ipl-logo

Analysis Of Zachary Shemtob's Executions Should Be Televised

1125 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: How violent media may be influencing violent crime rates today

Imagine, your children are flipping through the channels and they come to find a prisoner being displayed ready to be executed. They have just witnessed a person's life being taken away. Zachary Shemtob teaches Criminal Justice at Central Connecticut State University; David Lat is a former federal prosecutor. Together, they worked on an essay and published it in the New York Times in 2011. The essay is an analysis of whether, "Executions Should be Televised." Shemtob and Lat strongly agree that executions in the United States ought to be made public. Also, they argued that reading about an execution and watching an execution has a big difference. Also, public executions declare a message to the audience. I disagree with Zachary Shemtob and …show more content…

Being numbed to violence can be very dangerous as many children will find violence a normal thing to do. In this case, it will make killing seem normal. According to Douglas A. Berman, a law professor, "[I] fear that people might come to equate human executions with putting pets to sleep" (63). Rather than fearing death or execution, killing will feel like blinking your eyes or breathing in air. I fully agree with Berman as bringing visibility to executions will have people from all ages view the death penalty. As a new generation of innocent children turn on the television, and accidently flip to a random channel to find someone put to death, they may be feared for a while. Eventually, they watch it countless amount of times until it becomes regular to them. What …show more content…

"There is a dramatic difference between reading or hearing of such an event and observing it through image and sound" (Shemtob and Lat 62). There is no reason for us to care about criminal's privacy as they have committed an immoral act. If the criminal is truly guilty, they should lose their rights to privacy and shouldn’t be protected by the government. Also, they believe once capital punishment has been spread throughout the media, people see that crime has real consequences and generations of people may be less likely to participate in criminal activity. Making it viewable for everyone will greatly cut down on numbers of violent crimes, which will eventually create a world with no crime and execution free. According to Richer C. Dieter, an Executive Director of the Death Penalty Information Center in Washington, DC, executions in public gave an impactful message to the society. "Hangings were a public warning, intended to impress the local community with the consequences of crime" (798). I totally disagree with these statements as everyone's privacy should be protected and the warning towards the public only adds unnecessary fears. Every people in the states have the rights to have their privacy protected and need to gain the individual's explicit consent before releasing information about the criminals. Most importantly we need to

Show More
Related
230 Words | 1 Pages

Execution is the act of carrying out of a sentence of death on a condemned person. This is carried out either by lethal injection or electrocution. Execution despite its barbaric nature has survived in many legal system and will continue to because it: reinforces a state of security of the general public, detters other individuals from committing such crimes, and enforces the concept of cause and effect within the legal system. In the text “The Penalty of Death” H.L. Mencken discusses not only why he supports executions, but also the ripple effects this action has on a society. While in a text entitled “Death Penalty,” Anna Quindlen discusses her objections to execution, because, as she states:”it consists of stooping to the level of the

Read More
1434 Words | 6 Pages

Oshinsky did a remarkable job explaining the history of the death penalty in a clear and concise way. While the text was fairly short, he effectively provided his readers with well documented and relevant information on how controversial the death penalty has been throughout the past few centuries. He undertook an exceptionally important issue that many Americans do not know much about, or may have conflicting feelings

Read More
1411 Words | 6 Pages

There are strong advocates on both sides of the topic. A Santa Clara University study suggests, “Capital punishment is often defended on the grounds that society has a moral obligation to protect the safety and welfare of its citizens”(Andre). Still others argue that the death penalty is a cruel punishment and should be abolished. This topic should be addressed in schools as a way to open up all perspectives of students on capital punishment and encourage healthy

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

Public executions were used to scare people so they wouldn’t violate the law. Ted Bundy, American serial killer, rapist, and kidnapper was one of several people executed for his murders/crimes in the late 1970’s although, humans weren’t the only ones electrocuted. In 1903 Thomas Edison executed an elephant in front of 1,500 and videotaped it. The elephant was electrocuted at Luna Park Zoo on Coney Island in New York. People that are faced with the death penalty prefer the method of lethal injection rather other methods such a the gas chamber, electrocution, hanging, and even Crucifixion which is still used in Sudan as a form of the death penalty.

Read More
474 Words | 2 Pages

David B. Muhlhausen wrote an article “How the death penalty saves lives,” With a heading of “Capital punishment curbs criminal behavior and promotes a safer country.” Muhlhausen talks about a man named Earl Ringo Jr, his purpose was to bring the question ‘How does the death penalty saves lives,’ into people's minds. The date of this article is Sept. 29, 2014, Muhlhausen works for US New and World Report. Muhlhausen informs ages 10 and up in this article because death penalty might be a little too harsh for little kids who still do not even know what death is yet. Therefor, Muhlhausen also states examples of how the death penalty can save lives.

Read More
615 Words | 3 Pages

Should society have the right to view any execution at anytime? In the essay “Executions Should Be Televised” written by Zachary Shemtob and David Lat respectfully claim executions need to be publicly released to all U.S citizens. By using experts in law to give their opinion on the topic try to defend the reasons for their argument. The authors do not provide enough information about the opposition to counter argue an effective debate. Instead, killing criminals on live television will be as humiliating and emotional as putting a pet to sleep.

Read More
2122 Words | 9 Pages

An Ethical Critique of the Texas Death Row Appeals Process Rachel St. Pe’ CJ412-Criminal Justice Ethics Texas A&M University-Central Texas Abstract Although the methods of execution in Texas have evolved throughout time to more humane techniques, an increase in the cost of living of prisoners and the time between conviction and execution has resulted. By shortening the appeals the process, the overall funding and labor to house death row inmates will be decreased and a the possibility of an 8th Amendment violation by keeping prisoners on death row for years and years will be diminished.   Introduction

Read More
1449 Words | 6 Pages

There will be some individuals who stand behind it, some who do not, and some who prefer other options like solitary confinement. Sentencing one to death out of fear of what they might be or what they could become is not a reason to end someone’s life. Those who are on death row have to spend days, months, or even years waiting; waiting to hear if might be released or if their execution date has been set. If an individual has committed such a barbaric crime, the court should not stoop to their level and commit murder. Outsiders, who have never stepped a foot in prison, do not know what it is like.

Read More
1041 Words | 5 Pages

Capital punishment is a highly debated issue, with questions surrounding its fairness and constitutionality under the Eighth Amendment due to the protections it provides and the

Read More
1122 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout the media lately, a majority of the reports are about government brutality, especially against people of minority groups, and convictions of murder cases. The death penalty is defined as punishment of execution, but the death penalty is more than a punishment, it is legalized killing. No matter where a person stands on the death penalty, one statement that people cannot make is that killing is always right. The death penalty is inhumane and should be abolished because it discriminates against human beings and oppresses the lives of the challenged, specifically those with mental illnesses. The government claims that everyone is equal, when in reality stereotypes and discrimination always are present.

Read More
743 Words | 3 Pages

Alex Williams Mrs. Jones AP American Literature February 19 Should Executions Be Televised? The Capital Punishment, (which is the execution of defendants in the court of law) has been in debate for some time. My debate involves whether or not the Capital Punishment should be televised to the public via Television and or Web. Since the time of Greeks, executions have been a public event, but they were solemn events, not frenzies that TV, movies, and video games portray. That solemn reaction to public executions shows that the public wouldn’t necessarily find any satisfaction in the death of prisoner but seeing the death of a person would add a shock factor in today’s society due to the closed door of the capital punishment from the American

Read More
591 Words | 3 Pages

Through out history, the carrying out of the death sentence was often accompanied by torture, and executions were most often made public so the public would be able to see. Many individuals see the death penalty as a huge problem in today’s society because it makes the world look barbaric and some say conducting these events make us no better than the criminal. Capital Punishment

Read More
605 Words | 3 Pages

Mr. Boss, In the best interest of our site and public at large, we should not air the execution live. My primary support to my argument is that there is no true journalistic purpose to airing this video. It is not about being morally sensitive to the subject, as we do not have as many restrictions that normal television would, but it is about being correct. The footage of the electric chair would not provide greater details the story of the execution, or help the audience understand the story better.

Read More
659 Words | 3 Pages

Although the death penalty may bring some closure to families of the victims and even the victims themselves it still should be abolished because the negatives outweigh the positives. People could be murdered by the state even if they are innocent. They are taking away any chance these people have at a normal life even though it's a life that they deserve and did nothing to have it taken away. 6. Conclusion

Read More
1609 Words | 7 Pages

Pros and Cons of the Death Penalty as a Form of Criminal Punishment Maya Johnson University of Bridgeport April 22, 2018 Abstract This essay details the pros and cons of the death penalty in the United States of America as a form of criminal punishment. It’s an issue that has continued to be a topic of discussion for many years in the criminal justice field, and still receives different opinions by many. As of November 2016, the death penalty is still allowed in 31 states, abolished in 19 states, and on hold in 4 states. The issues with the death penalty still remain and will be discussed in this research and the imperfections with the system can be fatal and must be addressed.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Zachary Shemtob's Executions Should Be Televised

Related Topics

Open Document