ipl-logo

Compare And Contrast The American Revolution And Inglis

713 Words3 Pages

Throughout history, there is a vast majority of opinions solely on one event in history but in order for someone to grasp an idea of something, such as the American Revolution, one has to look and evaluate the different ideas on a historical event. In the case of the American Revolution authors Charles Inglis, Thomas Paine, Howard Zinn, and speaker Patrick Henry had to compare and contrasting ideas. Inglis and Zinn identified the revolution as something that was unnecessary as there are more advantages in staying with Britain and as a result of the revolution there are more problems, while Paine and Henry suggested that the revolution is needed due to the subordination and inflicted pain to the colonists, and King George III not being able …show more content…

Inglis in his writing lists several reasons for colonists to stay with Britain. Many of the reasons state that trade of the colonies will be guaranteed with the protection of “the greatest naval power in the world”, agriculture and economy would be restored to great health, and a “reconciliation” with Britain will be able to restore tranquillity (Inglis). Inglis is implying that the colonists are going in the wrong direction if there are way more reasonable advantages in staying with Britain. Framing the whole revolt as something unnecessary in general. Zinn - in accordance with Inglis - uses his own insight and others to argue that there has been a conflict in society by cause of the revolution (Zinn 77-87). Zinn states, “The Continental Congress, which governed the colonies through the war, was dominated by rich men”, a result of the revolution that created tensions as he explains, but also problems that were solely on the poorer colonists (Zinn 81). Many problems included: soldiers [usually poor] who sacrificed their life for freedom and not getting paid (Zinn 81). Inglis and Zinn both agree that it was probably bested that the colonists should have stayed with …show more content…

Paine is against America having a connection with Britain and a single person having power. As Paine expresses, King George III is not and should not be able to be in power of the colonists because mankind is created to be equal and therefore kings should be “disapproved by nature” (Paine 217). Not only does Paine express his anger at the topic of a ruler for all, he also voices that America is connected to whatever Britain does and whatever problems Britain has: implying that America has no say what so ever under Britain (Paine 218). Paine is suggesting that Britain is not only hurting but also is subordinating America and its colonies, so a declaration of independence is in need. Henry, in agreement to Paine, also expresses that the King has reached a point where he does not care of the colonists and treats them as inferior, Henry is hinting at the point that Britain is just hurting the colonists (Henry). Not only does he express this he concludes with this quote: “Why stand we here idle?... Give me liberty or give me death” (Henry). Paine and Henry and Paine both suggest that a revolution should commence due to the pain inflicted and subordination inflicted. Why should the colonists not

Show More
Related

Analysis Of Howard Zinn's Fourth Chapter Summary Is Tyranny

417 Words | 2 Pages

In his fourth chapter titled "Tyranny is Tyranny," of his book A People's History of the United States, author Howard Zinn presents a ground breaking interpretation of motives for the American Revolutionary War. Zinn asserts that the leaders of our nation found, by creating their own nation, "they could take over land, profits and political power" held by the British Empire. What's more, the founding fathers could subdue rebellions in their own land and create "popular support for the rule of a new, privileged leadership." In other words, though the history books have always taught that, through the revolution, America overthrew the tyranny of the British privileged ruling class, Zinn is asserting America really only created its own new privileged class.

Read More

Thomas Paine: The Crisis

82 Words | 1 Pages

Thomas Paine wrote a series of articles known collectively as "The Crisis" to support his argument for independence from England during the Revolutionary War. Thomas Paine 's reasoning for writing this collection of articles is rather sound. The call to arms in this document calls “tens of thousands” to arms to battle Great Britain and their unfair rule over their country. Paine was justified in his writing, the unfair rule of the British government did need to be “called out” sort of speak.

Read More

How Does Thomas Paine Use Rhetoric In The Crisis Number 1

1307 Words | 6 Pages

Tories, just like the Patriots, were also outspoken in their beliefs and existed among the colonists. Here, Paine urges the colonists to define what a Tory truly is, which sets up for Paine to later define them as cowards. By asking this question, he pushes the mindset that Tories are selfish, spiritless people, and his viewpoint incites anger and detestment in other colonists against these “traitors”. In reference the British King and his armies, Paine questions, “... But if a thief breaks into my house, burns and destroys my property, and kills or threatens to kill me, or those that are in it, and to ‘bind me in all cases whatsoever,’ to his absolute will, am I to suffer it?”

Read More

Thomas Paine Against Great Britain

133 Words | 1 Pages

Thomas Paine had many reasons for America 's need to separate from the British Empire, beginning with the fact that Great Britain was taking advantage of America by using America only as a source of new commerce or a new investment, instead of truly caring for the colonies. In addition to taking advantage of America, another reason Paine said to fight Great Britain was because, although they protected America, Great Britain was only fighting for their own investment in the colonies, instead of for the people within the colonies. The colonies were also persuaded by Thomas Paine in "Common Sense" to separate themselves from Great Britain because the only reason the colonies were connected was through the mother country (England), and the colonies

Read More

Compare And Contrast Patrick Henry And Thomas Paine

718 Words | 3 Pages

The act of violence is not always what wins a revolution. The men of the revolution saw the power in words and used this to their advantage. Both Patrick Henry and Thomas Paine created monumental pieces of history which helped to advance the revolution by using nothing more than their words. By examining Patrick Henry and Thomas Paine's accounts of oppression from the king, the necessity of the revolution is clearly seen through the spiritual take by Paine and the logical take by Henry; both methods led to the conclusion that the rebellion was needed. Although two very different methods, they both are very similar when looking at their reasonings.

Read More

Ivring Kristol's Reevaluation Of The American Revolution

365 Words | 2 Pages

Ivring Kristol focuses on revolutionaries for example George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, and Thomas Paine as he proves wrong many present day Americans who have misconceptions about the American Revolution. Kristol 's primary focus is on reexamining the American Revolution. Kristol blames us for the stereotypes that we hold today. Kristol says "Incomprehensible to us is the idea that George Washington was the central figure in a real, honest-to-God revolution.”

Read More

Common Sense Vs. Plain Truth By Thomas Paine And James Chalmers

1069 Words | 5 Pages

In his discussion, Paine argues out that apart from gaining international respect, America would advance its own security and commerce by being able to trade with other partners in Europe and the globe. He mentions that all Europe should benefit from America’s goods not only Britain. He explains that by saying British are not the only people who settled the continent but different parts of Europe, so British should not be the only European country to benefit from the colonies. As a result of all the reasons above, the colonies needed no reason to continue submitting to Britain authority and should gain their

Read More

Words Influenced Others In Thomas Paine's 'American Crisis'

505 Words | 3 Pages

If there should be loss of life and turmoil, any parent would want it to be during their lives so that their child could have a better life. This hit a soft spot in the revolutionists because it is a parent’s natural instinct to protect their offspring, and any good guardian wants their child to have a better life than they had. The American Crisis influenced the colonists because though their lives would be affected by the revolution, the outcome would be a better life for their families and future

Read More

To What Extent Was America Justified In Waging War

625 Words | 3 Pages

The first reason the revolution is justified is that the colonists had no representatives in parliament. Parliament was a branch of the British monarchy that created laws and acts for the colonies and the U.K. The problem was, not one representative in parliament was from the colonies and knew the conditions there. Parliament was absolutely clueless. Most of this,of course, was the King’s doing.

Read More

How Did Political Ideas Influence The Declaration Of Independence

615 Words | 3 Pages

To colonists who feared the economic consequences of severing ties with britain, Paine argued that america could handle its own affairs and avoid the dangers of european wars if freed from british control. While its politics were influenced by enlightenment ideas about the importance of liberty, paine was among the first to articulate the need for america to distance itself from europe. This theme would grow increasingly more significant in american foreign

Read More

American Revolution Dbq Essay

868 Words | 4 Pages

The call to revolution is often romanticized to show a needy people rising up against their oppressors. The entire population tends to advocate for the change. Unfortunately, reality is often the opposite. Even though a minority of colonists, patriots, demanded revolution the war and Revolution, itself, had a huge impact on the political, social, and economic aspects of life in the American colonies from 1775 to 1800. Politically, the time after Revolution, 1777 – 1800, was full of tension.

Read More

Paine's Argument For American Independence

887 Words | 4 Pages

In summarization, he says reconciliation will bring ruin because of the British desire to advance at the expense of America and Great Britain’s inability to protect or govern the colonies due to its distance from the continent (page 36-40). By providing numerous logical responses to arguments opposing the formation of America into its own state, Paine assures worries common among colonists, gaining even more advocates for American

Read More

Should The Patriots Want To Change?

699 Words | 3 Pages

“It is foolish to be always running three or four thousand miles with a tale or petition. Waiting four or five months for an answer, which when obtained requires five or six more to explain it” Paine is frustrated by a time lag to ask for king and parliament to address their opinions. So if the colonists formed their own independent country, they would not have to wait for a response from their goverment. The patriots love local control.

Read More

Excerpts Of Thomas Paine's 'Common Sense'

260 Words | 2 Pages

Throughout the excerpts of Thomas Paine’s “Common Sense” he makes many compelling points on why America during that time was in the perfect position for independence. In the first paragraph Paine writes about how the economy of the colonies could thrive if they were not under the rule of the Britain. He makes points on how if America was not limited in trade by Britain and the colonies had its own legislative branch the economy would be a lot stronger. In the second paragraph Thomas Paine talks about how in the past if the colonies tried to rebel their military would not have been ready but during the time “Common Sense” was written the American military was ready. Another factor in why Paine supported Colonist independence was because it was

Read More

How Did Thomas Paine Give Me Liberty Or Give Rise To Independence

766 Words | 4 Pages

“It is wholly owing to the Constitution of the people, and not to the constitution of the government that the crown is not as oppressive in England as in Turkey.” We should give power to someone who is fair and not self-centered. Paine stated “from the errors of other nations, let us learn wisdom” to advise us to avoid repeating the past in the future from learning about bad past experiences. Paine argued for American’s separation from England by comparing the Kings that Great Britain has had to what a government should be

Read More

More about Compare And Contrast The American Revolution And Inglis

Open Document