ipl-logo

Argumentative Essay On Pope Urban 2

1451 Words6 Pages

1a) In a speech given in Western Europe in 1095 CE, Pope Urban II (r.1088 – 1099) called for all Christians regardless of social status to rise up and reclaim Jerusalem; arguing that “Christian blood … and Christian flesh, akin to the flesh of Christ”, meaning Christians living in the Byzantine empire and the east in general, were living under brutal conditions and facing oppression under the rule of Muslims and it was the job of other fellow believers of Christ to go and liberate them. I think that by comparing eastern Christians’ supposed mistreatment under the Turkish Muslims to that of what Jesus had to deal with from the Romans, Urban II is trying to enforce the point that as Jesus is described to be the son of God in the Bible, that therefore means that all his followers are also God’s children. Urban’s cries about the mistreatment of eastern Christians seems to be the biggest motivation for the Crusade among other reasons; Urban urged people, knights especially to stop fighting amongst themselves and to turn …show more content…

Albert, himself, never took part in the Crusades but the accounts that he wrote about were from individuals who were. So, it’s safe to say this story could be accurate because it’s a retelling of accounts of returning crusaders, but it could also be ‘biased’ in that Albert could’ve changed certain accounts from crusaders to fit a certain narrative. I think that there are some biases in Albert’s recounting of the crusaders’ tales. Though the actions of the crusaders pretty much line up with what Urban II called on them to do, I think the way that Christians were presented in these accounts, especially considering the height of anti-Semitism during this time, it would’ve been easy to make every crusader seem as if they were just a bunch of murdering barbarians, when that could’ve been a case of a few men and women but not children or the elderly who also took part on the

Show More
Related

Ap Euro Chapter 6 Summary

876 Words | 4 Pages

8.2.1- In 1097 an estimated 100,000 men enlisted in the first crusade, due to the fact that the pope promised salvation from purgatory if they joined the pilgrimage to Jerusalem to liberate the Holy Land. Peter the Hermit left, to the Holy Land, with 30,000 peasants, they terrorized Jews in Germany, and Christians in Bulgaria, when they got to Constantinople they were transported to Bosphorus and the Seljuk Turks defeated them, and the living were sold into slavery. After a five-week siege Jerusalem fell on July 15, 1099, the first crusade was a success, and because most crusaders were younger sons of nobles (Oldest gets the kingdom), they made four Crusader states based on the French Feudal model: the Country of Edessa, the Principality of Antioch, the Country of Tripoli, and the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem. 8.2.2-

Read More

Why Was Pope Urban II The Ideal Figure To Orchestrate The First Crusade?

683 Words | 3 Pages

He was a charismatic man who gave powerful speeches which moved people to sell their homes, leave their lands, and follow him across a continent. Pope Urban II marketed and advertised this crusade by promising salvation to those who came along. 4) What key event in 1095 sparked Urban II and the Western church to assemble an "elite force of knights" to reclaim the holy city of Jerusalem? In 1095, the Byzantine Emperor, Alexius I, who was also the leader of the Greek Orthodox Church at that time, sent a call for help to Pope Urban II.

Read More

Were The Crusades Dbq Essay

746 Words | 3 Pages

Pope Urban II called upon all Christians into this war, calling those who don’t believe in God Heathens and providing reason to take control of Jerusalem again. Also assuring that the soldiers of this war will get an admission into Heaven. (Document 1) Christians, no matter the empire or region were being united by the Crusades through their love of Christ. (Document 2) French and German crusaders invaded a Jewish City, killing people for sanctification of the Lord. (Document 5)

Read More

Summary Of Pope Urban II's Speech At Clermont

582 Words | 3 Pages

Pope Urban II’s speech at Clermont in 1095 was a call to crusade given outdoors to the nobles, commoners and church leaders of the Western European Christians (the Franks). The people were moved by this speech and it changed history, launching the first crusade to capture Jerusalem from the Muslim Turks. After hearing Pope Urban II’s speech, thousands of Western European Christians were moved to embark on the dangerous journey and fight in the crusade. I believe the main reasons they were moved and persuaded to fight was; 1) they felt it was their Christian duty, 2) Pope Urban promised them absolution for their sins and 3) they felt compelled to defend Christianity, their holy land and the Eastern Christians.

Read More

Pope Urban II's Speech On The First Crusades

1598 Words | 7 Pages

Pope Urban II’s speech stating he had a goal to capture the Holy Land that took place in the eleventh century, at the Council of Clermont meeting, started a series of crusades. The First Crusade, starting in 1095, was a Christian military expedition undertaken. Four armies of Crusaders formed from different Western European regions to start their fight for the Holy Land. They led crusaders to battle for Christian “hierarchy” due to the belief that Islamic values contradicted those of Christian. Pope Urban II’s speech sparked an uprising; and from what he led them to believe, they saw no issue in physically harming those who were not Christian.

Read More

What Is The Justness Of The First Crusade Unjust?

586 Words | 3 Pages

Regarding cannibalism, it must be noted the extreme circumstances the Crusaders faced during the siege of Ma'arra, where starvation led to desperate measures. While cannibalism is condemned universally, arguments are made that the dire situation forced by the prolonged siege could lessen the moral culpability of those involved. Concerning greed, while individual Crusaders may have been motivated by personal gain, the overarching goal of reclaiming Jerusalem for Christianity was driven primarily by religious fervor and territorial concerns. Regarding genocide, while atrocities were committed during the capture of Jerusalem, they were not organized or intended to eradicate an entire city. The intentions of the Crusade, as initially conceived by Pope Urban II, were noble, aiming to protect Christian pilgrims and aid the Byzantine Empire against the threat of the Turks.

Read More

Examples Of Excluding Usamah

688 Words | 3 Pages

Pope Urban II proposed the First Crusade as a war where Frankish peoples would “liberate the church of God at Jerusalem” (Lambert 62), while Robert the Monk justified it as a chance to “avenge” alleged misdeeds done by people from Jerusalem (64). Guibert of Nogent framed the Crusade as a chance to “restore some parts of the East to the faith” (67). Whereas Solomon Ben Simson, a victim of an attack on the Jews at Mainz, claims that the Crusa On the contrary, Usamah ibn Munqidh, who lived near Palestine almost a century after the First Crusade, does not claim the Muslims are chosen by God, nor does he advocate for violence against the former Crusaders who settled in his homeland. Excluding Usamah, each of these authors believe that their people are “people chosen and loved by God, distinguished from all other nations.”

Read More

Summary Of Pope Urban's Response To Alexius Comnenus

1749 Words | 7 Pages

Pope Urban had succeeded in shifting the anger of Christians from each other onto the Muslims and therefore united and encouraged them to take up the cross. His speech had been so powerful that according to Baldric of Dol Urban’s listeners’ had tears in their eyes and trembled at his words. However According to Asbridge The Muslims and the Catholics had been living amongst each other for centuries with little conflict and the Muslims had proven to be the more tolerant of other religious views this thus contradicts Urban’s portrayal of Muslims as “subhuman savages” and we can assume that Urban may have exaggerated and constructed what the Muslims in the East were doing as an act of desperation to create unity amongst Christians. Asbridge goes on to state that the crusades were “proactive rather than reactive, and the crusades were designed, first and foremost, to meet the needs of the papacy” suggesting that the threat Urban preached he felt from Muslims in the east was not actually present and was fabricated in order to establish authority of himself and the

Read More

Why Do People Join The Crusades

377 Words | 2 Pages

In 1095, Pope Urban the II received an urgent message from the Byzantine Emperor asking for aid in the west. He asked Urban to send the Christian people to claim back the land they believed was rightfully theirs from the Turks (Muslims). Pope Urban said that he had received a message from God to tell the Christians that they needed to go on a crusade. He told them

Read More

Human Rights Violations In The Crusades

1290 Words | 6 Pages

After the wars started, the Christians were violated back by the muslims. This topic “Christians' ' is relevant to the enduring issue “Human rights violations' ' because the Crusades were between Christians and Muslims and the Christians initiated the war first so it’s important to learn about their side’s perspective. “Urban II’s call for participation in an expedition to the East at the Councillor Clermont “God wills it!” to be the divinely inspired battlecry for the Crusaders.

Read More

Religious History: The Crusades

427 Words | 2 Pages

some of us know, the Crusades is not something that we enjoy discussing, but they were a big part of religious history. The Crusades were what the pope called “holy wars or expeditions,” that knights or people of their religion went on to gain control over holy land. Each Crusade had a social, economic, and/or political goal and aimed for one land at a time. The pope even exclaimed that if you went on a Crusade that you were assured a place in heaven. These Crusades, or “holy wars”, were driven by religious faith within varieties of religion like Muslims and Christians.

Read More

Christian View Of The Crusades Essay

1495 Words | 6 Pages

The Christian View vs. The Muslim View of the Crusades The crusades were a set of different military actions that were sanctioned by the Catholic Church and the papacy. Their intention was to recapture Holy Lands they believed were rightfully theirs from the Muslim people that had invaded it. As any attack on a large group of people would do, every major group was affected. The Christians had their own reasons and beliefs for going on these Crusades.

Read More

Perspectives Of The Crusades

1701 Words | 7 Pages

Pope Urban II, ”Speech at Council of Clermont 1095” is a document of multiple versions written by many different men who were present of the speech given by Pope Urban II. In the Robert the Monk version, Pope Urban II calls the Persians or the Muslims a foreign people and “a generation that not set their heart aright and whose spirit was not stedfast with God” (Urban, Robert,79). He gives a biased feeling towards them saying that they were filling the holy land of Jerusalem with their filth and wreaking havoc amongst the rest of the Christians living in Jerusalem. He believes also that the other cultures have reduced the city to a “pollution of paganism” (Urban, Baldric, 30). He convinces the Christian world that the Muslims are a “wicked race” and that they need to deliver the land from them and take it back.

Read More

The Crusades Research Paper

730 Words | 3 Pages

“Christians, hasten to help your brothers in the East, for they are being attacked. Arm for the rescue of Jerusalem under your captain Christ. Wear his cross as your badge. If you are killed your sins will be pardoned,” Pope Urban II. The Crusades was a series of wars in the 1000s to 1300s between European Christians and the Arabic Muslims over the Holy Lands, especially over the city of Jerusalem.

Read More

Benedict's Argument Essay

923 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout the Church 's long history, Her popes, and other popular religious figures, have written letters addressing issues that She, and or her people, are facing at the time. In 2009, Pope Benedict the 16th authored the encyclical (letter to the church), Caritas in Veritate. The title, and first three words of the encyclical, Caritas in Veritate, translates to "Charity in Truth." Pope Benedict writes the encyclical to tell his people about the importance of truth.

Read More

More about Argumentative Essay On Pope Urban 2

Related Topics

Open Document