ipl-logo

Ian Wright's Critical Thinking, Why Bother

2192 Words9 Pages

Critical Thinking, Why Bother? Ian Wright (2002)

‘Critical Thinking, Why Bother?’ is a chapter from ‘Is That Right? Critical Thinking and the Social World of the Young Learner’. I selected this work due to its practical nature and applicability to my profession, primary school teaching. Wright outlines a fair discussion about critical thinking intending to guide the teacher to help children to ‘think through situations where the answer is in doubt’ (2002, p.9). Throughout this chapter Wright pioneers critical thinking has a ‘practical value’ for social education, that it could help children grasp subject content in a profound and meaningful way.
Examples of how to teach critical thinking are included throughout this chapter however, the lessons overlook other views of critical thinking as a process of developing skills and sub-skills. Wright (2011) generalises that critical thinking involves questioning from the higher end of the cognitive domain according to Blooms Taxonomy; ‘analyses, synthesis and evaluation’ (2002, p51). …show more content…

Wright (2002 p.25) claims that controversial issues might be opposed by parents however, possible responses to the limitations could have been more considered by Wright particularly from an ethical point of view. Controversial issues could potentially transform something positive and autonomous into something negative and controlling. The teacher is not advised how to avoid or respond to this possibility. Mulnix (2012, p467) elegantly expresses, in moral terms, that critical thinking ‘is a theory about how to think, not about how to live.’ From an inclusive, ethical, moral and academic point of view, the author did not deliver this essential message strongly enough. Wright (2002, p26) subtly remarks; ‘In the first years of schooling, the making of

Show More
Related
196 Words | 1 Pages

As critical thinkers, they now observe the world around them in a whole new way. Numerous students have expressed to our members how inspired they were to not only

Read More
1421 Words | 6 Pages

Critical inquiry is the process of gathering and evaluating information, ideas, and assumptions from multiple perspectives to produce well-reasoned analysis and understanding that leads to new ideas, applications and questions. Critical inquiry is more than what is listed above, it is also possessing the ability to assess pieces of writing and use them within your own writing. I think the best example of my writing that supports this is my in-class writing “Seattle Versus the Homeless.” All over the essay, I included poll numbers from various sources, and statements from credible sources, like the mayor of Seattle. This was something I found a bit challenging because it was difficult finding unbiased and trustworthy polls and statements.

Read More
734 Words | 3 Pages

Critical thinking is necessary to evaluate and scrutinize thoughts, beliefs, and feelings. For instance, when people decide to make a decision about religion, critical thinkers will have more skill in making their belief and action more accurate. In the drama Inherit the Wind, Brady is a man who has a strong belief in God through the Bible. Drummond is an agnostic who does not affirm in the existence of God, and accepts in the evolution theory of Darwin.

Read More
211 Words | 1 Pages

Alexander and Entwisle, two sociologist planned to study how children navigate one of life’s first major transitions, from home to school. They wanted to follow them from first grade into second. Their research was called, “Beginning School Study”. Alexander and Entwisle did not set out to follow these children for what would become whole careers and lives. This research was conduct for a quarter-century.

Read More
1456 Words | 6 Pages

In 1998, McClintock High School in Tempe, Arizona assigned students to read The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain. The book has long been regarded as a controversial novel, and each generation that comes upon it has found something that rubs against the current societal norms. The mother of a student at McClintock took serious offense to the use of the word, “nigger” throughout the book and protested that it be banned due to the racial discrimination (Source I). Huck Finn is just one of the many pieces of literature that have been labelled “challenging,” and many feel that they do not deserve a place in schools’ curriculum. However, the study of challenging literature introduces students to new ideas and lessons that they can apply

Read More
1503 Words | 7 Pages

Hanna Rosin’s article, “The Overprotected Kid”, addresses the issue that kids are missing out on developmental benefits when they are not allowed to explore the world by weighing their own risks. She introduces rhetoric concepts such as audience, genre, and purpose to get her point across to her readers. Rosin uses these ideas to portray her opinion in a unique way to connect to her readers and persuade them to consider her viewpoint as their own. This article seems to be written as a persuasive journal entry to parents to sway their parenting behaviors to be less overprotective. In Rosin’s article, she makes a strong argument that kids need independence by making her audience, genre, and purpose known from start to finish.

Read More
153 Words | 1 Pages

Dr. Derek Cabrera’s thought on metacognition, human and education is absorbing. He shares perspectives on four universal thinking skills: Distinctions; “Systems; Relationships; and Perspectives (DSRP)” that should be taught in learning institutions. Dr. Cabrera states, “Thinking is simply a process of structuring information and doing something meaningful with it.” Dr. Cabrera also argues that people lack critical analytical thinking, great at school work, but not real life situation. Education needs to be fixed from the bottom up; that can be accomplished by teaching thinking skills.

Read More
1317 Words | 6 Pages

Allowing children to learn to think critically helps them to solve problems and have a logical argument about something they believe is true. Applying critical thinking into schools gives a child a chance to make a difference. Also, Elizabeth McKinstry agrees with Hummell in challenging the next generation to think for themselves. McKinstry writes about how Common Core education helps children become more interactive in the world and teaches them how to apply the knowledge they have learned in life. McKinstry said, "Their reality is not connected to a world outside the boundaries in which they live" (McKinstry 20).

Read More
1530 Words | 7 Pages

In “A Defense of Abortion” Judith Jarvis Thomson argues that abortion is not always immoral, even when we assume for the sake of argument that a fetus is an innocent person. In cases of rape and even some cases of protected consensual sex, Thomson says it is not immoral for a woman to kill a fetus by denying it use of her body. There are two pieces to Thompson’s argument. First, she rejects the common assumption that to kill an innocent person is always morally wrong. And she uses a clever counterexample (the violinist) to show that even aside from the case where you would need to kill an innocent person to save your own life, it is not always morally wrong to kill someone by denying him use of your body when he needs it to live.

Read More
1020 Words | 5 Pages

The play, Inherit the Wind, by Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee has caused me to think about how a teacher can impact/influence how a student thinks about important/controversial topics. Throughout the trials and testimonies, I believe that Howard’s testimony was the most important because he was the child that was given the right to think. This is who the story affects the most because children are still able to change their minds about things as they begin to think more independently whereas adults have pretty much already decided that they believe in creationism and that that is the only way. Teachers have such a big influence on students because they look up to them, and they listen and learn in the classroom every day.

Read More
1654 Words | 7 Pages

The theoretical perspective that supports Leeman, Rabin, & Román-Mendoza’s study is that of critical pedagogy as a source of agency and social

Read More
1340 Words | 6 Pages

The Other Education Rhetorical Analysis David Brooks is a well-refined journalist for the New York Times News Paper Company. He writes many different controversial articles, that tends to focus around arguments of education. Within Brooks’ arguments he uses effective techniques to persuade the audience. In this specific column, he addresses society as a whole, but with special emphasis on students. David Brooks successfully persuades his audience through his presentation of his claim, his persuasive writing style, and his usage of emotional appeals.

Read More
749 Words | 3 Pages

King has provided his opinion about education is building character. Dr. King uses his words to create an audience awareness to think for yourself isn’t the same as you may call it critical thinking. Against the common assumption that colleges should teach their students “critical reasoning,” Dr. King argues that critical thinking alone is insufficient and even dangerous. Teaching one to think critically is no small task. Most students learn by constructing knowledge based on an engaged learning process rather than by absorbing knowledge from passive sources.

Read More
972 Words | 4 Pages

In my experience, what Martin Luther King Jr. calls “thinking intensively and critically” is very different from what my high school teachers called “critical thinking”, most especially by the way Dr. King links intelligence and learning to the development of character, that is, growth as a person. Too often in my past, teachers mentioned critical thinking only as a mental activity of seeing through stereotypes, evaluating both sides of issues and understanding and accepting differences. As worthwhile as these are, I have found that high level thinking without having a more enlightened character is simply inadequate. That was a recent, very positive experience with two very nice people of different faiths. As much as we had been taught in class about prejudice, the recent terrorists attacks across the world bred a good deal of ill-will in

Read More
1056 Words | 5 Pages

Some of these concerns have been explored and articulated by such as Shirley Grundy, who sees it as overly dependent on “cultivation of wisdom and meaning-making in the classroom” and as a result the actual capability of students to “make sense” of subject matter and the world around them, can be

Read More

More about Ian Wright's Critical Thinking, Why Bother

Related Topics

Open Document