ipl-logo

Behind Closed Door: A Comparative Analysis

1937 Words8 Pages

Behind Closed Door: A comparative Analysis of Global Domestic Violence

Introduction

I. Background Information
Domestic violence is a universal phenomenon, with millions of people as victims and perpetrators (. It destroys homes and families. Victimization occurs regardless of race, gender, religion, class, and sexual orientation. The term is often used to refer to violence that occurs between two people in an intimate relationship, but extends to violence against children and the elderly (Valiulis, 2014, p.124). I use the term domestic violence in this research refers to intimate partner violence. Globally, 35% of women have endured either physical or sexual abuse at the hands of their partner (World Health Organization, 2012, p.2). Unfortunately …show more content…

Sometimes the definition changes and becomes complicated as society begins to speak against the phenomenon. According to Johnson and Kelly (2004), ?the term domestic violence was adopted by women?s advocate to emphasize the risk to women within their own family and household (p. 476).? Two controversies surround the definition of domestic violence. The debate focuses on two areas: breadth (narrow v. broad) of definition and language. According to the narrow v. broad argument, the narrow definition focuses only on physical assault and sometimes sexual assault regardless of injury (Straus, 1999, p.37). The problem with this definition is that it exacerbates the problem of reporting because it disregards other forms of victimization. It also creates the hierarchy of abused based on seriousness. On the other hand, Straus notes that the broad definition tends to use a wider range of behaviours such as physical, sexual, verbal, economic and spiritual abuses and the resulting injuries (p. 37). The differences in definition are seen with how each country defines domestic …show more content…

Feminist scholars view the term domestic violence as gender neutral because it hides the fact that women and children are more often abused (Hammer & Itzin, 2000, p. 26). It is for this reason Hammer and Itzin noted, terms such as ?wife battering? or ?wife abuse? are preferred as it clearly identifies the victim and the perpetrator (p.26). This is a response to researchers that denies the gender asymmetry of domestic violence (P.26). I expect my research to support the gender asymmetry in domestic violence.

IV. Objective of the Research
Despite evidence showing that domestic violence occurs in every culture and country, leading literatures and evidence are largely from North America. Therefore, this research is necessary because other than the World Health Organization studies, there are little to no research on global multi-country analysis of domestic violence. This study has three aims.
The first goal is to examine the incidence of domestic violence in five countries.
The second objective is to scrutinize the legal framework around domestic violence in those countries.
The third objective is to explain the prevalence and the manifestation of domestic violence in those states.
The study aims to answer two central questions. Do different cultures have similar risk factors that lead to domestic violence? Is it possible to implement an efficient global response method to deal with domestic

Show More
Related
746 Words | 3 Pages

The National Crime Victimization Survey (2008), the rate of intimate partner violence declined from 1993 to 2008. Intimate partner violence affected about 1 in 320 households in 2005 (Klaus,

Read More
629 Words | 3 Pages

Nowadays domestic violence can happen to anyone, regardless of race, sexual orientation, income, gender, or ethnicity. Currently 3 million victims of physical assaults in the USA are men (Domestic Violence: Statistics & Facts, 2015). One in four women will be exposed to domestic violence during her lifetime (Domestic Violence: Statistics & Facts, 2015). Women between 20 years old to 24 years old are more likely to experience domestic violence (Domestic Violence: Statistics & Facts, 2015). Around 4 million women experience rape and physical assaults by their partners (Domestic Violence: Statistics & Facts, 2015).

Read More
1096 Words | 5 Pages

“Sexual, racial, gender violence and other forms of discrimination and violence in a culture cannot be eliminated without changing culture.” - Charlotte Bunch. Domestic abuse is a hostile dispute involving the use of violence among household or family members. It is a universal phenomenon that occurs in all races, ages, socioeconomic backgrounds, occupations, and genders (“What is Domestic Violence?”).

Read More
1297 Words | 6 Pages

Women are stripped of their ability to be able to live a life full of dignity and respect. A woman is assaulted or beaten every 9 seconds in the United States. There are more than 20,000 phone calls placed to domestic violence hotlines nationwide daily. Weapons are involved in 19% of domestic violence. Victims of domestic violence have higher suicidal and depression rates.

Read More
1282 Words | 6 Pages

Spousal Abuse People often turn away from issues that do not affect them, but this only lets the issue grow further until there is nothing left to do but deal with it. This could be why domestic violence has been taking place for centuries now. One issue that comes with domestic violence is spousal abuse- a problem that only seems to be getting worse, with ten million victims being beaten by an intimate partner each year (“Domestic Violence”). Although spousal abuse seems to be an ongoing issue in the United States, efforts are being made at both national and local levels to suppress the violence.

Read More
389 Words | 2 Pages

The organization WHO explained that intimate partner violence is behavior, includes physical aggression, sexual coercion, and psychological abuse and controlling behaviors, that causes physical, sexual or psychological harm by partner or ex-partner. Socially shared norms about gender relations and the acceptance of violence play important roles in determining if behavior is considered partner aggression. Through the ‘ecological framework’ by Heise in 1998, the interplay relationships of personal, situation and sociocultural factors of intimate partner violence are best explained. Heise tries to explain men’s violence against women by specifying risk factors at four levels which includes society, community, relationship and individual perpetrator.

Read More
668 Words | 3 Pages

Based off of this notion, both domestic violence and honor based violence are considered to be “gendered” issues (Standish, 2014). Society never envisions a woman hitting a man, and it never causes nearly as much outcry as when the roles are reversed. While we never imagine those situations to exist, there is truth in that men can also be victimized. With both honor based, as well as domestic violence, there is a minority, which includes underreported male victimization, with less than 1% reporting assaults to the NCVS (Muller, Desmarais, & Hamel, 2009). Part of the reasoning behind its underreporting is there is this fear of not being believed by society, because of an established patriarchal mindset (Muller et al., 2009; Reddy, 2008).

Read More
849 Words | 4 Pages

Intimate partner violence is a pending problem in many countries. The term refers to any violent act committed in an intimate relationship , thus making one of the partners an abuser and the other a victim. Unfortunately, there are some people who would blame the victims for the suffered violence. Scientists, who believe that the victim is always the cause of violence . Legislative arms of states, with the opinion that certain victims do not deserve to be included in the judicial system .

Read More
1232 Words | 5 Pages

Universally, domestic violence is referred to abusive behavior that is used by the intimate partner to control or power over the other intimate power. This can be in the forms of psychological, sexual, economic or emotional threats or actions that will influence your partner (Kindschi,2013).Domestic violence studies provides that psychopathology, which happens when in violent environment in child development can make the argument of domestic violence progress of being a generational legacy (Kindschi,2013).I chose to write about the Feminist Theory to explain why people commit domestic violence. It believes that the root causes of domestic violence is the outcome of living in a society that condones aggressive behavior by men, while women

Read More
951 Words | 4 Pages

I strongly believe that there should be tougher law enforcement to protect against domestic violence. No one should experience or be exposed to domestic violence for it; affects family life’ increase the crime rate in countries, and it affects one’s body and mind. Firstly, domestic violence causes a number of effects on family life, it affects how family members relate to one another because they will not feel the appropriate

Read More
1004 Words | 5 Pages

Intimate Partner Violence Fatalities: Prevention and Intervention Intimate partner violence is considered the most life-threatening and distressing family issue on a societal platform (Hamilton, Jaffe, & Campbell, 2013). The term family is utilized loosely as familial depictions vary, but to be certain the family has two partners that can be diversified roles and gender. By definition intimate partner violence illustrates a pattern of behaviors that are deliberate and intended to gain power and control over another person (Hamilton, Jaffe, & Campbell, 2013). Intimate partner violence does not need to be necessarily violent actions, but can be verbal threats, isolation, neglect, and disempowering tactics. The series of behaviors and violence can hastily escalate and the probability of homicide increases in those relationship dynamics.

Read More
1232 Words | 5 Pages

Domestic violence has attracted much attention of the sociologists in India since the decades of 1980s. Violence affects the lives of millions of women, worldwide, in all socio- economic and educational classes. It cuts across cultural and religious barriers, impending the right of women to participate fully in society. Domestic violence occurs in all cultures; people of all societies and classes. In earlier times, violence against women was a result of the prevalent atmosphere of ignorance and feudalism.

Read More
517 Words | 3 Pages

Jacquelyn C. Campbell defines intimate partner violence as “physical or sexual assault, or both,” of a spouse or sexually intimate partner. She speaks about how damaging this type of violence can be to women. Campbell provided information from past studies to explain why interventions and assessments should be increased in health-care settings to identify more of these situations. The author looked at information from the past decade and used only the surveys that were in English.

Read More
1580 Words | 7 Pages

Domestic violence is a representation of Judith Butler’s ‘Gender as a Performance’ theory because it embodies the structured power relation amongst genders and how this power influences both individuals involved. The act of domestic violence in heterosexual relationships adversely enforces the identities in which males and females categorize themselves into, based on their gender performance. Domestic violence can be defined as a series of behaviours which are used to assert control over a partner in an intimate relationship (McFeely, Lombard, Burman, Whiting, & McGowan, 2013). Domestic violence is a universally known phenomenon that impacts

Read More
1614 Words | 7 Pages

There also clearly exists a gender divergence in relation to emotional violence. Women are more likely to experience emotional violence, different types of emotional violence, and intimidation/control. A third of women stated they had been made fun of and one in five girls reported that partners often yelled at them and controlled their lives (Gill, 115). In all these categories men reported much lower repeated

Read More

More about Behind Closed Door: A Comparative Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document