ipl-logo

Analysis Of Make College Free For All

2021 Words9 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The-pros-and-cons-of-free-college

Jennifer Serrano
Dr. Salome
English 1302
June 17, 2023
Analyzing two sources with respect to a free college education for all
The topic of free college is an argument that has grown to become popular within the last decade. Every day future college students and parents are faced with the overwhelming pressures of being financially capable of going to college. The purpose of this paper is to analyze two opposing opinions on free college education. As is most known, there are always two sides to an argument, and this analysis will break down two articles using the Toulmin Model to determine each of the article’s claims, warrants for those claims, and their evidence. The first article being analyzed was published by the Washington Post. The …show more content…

Throughout this article, Sanders mentions the many financial differences that people are now facing as opposed to what they used to face back in the 1950s. Taking a rather opposite approach is Bob Luebke, in his article “Why Free College Is A Bad Idea” in which he expresses many concerns and arguments for the people who are in favor of free college. Luebke mentions that the idea of having a free college education sounds great, especially to those with low income and students who really want to attend college, but the truth is quite the opposite. For the analysis of both articles, the Toulmin Model will be used to break down arguments down to their claims in which we will get data and backing for each claim. The Toulmin model is a structure for analyzing arguments and breaking them down into 6 parts. The sections being inspected include claims, which are the statements that are argued throughout the paper. Data, which is the evidence for each claim, and lastly, backing to support the claims and data …show more content…

The first contrast between the articles is in Luebke’s article in which he mentions that there is a maldistribution of students and their careers. He claims that “The sad fact is that for every student in business, engineering, or a pre-professional program, there are others in less marketable areas” (Luebke, 1). Luebke states that very few people are in educational programs that will actually bring practical benefits to the country. As opposed to the other students who are majoring in field’s that will be difficult to become employed in. To back Luebke’s claim, he argues that “areas such as art history, psychology, and history keep generating graduates who have difficulty finding gainful employment” (Leubke, 1). He lets readers know that money is not being used appropriately by giving people in those fields free tuition, as opposed to people in business or engineering programs who have an opportunity at seeking employment. On the other hand, Sanders mentions countries in which free education is granted to everyone and claims that “free college is still a priority in many parts of the world including Finland, Denmark, Germany, Ireland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden, and Mexico” (Sanders, 3). Through his article, he does not disparage or praise any field of higher education, rather, he sees them all as equal. He supports the belief that everyone should get a free education no matter

Show More
Related
730 Words | 3 Pages

He structures his essay to make a valid argument. The formation of his essay is a preview of what will be discussed in detail. He begins his argument from an economic perspective, pointing out that the national Bureau of Labor Statistics data is incorrect because it under-predict demand for college educations. He shows his audience that the BLS predictions do not come close to what actually happened in the economy. For an example, the Bureau undercounted the number of postsecondary educated workers by about 17 million in the year of 2006.

Read More
963 Words | 4 Pages

Since his argument would be weak without an outside source, Selingo gathers information from, “Tony Carnevale, director of Georgetown University’s Center on Education and the Workforce. With this new ethos, Selingo’s credibility skyrockets, enhancing his overall argument. After introducing the table, Selingo proves that it’s trustworthy by citing it. Underneath the table are the sources such as, “National Postsecondary Student Aid Review; National Center for Education Statistics [and] Post Secondary Financing Strategies,” (Selingo Table). This emphasizes his credibility and persuasiveness to his audiences since he cites such prestigious sources.

Read More
1309 Words | 6 Pages

Beginning with a short summary of Obama’s proposal, Coulter quickly attacks every morsel of the idea. Coulter assumes a college degree is essentially worthless, and according to her, making it free will only devalue it more. She reports that most graduates are working entry level jobs that don’t even require a degree. Coulter’s stance on “the state of higher education” is the “product has… gotten much, much worse.” College students are being “brainwashed” into becoming Democrats, she claims.

Read More
374 Words | 2 Pages

A Rhetorical Analysis of “Should Everyone Go to College?” Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill’s “Should Everyone Go to College” is broadly argued across the idea that college isn’t the smartest investment for everyone. College can’t just be a pick, choose, then go there sort of deal, it is something that needs to be thought about and carefully observed. There are many factors that go into choosing a college, such as “what’s better, an associates or a bachelor’s” or “how much will college cost?” However, those are just a few underlying factors in considering college.

Read More
1589 Words | 7 Pages

When discussing the opportunity cost of college, evidence shows that “[u]sing average earnings for 18- and 19-year-olds and 20- and 21-year-olds with high school degrees (including those working part-time or not at all), Michael Greenstone and Adam Loony of Brookings’ Hamilton Project calculate an opportunity cost of $54,000 for a four-year degree” (par. 4). The statistics of opportunity cost of college displays an effective example of a strong type of supporting evidence since we are given the authors of the study, the project name, and also the statistics were presented clearly and effectively with the appropriate evidence for this article. The evidence also effectively tie in with the main idea of paragraph 4 where Owen and Sawhill were discussing other factors to consider when figuring out if the cost of college will negatively impact the student and be a disservice when choosing to attend college. Furthermore, when discussing the non-monetary benefits of schooling, “[r]esearch suggests that additional education improves overall well-being by affecting things like job satisfaction, health, marriage,... and social interaction” (par. 4). The details of non-monetary benefits presents an example of weak supporting evidence since the reader is not informed with various

Read More
991 Words | 4 Pages

They argue that while college is a valuable investment for many students, it is not the right choice for everyone. They point out that the cost of attending college has skyrocketed, and many students graduate with large amounts of debt, which may not be worth the investment for some students. Additionally, there are many good-paying jobs available that do not require a college degree, and students who pursue vocational training or apprenticeships may be able to earn just as much money as college graduates. The authors also argue that society has placed too much emphasis on college degrees and not enough on other forms of education, which can lead to a shortage of skilled workers in trades and other professions. Ultimately, they argue that the decision to attend college should be based on a student's individual goals and circumstances, and that other forms of education should be valued just as highly as college

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

Recently, many have begun to attack and degrade higher education in the United States. In the book How College Works, authors Daniel Chambliss and Christopher Takacs claim, “As state support has eroded, and as more students attend college in an increasingly desperate attempt to find viable jobs, the price to students of attending an institution of higher education has gone up, especially at more selective institutions” (172). So is college even worth it? Caroline Bird’s excerpt from her book Case Against College “Where College Fails Us” is an adequately written article that agrees with those who question whether college is a good investment. Bird argues that although some students would benefit from college and succeed, many fall short, wasting

Read More
133 Words | 1 Pages

Through the use of statistics and contrasting features, Keith Ellison argues that college tuition should be free and accessible to all. Logically, Ellison utilizes statistics to convince the audience by eliminating the student loan debt would significantly help many low-income graduates. Along with statistics, Ellison presents contrasting features to persuade the audience that building a truly affordable higher education system is an investment that would pay off economically. In contrast to education, the nation spends billions of dollars on the gas and oil industry. Ellison argues the money should be going towards education, so we can afford to pay for higher public education.

Read More
502 Words | 3 Pages

In the editorial "Should College Be Free?" Mikaela Mosley argues that the cost of public education is too expensive for working families and that student loan debt in the United States has become a major problem. The article suggests that making college free could allow more students to attend college and contribute to a vibrant economy without the burden of student debt. As an individual who has always believed in the importance of education, I found myself in agreement with many of the points presented in the piece. However, as I delved deeper into the argument, I found myself playing the doubting game.

Read More
1318 Words | 6 Pages

Jada Shaw Ms. Roth English 102.240 03/31/2023 Rhetorical Analysis Essay While the cost of college is expensive, you could earn more than individuals with only a high school diploma because individuals who earned a four-year degree earned about 43 percent more than those only with a high school diploma, and you could pay off college debt within a few years. In the article, “Is It Still Worth Going to College”, Mary C. Daly and Leila Bengali explain that college may not be worth it because it can be very expensive. Most people want to go to college but they just can’t financially afford it, not everyone can get approved for financial aid, grants, loans, or scholarships. Other people like myself have to pay out of pocket because according

Read More
968 Words | 4 Pages

For those who have graduated from high school and will continue with their higher education, many if not all of these students will have to pay out of pocket for college. Most of students think that if they graduate from college or a four-year university they will have a chance to work in the professional field rather than work for minimum wage. It is an opportunity for anyone, particularly those who have low wages, to earn a degree and make more money. In the article “Expanding Community College Access” from The New York Times, President Obama states that tuition for community college should be free, because the American workforce is not educated enough for the global and national workplace. The presiding evidence and statements from experts

Read More
1029 Words | 5 Pages

During a press conference in Washington D.C., democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders proposed six action steps to make education tuition and education debt free with the purpose to increase the affordability of higher education and help students graduate from college without a debt burden. However, as favorable as Sanders’s plan sounds, current debates prove it to be double-faceted. On the positive end of a spectrum, Sanders’s notion will create an influx in quality human capital by lifting the burden of expensive tuition and high loan interest rates, thus allowing more students to attend college, which in the long run will benefit the economy. On the other end, the means of revenue (the Wall Street Speculation Tax) needed for the

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

Education is widely regarded as a key factor in the economic and social development of a country. With the extremely rapid development of the society, in order to enhance their competitiveness, increasing young people choose to accept higher education. Yet, there are different attitudes about whether students should pay or not. Some people regard education as a basic right, which should therefore be provided free, while others think the individual student should have to shoulder some of the costs of his or her education. According to Matt Bruenig’s Dissent article “The Case Against Free College: Free college is paid for by the working class people who don 't attend”, Bruenig against the free college because it seems more fair and benefit to

Read More
1314 Words | 6 Pages

Vilorio (12) contends that the youths need to understand the essence of hard work and working their way up a college degree. A free college education will not only bring the quality of higher education down, but it will also strain the taxpayer's resources. In the end, free education will negatively impact the economy. This essay opposes free college education due to its adverse effects on the government, citizens, task force and the

Read More
1759 Words | 8 Pages

Did you know that Forty-one percent of four-year college students did not graduate within six years? College students around the country are in insane amount of debts and have no way to get rid of it and that’s a reason many do not graduate. Due to the rise in costs to attend college there has been discussions about free education, but how the debt could have been minimized and the effects on economy have not been brought up. College education should not be offered for free to all students because of the missed opportunities and unintended costs of free education are very expensive. Students don’t take advantage of the opportunities they are provided in high school, like dual-enrollment, that could save them time and money in college.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Make College Free For All

Related Topics

Open Document