ipl-logo

Argument Against Desegregation In Schools

791 Words4 Pages

The question at hand goes deeper than desegregation. Desegregation was achieved thru a ruling by the Supreme Court. I feel the Supreme Court overstepped their legal power in doing so. Therefore, I have to take the position that desegregation should not have been mandated. The Supreme Court was established by the founding fathers for a very specific reason. It was formed to be a watch dog to the Constitution. While this may seem like a mote point to some since the integration of the schools has been a success, it is not. The highest court in the land must be careful at all times to keep itself out of the practice of dictation what the states must do. We go back now to States rights vs. Federal powers. The Supreme Court said in its …show more content…

(This is mentioned in the article, High Court Bans School Segregation, by Luther Huston, NY Times, May 17th, 1954). The 5th Amendment to the Constitution states, no person shall be denied life, liberty or property without due process of the law. Again, this Amendment to the Constitution had nothing to do with Desegregation. No one was denied life over this. You may try to make the argument that liberty was denied, because, by everyone’s admission, the schools were not equal. (This was mentioned in, High Court Bans School Segregation, by Luther Huston, NY Times, May 17th, 1954). So the States should have had the right to make the schools equal in every way. If the States were given that choice, and had complied with that court order, would Desegregation have been ordered by the Supreme Court? Again I will say, as I have thru this essay, that it isn’t the end result that is a problem. Rather it is the High Court overstepping its powers. That is more concerning. The States rights must be protected. History has shown that over time the States of the Nation will come around and do the right thing. Although, sometimes it may be a very slow process. Most will say that the schools were not on equal playing fields. If you were black, you got inferior buildings and materials for schooling. If you are going to say separate but equal, then you must make them equal. They

Show More
Related

Lum V. Rice Case Study

1170 Words | 5 Pages

Notаbly absent from the opinion, as it was in Plessy, is any citаtion to a Supreme Court cаse that considered whether the prаctice of segregating schools was a violation of the Fourteenth Аmendment. It was an open question for the Court. The Court аdmitted that the precedent to which it cited involved discriminаtion between whites and blacks rаther thаn other rаces. However, the Court found no аppreciable difference here—"the decision is within the discretion of the state in regulating its public schools, and does not conflict with the Fourteenth Аmendment."

Read More

With All Deliberate Speed By Liva Baker: Article Analysis

469 Words | 2 Pages

Analyzing the case was divided into two parts, racial segregation in public school was constitutional or unconstitutional, and it was the business of Supreme Court or Congress. Another problem was about how and when desegregation should be applied. The defenders of South Carolina and Kansas, who were top legal officers, also argued that the equal protection of the Constitution did not need any integration because they had already begun to make their facilities equal to all the citizens. However, the attorneys from Brown`s side used the law and morality to support their

Read More

Cooper V. Board Of Education Case Study

1391 Words | 6 Pages

Picture a classroom today, more than likely the classroom is full of mixed races. African Americans and minority races are aloud to attend whatever school of their choosing. This however, was not how the education system was always set up. African Americans were not allowed to attend schools close by, or ones that offered the best education, but instead forced to attend colored schools, the only schools who welcomed their race. Even after multiple court cases aiming to install equal education, the idea was still not being enforced.

Read More

How Did Brown V Board Of Education Affect The Civil Rights Movement

830 Words | 4 Pages

Board of Education case, there were separate white and black schools. White schools are profusely safer and nicer than black schools. Black schools did not have as much funding or as great of an education. One family wanted their child to attend a white school due to it being closer to their house, but they were not allowed to. They brought the problem to the court and argued that it was a violation of the 14th Amendment, which said that “No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property.”

Read More

Brown Vs Board Of Education During The 1960's

231 Words | 1 Pages

During the 1960’s, African Americans were facing extreme segregation with the Jim Crow Laws enforcing “separate but not equal” schools. In defiance of this there was a case of Brown vs. the Board of Education which had a unanimous decision that separate but equal schools should no longer exist because of it being “unconstitutional.” With this victory, blacks are now to be able to conjoin with whites and get a better education, a “white education”. We, representing the NAACP, have reason to believe that the idea of desegregating education is a step forward. To have a better future, the Supreme Court ruled that the Board of Education of Topeka desegregate schools and if this isn’t enforced, other schools won’t comply with what the Supreme Court

Read More

The Supreme Court Case Of Brown Vs. Board Of Education Is Separate But Equal

519 Words | 3 Pages

“Separate but equal” is what education was said to be in Topeka, Kansas in 1954. It was separate, but was it really equal? In Topeka, black children were forced to walk twenty-one blocks to school when there was one right around the corner, but it was a school for white children only. This caused many issues among the community of Topeka and even caused a Supreme Court case between Brown vs. Board of Education of Topeka. Oliver Brown was the parent of a child at a black only school.

Read More

Social Issues In The Court Case Of Plessy V. Ferguson

1701 Words | 7 Pages

Schools began to separate off races with the primary issues becoming lack of truly “separate but equal” facilities. Many African American schools were literally falling apart during classes. The underfunding of these schools was incredible due to the lack of qualified teachers available in addition to the number of resources present. The issues that arise from the court case make some believe that there is a bigger issue at hand. Underneath it all, there is a human rights violation present within the context of the court’s ruling.

Read More

Essay On The 14th Amendment

707 Words | 3 Pages

In the case Brown Vs Board of Education the segregation of public schools was based on which race was allowed by states if the facilities were “equal.” Brown overturned that decision. Regardless of the “equality” of facilities, the Court ruled that separate is not unequal. Thus public school segregation based on race was found in violation of the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause. (1875)

Read More

Brown V Board Of Education Essay

420 Words | 2 Pages

Schools were originally separated as a result of the Plessy v. Ferguson ruling, which did not prohibit the Jim Crow South from the outright segregation of races. This Supreme Court ruling was later overturned in Brown v. Board of Education, which mandated that all schools be integrated immediately. Unfortunately, the entrenched, systematic oppression of the American South made school desegregation a long battle with many obstacles along the way. The state of Virginia adopted policies of “massive resistance” in response to the Brown v. Board of Education ruling.

Read More

Jim Crow Laws Dbq

725 Words | 3 Pages

Board of Education and various Civil Rights Acts passed by Congress. While it is true that the Equal Protection and Due Process Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment were violated by Jim Crow laws, some proponents of segregation argued that these laws were necessary to maintain order and protect the interests of both whites and blacks. They argued that separate facilities for different races were not inherently unequal and that the federal government had no right to interfere in state affairs. However, the Supreme Court's decisions in Brown v. Board of Education and subsequent cases recognized that separate facilities for different races were inherently unequal, as they perpetuated a system of segregation that denied African Americans equal access to resources and opportunities. The Court also held that the federal government had a duty to ensure that state laws did not violate individual rights protected by the Constitution.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Ruby Bridges

1193 Words | 5 Pages

In 1954, the U.S. Supreme Court ended the “separate but equal” education for African-American students. Although this was the law, the citizens of the South choose to ignore it. Less than 2% of southern schools had integrated. Even after the Little Rock Nine, Louisiana continued to keep blacks and whites separate in school.

Read More

Brown V Board Of Education Essay

783 Words | 4 Pages

The fight for desegregation has been a continuous fight for African Americans ever since their freedom in the 1860s. In the early 20th century, prejudice against African Americans skyrocketed with an early introduction to Jim Crow laws being forced upon African Americans forcing them to be segregated. After many years, the African American people were fed up and challenged one such Jim Crow law that forced schools to be segregated, and this court case was Brown v Board of Education. This case ruled that segregation at school was unconstitutional, and that schools shouldn’t be segregated. The Brown decision failed to desegregate and to improve the lives of African Americans by limiting education and social standards.

Read More

Civil Rights Movement: Brown Vs. Board Of Education

666 Words | 3 Pages

Brown vs. Board of Education concluded that to segregated students was a violation of the students’ 14th amendment right under the constitution. “As an extension of this argument, the Court maintained that

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Desegregation

1024 Words | 5 Pages

Therefore, in 1954, the Supreme Court held in Brown v. Board of Education that state-imposed racial segregation in public institutions violated the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution. While Brown has come to be regarded as a civil rights milestone, the court’s actions also had negative effects on the black people it intended to help.

Read More

Desegregation In Schools Essay

511 Words | 3 Pages

“More than 62 years after the Brown vs. Board, the nation is still wrestling with how to integrate our schools. Recent evidence indicates the problem has been worsening.” states Roda in Remedying School Segregation. Though we may not see it and it may not be as bad as it was in the past, it still is affecting our students today. No one is enforcing any rule to prevent this from happening.

Read More

More about Argument Against Desegregation In Schools

Related Topics

Open Document