ipl-logo

Controversial Political Arguments Against Imperialism In The United States

418 Words2 Pages

During the 1900’s, imperialism was a very controversial political issue in the United states. This national argument becom particularly strong when the Filipinos began to fight back against U.S occupation in their country. This sparked many conflicts between people that believed in imperialism and people who were against imperialism. Since many larger companies were taking over more land and expanding their power, some people believed the US should do the same thing so they would be able to compete with those growing countries. Although, imperialism would allow the U.S to become a more powerful nation, there were many reasons why imperialism was not a proper and legitimate policy for the United States. Imperialism was not proper because it contradicted the policies and morals built around the United States.

One of the main arguments against imperialism was that the U.S had no right to govern a nation without their consent. This theory was especially strong with religious people and religious political …show more content…

This group showed their opposition of imperialism in hopes of changing the government's mind. For example, in the Anti-Imperialist League’s platform it talks about how governing other nations goes against the United States promise of freedom. “We regret that it has become necessary in the Land of Washington and Lincoln to reaffirm that all men, of whatever race or color, are entitled to life, liberty and the pursuit of Happiness” (Document 7). In this quote it restates the promise that the United States made to all people. If the US governs other nations, without their consent, they are breaking their promise of a free life. As stated by Lincoln, “no man is good enough to govern another man without their consent” (Document 7). These examples show that imperialism goes against the policies, morales and promises of the United States of

Show More
Related
1237 Words | 5 Pages

The United States during the early twentieth-century was a heated debate. Constant changes including World War One, the Spanish-American War, and the idea that the United States would join the League of Nations would lead to major debates determining what role the United States should have taken during the constant changing world. This essay is here to go into detail about what the United States should have done during this time period as well as highlight some of the outcomes from a more progressive nation. Imperialism is defined as “The use of diplomatic or military force to extend a nation’s power and enhance its economic interests, often by acquiring territory or colonies and justifying the behavior with assumptions of racial superiority”

Read More
599 Words | 3 Pages

However, when looking through the viewpoint of the United States, imperialism was still beneficial. Imperialism was relentless, the strive to extend the country’s power

Read More
1764 Words | 8 Pages

American imperialism is economically, socially, and politically damaging to countries, as well as costly for America. Furthermore, it infringes upon national sovereignty and the right to self-governance. Historical cases have shown the detrimental repercussions America has repeatedly caused. The few cases of success should not undermine the calamitous effects American neo-imperialism has caused. The United States should cede its colonies and stop intervening in the affairs of other nations.

Read More
695 Words | 3 Pages

In Support of an American Empire Speech is a primary source concerning American imperialism in the Philippines. Within this essay the primary sources value will be based on the author’s credibility, the validity of the source, and the bias presented in the address from the author. The source is an address from Albert J. Beveridge called In Support of an American Empire Speech accessed through the ABC-CLIO databases. The source provides an excerpt from the address. .

Read More
598 Words | 3 Pages

Imperialism can impact a nation in many ways; some of the changes may be good for a nation, and some of them may be bad. However, why did Americans and Europeans seek to imperialize Africa and Asia? How was the age of Imperialism depicted? And how did Americans and Europeans react to their nation’s imperial actions? Americans and Europeans believed it was their “white man’s duty” to civilize and educate the people of Africa and Asia, who were beneath them and not as civilized as them.

Read More
949 Words | 4 Pages

These are the Anti-Imperialists. The first of which is William Graham Sumner. Sumner is greatly against imperialism for the one sole reason, because it would show that the U.S. and Spain are not that different. He says, “What is that (use of force to extort foreign countries) but the policy of Spain to her dependencies?” (Document 2), and explains that the U.S. should not be abusing other countries to benefit the economy like how Spain does to its colonies.

Read More
634 Words | 3 Pages

Imperialism was beneficial because it allowed nations to become unified, built a stronger military, along with cultural superiority. Like anything else, imperialism had its positives, but it also has its negatives. Imperialism unified nations and built a

Read More
746 Words | 3 Pages

The United States is an ever-evolving country that learns and benefits from not just its mistakes but right doings as well. Imperialism is the policy of extending the rule or authority of an empire or nation over foreign countries, or of acquiring and holding colonies. Many imperialists claimed moral responsibility as the reason to expand American land claims, the anti-imperialists decried it because of the negative effects on the colonized. In both camps, the issue of race relations was the source of most similarities and differences. The pro-imperialist group felt it was the duty of the American race to colonize others and subjugate those peoples without offering citizenship, while the anti-imperialists felt it was unfair to foreigners to

Read More
474 Words | 2 Pages

United States Imperialism in the late 19th century was very selfish time. Many people in that time, debated about whether are not benefiting our country was the right way or the wrong way. The motiving factors that impacted our imperialism are economic, military, and cultural. These factors impacted the American Imperialism from 1890-194 by having control over weaker territories meeting our expanding needs.

Read More
615 Words | 3 Pages

A common topic of interest today would be whether American Imperialism overseas was justified or not. One who is a supporter may argue that it helped US industry; an opponent may think it was unfair of the US to take over land owned by other forces. As significant as the positive effects of imperialism may be, there were also negative results of imperialism as well. Although it has produced some positive outcomes, American expansion overseas was not justified, as there were detriments such as poor conditions for the residents, forced rule over land, and exploitation. To start out, people of the acquired land suffered under poor conditions.

Read More
545 Words | 3 Pages

The supporters argued that the US has to expand to compete economically. During a period when the Europeans were establishing colonies to serve their political interests, the US had to join in the game to compete. Some argued that the US has a duty to spread civilization to nations living in the dark and other were more concerned with power. To become a world power, the US had to acquire naval bases outside the US. Alfred T. Mahan was one staunch supporter of imperialism.

Read More
512 Words | 3 Pages

Imperialism drove the world, from the Roman Empire, to America in the early 1900’s. The US imperialized nations to give them peace, gain their natural resources, and protect them. But not all things imperialism are good. When the US imperialized some nations, it limited their ability to govern and protect themselves. But the US has more experience doing so in a modern world, and would ultimately benefit them.

Read More
1065 Words | 5 Pages

Imperialism is an issue deeply rooted in American politics. The question of whether to partake in the imperialistic trend set by other world powers or to condemn the act has always been a debate among American politicians and economists alike. Imperialism is just a waste of time and resources and makes the United States vulnerable. Imperialism does more harm than good to the United States’ economy, values, and military resources.

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

Imperialism is a policy of extending a country's power and influence through diplomacy or military force. It is a great way to strengthen the economy and gain power and territory for countries that practice it, though it often failed and resulted in war and the deaths of innocents. Four intellectuals that played a big part in influencing American imperialism were Frederick Jackson Turner, Alfred T. Mahan, Herbert Spencer and John Fisk. All of these influencers had different ideologies and came together to justify American imperialism. They believed America needed to expand power and gain territories.

Read More
496 Words | 2 Pages

Imperialism can not be seen as a horrible thing all the time. These countries often do get protection from us, if ever threaten. My intent for American imperialism is for America to be put on the map. Some of my tactics will help America to do just that. Let us keep positive as American’s that our nationalism being spread for bigger and better things in these countries.

Read More

More about Controversial Political Arguments Against Imperialism In The United States

Related Topics

Open Document