been much debate of whether the famous Canadian Icon, Louis Riel is thought of as a hero or a traitor. As such, he was the leader of a Metis rebellion against the Canadian government; and founded the Canadian Province Manitoba. He also proceeded to murder a Canadian government representative, and largely contributed to improving the Metis Social Rights. We believe that Louis Riel deserves recognition for being one of Canada 's Greatest heroes. Louis Riel’s heroism can be represented through his foundation
Throughout the text, Louis Riel is portraying as a dedicated leader for the Metis. In the text, Riel thinks it was best for the Metis to capture Fort Garry because of its high loot, and the potential dangers of John Schultz possessing the loot. Riel decides to form a provisional government so that everybody’s opinion including the French and English will be valued. Eventually, he receives the position of president. He sees that there is a problem with the Metis’ rights. For this reason, Louis repeatedly sends
Who is Louis Riel? He was a Métis born in 1844. However most importantly, Riel was the leader of the Métis during their rebellions. He will forever be remembered for his role in the Red River and the Northwest Rebellion. Some may see him as a traitor for leading a rebellion on his own country. However, many others think of him as a hero for fighting for the rights of the Métis. This essay discusses some of the many reasons why Riel is in fact, a hero. Riel is a hero because society and the government
individual who was seen by many as a hero, a humanitarian, or a prophet. None the less, this was the fate of Louis Riel. Louis Riel was seen by many as a man of good intention, but by some he was seen as a villain, a lunatic, and a traitorous man. Regardless of the view one may hold, and regardless of the historical debate about the character of the late Louis Riel, one thing can be assured. Louis Riel made an everlasting impact on the view and treatment of minorities as a whole throughout modern and historical
Louis Riel was a Canadian politician, leader of the Métis nation, and a founder of the province of Manitoba. Due to his willingness to stand up for his rights and what he believed in, Riel was pinned as a hero for the Métis. On the other hand, Riel’s many accounts of treason lead many to believe he was a traitor to the Canadian Government. Taking into account how wrongly the Métis were treated by European immigrants, the acts of rebellion Louis Riel performed against the Canadian Government were
I, the Sir John Alexander Macdonald strongly believe that Louis Riel is guilty, for all he has done, and deserves to be hanged! I strongly believe this because he led a group of rebels that created their own provisional government that wanted to overtake the Canadian government, he was involved in assaulting and executing unarmed Canadian civilians, and when William McDougall, the governor that I appointed of Rupert’s Land and the North West Territories, had gone to Canada’s own land, he was stopped
Louis Riel, one of the Metis most trusted allies and leaders. He was a voice for the Metis, and led two Metis rebellions against the Canadian government. He wished to save and preserve the rights and way of life of the Metis. Although some feel that Riel was a traitor to the Canadian government, I take into consideration of his alliances with the Natives, and think that Louis Riel was a martyr. What is a martyr, anyway? A martyr is a person who is punished or murdered due to their own beliefs or
The nineteenth century saw the emergence of the Metis leader Louis Riel, one of, if not Canada’s most controversial and contentious public figures. Since the hanging of Riel for treason in 1885, his legacy and reputation has been under continuous scrutiny and invented and reinvented to suit the political, ideological and philosophical agendas of historians, Political Scientists, politicians, policy makers, ethnic groups and the majority of Canadian Citizens. The depictions and perceptions of this
Louis Riel, a leading figure in Canadian history, was renowned for his steadfast commitment to defending the rights and interests of the Métis people. His role in spearheading the Red River Rebellion and the North-West Rebellion, both of which aimed to safeguard Métis rights, led to a direct confrontation with the Canadian government. This confrontation culminated in Riel's trial and execution for treason in 1885. When one scrutinizes the conditions surrounding Riel's trial, it becomes clear that
Louis Riel; Hero Or Traitor Louis David Riel was a Metis man who was born in Saint Boniface, Winnipeg in 1844. Later on in his life Riel became a Canadian Politician and leader of the Metis people of the Canadian Prairies. At the end of the trial of Louis Riel, he became a founder of the province now known as Manitoba. Was Louis Riel a hero or a traitor? Louis Riel was a hero. On July 28, 1885 the trial of Louis Riel had started. Louis riel had risen up against the Canadian Government and spoke
On May 20, 1885, Louis Riel was hung by the order of John A Macdonald for high treason. He was arrested when he ordered a military resistance that became a military confederation called the North-west Rebellion. This was when Ottawa sent thousands of Combat soldiers on their new railway to fight against Louis Riel’s military resistance, he had later been arrested and convicted. Louis David Riel was born on October 22, 1844, in Red River colony, Rupert's Land, British North America. This is near
Louis Riel Essay Do you think Louis Riel is a hero or villain? I believe that Riel is a hero because he stood up for the rights of the Metis to the Canadian government during the Red River Settlement and the Northwest Rebellion. He was a great leader who would do anything for his people, even if he had to sacrifice himself. However, in the view of the government people think he’s the complete opposite. Louis Riel did go against the government and do many illegal things, but it was all for his people
Louis Riel (born October 22, 1844) was a Métis leader. He was born in the Red River settlement to a businessman/ political leader, Louis Riel Sr. Louis was a standout student, heading to Sulpician school, on a scholarship, in Montreal at the age of thirteen. He studied there and soon fell in love with Marie-Julie Guernon; they got engaged but the engagement was soon broken after her parents found out that he was a “half-breed”. With a broken heart, and new knowledge he headed back to the Red River
Louis Riel, Hero or Villain? For many years now, people have been raising the question of Louis Riel. Some see him as the Father of Confederation, while others see him as a cult villain. He is without doubt a cult villain. Reading and researching through many primary sources of data, it can be very easily proven how much of a threat Riel was to Canada. When Canada had bought the Red River, settlers started moving in. However, those who had already live there, the Metis, wanted to keep their rights
Canadian forces and the members of the resistance. Riel and his men captured and arrested 48 of the government’s men in Fort Garry and sentenced “one particularly defiant man named Thomas Scott” (Smith, 1995) to death. According to Thomas (1982) the death of Scott was soon forgotten in the settlement, but in Ontario “the “murder” became a major issue”. He also wrote that it was Riel’s one great political blunder. Thomas (1982) specified that Riel promised to release all the other prisoners held at
1844-185 Louis David Riel, a Canadian figure, died at the age of 41 on Monday, November 16, 1885 due to his execution for treason in Regina, Saskatchewan. Born on October 22, 1844 to Louis Riel Sr. and Julie Lagimodiere in St. Boniface, Red River settlement. Being born in 1844, he was the eldest of his siblings, seven sisters and four brothers. Louis was constantly around the Metis people and growing up he never felt tied to one identity, he only felt mixed, which he had inherited from his father’s
Louis Riel once said, "We must cherish our inheritance. We must preserve our nationality for the youth of our future. The story should be written down to pass on". Louis was born on October 22, 1844 in the Red River settlement,Manitoba.His father,Sr. Louis Riel, a businessman and political leader in the Métis community, organized a large Métis resistance to the Hudson’s Bay Company fur-trading monopoly at the trial of Pierre-Guillaume Sayer in 1849. This likely influenced his son who was sent at
Louis Riel was considered a criminal and a traitor to Canada for over one hundred years, but really, his involvement in the development of Manitoba and the fight for Métis rights makes him a true hero in the eyes of many Canadians. He spent ten years in Montreal becoming a priest, but his heart was where he was born in 1844: Red River, where Manitoba is now. Shortly after Confederation, this area, and the Métis people who lived there were facing a dramatic change of lifestyle as more settlers moved
In 1884, the Métis people sought help from Louis Riel to help them grab the attention of the Canadian government who had been ignoring their complaints and petitions, and treating them as lower class citizens. They needed Riel to be the effective voice to speak on their behalf in order to obtain rights to elections and such so that their land was not threatened by immigrants from the east due to past experiences. After attempting to fight the Battle of Batoche, he was accused of high treason, and
Louis Riel: Hero or Traitor? Louis Riel was born in Saint-Boniface in the Red River Settlement on October 22nd in 1844. He was the leader of the Aboriginal tribe the Métis and led two popular governments of theirs. Louis was also the founder of what is known as Manitoba today. In his early life he was proving himself to be quite smart, by the age of thirteen he was already sent off to college. Unfortunately just a couple mere months before his last exams of his college career his father had passed