Technology at the time was improving and doctors "hopefully embraced the new treatments" (Rochefort 31).
Doctors believed that they finally found a universal treatment that helped people with these difficult mental illnesses. The hopeful perspective of the lobotomy brought attention to the Mental Health System as an advancement.
The technology advancement that the lobotomy brought attention to the awareness of mental illness and brought funding to the Mental Health system. The support the Mental Health System was getting helped it to advance and develop more.
Although now the lobotomy is viewed as a faulty treatment, it was first viewed “as a major medical advance in 1935”

Show More
Related
268 Words | 2 Pages

Howard Dully wrote a book about his life, also about how he received a lobotomy. His book is called, “My Lobotomy.” A lobotomy is a surgical operation involving an incision into the prefrontal lobe of the bain. Howard should not have received a lobotomy for many reasons.

Read More
238 Words | 1 Pages

I acknowledge the fact that lobotomy was certainly groundbreaking

Read More
307 Words | 2 Pages

Many people who received the transorbital lobotomy seemed to lose their ability to feel intense, emotions, appearing childlike and less prone to worry. Six of the psychiatrists, i found out later, said my behavior was normal for of them

Read More
655 Words | 3 Pages

These procedures continued on through the 1940-1950’s some of these treatments help some patients with severe mental illnesses. A lot of the techniques the doctors used became less popular to use for the patients and in the years to come there was a new method of treatment people with mental illnesses began to

Read More
2068 Words | 9 Pages

Otherwise, they couldn't come up with a better way for mental illness patients, but this turned into a problem of ethics since this kind of brain surgery represents brutal for people, “Since lobotomy went out of favor in the 1960s, it's become synonymous with cruelty or hubris, the work of sadists and megalomaniacs”(De Young). After decades from the 1940s, “sadists and megalomaniacs” referred that lobotomy as symbolized brutal, and it already had been eliminated from the professional operation. In the case of losing personalities or intellectual impairment, many women have to be admitted to a nursing home in order to avoid the inconvenience of physical

Read More
927 Words | 4 Pages

Research Question The introduction of the lobotomy procedure to North America was primarily due to its endorsement by famed neurologist Walter Freeman in the early 20th century. Despite a barrage of criticism and hostility from both psychoanalysts and a small portion of the medical community who questioned the ethics of the procedure. However, Freeman’s procedure success was mainly due to his reputation as one of the nation’s best neurologists. Freeman was a professor of neurology at George Washington University and performed the first lobotomy in the United States.

Read More
654 Words | 3 Pages

The State Care Act was passed in New York State. This ordered U.S, indigent mentally ill patients to be transferred from the poor-houses into institutions for psychiatric research. In 1892 the foundation of the American Psychological Association was founded. 1895 the first laboratory for psychodiagnosis was founded by G. Stanley Hall.

Read More
2163 Words | 9 Pages

The media often framed the use of ECT as part of a grand battle against mental illness, and in viewing treatment this way, side effects or dangers of treatment were seen as somewhat inevitable quote-unquote “casualties” of this fight (Hirshbein & Sarvananda 4). Further, evidence of ECT’s success represented a triumph of man and science over seemingly incurable disease, a feat so magnificent it made people more willing to dismiss potential consequences. From the point of view of practitioners, ECT benefited them significantly in multiple ways. First, their success and the idea that they were able to cure such a seemingly hopeless condition improved the reputation of psychiatry as whole. Its tendency to calm erratic patients also bettered the atmosphere of psychiatric hospitals, as the patients undergoing this treatment were often violent or dangers to themselves (Hirshbein 149).

Read More
207 Words | 1 Pages

The widespread of lobotomy happened because families wanted hope that lobotomy will cure their loved ones. I do not think lobotomy worked, but so many psychiatrists believed that lobotomy did because there were some temporary changes to the patient’s behavior, but from the video, the patient symptoms came back, some died and some of the

Read More
513 Words | 3 Pages

Psychology has had a huge impact on how we study behavior, and how we treat any problems related in any way with the brain, psychologically,and physically. Back in the nineteenth century however, any means of studying an active brain was nearly impossible due, to the lack of technology and proper equipment. However, on September 13, 1848, a young man by the name of Phineas P. Gage, suffered a very severe Injury, in which an iron rod pierced through his head, when unexpected explosion occurred while he worked on a American railroad construction site, with his fellow workers. The damage he sustained from the incident included the destruction of his left and right frontal lobe, also losing his eye, regardless of the injury, he survived the incident. This was the first case, that anyone was able study an active, live brain.

Read More
1390 Words | 6 Pages

Lobotomy in 2018 by Tiana Y. If doctors switched over to the 1930s, the medical world now would be in risk. Mental illnesses would not be treated the same; lobotomies would still be at its peak of popularity; people’s lives would be reaching an end or finding itself at a beginning. Lobotomy is a procedure that originated back in the 1930s. It was used because doctors believed it could help with mental illness.

Read More
2129 Words | 9 Pages

An article by Long (2010) stated that lobotomy was first performed in Lisbon in 1935. Lobotomy was performed by drilling two holes in the patients’ skulls, and the doctor would insert pure alcohol to destroy the brain’s tissue or surgically destroy the nerves that connect parts of the brain. Lobotomy was believed to be able to cure mental illness. However, because of its huge amount of failures and protests, many stopped performing lobotomies since it was considered barbaric. However, United States was among the countries that still performed lobotomies until the 1980s.

Read More
1629 Words | 7 Pages

Some of these techniques may not have worked on particular cases, but were still conducted due to the majority of change that was proven to be the outcome. Society today may look down upon

Read More
1759 Words | 8 Pages

A report published in the Transactions of the American Institute of Homeopathy's meeting, 1891, reports a difference of 50% of patients discharged from the homeopathic mental hospitals in the State

Read More
461 Words | 2 Pages

Some treatments from 20th centuries are still used today like EST, but some of the treatments they needed to get rid off. Patients may only receive up to 12-14 treatments, compare to 100+ that were used in the 1950’s. Instead of Lobotomy or any torture treatments that were used before, patients are cared for with one-on-one assistants who help them back to a healthy mental or physical state. Mental hospitals had changed over the time, they are not what they used to be and they have definitely taken a turn for the

Read More

More about Why Is The Lobotomy Important

Related Topics

Open Document