ipl-logo

Why Minors Tried In Adult Prisons

1489 Words6 Pages

Drake Hayes
Christopher Kutz
Legal Studies 39I
20 October 2017
Why Juveniles Tried In Adult Courts Have Higher Recidivism Rates? In the United States we punish people based on their crimes in different ways. All of these punishments fall into two subcategories: adult prisons/jails and Juvenile Detention Centers (JDC). When minors are punished they are supposed to be sent to a JDC, but they can be waived (transferred) into an adult prison. This became a trend in the 1990’s as juvenile crime was considered “out-of-control”. Ever since Juveniles have been split up between Juvenile Detention Centers and Adult Prisons, having two different types of results. This essay will answer the question of “why juveniles tried in adult courts have higher …show more content…

According to the U.S. Department of Justice, 921,600 minors were arrested in the year 2015. These minors are then tried in Juvenile court (unless they are 16 or older in North Carolina and New York). They are either tried and if guilty, sent to a JDC or waived to an adult court. PBS’ Frontline cites two assumptions that justify trying Juveniles as adults. One, that juveniles are tried as adults to have longer, more proportional sentences to their crimes. Two, that adult prison will lower Juvenile crime rates. Author of The Recidivism of Violent Youths In Juvenile and Adult Court David L. Myers writes that “This expectation of greater deterrence is based on the perception that juvenile courts are too lenient and that criminal courts can provide increased accountability and stronger punishment, which will reduce youthful offending” (Myers). These assumptions and perceptions false and are supported by opinion, not by …show more content…

This place of punishment focusses more on reformation than spending time in a prison cell. They have all different types of programs to help support the adolescents that are in JDC’s. Some of those programs include drug treatment, educational, vocational, counseling, and hate crime. In an article called From Both Sides Of The Bench - What Works? By PBS’ Frontline, multiple judges and attorneys speak about the effects of JDC’s and why they are better suited for youth. Kurt Kumli, the DA for the Juvenile Division of the Santa Clara County DA’s office says that “There are a whole of things that you can do in juvenile court that, frankly, adult court just doesn’t do.” Unlike adult prison in which the main difference in punishment is sentencing, the juvenile system can adapt to what will best reform the defendant. If that means going to counseling, school, or art classes, that can be arranged to give the minor the best chance of not committing another crime. Judge LaDoris Cordell believes that “the beauty of the juvenile justice system is that ic can be applied and modified to deal with the needs of the particular juvenile.” Similar to what Kumli said, Cordell is appreciating the fact that the Juvenile system works because it adapts to the needs of the “particular

Show More
Related
1622 Words | 7 Pages

There are indication that most criminals have a juvenile records in the US, indicating that crime manifests from a tender age. Therefore, to reverse the incidence of crime, it follows that the best strategy is to reduce the criminal orientation in the juvenile offenders as opposed to hardening them and preparing them for criminal careers. The case of the Crossroads Juvenile Center demonstrates the willingness of the juvenile justice systems to make these changes on the children. References Day, S. (2014). Runaway Man: A Journey Back to Hope.

Read More
743 Words | 3 Pages

Juveniles that go through the rehabilitation process will be able to have a clean record after they reach 18, whereas the exact opposite if they went through the adult justice system. Stevenson feels that, “We’ve become so fearful and vengeful that we’ve thrown away children, discarded the disabled, and sanctioned the imprisonment of the sick and the weak—not because they are a threat to public safety or beyond rehabilitation but because we think it makes us seem tough, less broken.” (289) This quote represents the treatment towards juveniles in prison and how the potential of these children is wasted. The goal of rehabilitation is to help the youth understand the consequences of their actions and learn how to make better choices in the

Read More
965 Words | 4 Pages

In order to eliminate crime, we must recognize the negligence that lies within the juvenile prison system. These major criminals often started out in the juvenile system, so if they receive the help they need as teenagers, we can curb the negative behavior and diminish

Read More
1031 Words | 5 Pages

A writer for The Economist by the name of Estudillo Mary Onelia had a very strong opinion on this topic. Onella stated, “Trying minors as adults will toughen the system and hold someone responsible. Minors must be fully culpable for their behavior if we are to deter future delinquents from committing violent crimes,” however; this is not the case. Placing a juvenile in prison is not teaching them how to be lawful adults it is locking them up in a building where they are exposed to older criminals whom will not set them on a successful

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

To better understand both sides of trying juveniles as adults, data on of trying juveniles as adults will be looked at. In doing this, evidence for why trying juveniles as adults is harmful will become clearer. The data will show that alternate programs such as community based program geared towards restorative justice and programs such as diversion will be most beneficial in helping juveniles learn social skill and learn the effect their behavior has on the community and the victim. Bringing both the juvenile and the community together with have a lasting effect and has been shown to reduce recidivism rate. Literature review Researchers look at the trying juveniles as adult in one of two ways, they look at juvenile delinquency as learned through peers, the second way they look at it is trying juveniles as adults is through a critical lens where the researchers believe that policy makers and judges benefit by keeping minority juveniles in detention centers or prison.

Read More
1247 Words | 5 Pages

they are far more able than adults to learn new skills, find new values, and re embark on a better, law-abiding life” (“Minors Are Not…”). Juveniles can rehabilitate from their mistakes and change their lives. They may need a little help to change, but the help and resource they need are not found in prisons. Sentencing juveniles as adults causes them to lose hope in their future. It makes these teens feel as though they can never accomplish anything in the future because of their one mistake; however, that is far from the truth.

Read More
1303 Words | 6 Pages

Minors are often immature when they commit horrendous crimes. Furthermore, they don't have an appropriate level of psychological understanding to make sound decisions. Trying juveniles as adults is wrong because juveniles are not mentally stable enough to understand that the decisions that they make can negatively impact their future, trying minors as adults hinders their growth as individuals and harms their productivity in the long run. Instead of juveniles being sentenced as adults for their criminal offenses, they should be obligated to participate in intervention programs. Juveniles don't have a fully developed mental stability to make sound decisions.

Read More
1763 Words | 8 Pages

The tension is so strong, it still continues to this day, where we are still having to deal with our juvenile justice system. There has never been a clear single dominant path to follow in regards to the juvenile system. But through the following research conducted and arguments placed. The benefits of

Read More
1416 Words | 6 Pages

We live in a society today, juvenile justice is a concern for law enforcement. One thing us whether or not to try teen criminals in adult courts and sentence them to adult prisons. In virtually all states there are juvenile justice systems where teens are tried and put into juvenile facilities. The main focus of these facilities is to rehabilitate juveniles, not just punish and imprison them. The problem is that some teens are still being tried in adult courts and sentenced to adult prisons.

Read More
506 Words | 3 Pages

We have seen today in society of how crime rates have been rampant and how statistics show that most of the crimes were being made by minors. I believe that when most of them look at the bottom of these young offenders come disproportionately from impoverished single-parent homes that are located in the neighbourhoods desinvertido and have high rates of learning disabilities, mental health, and substance abuse and problems with the help of the system of juvenile justice that can make a great return on a successful transition to adulthood. Their ages ranged from 20 and under, most are under fifteen years of age. Juveniles tried as adults must assume the same consequences as any other criminal and are subject to state prisons with inmates much higher and that have probably committed crimes much more tortuous then you could ever have. These minors between the ages of nine to twenty according to the offence committed or of the number of times that are prosecuted and believe that it is immutable.

Read More
1128 Words | 5 Pages

Every day in America, an average of 1,200 youth of the 5 million people are incarcerated in youth detention facilities, and nearly 200,000 youth enter the adult criminal justice system each year; most for non-violent crimes. Despite the life-altering consequences of incarceration in an adult prison, relatively little attention has been given to these youth. These children lose more than their freedom when they enter adult prisons; they lose educational and psychological benefits offered in the juvenile-detention facilities. The worst case scenario, juveniles are more likely to suffer from sexual abuse and violence at the hands of vicious murderers and it will negatively influence their growth and development. A child is not an adult, they are legally allowed to receive proper care and benefits even when serious crimes have been committed.

Read More
636 Words | 3 Pages

Imagine being a child imprisoned for committing a crime for which you did not understand the consequences. Alone and afraid, with only hardened criminals and psychopaths as adult role models, you live in fear. Through a vicious combination of physical, sexual, emotional, and mental abuse, there is no option but to turn back to crime as an adult, and continue the cycle. This is a daily reality for thousands of American juveniles. Yet, we continue to call it the juvenile justice system.

Read More
849 Words | 4 Pages

There are differences between a juvenile court and criminal court in the United States. The focus of the juvenile justice system is on rehabilitation, in hope of deterring the minor away from a life of crime so they will not commit a crime again as an adult. In contrast, the criminal justice system focuses on the punishment and often bases the sentencing outcome on the criminal history of the youth. In a study conducted, Butler (2011) showed that the participants’ experience with adult jails and prisons show that those facilities may instill fear but are otherwise emotionally—and often physically—dangerous for youth. Many of the adult prisoners, who were minors when they enter the adult institution, felt they were forced to “grow

Read More
1043 Words | 5 Pages

Annotated bibliography Childress, S. (2016, June 2). More States Consider Raising the Age for Juvenile Crime. Retrieved from PBS: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/more-states-consider-raising-the-age-for-juvenile-crime/ More states are considering to raising the age for juvenile crimes before being tried as adult because young offender's mental capacity. The idea is to cut the cost of incarcerate young offender in adult prison and ensure offenders to receive proper education and specialized care to change their behavior. Putting children in adult prison does not deter crime.

Read More
760 Words | 4 Pages

Can you imagine waking up behind closed walls and bars? Waking up to see your inmate who is a 45-year-old bank robber and you are a 14-year-old minor who made a big mistake. This is why minors who have committed crimes should not be treated the same as adults. Some reasons are because the consequences given to minors in adult court would impact a minor’s life in a negative way. If a minor is tried through a juvenile court, they have a greater chance of rehabilitation.

Read More

More about Why Minors Tried In Adult Prisons

Related Topics

Open Document