More handpicked essays just for you.
An essay about why the giver is dystopia
The giver dystopia and utopia
Is the giver a utopian or dystopian society
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
The Giver is a novel that is set in a society that strives to be a utopia. A utopia is essentially a is “a place where no one has to make a decision, feel pain or even have a negative thought or a bad memory” (Goepfert). In The Giver their community focuses so intensely on this concept of a peace that they make many sacrifices in their pursuit to obtain it. This includes the loss of emotion, lack of individuality, deceit of the public, and a great burden on a small few. Ultimately the cost of this utopia is too high for this society.
Dystopia is a made up futuristic society that is unpleasant to most citizens living there. The society can be a place where rulers dehumanize the citizens living there. A dystopia can be a place that is filled with disaster or it can be a place where everything is in such proper order that it becomes too perfect. A utopia is a picture perfect place. A utopia can become a dystopia in the blink of an eye.
There is no doubt the society in The Giver contrasts our own, however the similarities between the two might be startling. The dystopian environment in the Giver can be a humbling thought for how good we have it in our life. Following that trend, we are also forced to look at the horrifying similarities between these two societies. As we look at The Giver’s rules, family, and leadership we see the vast differences and also the shocking familiarities.
Anthem and The Giver are almost alike. In both the book and the movie, utopian societies are portrayed through idealistic systems and community framework. The Giver depicts a people of which past memory of human civilization and emotion does not exist. In addition, people living in this society can only view their surroundings in black and white. Jonas, the main character, is assigned as the Receiver of Memory.
The Giver, by Lois Lowry, depicts a dystopia that strips people of all their freedoms and humanity. On the surface, the Giver’s society is a perfect utopia, free from the problems that plague humanity today, but after looking more closely at the people’s lives, the dystopic nature of this society is evident. The Giver’s community and our society have many similarities and differences, although our societies are comparable in that they have similar goals, such as helping people and having perfect equality, the means to achieve these goals are very different and as a result, the freedoms, laws, and day-to-day lives of the people are vastly different. The freedoms in the Giver’s society and our society are very dissimilar.
To what extent can a perfect society be possible? In the novel The Giver the society was established to be a utopian world but, ended up becoming not so perfect after all with terrible things hiding underneath the surface. Modern day society is far from perfect; however, it does have some similarities with Jonas´ home along with many differences. In today's society we pride ourselves on having the freedom to choose our own lifestyle.
When presented with the decision of living in a utopic or dystopic society, one may lean towards the utopian civilization- thinking that a utopia is the definition of a the most perfect place to be. However, what people may not realize is that there are great lengths to achieve the type of paradise-like society, and after all is said and done, the utopian society is not actually what is said to be. In the novel The Giver by award winner Lois Lowry, the author explores the idea of one’s perfect world. She garnered information on what people would consider their ‘perfect utopia,’ with the knowledge that such thing can never be achievable without its drawbacks. Lois wrote and introduced the process and daily operations needed to be taken by communities-
People have always wondered what a difference and similarity a dystopian/utopian society would have with our modern day society. With the help of modern day society and the givers society we can figure out the differences between Modern day society and the Givers society. Modern day society and the society in the Giver have many differences including Rules, Family, And Figurehead/Leadership; however they also have a few similarities. In modern society the rules do not say that people can not ride a bike without a given age, people can take food from the restaurants as long as the people paid for the food, people have the right to be different from other people, people can choose who they want to marry, how many children they want, what job people want to have in the future, people have
Jonas lives in an overruling dystopian community. During the communities, annual Ceremony of the twelves, Jonas and his classmates await their assignment. Except when going through the assignments they skip Johnas. As he waits uncomfortably the chief elder finally returns to Johnas and assigns him as the Reciever. Everything Johnas has once known soon becomes forgotten as a man named the Giver teaches him about feelings and how overpowering they can be.
What if there were no rules in a dystopian community? We live in a world without the overstated rules, without order, without having to be impeccable, but we have freedom an individuality. “Dystopia” is defined as a fictional world where people live under a highly controlled totalitarian system, where individual identity is suppressed and families no longer exist. Rules and orders are negatively portrayed in dystopian societies and are acclaimed to take away the freedom, choice, and individuality. Henceforth, to inhibit the control within the community, the rules should be restricted.
PART TWO For Part Two of this assignment, I chose prompt #9, “Newsworthy” (3-5 pages) “Riots” A utopia is an imagined community or society that possesses highly desirable or nearly perfect qualities. In Lois Lowry’s 1993 John Newbery Medal winning novel, “The Giver,” the citizens feel no pain, they have no feelings. A dystopia is a utopia where things have gone wrong. If the Bible is to be believed, the “Garden of Eden” was our utopia.
Both of these aspects emphasise the dystopian theme that “citizens no longer have the power to choose” because a totalitarian government has taken over with a small group of people holding power over the rest of the society. The varying camera angles represent how the government is structured in a way where few have authority, while the Dutch tilt represents the fragility of the stability of the world of the “Giver”. These featured film techniques can be linked to a common idea of the genre, where not everything is as it seems. The idea of “appearance versus reality,” is demonstrated in how the government has designed routines for the citizens to follow. The world leaders do not provide any choices to their citizens because they believe that,
The Giver Writing Assignment Imagine living in a community like Jonas’, what would be thought of about the government? Is the government a dystopia or is it a utopia? This essay is going to be debate if Jonas’ community could be a dystopia and a utopia. It could also be both a dystopia and a utopia at the same time.
Imagine living in a perfect society. No pain, everyone is equal, and perfect laws that every person follows. Now imagine being exactly like every other person with all your daily choices being made by someone else for you. In the book The Giver by Lois Lowry, this is exactly how they are living. The author writes about how Jonas’ perfect society is not so perfect after all.
The Perfect Place The society Lowry depicts in The Giver is a utopian society; a perfect world as envisioned by its creators. It has removed fear, pain, famine, illness, conflict, and hatred, all things that most of people would like to eliminate in today’s society. In this utopian community, major problems are rare, only minor problems such as scraping your knee would happen. Even when this would happen there would be medications sent to them.
