ipl-logo

Wicked Silence Film Analysis

1727 Words7 Pages

Wicked Silence is a short documentary that focuses on the 7600 forced sterilizations that occurred in North Carolina even after World War II, making North Carolina among the worst in state sterilization programs. The film began with a forum for victims and their family members, in which the audience is introduced to the concept of feeblemindedness as the criterion that the Eugenics Board of North Carolina used to target victims for these forced and coerced sterilizations. Social workers would target people and form petitions based on this for the “operation of sterilization or asexualization by the Eugenics Board of North Carolina” (Haq, YouTube, Wicked Silence), most often not obtain consent from the patients, and send the cases to Raleigh …show more content…

With regard to coercion, North Carolina’s Commissioner of Public Welfare urged the state to follow up with people who were receiving assistance from the Aid to Dependent Child Program (243). This program targeted people who were already sterilized to see if other family members would also benefit (243) as was the case with Ann. These people were taken advantage of and their natural ability to have children was taken away from them under the guise of ridding the population of unfavorable characteristics that these people just so happened to have. They were also subject to immense psychological, emotional, and physical harm for seemingly no reason. Doctors must recite and uphold the Hippocratic Oath which states that one must “do no harm” and ethics was a large topic of debate during the 1960s and early 70s after a slew of unethical experiments had taken place i.e. The Humphreys, Stanford, and Milgram’s studies. I would assume that as a result, the same practices and increased ethical standards would be demonstrated in hospitals in the later years, but when dealing with low income people and people of color, the same standards do not seem to hold. Even today, there are instances of forced sterilizations in the United States, specifically in the United States prison systems as well as many other unethical practices taking

Show More
Related
104 Words | 1 Pages

A recent federal lawsuit has been filed by the American Civil Liberties Union’s (ACLU) challenging the constitutionality of three provisions of the Setonia’s Abortion Laws. The three provisions ACLU are challenging are as follows (McCauliff): • Law which prevents state health officials from renewing or issuing licenses to abortion clinics located with 2000 feet of an elementary school (McCauliff). • Law which requires physicians performing abortions to complete 10 hours annually of continuing medical education on abortion procedures (McCauliff). • Law which requires abortion providers to give every patient a copy of her medical records, regardless of whether the patient requests such records (McCauliff).

Read More
338 Words | 2 Pages

The issue of involuntary sterilization, especially after World War II, violates many moral and ethical principles. Why do you think sterilizations in Alberta continued until 1972,

Read More
966 Words | 4 Pages

Most sterilizations were also done without the patient's consent or knowledge. A patient's consent should always have been the main part of the sterilization. Once the sterilization was over the person’s life was changed forever. I feel that the Buck v Bell case had a lot of influence on today's society. I

Read More
583 Words | 3 Pages

Hypnosis is a topic widely discussed throughout society. There are many different points of view on it, whether it’s a battle between its existence, or a debate on the pros and cons associated with it. One can say it’s amazing; the fact that one can potentially read the lives of others. One may differ and find the idea disgusting, taking into consideration the privacy invasion. There is an interesting book written exactly on the consequences of hypnosis, called “A Stir of Echoes,” by Richard Matheson.

Read More
151 Words | 1 Pages

I agree with your point that we shouldn 't have the authority to take away anyone 's right to bear children but sterilization is not inhumane if someone chooses to do it for their own personal reasons. I myself, after bearing 3 children, made the personal decision to not have anymore. There was nothing inhumane about my decision or the procedure. I do agree however that the inhumane practice of forced or "coercive" sterilization, favored by eugenicists and population controllers was wrong. Much of the controversy over Sanger and her involvement with eugenics came from a letter she wrote and an inartfully written sentence that describes the sort of allegations that fueled people 's suspicions that she was opening clinics to exterminate a

Read More
711 Words | 3 Pages

Many of the eugenicists believed that certain racial and socioeconomic groups were more prone to degeneracy with criminal-like behaviors. Villarosa argued that these were the same attitudes that shaped family planning workers’ decision to target Minnie Lee and Mary Alice Relf for permanent contraception. The Relf sisters came from poor family and were living in public housing, which made them vulnerable to coercive sterilization. Villarosa allows history to help us understand the reproductive violence that the Relf sisters and other females suffered. She explains that forced sterilization was a common practice in the United States during the

Read More
127 Words | 1 Pages

The movie Carved in Silence was a very provoking and eye opening documentary for me. It depicted the experience of the Chinese immigrants of Angel Island very well through the narration and the dramatic recreation. As an immigrant, the opening scene and the many stories told evoked many memories and reflections of my family 's journey and aspirations. The stories and descriptions in this documentary were very surreal because they were too hard to believe.

Read More
619 Words | 3 Pages

The horrors of World War I are shown in many media sources. From books to movies, World War I has been a big influence. One movie that does a significant job at depicting the war is, All Quiet On The Western Front. This movie follows the story of a German soldier named Paul Bäumer who unfortunately experiences the worst of the war. What the movie does a great job with showing is how the war itself caused the Roaring 20's, which was a time of great economic prosperity in the Western world.

Read More
1064 Words | 5 Pages

Scientific research has undergone a transformation from knowing little about cells to experimenting on the cells and advance in medicine. The fascination to discover the unknown has triggered scientists to unconsciously over-step ethical boundaries. In The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, Rebecca Skloot (2010) elaborates on the legal unethical practices in 1951 in the United States and the standard medical practices during the Jim Crow era. The policies and regulations have structurally created disparities among the African American population leading to skepticism towards the healthcare system.

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

In the case of Henrietta Lacks and her family, the mistreatment of doctors and lack of informed consent defined nearly 60 years of the family’s history. Henrietta Lacks and her children had little to no information about serious medical procedures and the use of Henrietta’s cells in research. Henrietta’s cells launched a multibillion-dollar industry without her consent and doctors even took advantage of her children’s lack of education to continue their research without questions: “[Doctor] did not explain why he was having someone draw blood from Deborah… he wrote a phone number and told her to use it for making more appointments to give more blood” (188). Deborah did not have the knowledge to understand the demands or requests the doctors made of her, and the doctors did not inform her explicitly.

Read More
1877 Words | 8 Pages

Throughout the career of writer and director Jim Sheridan, there has been a significant change to not only Irish-made films but those directed by Irish individuals as well. Sheridan has attempted to maintain a realistic balance of both local and global expectations of “Irish Films.” Mr. Sheridan has helped move Ireland away from the many stereotypes found in films about or even set in the country. One of the lasting films in Ireland was director John Ford’s The Quiet Man.

Read More
223 Words | 1 Pages

The recorded setting of the Eugenics framework began in North Carolina in 1929 and continued till 1973. The Eugenics Board of North Carolina affirmed more than 8,000 sanitizations. The aggregate number of setbacks that were really sanitized is said to have been more than 7,600 (Winston-Salem, "Starting a Shameful Era"). Of this number, females accounted to approx. 85% of those cleaned (State Library, "Insights," p. 1).

Read More
893 Words | 4 Pages

Annotated Bibliography "Abortion ProCon.org." ProConorg Headlines. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Apr. 2016.

Read More
256 Words | 2 Pages

Sterilization started back a while ago in america 's history. It was used during a time when the government and people wanted to control the undesirable populations, such as immigrants, people of color, poor people, unmarried mothers, the disabled, the mentally ill, and whoever else seemed unfit to reproduce. This procedure took place in thirty-two states throughout the twentieth century, particularly in California. Eugenics was commonly accepted as a form or protecting society from the offsprings of individuals listed above. More recently, between 2006 and 2010, almost 150 female inmates in california prisons were authorized to have sterilization procedures done to them.

Read More
1529 Words | 7 Pages

Breathless, originally titled ‘À bout de souffle’, made in 1960 is a movie about a small-time thief who steals a car and murders a policeman. The story is about authorities chasing him while he reunites with an American journalist and attempts to persuade her to run away with him to Italy. Jean-Luc Godard, the director of the movie often quotes, ‘To make a film, all you need is a girl and a gun.’, which is probably the inspiration behind this movie. Breathless was one of the movies that kicked off the French New Wave. Like several of his French New Wave members, Jean-Luc Godard started as a film critic, and wrote for the magazine ‘Cahiers du Cinema’ in the 1950s, when he was in his early 20s.

Read More

More about Wicked Silence Film Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document